Free Essay

Trigger, Aggravator, or Rescuer? Criticisms on the Controversial Roles of Imf in East Asia Financial Crisis

In: Social Issues

Submitted By shinyxf
Words 2781
Pages 12
Trigger, Aggravator, or Rescuer?

Criticisms on the controversial roles of IMF in East Asia Financial Crisis

Introduction

Now and then, nation to nation, financial crises are inevitable: Mexico in 1994, the whole East Asia region in 1997, Brazil in 1999, and the most recently Argentina in 2001. Looking back to the victims of such financial crises, we found that most of them are labeled as the developing countries, whose financial sectors were still weak at that time yet were impetuously exposed to the advocated ‘Liberal financial market’ which was supported by the Neoclassical Liberalism social economists.

Among all these financial crises, the financial storm in East Asia, starting from the year of 1997, wreaked beyond doubt the greatest havoc on the Asia and the world economy as a whole, dragging down the ‘Asian tigers’ (Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippine, Hong Kong, Korea, Taiwan and Singapore) from the peak of the glorious ‘Economic Miracle’ in the past few years. Because of the severity and contagion of the East Asia Crisis, important questions have been raised such as the causes of the crisis, the role of the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and the financial architecture of international capital markets.

As one of the most important international organizations, IMF has its great impact on the world economy. In this paper, the influence of IMF before the eruption of the crisis and its role in the recovery of East Asia economy will be presented. The paper then focuses on the criticisms on IMF’s roles and adopted policies before and after the eruption of the financial crisis from the view of two main research camps ----Neoclassical and Keynesian. Thus, the paper elaborates the contradictory roles of IMF which was viewed as both a powerful international forces associated with both the creation and the attempted resolution of the East Asian crisis.

I. IMF, the creator of East Asia economy crisis

‘In theory, IMF supports democratic institutions in the nations it assists. In practice, it undermines the democratic process by imposing policies.’ --------- Joseph Stiglitz

As the world most important international organization that oversees the global financial systems and provides financial and technical assistances, IMF played the controversial roles in purporting the principle of ‘liberalized market’ and at the same time intervening the national/regional economic and financial operation by their imposing policies before the collapse of East Asia crisis. Keynesian economists criticized the ‘Washington Consensus’ based policies IMF adopted before the crisis. They claimed that the enforcement of capital account liberalization as a sequel to the process of trade liberalization conduced to the ‘overheating’ economy, irrational investment and speculative bubbles, resulting in the eruptive collapse in 1997. On the other hand, IMF was also criticized by neo-classical researchers about its political impacts on Asian countries. From their point of view, the East Asia crisis has never been simply an economic event but shaped domestic policy responses between IMF and these Asian countries.

Neo-classical liberalism and IMF policies

The IMF carries out series of policies under the discipline of the Neo Liberalism and its ‘Washington Consensus’. Deriving from Neo-classical theories, Neo Liberalism extends the ‘Liberal market’ philosophy to the global aspect. Besides a pretension of the deregulation of government in economy, Neo-Liberalism advocates privatization as well as a market-centered global trade liberalization in a way of competitive exchange rate, low tariff and active foreign direct investment (FDI) (see John Williamson’s 1989 Washington Consensus). With the content of Neo-liberalism’s ‘Washington Consensus’, IMF required the membership governments to assume ‘carefully defined and consistently applied obligations’ with regard to capital account liberalization for the ultimate goal of a complete market liberalization where every action of every being is a market transaction so that the government power and discrimination against small business are tempered. However, the slapdash action of opening financial account as a main requirement of IMF brought more dangers to Asian countries with an undeveloped financial systems and a lack of regulation and control of international financial flows.

The Keynesian criticism on IMF policies

Beyond the phenomena of East Asia Crisis, researchers concluded the causes of the crisis into several categories: Reliance on short-term capital flows (over-borrowing), decline in foreign exchange earning capacity due to the shrink of exports (over-producing regardless demanding), and speculative bubbles in asset markets such as real estate and stock market (over investment) (e.g., Beeson & Robison, 2000; Lim, 1999; Zhang,1999). IMF was then criticized by Keynes’s camp about the endorsement of capital account liberalization in developing countries without prudential regulation and sound financial construction. They claimed that opening up the capital account aggravated the volatility from increasing short-term foreign loans and portfolio as well as exaggerated inflows to risky and speculative sectors (Lim, 1999). They introduced Keynes’s analysis to explain the current wave of speculative inflows and attacks in East Asia. From Keynes’s view, individuals are not rational investors as Neo-classical economists’ assumed. The short-term horizon and get-rich-quick mentality of human beings drives to a speculation not necessarily related to real yields of perspective investments. It is intrinsic also to speculation to depend on ‘mass psychology’ to get bubbles up, make large winnings, and then get out ahead before the bubbles burst. Keynes then indicated that the capital control in the form of prudential regulation is central to reduce the harmful effects of short-run speculative activities (Lim, 1999). In the case of East Asia crisis, IMF was criticized for its inconsistency in the imposing policies. It required the regulation of the domestic financial markets but not the control and supervision of the international financial flows, thus catalyzing the irrationality of domestic and foreign investors’ behavior in borrowing and investing, under the name of ‘capital account liberalization’. Owing to the lack of prudential regulation and supervision, the speculative bubbles in the stock and real estate market grew bigger. Following Lietar’s report, more than 97 percent financial capital is speculative and unconnected the production of goods and services (Lietar, 1997). Moreover, because most of these short-term debts came from hedge funds, given a liberalized financial market combined with new high-tech international financial instruments, hedge funds become an important source of disturbances of the financial markets, as they move in and out not only quickly but also massively (Zhang, 1999). The Keynesian economists finally asserted that the capital opening up advocated by IMF was one major root cause of the financial crisis in East Asia.

The Neo-classical criticism of IMF’s political impact With the standing point of Neo-liberalism’s ‘Liberal market’, IMF in practice played a role of ‘exogenous agency’ regarded as a Keynes’s way of institutionalization. Therefore, IMF was also criticized by Neo-classical school due to its external intervention of regional economy, which violates the principle of a ‘Liberal Market’. In the opinion of Neo-classical economists , the IMF’s role is indicative of the essentially political impact of nominally economic policy advice. The IMF has provoked both resistance and enthusiasm, influencing the struggle over policy agendas throughout the region, and being instrumental in the downfall of the governments of Korea, Thailand and, most dramatically, Indonesia. Hence, it is clear that the crisis is an inescapably political phenomenon with the constellations of power and interest in shaping outcomes in Asian countries. From the Neo-classical opinion, it was IMF that led the East Asian countries to a managed and governed market instead of a complete liberal market and thus initiated a powerful institutional forces associated with the creation of the East Asia crisis (Beeson & Robison, 2000). In summary, IMF was viewed as the main cause of the East Asia crisis by both camps of economists because of its controversial roles played in the East Asia economy. However, the criticisms on IMF did not cease in the financial recovery in East Asia. In fact, IMF became the target of criticism in relieving the financial crisis in East Asia.

2. IMF, the exacerbating factor of East Asia crisis

After the explosion of Asia financial crisis, IMF adopted the same bailout package succeeded in mitigating the Mexico financial crises, nevertheless, this package failed to restore the market confidence but halt the exodus of capital from Asia-5 economy. This time, the austerity approach IMF adopted to tackle the crisis, which was in the teeth of more fierce criticism from academics, politicians and NGOs.

The bailout remedy of IMF in East Asia crisis

Following the successful experience in dealing with the Mexico’s financial crisis in 1994-1995, IMF continued the tight monetary and fiscal policies supported by the Neo-classical theories. IMF required Asian countries first to raise the interest rates to defend and stabilize the exchange rates and set a surplus government budget to reduce inflation and capital flight, as an exchange of financial support from IMF. However, the austerity remedy worked well on solving the Mexico financial crisis yet worsened the situation in East Asian countries.

IMF as the aggravator of East Asia crisis

It has been widely argued that the failure of the IMF to understand the specific nature of East Asia crisis and the extreme urgency for action worsened the financial situation in East Asia. The cause of East Asia financial crisis was different from that in 80s Latin America and its extending crisis in Mexico in 1994. Both the 80s Latin America and 94 Mexico crises were mainly the result of wrong ‘fundamentals’. The expansionary fiscal policies bloated public deficits and loose monetary policies led to runaway inflation (Palma, 1998). Therefore, the austerity policy imposed on the governments of these countries was correct. But before the crisis in 1997, the East Asian countries still maintained a budget surplus, moderate inflation rates of about 6%, high saving rates of over 32%, trade openness indicators of nearly 39% and credit ratings that were higher than investment grade (Karunaratne, 1999). In fact, in East Asia, the detonators were not a traditional balance-of-payments crisis due to a reserve depletion and falling credit ratings in a hasty financial liberalization as in Latin American, but the bankruptcies of banks and companies as well as the shortage of foreign reserves drew into a sudden collapse of confidence, panic capital outflows, depreciating currencies and falling asset prices. Because of the ‘herd mentality’, these panics and loss of confidence disseminated from countries to countries, immediately turning into a region-wide panic and financial collapse (Lim, 1999; Palma, 1998). As Joseph Stiglitz indicated, ‘austerity measures would not revive the economies of East Asia—it would plunge them into recession or even depression.’ (Stiglitz, 2000). High interest rates might devastate highly indebted East Asian firms, causing more bankruptcies and defaults and ensuing a credit crunch. Reduced government expenditures would further shrink the economy. What’s more, even after a tight monetary policy, the currencies of the affected countries continued to depreciate for extended periods of time (Lim, 1999; Palma, 1998). All these consequences of the austerity strategies utilized by IMF intensified the panic among investors and subsequently leaked away more capital flows. The financial situation in these Asian countries was thus mired more deeply.

Criticism of IMF’s remedy Based on the negative facts, IMF was criticized for its wrong approach of tackling East Asia crisis. The Neo-classical methods were proved wrong by Keynesian economists. They emphasized that Asian countries did not need economic austerity, but indeed expansionary policies to restore the confidence and prosper the gloomy economy in East Asia region. In the time of recession, Keynes’s contended that expansionary policies referring to government expenditure injection (also the allowance of a moderate deficit ), tax cutting and the raise of interest are crucial for stemming loss of confidence, panic and negative contagion. As a vital variable in his theory, the speculative demand for money is very sensitive to interest rates, because it pits demand for liquidity against for interest-yielding bonds. People do not want to invest in bonds or credit instruments and preferred to keeping the additional money as speculative demand. This results in a credit crunch (Lim, 1999). Given that the embedded cause of East Asia crisis was more about the psychological panic and loss of confidence, carrying out an austerity policy aggravated the credit crunch in countries and the growing ‘liquidity trap’ inflicted a vaster outflow of capital which accelerated the slide towards recession rather than recovery due to its failure of providing the liquidity required to avoid insolvency of financial institutions and calming creditor panic. In a whole, Keynes’s theories justified the criticism on IMF’s austerity policies in exacerbating the financial crisis in East Asia and delaying the recovery of East Asia economy.

A convert of IMF programs

Faced to a worsening financial situation in East Asia and numerous criticisms, IMF finally confessed its mistakes that the program projections badly misgauged the severity of downturn. In the second-phase (1998) of the bailout, the IMF drastically revamped its strategy by converting its policies from a Neo-classical aspect to the Keynesian expansionary strategies, attempting to re-instil market confidence. Although these modified policies helped relieve the financial crash in East Asia countries, the controversy of IMF’s remedies and its flunk in tacking with the East Asia crisis made it understandable why it was still the target of the criticisms from different schools of economists.

Conclusion

During the whole financial crumble period in East Asia, IMF was generalized into three roles: a trigger, an aggravator and a rescuer. It is no doubt that IMF boomed the economy in East Asia as well as provided tremendous support before and after the financial crisis. For example, IMF injected US$110 billion in total funding of the Asian countries in trouble and also assisted the local government to rebuild their financial market. We can never deny the rescuing role of IMF in pulling East Asian countries out of the financial crisis. On the other hand, IMF has to bear the blame for its controversial roles in impacting the East Asia economy and lack of experience in the financial retrieval. It is hard for every international organization to be completely neutral without any influence from powerful developed countries such as United States. Nevertheless, IMF should learn from the lesson of East Asia financial crisis not to apply indiscriminate policies to different regions and countries without a decent consideration of the realism of the aiding objects. Last but not least, it is also a necessity of IMF to have a reform that will engage in more effective use of its policy instruments of surveillance and conditionality, in order to establish a new global financial architecture that will countermand the casino economies that have emerged in a global economy governed by massive capital inflows and outflows as market sentiments fluctuate.

References

Becker, G. (1976). The Economic Approach to Human Behavior. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.

Beeson, M. & Robison, R. (2000). Interpreting the East Asian Economic Crisis. http://eprint.uq.edu.au/archive/00000959/01/mb_rr_00.pdf.

Bikhchandani, S., Hirshleifer, D. & Welch, I. (1998): Learning from the Behavior of Others. Conformity, Fads, and Informational Cascades. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 12(3), pp. 151-170.

Camdessus, M. (1998a), “Toward a New Financial Architecture for a Globalized World”, http://www.imf.org/external/np/speeches/1998/050898.HTM

Cesarano, F. (2003). Keynes’s Revindication of Classical Monetary Theory, History of Political Economy 35(3),491-520.

Krugman, P. (1998), “What happened to Asia?”, Mimeo, MIT.

Karunaratne, N.D. (1999). The Asian financial melt-down and the IMF rescue package. Economics Issues.

Lim, J. (1999). The Macroeconomics of the East Asian Crisis and the Implications of the Crisis for Macroeconomic Theory. The Manchester School 67 (5), 428–459.

Lietaer, B. (1997). Global currency speculation and its implications. Third World Resurgence, 87/88, 15-17.

Naim, M. (2000). Washington Consensus or Washington Confusion? http://www.foreignpolicy.com/Ning/archive/archive/118/washconsensus.pdf

Palma, G. (1998). Three and a half cycles of'mania, panic, and [asymmetric] crash': East Asia and Latin America compared. Cambridge Journal of economics, 22, 789-808.

Portes, A. (1997). Neoliberalism and the Sociology of Development: Emerging Trends and Unanticipated Facts. Population and Development Review, 23(2), 229-259.

Stiglitz, J. (1998), “The Role of International Financial Institutions in the Current Global Economy”, Address to the Chicago Council of Foreign Relations, The World Bank, http://www.worldbank.org/html/extdr/extme/jsspo022798.htm

Stiglitz, J.(2000). What I learned at the world economic crisis. http://www2.gsb.columbia.edu/faculty/jstiglitz/download/opeds/What_I_Learned_at_the_World_Economic_Crisis.htm

Williamson, J. (2002). Did the Washington Consensus Fail? http://www.iie.com/publications/papers/paper.cfm?ResearchID=488

Zhang, Y.L. (1999). Good Governance: The Lessons of the Asian Crisis. http://iaps.cass.cn/XueShuWZ/showcontent.asp?id=382.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

The East-Asian Crisis

...THE EAST ASIAN CRISIS Introduction: The East Asian crisis was a period of financial crisis that gripped much of Asia which beginning in July 1997 and raised fears of worldwide economic meltdown due to financial contagion.1 Several countries such as Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, the republic of Korea and the Philippines were hit directly while others such as Taiwan province of China, Singapore and especially Hong Kong, China were badly affected. What began as a speculative attack on the Thai baht in July 1997 quickly spread as ‘contagion’ to the other countries. Over a three-month period between July and October 1997, the baht fell nearly 40 per cent, the Malaysian ringgit and Philippine peso by about 27 per cent, the Indonesian rupiah by about 40 per cent and the Korean won approximately 35 per cent against the United States dollar. For countries that had been dubbed “miracle economies” this was a serious blow with wide-ranging economic, social and political ramifications.2 In this paper we would try to undertake an empirical analysis of the factors leading to the crisis by analysing on two major points: 1) How have these countries performed in the years leading to the crisis? 2) What was the policy response to the currency crisis and what similarities/differences were there in policy responses across countries? We try to do this by analysing the macroeconomic data of three countries, Malaysia, Thailand and the Republic of Korea, over a 13-year period, from 1990 to 2002.......

Words: 2206 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Financial Crisis

...O C C A S I O N A L PA P E R S E R I E S N O 1 2 3 / F E B R UA RY 2 011 THE INTERNATIONAL MONETARY SYSTEM AFTER THE FINANCIAL CRISIS by Ettore Dorrucci and Julie McKay OCCASIONAL PAPER SERIES NO 123 / FEBRUARY 2011 THE INTERNATIONAL MONETARY SYSTEM AFTER THE FINANCIAL CRISIS by Ettore Dorrucci and Julie McKay1 NOTE: This Occasional Paper should not be reported as representing the views of the European Central Bank (ECB). The views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the ECB. In 2011 all ECB publications feature a motif taken from the €100 banknote. This paper can be downloaded without charge from http://www.ecb.europa.eu or from the Social Science Research Network electronic library at http://ssrn.com/abstract_id=1646277 1 European Central Bank, Ettore.Dorrucci@ecb.europa.eu, Julie.McKay@ecb.europa.eu. The views expressed in this paper do not necessarily reflect those of the European Central Bank. The authors would like to thank, outside their institution, A. Afota, C. Borio, M. Committeri, B. Eichengreen, A. Erce, A. Gastaud, P. L'Hotelleire-Fallois Armas, P. Moreno, P. Sedlacek, Z. Szalai, I. Visco and J-P. Yanitch, and, within their institution, R. Beck, T. Bracke, A. Chudik, A. Mehl, E. Mileva, F. Moss, G. Pineau, F. Ramon-Ballester, L. Stracca, R. Straub, and C. Thimann for their very helpful comments and/or inputs. © European Central Bank, 2011 Address Kaiserstrasse 29 60311 Frankfurt am Main, Germany...

Words: 33129 - Pages: 133

Premium Essay

The Role Played by Regulatory Authorities in Mitigating the Financial Crisis in Developed and Developing Economies

...Introduction: The financial crises are major disruptions in financial markets characterized by sharp declines in asset prices and firm failures (11). The global melt down of 2007-08, the Great Depression of 1929 and South Asian crises of 1997 tested the efficiencies of concerned regulatory authorities across the world. Financial crises moves like cyclone and spirals down to all connected economies (13). Whether financial crises emerges in the developed countries or in the developing countries, the history witnesses that it has invariably led concerned economies into deep recession, unemployment, loss of public confidence, domestic and international trade reversal and even capital flight. The regulatory authorities engaged in watching and monitoring health of concerned economies have to proactively respond to mitigate and resolve the crises. There could be different causes for financial crises such as ongoing double digit inflation / uncontrolled monetary expansion, unsustainable internal or external public debt, excessive credit booms, large capital inflows, large current account deficits, balance sheet weaknesses due to maturity mismatches of public debts, fall out of impracticable exchange rate mechanism followed and currency crises (3). The selection of ways and means of mitigating and resolving a financial crisis and accelerating economic recovery is dependent upon root causes leading to financial crises. The policy options selected by regulatory authorities may be...

Words: 6201 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Asian Financial Crisis

...RESEARCH PAPER 99/14 11 FEBRUARY 1999 The Asian Economic Crisis This paper considers the economic crisis that began in the financial markets of South East Asia in 1997 and the consequences for the economies of the region and the rest of the world. The paper provides a chronology of and explores the factors that led to the crisis. An overview is given of the policy measures that the international financial institutions (IFIs), such as the IMF, have taken to deal with the crisis. Some of the arguments and policy proposals made to try to avoid future crises are also covered. Eshan Karunatilleka ECONOMIC POLICY AND STATISTICS SECTION HOUSE OF COMMONS LIBRARY Recent Library Research Papers include: 98/119 98/120 99/1 Unemployment by Constituency - November 1998 Defence Statistics 1998 The Local Government Bill: Best Value and Council Tax Capping Bill No 5 of 1998-99 16.12.98 22.12.98 08.01.99 99/2 99/3 99/4 Unemployment by Constituency - December 1998 Tax Credits Bill Bill 9 of 1998-9 The Sexual Offences (Amendment) Bill: 'Age of consent' and abuse of a position of trust [Bill 10 of 1998-99] 13.01.99 18.01.99 21.01.99 99/5 99/6 99/7 The House of Lords Bill: 'Stage One' Issues Bill 34 of 1998-99 The House of Lords Bill: Options for 'Stage Two' Bill 34 of 1998-99 The House of Lords Bill: Lords reform and wider constitutional reform Bill 34 of 1998-99 28.01.99 28.01.99 28.01.99 99/8 99/9 99/10 99/11 99/12 Economic Indicators Local......

Words: 16600 - Pages: 67

Premium Essay

Roles of Imf and World Bank

...Q5) International Monetary Fund (IMF) role is to stabilize the international exchange rates and promote liberal economic policies. IMF will also provide short-term loan to assist members to overcome short-term imbalance of payment problems. On the other hand, World Bank offers loans to members to finance productive investments as well as assisting developing countries in its economy so as to reduce poverty within the country. Singapore joins both IMF and World Bank under the Bretton Woods Agreements Acts in 1966, 3 August. Before we join to become IMF as a member, during the Singapore-Malaya separation, we had sought for their technical assistance and to act as a broker in the negotiation with Malaysia for a common currency and banking system. In order to so, IMF first conducted a preliminary study to identify the concerns of Singapore and Malaysia regarding the common currency issue. IMF then acts as a broker in the final round of negotiations between 10 June 1966 and 5 July 1966. Before joining World Bank as a member, Singapore had sought for 2 loans where the first loan of US$15 million was used for the construction of the first phase of the Pasir Panjang ‘B’ Power Station and the second loan of US$6.8 million was used to construct Johor River Water Project. As a pre-requisite for the loan, the World Bank then requested our government to set up statutory authority (Public Utilities Board [PUB]) to manage the utilization and repayment of the loan. The advantages...

Words: 1951 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Role of Imf

...University, Mankato The Role of the International Monetary Funds (IMF) in the East Asian Debt Crisis of 1997 By Yaro Sadek Tahirou Minnesota State University, Mankato 2 ABSTRACT During the East Asian Financial crisis in particular, the IMF has been criticized of promoting international cooperation because of the supervised enforcement of its rules. The purpose of this research is to find out how the IMF responded to the East Asian debt crisis and whether or not its responses were the best possible responses to this crisis. Through my research, I talked about the causes of the East Asian financial crisis, the role of the IMF in the international monetary system, and if the IMF responses to Thailand, South Korea and Indonesia were the best responses or not. After analyzing the IMF responses in this crisis, I found that the IMF policies need to be reformed in order to monitor and prevent future financial crises spill-over effects at the global and regional levels. I will analyzed 5 scholarly journals on the financial crisis in East Asia, 3 scholarly articles on the role of IMF in the East Asia financial crisis, and 1 novel called POLITICS IN SOUTHEAST ASIA DEMOCRACY OR LESS by William Case. INTRODUCTION Several financial crises have occurred in the world economy through the last decades. Some examples include the East Asian financial Crisis of 1997, the Latin American debt crisis of 1994-95, the Russian crisis of 1998, and the Brazilian crisis of 1998-99 which......

Words: 7746 - Pages: 31

Premium Essay

Conflict in South East Asia

...looking at how conflict plays a more significant role and more is impactful in South East Asia (SEA) compared to cooperation. Conflict is a state of disharmony between two or more parties of ideas or interests. In the context of this essay, conflict occurs when there is a disagreement such as different views, clashes of interest and different views on ideology between the countries. While there is an inevitable fact that cooperation exists within SEA, the impacts that conflicts leave on the history of the region is far more significant than those of cooperation. In the next few paragraphs, I will be going in depth into how conflict has left a deeper indentation on the history as well as more current affairs of SEA. Some countries have conflicts with other in their history, before they learn from their mistakes and work together to reach the level of agreement they have now, such as Indonesia and Malaysia. One major conflict between them is the Konfrontasi, where Indonesia had carried out attacks on Malaysia and there was high tension between these two countries. In December 1962, a revolt had broken out in Brunei to oppose Brunei from joining the Federation, and instead proposed a separate union of Brunei, Sarawak and Sabah (Borneo territories). This revolt had fitted Sukarno’s (former Indonesia’s president) beliefs that independence should only be gained through revolutionary struggle, thus he had publicly supported it. Another trigger cause is the formation of the......

Words: 1655 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Asia Crisis

... The financial crisis which began in July 1997 in the East Asian countries, Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia and Korea, has had devastating effects on their economies. Growth rates in these countries which were in excess of five percent before 1997, turned sharply negative in 1998 and, at the time of this writing it is not yet clear when these economies will turn the corner and resume positive rates of growth. This paper examines why these countries, which were part of what has been termed "the Asian miracle" and were able to eradicate so much poverty, are now undergoing severe economic contractions, with such harmful effects on their populations. A breakdown of information in financial markets is the key factor that has driven this crisis. After laying out an asymmetric information view of the Asian financial crisis, this paper goes on to use this framework to explore lessons from this crisis. 1. An Asymmetric Information View of the Asian Crisis The financial system plays a critical role in the economy because, when it operates properly, it channels funds from those who have saved surplus funds to those who need these funds to engage in productive investment opportunities. The major barrier to the financial system performing this job properly is asymmetric information, the fact that one party to a financial contract does not have the same information as the other party, which results in moral hazard and adverse selection problems. An asymmetric information view of......

Words: 7371 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Imf’s Role on Asian Crisis

...Trisha LaFleur Econ 375 McNeil 17 November 2014 IMF’s Role on Asian Crisis In July of 1997 Thailand devalued the Baht and thus began the ‘Asian Crisis’ that would soon affect other Southeast Asian countries including the other two that were hit the hardest Indonesia and South Korea. Each country had no choice but to seek help from The International Monetary Fund (IMF). The IMF would have to pull through in aiding these countries out of this crisis, after carefully reviewing each country and see to what extent their financial problems had developed. As you can see below on Graph 1 each country’s exchange rate had depreciated tremendously during the crisis. With the demise of each Country’s currency their public debt, as shown on Chart 2 below, had grown tremendously. Thailand, Indonesia, and South Korea each developed specific financial restructuring measures that were agreed upon with the IMF. Graph 1: Chart 2: It all started on May 14th 1997 when Thailand started pouring foreign currency into the market in order to ‘to defend the Thai baht against speculative attacks,’ according to the “TimeLine of the Crisis” written by PBS. Two months later the Baht had reached an all-time low of 20% devaluation. Indonesia started to widen its ‘trading band for the rupiah in a move to discourage speculators’ only seven days after Indonesia’s reach for assistance (PBS). No more than two weeks pass until the Singapore dollar starts to devalue. Shortly after that, the...

Words: 1734 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

East Asian Crisis

...East Asian Crisis Financial crisis is a situation in which some financial institutions or assets suddenly lose a large part of their value. East Asian crisis was a series of currency devaluations and other events that spread through many East Asian countries beginning in the summer of 1997. The countries majorly affected by this were: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. South Korea Japan Thailand Indonesia Malaysia Philippines The countries at the center of the recent crisis were for years admired as some of the most successful emerging market economies, owing to their rapid growth and the striking gains in their populations' living standards. With their generally prudent fiscal policies and high rates of private saving, they were widely seen as models for many other countries. No one could have foreseen that these countries could suddenly become embroiled in one of the worst financial crises. Their very success led foreign investors to underestimate their underlying economic weaknesses. Partly because of the large-scale financial inflows that their economic success encouraged, there were also increased demands on policies and institutions, especially those safeguarding the financial sector; and policies and institutions failed to keep pace with these demands. Only as the crisis deepened were the fundamental policy shortcomings and their consequences fully revealed. Also, past successes may have led policymakers to deny the need for action when problems first appeared1. Several factors......

Words: 1000 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Reflection on the Asian Financial Crisis

...Implications of the Asian Financial Crisis. The Asian Financial Crisis also called the "Asian Contagion". This was a series of currency devaluations and other events that spread through many Asian markets beginning in the summer of 1997. The currency markets first failed in Thailand as the result of the government's decision to no longer peg the local currency to the U.S. dollar. Currency declines spread rapidly throughout South Asia, in turn causing stock market declines, reduced import revenues and even government upheaval. Although the economic storm that swept through Asian in 1997 has now declined, the wreckage left in its wake has undoubtedly take years to repair. By indulging in a debt spree that ultimately bought its high flying economies crashing to the ground, Asia may have lost a decade of economic progress. Beyond this, however, the crisis has raised a series of fundamental policy questions about the sustainability of the so called Asian Economic Model, the role of the IMF, and the virtues of floating and fixed exchange rates. The crisis also has important implications for international businesses. For a decade, the Asian Pacific region has been promoted by many as the future economic engine of the world economy. Businesses have invested billions of dollars in the region on the assumption that the rapid growth of the last decade would continue. But at the dawn of the aforementioned crisis, it has come grinding to a halt. So what could this mean for international...

Words: 3167 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Financial Crisis

...Financial Crisis Introduction In recent decades, financial crises have stopped the momentum of economic development of many countries around the world. In some cases, they have destroyed almost completely different financial systems. The term financial crisis is applied broadly to a variety of situations in which some financial assets suddenly lose a large part of their nominal value. In the 19th and early 20th centuries, many financial crises were associated with banking panics, and many recessions coincided with these panics. Other situations that are often called financial crises include stock market crashes and the bursting of other financial bubbles, currency crises, and sovereign defaults. Financial crises directly result in a loss of paper wealth but do not necessarily result in changes in the real economy. Many economists have offered theories about how financial crises develop and how they could be prevented. There is no consensus, however, and financial crises continue to occur from time to time. The purpose of this study is to analyze the causes of financial crisis, the types of financial crisis and the impact caused in the countries that have experienced them. Explanation of financial crisis Financial crises have come in many forms although they have many common elements. A financial crisis is often associated with one or more of the following phenomena: substantial changes in credit volume and asset prices, severe disruptions in financial intermediation......

Words: 3358 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Role of Securitization in Financial Crisis

...The process of securitization as core of the subrime mortgage crisis The process of securitization created many opportunities for financing, given that the US financial system is much diversified and does not depend only on bank financing. Indeed, a long chain of intermediaries are involved in channeling funds from the ultimate creditors to the ultimate borrowers. The simple model of intermediation chain would consist of households (borrowers), mortgage bank and household (depositor). On the contrary, a long intermediation chain includes borrowers, a passive firm whose role is to hold mortgage assets securities (MBSc) and issue liabilities, an issuer who pools the MBSc into another layer of claims (such as CDOs), an investment bank which buys these securities and finance itself by collateralized borrowings through repurchase agreements (repos) with a large commercial bank, instead of issue short term securities on the money market in order to fund its lending. The last link of the chain is the households who will to invest their savings for higher yield. The establishment of a long intermediation chain enables the dispersion of credit risk to those who can better bear losses (rather than concentration in the bank’s balance sheet that was a case in the traditional model). It makes easier to perform maturity transformation (from long term to short term claims) and it enables some financial intermediaries to specialize in screening borrowers, others in arranging initial short...

Words: 1255 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Financial Crisis

...Journal of Contemporary Eastern Asia ISSN 2383-9449 Fumitaka Furuoka, Beatrice Lim, Catherine Jikunan and Lo May Chiun (2012) Economics Crisis and Response: Case Study of Malaysia’s Responses to Asian Financial Crisis Journal of Contemporary Eastern Asia Vol. 11, No. 1: 43-56 Journal abbreviation: J. Contemp. East. Asia Stable URL: http://eastasia.yu.ac.kr/documents/Fumitaka_11_1.pdf www.JCEA-Online.net Open Access Publication Creative Commons License Deed Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 Journal of Contemporary Eastern Asia, Volume 11, No.1: 43-56 http://dx.doi.org/10.17477/jcea.2012.11.1.043 Economics Crisis and Response: Case Study of Malaysia’s Responses to Asian Financial Crisis Fumitaka Furuoka, Beatrice Lim, Catherine Jikunan and Lo May Chiun The paper chooses the “Asian Financial Crisis” as a case study to examine its impact on Malaysian economy and describes how Malaysian government responded to the crisis. It also focuses on the Asian financial crisis’ impact on the employment of banking sector in Malaysia. In the finance, insurance, real estate and business service sector, a number of 6,596 workers were retrenched. Banks were forced into mergers and acquisition as well as downsizing, trim lean, organizational changes and introduction of new technologies. Excess workers were offered a “voluntary separation scheme.” These retrenched workers became the urban poor facing high cost of living and no opportunity for jobs as there is no safety net provided. 1.......

Words: 7422 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Imf Rescue Programs in the Financial Crisis in Eurozone

...IMF RESCUE PROGRAMS IN THE FINANCIAL CRISIS IN EUROZONE Mutegi Cliff United States International University IMF RESCUE PROGRAMS IN THE FINANCIAL CRISIS IN EUROZONE Introduction of Eurozone Crisis The Eurozone crisis began when it became evident that Greece was unable to repay its debts. This realization posed a threat not only to the 17 nations using the Euro currency but the whole European Union – 27 nations (Fullbrook, 2007). A report in 2003, by George Mason University’s School of Public Policy says, “The roots of Greece's fiscal calamity lie in prolonged deficit spending, economic mismanagement, government misreporting, and tax evasion." In order to avert the collapse of the European Union and the world economy, the EU together with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) had to find a means of bailing out the ailing states Greece, Italy and Ireland among others (Francis, 2002). IMF rescue programs in: Greece The first rescue program for Greece was in May 2010. The assistance was called “Troika” as it involved the IMF, Greek government, the federal commission of economic charge European Commission (EC), and the monetary control fund, the European Central Bank (ECB) (Fullbrook, 2007). This assistance was in the form of a three-year economic adjustment initiative involving a financial assistance of € 110 billion. EU countries contributed € 80 billion while the IMF gave € 30 billion (Fullbrook, 2007). The loan was on......

Words: 624 - Pages: 3