Premium Essay

'There Is No Convincing Case for a Written Consitution in Britain' Discuss

In: Social Issues

Submitted By ellieholland94
Words 592
Pages 3
Ellie Holland
There is no convincing case for a written constitution in Britain. Discuss.
A constitution is a set of fundamental principles; it sets out the distribution of power within a political system. In Britain we do not have a written or uncodified constitution meaning constitutional reforms are written down but have not been gathered together. There are many arguments surrounding the British constitution and its legitimacy and whether a change in our constitution would create a positive impact or whether our current system is the best and there are no convincing arguments against it.
The fact we have parliamentary system means that there is no need for a written constitution. Parliamentary sovereignty means that parliament have the highest legal authority in the UK. Because of our democratic system in the UK we have to power to elect our government and therefore this puts limits on the level of parliamentary sovereignty, parliament cannot afford to ignore the electorate’s wishes. For example the Local Government Finance Act 1988 that introduced poll tax was replaced by Parliament but only after nationwide riots and demonstrations. However with a written constitution it is close to impossible to change anything. To say that there are no convincing arguments surrounding change in Britain’s constitution may be seen as an over statement as a written, codified constitutions do carry some advantages. It hugely reduces the risk of an elective dictatorship because there is separation of powers. It was also mean that the people in power have some boundaries in law making as the written constitution would become the arguably fair foundations for any law to be built on. For example when Blair was in power he removed one session of Prime Ministers question time without consultation or changed composition of Lords. Blair also brought about the Iraq war in 2003 through…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Written Case Analysis

...Written Case Analysis Case: Taran Swan at Nickelodeon Latin America (A). Harvard Business School Case Jon Goebel Question 1: Considering various behaviors exhibited by Taran Swan, what do you think are the two predominant personality traits that characterize her? Rely on the class discussions from Session 1. Highlight important examples from the case that led you to this conclusion. In the case study about Nickelodeon in Latin America, Taran Swan exhibits glimpses of each of the five personality traits, but the two traits that most clearly epitomize her dynamic personality are “high extraversion”, and “high openness to experience”. Taran Swan has a tendency toward “high extraversion” and demonstrates this in how comfortable she is networking throughout all levels and functional areas within Nickelodeon / MTV and parent company Viacom. She was dealt a challenging situation when initially asked to launch the network station in Latin America. Taran is given direction to solicit resources and support from MTV personnel, but these employees are not familiar with the Nickelodeon brand and hold obvious bias toward their own network (MTV). Despite this situation, one MTV employee still gives Taran very high praise for not only involving all departments of the organization, but also for offering the opportunity to contribute their own ideas. Taran’s tendency for extraversion also allows her to infuse a sense of......

Words: 1600 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Kotler Botox Case Discuss

...COMPANY CASE for Chapter 1 Botox: Almost Trouble-Free New Faces Synopsis The Botox case illustrates the accidental success of a product developed for an entirely different purpose. Originally, Botox was used in the treatment of crossed-eyes, but ophthalmologists quickly learned that it would also erase wrinkles and frown lines around eyes. It wasn’t long before doctors across the United States were using Botox for treating wrinkles even though Allergan could not promote the product for this use. The case discusses the advantages (fewer frown lines) and disadvantages and side effects (drooping eyelids and the need to repeat treatments) of Botox; explains what the product is; lists potential target markets; selling of the product at “Botox parties”; use of Botox treatments to attract customers to resorts; Allergan’s marketing of Botox once it was approved for cosmetic purposes and the use of Botox to support the new strategy of Allergan to become a major player in the pharmaceuticals industry. It closes with the observation that the formula for Botox is one of the most closely guarded product secrets in the world—along with the formula for Coca-Cola. The case is especially useful for discussing added value and the creation of customer satisfaction. It raises questions about the difference between needs, wants, and demands; what constitutes value; is useful for illustrating the difference between a marketing oriented company (Allergan after Botox) rather than a...

Words: 1960 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Landau Company Written Case Analysis

...Written Case Analysis Landau Company I. Background: Landau Company is a manufacturing company that is currently using Absorption Costing System for the preparation of their monthly Income Statements. The company is considering a shift in the system to Variable Costing. II. Problem Statement: What Costing System should Landau Company used for their monthly income statement that could best reflect their monthly income? III. Objectives: - Differentiate Variable Costing from Full Costing/ Absorption Costing. - Assess the proposed Variable Costing and identify its pros and cons IV. Answers to the Requirements of the Case: 1. Pros and Cons of Variable Costing The major advantages of Variable Costing are as follows: - The contribution margin format income statement produced in Variable Costing provides information for CVP Analysis, hence useful in making decisions regarding profit-planning. - Estimating profitability is easier since it provides data for individual product profitability. - Aids management in controlling costs. Variable costing reflects direct and controllable costs that management could take into consideration for cost management. - Saves time and effort of allocating fixed manufacturing overhead to each product. Variable Costing uses fixed overhead as a lump sum, treats it as period cost, hence deducts it at once. This is in contrast with Absorption Costing where there is a need to compute for the per-unit fixed cost......

Words: 481 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Written Analysis of Case

... The aim of the brand was to inculcate in them a sense of pride with the ownership of the premium Xylys brand. ANALYSIS The commonly used basis for segmenting the consumer market for watches is technology, benefit sought and price. This segmentation basis, although widely used, doesn’t give a clear picture of the consumers’ perception towards the brands in the watch industry. A more helpful basis for segmentation, provided by Daniel Yankelovich, was segmentation by value, which basically segmented the watch market with respect to brand’s symbolic associations. The change in consumers’ symbolic associations, such as glamour, fashion, sports and fun, appeared to be highly correlated with a changing environment. As elaborated in the case, this change in associations remained highly parallel to concurrent changes in environment through all social classes, even through the worse economic downturns. A good reason for this would be that the middle and upper income groups associated watches with their self – image, becoming the drivers for growth in this market. This product category was not only associated with a consumer’s self – image but also the resulting social – image. While on the premium and luxury segments of the market, watches were positioned offering the symbolic and experiential benefits that middle and high – income groups sought, the brands targeting the economy segment of the market, accounting for majority of the market share in this category, also produced...

Words: 885 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Nstructions for Written Case Assignments

...BA 491: INSTRUCTIONS FOR WRITTEN CASE ASSIGNMENTS Competition in the Golf Equipment Industry in 2009 Case. Is this industry competitive? Why or why not? Remember instructions: use the concepts discussed on the external environment, I do not want to see a summary of each force. State the important force that supports your answer. FORMAT All case assignments must follow a simple memorandum format with the following sections: 1. The paragraph, a short one, must contain a sentence must stating the response to the required topic. For example, if a recommendation is required, the sentence might start with “I recommend . . .” or “This is to recommend that . . .” If a question is given, the sentence must respond to the question directly. The paragraph should also contain a summary of the justification for the response. 2. The next paragraph or two should contain the justification for the response along with supporting data or information. The latter would be a reference to a concept in Strategic Management and should include facts and information in the case. Stick with information and data provided in the case, materials taken from other sources are not acceptable. 3. A concluding statement. This should allow students to keep their case assignments to a one page limit. The purpose for imposing this format is to encourage students to focus on what is important and avoid unnecessary information. Place name and date on the upper right hand......

Words: 415 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Case for Britain Retaining Its Uncodified Constitution Remains Extremely Strong

...A constitution is a set of rules which may be written or unwritten, establishes the distribution of power in a political system, the limits of government jurisdiction, the rights of citizens and the method of amending the constitution itself. An uncodified constitution is unwritten, or at least not written all in one document. The constitution in the UK is found in a variety of sources, which are mainly statute and common law, conventions and traditions, European law etc. The British constitution itself is flexible as it allows the constitutions to evolve and generally adapt to the changing society. Compared to the US whose constitution is described as ‘rigid’; through the struggle of being able to amend constitutions; for example, the ‘right to bear arms’ amendment, which basically gives registered citizens the right to keep and bear arms. The topic of amending this constitution is very controversial, however due to the constitution being codified the process is very difficult, as is it entrenched and has been a part of the US culture for centuries. In this essay, I will be analysing the strengths of the British constitution and comparing it to a codified constitution, Some of the arguments for retaining the uncodified system are that; codification produces ‘judicial tyranny’, uncodified constitutions are more flexible and lastly that an uncodified system has worked well in the UK for many years and broadly speaking not many people have protested against an uncodified......

Words: 924 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Written Analysis of the Case - Prestige Company

...I. SUMMARY OF THE CASE Prestige Telephone Company is a public utility business. Since it is operated as a public utility, it is subject to the regulations of the Public Service Commission, as such, the rates charged by Prestige Telephone Company for telephone service could not be changed without the approval of the Public Service Commission. The state Public Service Commission had encouraged all public utilities under its jurisdiction to seek new sources of revenue and profits as a step toward deregulation and to reduce the need for rate increase, which higher costs would otherwise bring. In 1995, The Prestige Data Services started its operation as a subsidiary of Prestige Telephone Company. It is established to perform data processing for the parent company and to sell computer service to other companies and organizations. From the start of its operation, Prestige Data Services experienced several problems, to wit; delayed deliveries of equipment, personnel commanded higher salaries and most importantly, customers were lesser than the earlier estimates. By the end of 1996, the company had a very low income that revealed the lowest Return on Investment in seven years. Because of this, Daniel Rose, the president of Prestige Telephone Company, felt it was time to reassess Prestige Data Services. The reports for the quarter revealed a persistent problem; available hours, which were unprofitable, remained HIGH. Revenue and cost data were summarized in the quarterly report on......

Words: 2160 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Written Case

...Andrew Wash GBA 490-321 Written Case 1 February 12, 2014 Table of Contents Issue #1 ……………………………………………………………………………… 2 Issue #2 ……………………………………………………………………………… 3 Issue #3 ……………………………………………………………………………… 4 Recommendation ……………………………………………………………………. 5 Dominant Economic Characteristics ………………………………………………... 7 PESTEL Analysis …………………………………………………………………… 8 Five Forces Analysis ……………………………………………………………….. 10 Drivers of Change in the Industry …………………………………………………... 12 Current Strategy …………………………………………………………………….. 13 Competitor Analysis ………………………………………………………………... 15 SWOT Analysis …………………………………………………………………….. 17 Financial Analysis ………………………………………………………………….. 19 Issue #1 Trader Joe’s first problem is that information is occasionally leaked regarding the identity of their private label suppliers. Trader Joe’s thrives off keeping the identity of their suppliers a secret to all consumers and media in order to maintain the integrity of their products. Since 80 percent of the products sold at Trader Joe’s are private label, the identity of the supplier is not known because the product is sold under the Trader Joe’s brand name. Information leaks regarding Trader Joe’s suppliers could damage their brand image because it could cause Trader Joe’s to lose its charm to consumers and because it could make other companies wary of supplying their goods. First, information leaks could cause Trader Joe’s to lose its charm in the eyes of the consumer. There were news reports spread......

Words: 4711 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Written Case Analysis

...------------------------------------------------- Cases Included: ------------------------------------------------- - Oracle – An Overview of Oracle Business Intelligence ------------------------------------------------- - Enterprise Health Information Systems ------------------------------------------------- - FedEx Express EMEA ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Cases Included: ------------------------------------------------- - Oracle – An Overview of Oracle Business Intelligence ------------------------------------------------- - Enterprise Health Information Systems ------------------------------------------------- - FedEx Express EMEA ------------------------------------------------- ITM505 Group 18 – 3 Long Cases ITM505 Group 18 – 3 Long Cases By: Ali Ahmed (500405839), Arham Gul (500393563), Qasim Malik (500450605), Arich Lengkong (500481555), Patrick Antwi (500461586) By: Ali Ahmed (500405839), Arham Gul (500393563), Qasim Malik (500450605), Arich Lengkong (500481555), Patrick Antwi (500461586) Contents Case Analysis – Oracle: An Overview of Oracle Business Intelligence Applications 3 Introduction 3 Key Issues 3 Key Assumptions 4 What are the advantages and disadvantages of using a Business Intelligence (BI) software system in a small/medium level business? 5 Procurement and Spend Analytics: 5 Supply Chain and Order Management Analytic 5 Financial/Monetary......

Words: 6034 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

A.) Aristotles Theory of the Four Causes B.) “Aristotle’s Theory of the Four Causes Is Convincing” Discuss.

...He claims that there are only four causes (or explanations) needed to give evidence for change in the world. A complete explanation of the change of any object will use all four causes. These causes are; material, formal, efficient and final. Aristotle understood that each of the four causes was necessary to explain the change from potentiality to actuality.             The material cause is the substance of which something is made out of; "That from which, as a constituent, an object comes into being." The human bodies ‘material causes’ are cells, skin and tissue. A computer’s ‘material cause’ would be its pixels and electronic components. Aristotle used the example of a bronze sculpture or a silver saucer. Bronze or silver, in this case, would be the material cause. The material cause is also a question scientists try and answer when they examine a specimen; they discover what it is made from. The material cause explains the general properties of an object. For example, the human body needs oxygen because its cells need oxygen, and a computer needs electricity because the electronic components need electricity to fuel them. Finally, the material cause can be split into two sectors: proximate matter and prime matter. Proximate matter is matter that has some working properties, such as cells and electronic components. Prime matter has no properties at all. Aristotle believed that prime matter did not exist, but was theoretically necessary.            The formal cause......

Words: 1432 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Britain Should Adopt a Codified Constitution, Discuss.

...“Britain should adopt a codified constitution”, Discuss. (40 mark) Intro A constitution is a set of rules/principles, which aim to set the duties and powers of government. There are two different types of constitutions, codified (written) and uncodified (unwritten), which the UK is an example of an uncodified and the U.S.A a codified. Codified and Uncodified Constitutions An uncodified constitution is a constitution made from principles that are not formatted into one single document and unlike codified is not authoritative and also not entrenched. A codified constitution is where the principles or rules are collected within a single document. Codified constitutions have three key features, the first is that the document itself is authoritative in the sense it constitutes a ‘higher’ form of law. The other key feature is that It binds all political institutions. And the final key feature is that they are said to be entrenched which means they are difficult to abolish or amend. UK for a Codified Constitution Some people argue that if the UK adopted a codified constitution is a good thing. If it was to be adopted it would significantly change the UK because it would affect: the power of the government and people’s rights and freedom. One of the biggest arguments for adopting a codified constitution is the fact it would make all rules/principles a lot clearer as they would all be in 1 single document and more clearly written meaning it would create less......

Words: 557 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Discuss Ways in Which Social Developments Associated with ‘Thatcher’s Britain’ Are Reflected in ‘Babylon’.

...Discuss ways in which social developments associated with ‘Thatcher’s Britain’ are reflected in ‘Babylon’. Babylon is a film from 1980, which was directed by Franco Rosso. Its about black youth growing up in Brixton, South London. To many it stood out because it reflected the very dark, depressing realisms of Britain at the end of the 1970s. Back then it wasn’t really received by the public, probably because it revealed the hard naked truth of Britain, but now it’s known to be one of the best British films ever made. Its about a young Rastafarian rapper who has hopes to rise above the trails of his daily life and succeed at a sound system completion. Around this time Margaret Thatcher becomes the new prime minister of 10 Downing Street. She was regarded as one of the most important prime ministers of the 20th century being credited for breaking ‘post war consensus’ in British politics. Thatcher re-invigorated capitalism, allowed for market forces to ‘let rip’. All of this, as well as increasing inequality between the rich and poor and also in some ways between the whites and the ethnic minorities. This is fully reflected in Babylon. A way in which social developments associated with Thatcher’s Britain that is reflecting in Babylon is police brutality. An example of this was when blue in the film gets chased b police for no reason and then beaten up. Then later accused of something he did and taken to court. Police brutality was prominent around this time, mainly due...

Words: 415 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Written Case Analysis

...The Body Shop International PLC 2001: An Introduction to Financial Modeling Written Case Analysis Mitchell Bredberg-(12205176) Mitchell Sovis-(12156556) Jake Rux-(12159615) Zach Dorer-(12171436) Finance 465-001 11/10/15 I. Executive Summary Anita Roddick was the founder of The Body Shop International PLC. Despite growing a successful business, the company recently ran downhill after losing revenue growth starting in the late 1990s. One of the major problems was intense competition. This unexpected phenomenon caused The Body Shop to lose its image of being the “go to” place in Great Britain’s many shopping venues. Later on, a new CEO, Patrick Gournay, took charge and was faced with a declining pretax profit of twenty-one percent. Facing a dilemma, Gournay’s recommended plan of action included a focused product strategy of increased investment. He was confident this strategy would produce improved results. To be effective, this strategy incorporated a reduction in product and inventory costs as well as a reinforced stakeholder culture. To justify the course of action with this strategy, we will prepare a three-year financial forecast to help predict The Body Shop’s future earnings and financial needs. This forecast will be based on The Body Shop’s historical financial statements to create the best possible financial model going forward. II. Statement of the Problem When Anita Roddick was still CEO, the main problem affecting The Body Shop was not......

Words: 3334 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Written Case Guidelines for Mktg 639

...Participants Sect 01 From: Dr. Keith C. Jones Re: Written Case Project Guidelines In addition to the Live Case, students will work on “written cases”. These cases are designed to provide the students the opportunity to demonstrate their mastery of all marketing related topics and issues. Each student, individually, is required to prepare a 2 to 3 page single spaced typed solution to the case. The solution should be in the format of an executive memo and be very strategic action oriented. If there are questions at the end of the case, unless otherwise directed, questions should only be used as guidelines. Answering only those questions will not be appropriate. The write-up is to be a “management directive” for the company. It should specifically state what the actions of the company should be to operate within the specific situation. This should not be a recantation of the case. On the case days, students will discuss each of their solutions in a simulated boardroom environment. There is no one set solution to the case. The success in this situation for the student is his or her ability to support their recommendations. Students should provide support as to why they feel their individual solution is appropriate. Students are not to “update” the case. Do not assume the actions taken from the time of the writing of the case by the company are the appropriate solutions/approaches to the case. This can be misleading and create myopia. Each write-up......

Words: 417 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Written Case Analysis of Toyota

...Submitted To: Sir Aly Raza Syed Submitted By: Saad Shahzad (12046005-005) M. Umair Arif (12046005-092) M. Ahmad (12046005-099) Noman Zafar (12046005-043) M. Umar (12046005-020) Date of Submission: 13/04/2016 Introduction: The time of the case is December 7, 2006. Sakichi Toyoda is the founder of Toyoda Automatic loom works and has advised his son Kiichiro Toyoda to begin with the idea of developing small engines, and in 1937 it was named as Toyota Motors Corporation. Automobile industry basically operate in pickup trucks, luxury cars, SUV’s and powertrains. The geographical location of the company is Aichi prefecture Japan. Hiroshi Okuda was played the rule of key player In Toyota motors, who joined the company in 1955 and became president in 1995. Toyota motors are competing globally but they have also competitors in their own country like Nissan and Honda and they have global competitors as well such as The U.S Big three which is consists of General Motors (GM), Ford and Chrysler, Volkswagen and BMW. The company deals in Cars, SUV’s and Minivan etc. The general issue of this case should they push for a more aggressive timing of launch or given the technical problems or delay the program to ensure a smoother launch? Situational Analysis External Macro Environment Analysis DEEP-LIST Demographic * With 9 million new registrations, united states was the largest national market......

Words: 5452 - Pages: 22