Premium Essay

“the Idea of a God Is Very Different from That of Aristotle’s Prime Mover.” Discuss.

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By georgewhu
Words 449
Pages 2
The idea and concept of a God can be seen as different from Aristotle’s Prime Mover. The first issue is that Aristotle’s Prime Mover, or God, is said to know only Himself and, therefore, not know about the Earth we inhabit or have any plan for us; He is also unaffected by us. This differs greatly from the God of the Old Testament (OT) and Jewish belief. This is because He willingly created the Universe and was aware of creating the Earth and man in his own image. The God of the OT also involves himself in human activity and displays his power to those described in the Bible. Another issue is that the God of Judeo-Christian belief is an imminent one. God’s creation was a special act of creation; God gave humans a special role in his creation and the relationship between God and humans is set up involving rules that must be obeyed by the humans. Aristotle’s Prime Mover on the other hand is impersonal and transcendent. The Judeo-Christian God is also not entirely immaterial as shown in the Bible; God first walks in the Garden of Eden and then secondly incarnates himself into the human Jesus. This is very different compared to Aristotle’s Prime Mover which is described as spiritual energy rather than being able to perform anything physical. There are similarities however between Aristotle’s Prime Mover and the Judeo-Christian God, one such being that both of them are shown to of created the universe or world for a purpose. Aristotle believed that the universe was a purposeful place and that individuals have a final cause and the ultimate final cause is the Prime Mover, this is similar to the Judeo-Christian God who created a purposeful world. Aristotle’s Prime Mover created the universe out of nothing and that nothing existed before the Prime Mover started the chain of causes and events, this is the same for the Judeo-Christian God who created the universe from…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

From Idea to Opportunities in Entrepreneurship

...2012 Entrepreneurship Homework Format (Should be typed) Common for Ch. 3 TEXT APU ID# | Class ID # | Name | 12409252 | 98 | HOANG Phuong Linh | Three Major Points of Contents | 1.Every opportunity starts with an idea and the ideas that most often lead to successful business first must be something the entrepreneur is truly passionate about. Idea multiplication and its exemplification of IDEO is one of the most useful processes that helps entrepreneur moving from the seed of an idea to something that is robust, exciting and powerful. There are four basic steps in this process: (1) gather stimuli, (2) multiply stimuli, (3) create customer concept and (4) optimize practicality2. Second, the idea is a strong opportunity as measured on the opportunity checklist. To be sure of having strong opportunity, entrepreneurs need a deep understanding of their customer, preferably knowing the customer by name. Better opportunities will have bigger market size and potentially growth in the future. Furthermore, these customers will buy the product frequently and pay a premium price for it (strong margins). Thus entrepreneurs need to be students of the marketplace, learning what trends are converging, and how do these shape customer demand today and into the future3.In order to prevent customers from shifting their attention to competitors, entrepreneurs need understanding competitive dynamics so that entrepreneurs can shape their opportunities to each the customer better than the......

Words: 599 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Ode to God; a Poetic Contemplation of Different Aspects of God

...Eulogy To God Title: Ode To GOD Author: Lekan Ojenike Publisher: Bestworth Books, Lagos Pages: 141 Year: 2010 Reviewer: Blessed Mudiaga Adjekpagbon Lekan Ojenike has, in his latest work, Ode to GOD, shown great reverence to the highest Being worthy of praise and worship. He is an award winning poet and a senior editorial member of the Christ-Herald Literature Ministry, and author of an earlier poetry collection titled, In Still Moments. Ojenike who has also authored a play, The Foolish Wise, that lampoons mankind for their foolishness and stultifies what many people call wisdom, uses Ode to GOD to give desirable praises to the Creator of the Universe in the 141-page book. The joy of reading the book lies mostly in its simplicity of language and subtle and humorous reference to immediate past and current events in Nigeria, especially the inordinate crave for political power that make African leaders want to hang on to power even when it is obvious that their times are up. The book is a ‘poetic contemplation of different aspects of God’. Though most of the qualities of God Ojenike contemplates on in offering praises and worship to God are well known and prevail from time immemorial, the styles the poet in Ojenike employs in his praise and worship are unique. For example, symbols and imageries are localized to enable readers to identify with the metaphors and other figures of speech employed. Therefore, reading the book, it is very glaring that many characteristics of God......

Words: 927 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

(I) Examine the View That the Cosmological Argument Provides an Explanation for the World and Is a Trustworthy Basis for Belief in the Existence of God. (21

...argument provides an explanation for the world and is a trustworthy basis for belief in the existence of God. (21) The cosmological argument, also known as the first cause argument, is a classical argument for the existence of God. The word cosmological comes from the Greek for order and it is an inductive argument as the premises are true but the conclusion may not be, and it is also synthetic where the truth is determined by experience and needs to be proven. It is also a posteriori and also based on natural theology. The Cosmological argument finds its answer for the start of the universe through causes, meaning everything is caused by something, or everything is dependent on something else. The argument attempts to find proof for God’s existence stating that as something cannot come from nothing God must exist in order for anything and everything else to exist. The origins of the cosmological argument come from Greek philosophers Plato and Aristotle. Plato 428-347 BC records one of the earliest versions of the Cosmological arguments in his book of ‘Laws’. Plato writes about the argument through an exchange between an Athenian and Clianis. The Athenian attempts to prove the existence of the gods by arguing that, of all the different types of motion, the motion “which can move itself” is “necessarily the earliest and mightiest of all changes”. It is clear from his argument that infinite regress does not exist therefore implying that there must have been a first......

Words: 1053 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Prime Mover

...Compare the concept of God as a prime mover to the idea of him as a craftsman If we were to accept the concept of God as a prime mover we would then have to accept that while God created humanity, he really wants nothing to do with it. If we were to accept the contrasting view of him as a craftsman then we have to accept that God created us for a reason and wants to forma relationship with us, this has its negativites however. IF we accept that then we must accept that all atrocities that have occurred have happened and God has no qualms with it happening. The support for viewing God as a creator comes from the Book of Genesis. The mention of God in this book has led to the belief that God created the world “ex nihilo” or out of nothing. In Genesis it is also implied that God wants to have a relationship with his creation because he has given them a list of commands to follow (the Ten Commandments.) This draws a parallel with the Aristotelian idea of God as more of a prime mover. This would make God an external agent working with matter, nor is he an agent over against other agents. This two ideas contrast here because if God were to not be against other agents, he would not have banished Lucifer, as it is told in the bible. Another point of conflict between these two ideas of God lies in the problem of evil. If we accept the traditional idea of God as a master craftsman we must accept that he himself made all things in the world and therefore they must be perfect.......

Words: 885 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Kabul, from a Different View

...From the past few days I had been thinking of writing something about the city of Kabul and its residents. Recently, I read an article (Ten things I love about Kabul) by Noor Jahan Akbar, a young social activist who works for the empowerment of women in Afghanistan and the second article was by a DW correspondent titled (Kabul is less conservative), which provoked and motivated me even more to pen down my version and my experience of this city. Though I don’t want to repeat the same things said in the above two articles, I would like to share, so far what different I have observed about here. So here we go… Politics: The people of this land have been into politics since the beginning of the times and I can claim that they are still the most politicized & politics-concerned people on earth. Here almost every TV channel has hourly news broadcasting followed by hours of current affairs programs which has the highest TRP and is aired during prime-times. Almost Everyone considers him/her self a political analyst, wishing to be the future president. A-Z in Tricolor: What do we (afghans) really want to prove?? that we are the most patriotic people on earth. Or we can sacrifice each and everything for this country of ours Or is it just a fashion trend? From headscarves to traditional neck scarves, from carpets to handicrafts, from ties ( even some expats in Kabul use the tricolor ties ) to the traditional cloth belts/rope used in local shalwaar-kameez, to wall clocks,......

Words: 598 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

‘Conscience Is the Voice of God’ Discuss.

...‘Conscience is the voice of god’ Discuss. Most people would agree that conscience is the reasoned voice inside us that guides and tells us what we should and shouldn’t do. However peoples views on the origins of conscience can differ a lot; whether people belief its Gods doing or whether it’s innate or even whether it is acquired. In this essay I will be showing the viewpoints of various philosophers with their beliefs on whether conscience is or isn’t the voice of God. Ultimately I believe that conscience is not the voice of God. John Henry Newman believed that conscience was the voice of God, and that following the suggestions of your conscience gives the same significance as to follow God’s laws and values. Newman used conscience as proof for the existence of God. He said that the fact that we feel guilty, even when it is impossible for anyone to know what we have done, for example, having bad thoughts about someone, proves that ‘there is one to whom we are responsible to’. This feeling we have of being accountable was how Newman saw our conscience. He believed that there must be a God that we are accountable to and the reason we feel guilty for wrong thoughts or actions was because we all knew that someone, who Newman believed was God, was looking down on us and we had to impress him in a sense. However there was a flaw to his theory as he didn’t consider people that perhaps don’t ever feel guilty. Also those who don’t believe in God – do they not have a......

Words: 1152 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Explain the Concept of the Judaeo-Christian God as a Creator

...a creator” The Bible first introduces God as a creator in Genesis. For example, the opening chapter of Genesis begins with the quote “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth” Many fundamentalist Christians would take this quote literally and would use it to support their view that God is the creator of the universe. Jews and Christians both believe that God is the creator of the world and both believe in the God described in the old testament of the bible. Christians and Jews believe that God does things on purpose, he interacts with people and he cares about what they do. God is believed to be omnipresent, omnibenevolent and omnipotent. Creation out of nothing, or creation ex nihilo, is the belief that God created this world out of nothing, ex nihilo being Latin for "from nothing." The Bible is clear that God is the creator of this world, but the controversial issue of how, is always discussed within Christianity. Typically there are two main answers: either God created this world from nothing, or he created this world from pre-existing matter. Within the Bible, there are four main Omni qualities that many Christians believe God to possess. Firstly, God is described to be Omnipotent. This could be defined as ‘all powerful’ A biblical quote to support the view of God being Omnipotent is “Have you an arm like God and can you thunder with a voice like his” (Job 40:9) The quote could suggest that Christians feel that God is the most powerful being in existence...

Words: 964 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Explain Biblical Ideas About the Goodness of God:

...Explain biblical ideas about the goodness of God: The Bible presents God as a morally perfectly good being, everything that he is, could be or ever will be, will be morally perfect like him. The Bible presents God as benevolent, an all loving figure. It displays this in a number of ways throughout the Bible. Everything he does is good and done out of love. He is the source of all goodness and love. His nature is goodness and love. However, it is not a sterile and remote source of goodness (Plato’s Ideal and Aristotle’s P.M). God’s is a goodness born out of a tender and deep relationship with his creation. The first and possible the most important way is in the first book of the Bible, Genesis. The creation account is possible the most important book in both Judaism and Christianity because it provides the evidence of how the earth was created and came into existence and gives prove of God's omnipotence that is unquestionable to both religions. God’s goodness is revealed in the creation and the sustaining of the world, since the creation of the world was an act of love Genesis states that everything that God creates is "Very Good". When God created the world in the Genesis creation account he commanded various things. "And God said, Let there be light: and there was light, and God saw the light, that it was good: and God divided the light from the darkness ". (Genesis 1:34). The authors of the bible when praising God do so because he provides reason for it God provides......

Words: 1524 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Plato's and Aristotle's Views on Knowledge

...Anthony Pulliam Humanities 09/17/2010 Plato's and Aristotle's Views on Knowledge Plato and Aristotle view knowledge and the process whereby it is obtained. They both point out that many epistemological concepts which they believe where knowledge comes from and what it is actually. Most of them have been astonished me in certain ways, but I found that rationalism and "wisdom consists in knowing the cause which made a material thing to be what it is" make the most sense to me regarding the nature of knowledge. As the following, we will discuss about why these two philosophical viewpoints are superior and the others are inferior. Aristotle believes that sensory perception of material objects is knowledge and he says, "Our senses begin the process of finding the answer, because they are physically close to our minds." However, sensations and feelings are very subjective, and the results of sensation vary from person to person and even within the same person, depending on the circumstances. What to one person is cold might be warm to another, one person may be more fatigued in the afternoon than in the morning, so that his or her perceptions may temporarily less accurate. Therefore one cannot claim that sensations provide sure knowledge for human beings. | On the other hand, Aristotle sustains that the perceptions of the senses form the foundation which leads to true knowledge. The senses "give the most authoritative knowledge of particulars" (individual material......

Words: 1414 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

A.) Aristotles Theory of the Four Causes B.) “Aristotle’s Theory of the Four Causes Is Convincing” Discuss.

...a.)  Aristotle’s Theory of The Four Causes. Aristotle argues for and explains the four causes in his books ‘Physics’ and ‘Metaphysics’. He claims that there are only four causes (or explanations) needed to give evidence for change in the world. A complete explanation of the change of any object will use all four causes. These causes are; material, formal, efficient and final. Aristotle understood that each of the four causes was necessary to explain the change from potentiality to actuality.             The material cause is the substance of which something is made out of; "That from which, as a constituent, an object comes into being." The human bodies ‘material causes’ are cells, skin and tissue. A computer’s ‘material cause’ would be its pixels and electronic components. Aristotle used the example of a bronze sculpture or a silver saucer. Bronze or silver, in this case, would be the material cause. The material cause is also a question scientists try and answer when they examine a specimen; they discover what it is made from. The material cause explains the general properties of an object. For example, the human body needs oxygen because its cells need oxygen, and a computer needs electricity because the electronic components need electricity to fuel them. Finally, the material cause can be split into two sectors: proximate matter and prime matter. Proximate matter is matter that has some working properties, such as cells and electronic components. Prime matter has......

Words: 1432 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Discuss the Extent to Which Roman Ideas About Their Gods and the Foundation of Their City Were Influenced by Greek Mythology.

...Discuss the extent to which Roman ideas about their gods and the foundation of their city were influenced by Greek mythology. Ancient Rome is filled with history of great wars and heroes, the mighty and the fallen. They were renowned conquers becoming one of the largest empires of their time. The romans were skilled finding their strengths in the engineering industry as well as the law. Although this ancient civilisation existed millenniums ago, they still effect the times of today. A prime example of this is the language, English. Romans spoke Latin and as they conquered and settled through Europe, “Latin fused with the native languages,” creating the romance languages of today; “Italian, French, Spanish, Portuguese… and Catalan.” The vocabulary of English has also largely derived from the Latin language. Although the current times of today have been influenced by the times of the ancients, the Romans however were influenced to an extent by the ancient Greek’s civilisation. By the 2nd century BC, Rome had a very evident impact from the culture of the Greeks. Greeks had begun to settle on the south then later migrating further north of Italy’s peninsula, and occupying the city of Sicily. There is neither exact date nor event that stipulates the cross of two nations however events such as the Macedonian and Carthage wars of Roman conquest would have aided in the direct contact to Greek colonization. The influence of Greece can be seen throughout every aspect of a......

Words: 1929 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Aristotle's Four Causes

...Aristotle’s four causes Aristotle's Theory of the Four Causes is a theory that explains how everything that is observed in the world appears to have existed through cause and effect. The point is that these four causes can encompass an objects complete description, such as what it's made of, what it looks like, what made it and its purpose. The Causation theory is the basis for much of Aristotle's work, including Physics, Metaphysics, and The Politics. They clearly define Aristotle's way of studying the world around him, which is empirical and observant of what we can see and know; a trait completely different to what Plato taught. The Final Cause differs greatly from the others because it describes something's ultimate purpose, not just a material viewpoint, and God (or the Prime Mover) has to be our Final Cause as he alone is perfection, and everything good that we do is to seek perfection. The first three causes are the Material Cause, the Formal Cause and the Efficient Cause. The Material Cause is what something is made of, and without the material to make the object, the object could not exist. This essay is made up of words, but without words the essay would cease to exist. The Formal Cause is what the shape of an object is, or perhaps the structure of the object that makes it what it is. Without its shape it is just the material that has potential to be an object. This essay is in the shape of an essay; it has a title, is structured in paragraphs, and the......

Words: 540 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Where Do Ideas Come from?

...Where Do Ideas Come From? Consultant Case 1 Meredith Bredeweg BBA 425 Small Business Finance and Financial Analysis Professor Chris Hansen January 25, 2016 Where Do Ideas Come From? Consultant Case 1 Explain how these entrepreneurs exhibit the entrepreneurial spirit? As mentioned by Scarborough, researchers have identified several characteristics that are often found in entrepreneurs. A prime example of one of these characteristics is the future orientation, which seems to be perfectly describe Derek Johnson who listened to his friend at the University of Houston who was often tasked with having to send text messages to a large number of people, which is time consuming and problematic. After hearing the problem, Derek came up with the idea of his company which allowed a person to type the text from a computer, rather than a phone, and send the message to multiple people via text messaging rather than email or social media. Susan Gregg got her love of vintage clothing from her grandmother’s old clothes. After thinking she would just sell her stock pile of clothing, she became aware of the opportunity to make a career of it. Her spirit, enthusiasm, excitement, initiative, commitment, will to succeed and dedication to the venture are examples of the entrepreneur spirit. These are each characteristics of value of achievement over money which is another trait identified in the aforementioned studies.  Have you encountered a “stress point” recently or talked......

Words: 670 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Aristotle's Idea of Philia as Foundation for Human Relationships

...emotions make up a part if not most of our humanity. It can be also called passions like how it was used in antiquity. One of these emotions is love. To feel love and to reciprocate it is proper to rational beings such as the human person. But the term “love” has taken quite different meanings around the globe, a lot of persons even have their own notion of love. It is the one of the most elusive and abused term of mankind. It eludes definition for the reason that one really cannot exhaust love in one specific definition. As Benedict XVI said (2006, p. 7) “In our present context, the term “love” has become one of the most frequently used and misused of words, a word where we attach quite different meanings.” We human persons are capable of expressing and accepting love, since we are endowed with intellect and will aside from our passions. These faculties make it possible for a human to feel being loved and to love back in return. The faculty intellect is the one that perceives and comprehends love, where we can interpret it, while the faculty of the will is the one that is responsible for conveying and reciprocating love. Our acts as human beings such as loving are very much different from those of the animals’. This is because human acts require the use of both the intellect and the will. It requires knowing and willing a particular act, making it voluntary. Aristotle notes that “What is voluntary would seem to be that of which the moving principle is in the......

Words: 5565 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Discuss the Research Into Different Types of Attachment

...Discuss the research into different types of attachment Attachment promotes survival; babies will always need their caregivers. This is the idea that Bowlby put forward. Bowlby explained the three main ways in which secure attachment provides survival. Firstly, safety results in a desire to maintain proximity ensuring safety of the baby and is reflected by both the infant and caregiver being distressed when separated. Attachment enables babies to form healthy emotional relationships. This is the continuity hypothesis – the idea that there is a direct link between early attachment behaviour and later emotional behaviour. The final way attachment promotes survival is a secure base for exploration. Having an attachment is important for protection. A child can explore the world e.g. when they go school and have a safe haven (a safe place) to come back to for protection and comfort. This will ensure that the child develops well intellectually, socially and emotionally. Bus and Van Ijzendoorn (1988) found that securely attached children showed more interest in written material than did the insecurely attached children regardless of their intelligence and the amount of preparatory reading instruction. Maccoby (1980) argued that you can tell two people have an attachment by looking at their behaviours. There are 4 areas he put forward. The first is seeking proximity. This is the desire of the infant and caregiver to be near one another and spend time together for example......

Words: 1633 - Pages: 7