Premium Essay

The Difference Between Legislation and Case Law

In: Other Topics

Submitted By judgenjurysherry
Words 409
Pages 2
1. The case study references one state statute. Identify it and explain what it prohibits.

Tex. Penal Code §42.09(a)(3) It prohibits the “desecration of a venerable object” (Case Study)
2. Which branch of government (executive, judicial, or legislative) created the state statute?
The Legislative branch of the government created the state statute.

3. The passage above also discusses one court case. Who were the parties involved in the case?

The parties involved in this case were the State of Texas and Gregory Johnson.

4. The case was heard by three lower courts before it reached the United States Supreme Court. List those three courts in order, beginning with the court that has the most authority and ending with the court that has the least amount of authority. United States Supreme Court, Texas Court of Appeals, Fifth District,
Dallas County Criminal Court

5. Provide the citation for the United States Supreme Court’s decision in this case.

Texas v. Johnson, 491 U.S. 397 (1989).
6. What effect did the United States Supreme Court’s decision have on the Texas statute?

The United States Supreme Court struck down the statute, stating it violated the First Amendment of the Constitution.

Legislation enacts statutes. Statutes are passed laws. Some statutes are “new law” and some “supersede or adopt common laws” (Yelin, Samborn, 2012). Codification occurs when the Legislative branch of the government “adopts a common law” (Yelin, Samborn, 2012). Statutory law has priority over case law. The course book stated, “Statutes and the U.S. Constitution comprise one body of law called enacted law” (Yelin, Samborn, 2006). In the balance of power in the U.S system, courts may declare Statutes to be unconstitutional if they violate the provisions of the constitution, which “invalidates” the law (Yelin, Samborn, 2006). Courts…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Differences in Types of Law

...III, and Samantha Jones Law 421 September 24, 2012 Karen Hutchins J.D.   From a business perspective it is important to understand distinctions between procedural, substantive, criminal, civil, statutory and case laws. In this paper Learning Team D reviews the differences between the aforementioned types of laws, will provide an example of each, and will provide an example of a constitutional amendment designed to protect businesses and organizations. Each team member will also provide their thoughts on the course topics learned thus far and how those topics relate to each member’s respective business field. Procedural and Substantive Law Procedural law comprises the set of rules that govern the proceedings of the court in criminal lawsuits as well as civil and administrative proceedings. The court needs to conform to the standards setup by procedural law, while during the proceedings. These rules ensure fair and consistency in the “due process”. Substantive law is a statutory law that deals with the legal relationship between people or the people and the state. Therefore, substantive law defines the rights and duties of the people, but procedural law lays down the rules with the help of which they are enforced. (Diffen, 2012) Substantive law is an independent set of laws that decide the fate of a case. It can actually decide the fate of the under-trial, whether he or she wins or loses, and even the compensation amounts etc. Procedural laws on the other hand......

Words: 1520 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Differences Between an Adn and a Bsn

...The Differences Between an Associate Degree Nurse and a Baccalaureate Degree Nurse Grand Canyon University Although the Associate degree in Nursing and the Bachelors degree in nursing ultimately lead to a nursing profession in the health care industry, there are many differences between them. The fast growing complexity of health care and broadening clinical knowledge have forced nurses to have the educational preparation to meet its complex demand. Unlike the Associate degree program (ADN), the Baccalaureate program (BSN), prepares professional nurses whose practice is based upon science in order to restore and maintain health. Both the ADN and the BSN degrees lead to a profession as a registered nurse upon successfully passing the NCLEX board of licensure exam. However there are major differences that set both degrees apart in the Health care industry There are major differences between the ADN and BSN degrees. One of the differences is the length of time required to complete both programs. The Associate degree requires two years of course work to complete whereas the Bachelors degree normally requires four years of course work. In some instances it but could be less especially in cases where the prospective student already has a bachelors degree in another field or an associate degree in nursing from a community college. In comparing the competencies of both the ADN and BSN degrees both programs produce competent......

Words: 838 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Differences Between Advertisements and Contracts

...Certification of Authorship: As a student of American InterContinental University I pledge that all tests taken by me, and that all work submitted by me, will be original and solely the results of my own efforts. _______________________ ABSTRACT In this paper we are asked to answer specific questions concerning the case involving a man from Seattle who filed a lawsuit against a very popular soft drink company in regards to a Harrier Jet that the man alleges was promised as part of an offer through advertisement. I will discuss the objective theory of contracts, the four essential elements of a valid contract and how they correlate to the case mentioned above. I will also bring light as to why this specific case did not succeed in court and how this case was different from any other case that used the same approach to customers through advertisements. When dealing with contracts there are 4 essential elements that make a contract valid. These 4 elements would start off with an offer, then Acceptance, intention of legal consequences, and then consideration. An offer means that clear, definite statement to do something must occur. Estimates, requests for proposals and letter of intentions do not count. With an offer of course comes an acceptance. An acceptance is when the offer brought to a person whether it’s a verbal or written agreement is accepted. Acceptance of the term in its exact form......

Words: 1496 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Reviewing a Case Study and Explaining Differences in Law

... PA 205-01 Unit 1 Assignment * Read case study * Describe the difference between legislation and case law The main difference between legislation and case law is who makes them. Legislation (or statutory) law consists of laws that are passed by the legislature, that is legislative branch of the U.S. government, or other governing agency. Examples of legislation include rule regulations and statutes. Judges can interpret what legislative law signifies if a dispute arises about a particular statute’s meaning. Also, a judge can declare a statute unconstitutional if it conflicts with the U.S. Constitution or state constitution. Case law is court or judge made law. It is also referred to as common law. Case law, on the other hand, is not based in origin by the government or legislature but evolves with new decisions made by a judge or court (Cheeseman & Goldman, 2010). * Answer Questions 1. List a statute from the case study and explain what it prohibits The statute in the case of Texas v. Johnson was Texas Penal Code section 42.09(a)(3). This statute prohibited disorderly conduct by a citizen. The Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute (LII) noted that in this case, Gregory Johnson’s desecration of a venerable object (the U.S. flag) was viewed as disorderly conduct and a direct violation of this Texas statute ("Texas v.......

Words: 1160 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Differences Between Csr and Pr

...Discuss the relationship between CSR and PR and analyze the ethical issues that arise. How may practitioners ensure their CSR programs are more than just rhetoric? CSR "Corporate Social Responsibility is the continuing commitment by business to behave ethically and contribute to economic development while improving the quality of life of the workforce and their families as well as of the local community and society at large".(Lord Holme and Richard Watt-Making good business sense) CSR has become a relevent issue in the business field. Nowdays people judge a companys reputation with the way how they deal with their social and environmental responsibilities. Sevral studies revealed that responsible ativities are increasingly valued and demanded by stakeholders.(consumers, investors, community,journalist etc) who see in such activities the civic behavior of bussinesses, and which in turn influences their evaluation of the companies. According to study carried out by MORI in UK indicates that ,75% consumers while evaluating a company considers its level of social responsibility to be important, almost 90% of employees believe that their company should be socially responsible, almost 40% of analyst and investors consider it very important while evaluating the company and over 50 % of journalists consider social responsibility to be very important while judging the company. CSR can be better understood as a means of reinforcing both reputation and legitimacy, as it provides......

Words: 1453 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Difference Between Law and Rules

...Difference Between Rules and Laws • Categorized under Grammar,Language | Difference Between Rules and Laws Rules vs Laws The main difference between rules and laws is the consequences associated with breaking them. While each is developed to invoke a sense of order, fair play, and safety, the weight of a law is much heavier than the weight of a rule. Laws are like the legal version of rules. When you are a child, a parent sets rules to be followed. When you are in a society, the government sets laws to be followed. When a rule is broken, the consequences tend to be uncomfortable but mild in comparison to the breaking of a law. Laws are enforced by a higher governmental office, usually the police and the prosecutor’s office. Laws are written in specific code so that they can be interpreted as needed. When you break a law there is legal action that follows, provided that you are caught. Rules are more flexible and carry low end consequences. You can set up rules for games, rules for the home, even rules for fighting or being intimate with a partner. Rules are personal in nature, and they are often adjusted as the conditions and circumstances of the home change. Laws must be passed through due process in order to take effect. A law starts off as a bill, and must go through a series of checks, balances, and votes in order to become a law. Rules are merely set and adjusted as the need arises, and should be followed out of respect for those setting the rules. Rules help us...

Words: 5737 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Difference Between and Felony and Misdemeanor

...The Difference between a felony and misdemeanor Laura Macella AIU Online The Difference between a felony and misdemeanor Abstract In this paper it will be discussed the differences between a felony and a misdemeanor. There will be examples of real life situations and memo discussing to a client the differences between the two. It will be discussed to the client that was charged with breach of peace about the crime she committed, her concerns about prison and the death sentences, and the punishments that she will possibly face if she is convicted. There are two divisions that a crime can fall under. When a crime is committed, the crime can fall either under a misdemeanor or a felony charge. Misdemeanors are usually small, petty crimes that one commits which are usually punishable by a fine, short jail sentence usually less than 1 year, or community service. When talking about a felony they are much more serious crimes, which will carry a severe sentence of more than a year in jail or even a death sentence. According to Money Matters 101, a misdemeanor is a less criminal act in many common law systems ( A misdemeanor are generally less severe crimes that are committed and are usually punished with fines, community service, a less than 12 months in jail. Misdemeanors usually don’t result in the loss of civil rights, but if you are convicted of a misdemeanor, you might find it difficult to obtain a professional license or public employment......

Words: 1682 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Differences Between Leadership and Management

...main differences between leaders and managers are: the relationship between the followers and managers and leaders, how leaders and managers solve problems, and the difference in emotional intelligence between leaders and managers. Leaders and managers have a difference in emotional intelligence. A leader is an individual who strategizes a visionary and most importantly someone who inspires other people to greatness. In order to achieve this, while leading one must share their vision with the staff or people brought together to solve a problem or create a strategy. Leaders serve as role models, motivate their staff, inspire cooperation and create a community both inside and outside of the organization. They mostly follow their intuition which in most cases benefits the company and in most cases they gain followers who become loyal to them and the organization. This is a direct contradiction to managers who carry out their instructions by the book and follow the organization’s policy to the letter and as a result the staff may or may not be loyal to them. Even when the idea of a divinely appointed leader prevailed, there existed a contrary view that the leader was actually empowered by followers, this theory was analyzed by Thomas Paine “Titles are but nicknames…it is common opinion only that makes them anything or nothing . . . . [A]body of men, holding themselves accountable to nobody, ought not to be trusted by anybody” (1944, pp. 59-60, 63). Another major difference......

Words: 1093 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Differences Between Ethics and Law

...THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN ETHICS AND LAW DEFINITION OF ETHICS In general, ethics is a moral philosophy where a person makes a specific moral choice and sticks to it. On the other hand, ethics in computing means moral guidelines to refer to when using the computer and computer networks. This includes the Internet. DEFINITION OF LAW Law is a legal system comprising of rules and principles that govern the affairs of a community and controlled by a political authority. Law differs from one country to another. In the era of technology, computer law is needed to clarify goods or actions that fall under the computer law. Computer law refers to all areas in law that requires an understanding of computer technology such as hardware, software and Internet. Examples of laws of computing in Malaysia include the Malaysian Communication and Multimedia Act, the Computer Crime Act 1997 and the Telemedicine Act 1997. WHY DO WE NEED ETHICS & LAW IN COMPUTING? Ethics and law are needed i computing to: • • • Respect Ownership Respect Privacy & Confidentiality Respect Property Respect Ownership We must respect ownership by not stealing other people’s work either by duplicating or distributing it. Duplicating and distributing copies of audio tapes, video tapes and computer programs without permission and authorisation from the individual or company that created the program are immoral and illegal. Respect Privacy & Confidentiality We should respect other people's privacy and confidentiality by...

Words: 552 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Differences Between Aql and Olap

...Differences between AQL and OLAP Auteur Peter den Heijer Adres Veldhofstraat 16 Postcode 7213 AM Plaatsnaam Gorssel Emailadres Telefoonnummer 0575-490719 Datum 26 mei 2012 Opleidingsinstituut CAI Opleiding Business Intelligence Opleidingscode BUSI1201UTRx Docent Emiel Caron Versie 3.0 Pagina 1 van 19 Inhoud 1. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 3 2. Business Case................................................................................................................................... 3 3. Central Research Question .............................................................................................................. 3 4. Purpose............................................................................................................................................ 3 5. Sub Questions.................................................................................................................................. 4 6. Research Methodology and Scope .................................................................................................. 4 7. Introduction Qlikview ...................................................................................................................... 4 8. Definition of......

Words: 4959 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Law - Consitution, Legislation

...Sources of law: a. 宪法constitutional i. Federal constitution: 1. Treaty with other countries: approved by 2/3 of senate; signed by president 2. What the government can and cannot do ii. State constitution: cannot conflict with federal constitution b. Statutory Law : 指的是"实定法",是指经立法机关制订通过的法律条文。法院诉讼审判依据,即是这个既存的法律条文,而非过去的判例。  iii. Federal statutory law: Law starting from senate(参议院) , and then house of representatives(众议院); finally vote or veto by president; such as Act 1934 iv. State statutory law: law starting from state senate, and then state assembly. Finally, signed or veto by governor c. Common law/ Case law/judge made law: 简单而言,就是"判例法"的意思;就是说,法院在进行诉讼审判时,寻求过去的司法判例当作审判依据,根据的是"平等原则"(或者说"正义原则"),亦即"相同的诉讼,有相同的审判结果",因此对当事人有了公平与正义的保障。  v. Law made through interpretation by judges of common law, constitution, statutes, & admin law d. Administrative law:行政法 II. Graph III. Law v. Equity: e. Law can get monetary damage f. Equity can get injunction, specific performance, rescission g. Controlling precedents: supreme court binds all; us court of appeal bind with US district court. IV. School of law thoughts h. Natural law school: 法律正道是国家制订的法律之外的、存在于人的内心中的自然法,而非由人们的协议产生的规则本身的法学学派 i. Positivist school:there is no law higher than the law created by the government j. Historical: passage of time to shape present laws ......

Words: 566 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Difference Between Law and Morality

...Assignment: Difference between Law and Morality Instructor: Mr.Garmon Student: Mr. Rupert L.Griffith 03/31/15 The Debate between Law and Morality: Laws are absolute rules prescribed by government representatives, while morality has to do with personal views on what is right or wrong. A major difference between these two concepts is that a law is formal public policy that has consequences for those who violate it. Someone who murders or steals, for instance, goes to jail if found guilty in court. In contrast, someone who violates what others view as a moral standard may have no tangible consequence other than damaged relationships. Laws are sometimes viewed as legislation on moral issues. Many people lean on religious beliefs to frame their moral viewpoints. Politicians and some citizens also point to faith-based principles in suggesting that laws should follow what God commands. Others believe that laws should protect individual rights and freedoms but should not extend to topics viewed as ethical gray areas. In some cases, laws and morals evolve over time based on changing societal views. The Civil Rights laws of the 1950s and 1960s developed as Americans became more supportive of an end to segregation. Sometimes, though, principle-based politicians and leaders look to enact laws based on personal convictions, even though they may contradict the popular opinion of the time. My Position on this View: This would lend itself to the current “Religious freedom Law”......

Words: 584 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Difference Between Juvenile and Criminal

...Difference between Juvenile and Criminal Justice System David E. Foster Kaplan College – Las Vegas Campus CJ 150 Professor Laura Fletcher December 5, 2013 Difference between Juvenile and Criminal Justice System How would it feel if our children were being treated like adults in the criminal justice system; getting sentenced for life without parole, or maybe have your child sentenced to death as a teenager. Well thanks to our juvenile justice system they discipline adolescent different than adult, the system is design to solely handle children’s matters. The juvenile court system is a dedicated court, for an adolescent which is intended to encourage rehabilitation for youth in a structure of procedural due process whereas the criminal justice system is designed to punish adults who choose not to obey the laws. It has concern for acting in the best interest of the child and the greatest interest of public safety. A juvenile court judge has to be elected or appointed to be in charge of juvenile cases and his or her decision can only be reviewed by another judge but from a higher court. Some of his duties might consist of making a decision if the juvenile should stay in detention prior to trail or release them to their parents; also the judge handles all waiver proceedings meaning if the crime committed is that serious where the judge thinks the juvenile should be treated like an adult, then he can give them a waiver into the adult justice system. As for......

Words: 906 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Environmental Law Legislations

...Practical Difficulties of Enforcement of Legislation of Conservation of Species Legislation for the conservation of species is notoriously difficult to enforce for several reasons. Long lists of species are of relatively little use if few people can recognise the species concerned. The negative listing approach may help considerably in this respect, as public and enforcement personnel have only to be able to recognise a relatively small number of authorized species, as has the 'small bunch' rule for plants. An element of intention is often required in order for an offence to have been committed, yet this may be extremely difficult to prove and it is more usual for good faith to be presumed. In this context, the hunting proficiency test is particularly valuable. Hunters who have passed the test have learned about protected species and would therefore have greater difficulty in pleading ignorance of the specimens they may have taken or damaged unlawfully. Reversing the burden of proof can contribute significantly to effective enforcement. The effect of such a reversal is that possession of a specimen of a given species is deemed to be unlawful, unless the possessor can prove otherwise. For example, under the Customs Code in France, the possessor of CITES specimens must be able to prove that these have been lawfully obtained. However, great care must be taken if an offence is deemed to be one of strict criminal liability, as there may be a serious risk of injustice......

Words: 1314 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Difference Between Jails and Prison

...Difference between Jail and Prison CJS 200 February 7, 2012 Difference between Jail and Prison When you talk about Jail and Prison, they both house people who have committed crimes but there is a difference. Jails are usually run by Counties and then you have a central area where they house people from all the surrounding areas. These are usually criminals handled for short periods of time. They stay here untill they go to court and their crimes are minor crimes. If they are sentenced to more than two years they are usually transferred to prison (based on interview with released inmate) and they even have people who serve on week-ends only. These are minimum security people . (Sheriff Millrons, Giles County Police Department). The past three paragraphs are based on my talking with the Sheriff. Prisons are state run and they hold people who have broken laws and are given a number of years to serve. You can be moved far away from your home, while still in the state, if you are sentenced to a prison term in your state. They have exercise areas, common areas for church and educational rooms, libraries, and area for holding them in solitary confinement if that becomes necessary. A prison can hold more prisoners and they have maximum and minimum security areas, depending on the inmates. They have a white collar crime prison in West Virginia where they send people who will not be a threat to anyone. They have embezzled money or hacked computers, anything......

Words: 342 - Pages: 2