Premium Essay

The Case of Birthright Citizenship

In: English and Literature

Submitted By 022096ga
Words 318
Pages 2
I do not think Chavez expected her audience to agree with her position as it was posted in the politically conservative section of the Wall Street Journal. Before I read the political background section of Linda Chavez, I had thought the author to be liberal. But after reading the excerpt I the beginning of the publication, I noticed that she was a Hispanic Conservative. I could tell that Linda Chavez did not expect her audience to agree with her when she stated that “Repealing birthright citizenship is a terrible idea.” Most conservatives wish to dismiss birthright citizenship, but in this passage she explains the significance of it, and what it would do to the future of the nation. One example is when she explains the origins of birthright citizenship dating back to 1898 with the Chinese. She also states the first immigration restrictions on the Chinese due to the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. Another example of Chavez that states upon American History is the Supreme Court Case U.S v. Wong Kim Ark. These statements support her argument by giving actual representation within early American History of a case/example involving birthright citizenship. Through her appeal to logos with these statements of American History it makes the audience evoke a much rational, cognitive response. Therefore her statements made in the story are very convincing due to a real reference from history.
Style and Structure I believe that the logical fallacy Chavez claims that her opponents commit is the belief that the Fourteenth Amendment was passed for the citizenship to the freed slaves, and not for the children of illegal aliens. I do not agree with Chavez that her opponents had committed a logical fallacy. At the time of the emancipation of slaves, the now freed slaves needed to somehow be citizens of America, because they were now part of our nation and no longer considered…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Corporate Citizenship

...Corporate citizenship is a term used to describe a company role in the society, many times people has changed the name for social responsibility of the corporations and in one way it´s true but we are missing a very important part in it definition, the part we are missing is that companies are like a citizen with a territory so they have their assets and they can sue or be sued, and when you seen the corporate citizenship like this you can understand that also the companies has all the rights that the people has, for example the right of free speech, participate in the politics of the country where they are and other rights that everyone has, but this is only in some countries because in another countries the companies are the ones who have to do everything and the country or government doesn´t give any right or benefit to them. The corporate citizenship has been present from many years or decades ago but only from 2000s many companies start to enter in this title if we can say it like this, this happen because in many countries the people start to buy the ideas that those companies that were social responsible were better than the others ones, so this become in a competition. The government also helps and gives many benefits to the companies that where social responsible and with this everyone wants to be a corporate citizenship and start many programs or regulations to become one. There are three ways to see the corporate citizenship in the world and this theory or......

Words: 577 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Immigration and Birthright Citizenship

...Immigration and Birthright Citizenship Many people feel the issue on immigration and birthright citizenship may have become a touchy subject. Some people argue that the undocumented citizens or illegal immigrants steal jobs away from rightful US citizens. Also people say that the undocumented citizens want to have a baby in the United States of America with the assumption they will grant US citizenship to them as a family. In certain states the police were allowed to stop anyone that they felt to not hold US citizenship just by looking at them. With this thinking different ethnic groups have been looked down on and even discriminated against. Some people just see the color of the person and form an opinion against a certain group of people, mainly minority groups, without knowing their true status. The fourteenth Amendment provides citizenship to the child of anyone who gives birth in the United States of America. Elizabeth Wydra, Chief Counsel, of the American accountability center writes, “the words and history of this constitutional text establish that it provides automatic citizenship-"birthright citizenship"-to anyone born in this country regardless of race, color or status of one's parents or ancestors.”(Wydra) Some people argue by doing this undocumented immigrants gain access to America by slipping through the cracks. “Along with the grand statements supporting liberty and equality, ethnic stereotypes and racial hostility were also on full display in the......

Words: 988 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Birthright of Citizenship

...The Birthright Citizenship Amendment is one that has caused controversy. Should  a person that is  born in the US, regardless of whether the parents were here temporarily, or illegally be considered an American citizen? The 14th Amendment states “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the States wherein they reside”, ( Spalding, 2010). The interpretation of this amendment has caused the controversy.      Those opposed to ending the clause in the Birthright Citizenship Amendment argue “The framers' intent was to create an objective basis for establishing citizenship—birth—not a subjective standard left to the whim of a majority. The United States has, for that reason, never struggled like other nations to integrate those born here” ( Fitz, 2010). These people feel that the children born here will always feel stigmatized if not accepted as an American citizen, and this will do more harm than good for our nation.      Those who seek to end this clause have a different perspective “It violates bedrock American principles and undermines the rule of law” ( Spalding, 2010).  He goes on to say that he has no problem with legal immigrants having children who are automatically given birthright citizenship, but this right should exclude illegal immigrants or temporary visitors.      I tend to agree with Spalding on this. I do not feel it is fair or beneficial to give Birthright......

Words: 711 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Citizenship Debate

...Citizenship Debate Part II Purpose and Audience 2. I do not think Chavez expected her audience to agree with her position as it was posted in the politically conservative section of the Wall Street Journal. Before I read the political background section of Linda Chavez, I had thought the author to be liberal. But after reading the excerpt I the beginning of the publication, I noticed that she was a Hispanic Conservative. I could tell that Linda Chavez did not expect her audience to agree with her when she stated that “Repealing birthright citizenship is a terrible idea.” Most conservatives wish to dismiss birthright citizenship, but in this passage she explains the significance of it, and what it would do to the future of the nation. 4. One example is when she explains the origins of birthright citizenship dating back to 1898 with the Chinese. She also states the first immigration restrictions on the Chinese due to the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. Another example of Chavez that states upon American History is the Supreme Court Case U.S v. Wong Kim Ark. These statements support her argument by giving actual representation within early American History of a case/example involving birthright citizenship. Through her appeal to logos with these statements of American History it makes the audience evoke a much rational, cognitive response. Therefore her statements made in the story are very convincing due to a real reference from history. Style and Structure 2. I believe......

Words: 939 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Citizenship Obligation

...rights. A citizen may also be subject to certain duties, such as a duty to uphold law and to serve in the military. A person may have multiple citizenships and a person who does not have citizenship of any state is said to be stateless. He is endowed with legal rights by, and duties to, the country of which one is a citizen. Citizens are the people who owe allegiance to a government and are entitled to be protected by this government. They are the nationals of a city, state and country. They can be inhabitants or in diaspora. Citizens are entitled to be protected, by the government in which they owe allegiance, in terms of security, safety and against molestation by any individual, group, organisation or country. Nationality is often used as a synonym for citizenship in English – notably in international law – although the term is sometimes understood as denoting a person's membership of a nation. In some countries, e.g. the United States, Israel, Philippines and the United Kingdom, "nationality" and "citizenship" have different meanings. Thus, a Nigeria citizen is someone who is allowed to vote in Nigeria state and federal elections, to serve in the Nigeria armed forces, to pass that citizenship on to their spouse and/or children, is entitled to state and federal social services, and who must file state and federal taxes. In Nigeria, Citizenship is based upon the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria. A good citizen is one who properly fulfills his or her role as......

Words: 1422 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Citizenship

...Mississippi Nationalization in Israel If you want to be an Israeli citizenship you can may be acquired by birth, the Law of Return, residence or naturalization. The nationality by birth is granted to a person who were born in Israel, who born outside and has father or mother that holds Israeli citizenship. You can apply for it in the period between 18 and 25 years old and/or have been residents of israel for five consecutive years, immediately preceding the day of the filing of their application. If a person wants the acquisition of nationality according to the Law of Return, this Law grants every Jew, wherever he may be, the right to go to Israel as an Oleh ( a Jew Immigrating to Israel) and become an Israeli citizen. The citizenship becomes effective on the day of arrival in the country or of receipt of an oleh’s certificate. The nationality by residence is granted to those who remained in Israel from the establishment of the State in 1948 until the enactment of the Nationality Law of 1952, became Israeli citizens by residence or by return or if a person wants to acquire the nationality by naturalization he or she must have resided in Israel for three years out of the five years preceding the day of submission of the application, the person is entitled to reside in Israel permanently and has settled or intend to settle in Israel or has renounced his/her prior nationality or proved will cease to be foreign nationals upon becoming Israeli citizens....

Words: 258 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Citizenship

...the majority of the country’s immigrants come from Asia and Latin America. US citizens have certain responsibilities as active members of this country and these responsibilities require you to participate in the political process by registering and voting in elections. Also, serving on a jury is another important required responsibility. Finally, respecting different opinions, ethnic groups, cultures and religions found in this country. Illegal immigrants living and often working in the United States have some rights under the US constitution despite their immigration status. Even if you are in this country illegally, the fourteenth amendment still applies to these non-documented illegal immigrants. The fourteenth amendment addresses citizenship rights and equal protection of the laws. As for regular legal citizens, illegal citizens still have the right to defend themselves and file law suits.   Today, illegal immigration has become an issue in the United States.  The U.S. is one of the Countries with the most undocumented immigrants.  Illegal immigration is a problem that affects all Americans.  There are many problems that develop such as overpopulation, rising crime rates, and unemployment.  There are eleven million undocumented immigrants living in the United States.  The reason for this is because they want to find jobs here and start a better life here than where they were living before.  The majority of the immigrants come from Mexico (60%).  President......

Words: 908 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Citizenship

...religion Freedom of expression Freedom of assembly and association Right to marry and start a family Protection from discrimination in respect of these rights and freedoms Right to peaceful enjoyment of your property Right to education Right to participate in free elections How the UK government have enforced human and legal rights The UK Gov and Ministry Of Defence has taken actions against atrocities caused by UK soldiers overseas. Following the human rights act of 1998, a British soldier has been jailed for stabbing a 10-year-old boy while serving in Afghanistan. Grenadier Guardsman Daniel Crook was jailed for 18 months and dismissed from the Army in June for stabbing Ghulam Nabi in Helmand Province. This is just one of many cases in where the MOD and the UK government have taken actions to apply the human rights act. This is a positive movement that has affected the world we live in today because it shows that we as human beings will protect people from overseas if that means prosecuting our own if they have done anything wrong. The Human Rights Act 1998 came into force in the United Kingdom in October 2000. All public bodies; such as courts, police, local governments, hospitals, publicly funded schools and many others plus bodies carrying out public functions have to comply with the Convention rights. The Human Rights Act 1998 came into force in the United Kingdom in October 2000. All public bodies; such as courts, police, local governments,......

Words: 1186 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Citizenship

...Citizenship Interview (Naturalization) Background of interviewee (paragraph) Juan Ramos was born in Medellin, Colombia in March 26 1998. He lives in Miami Florida with his dad and his brother and has been here for the last 14 years of his life. He currently works at Publix, but his aspiration is to join the United States Marine Corps. Gallego has always loved America and will always continue to love America. Interview What inspired you to become a U.S. citizen? • Interviewee: Juan Ramos was inspired to become an US citizen so that he could join The Military What steps did you have to take as part of the naturalization process? • Interviewee: My dad applied for citizenship and since I’m a minor I was also granted citizenship. How would you describe how you felt about the process? • Interviewee: The process was extremely long it took me and my family almost 13 years to finally get citizenship How has gaining citizenship changed your life? Is your daily life different because of gaining citizenship? • Interviewee: My life hasn’t really changed much ever since I got citizenship because I’ve always loved this country. Do you feel the process was worthwhile? • Interviewee: Yes I do believe that this process was worthwhile because now I can move on forward with my dream of joining the military If you had to, would you do it again? Please explain. • Interviewee: Absolutely I love this country and I am glad that I am a citizen of the United States of......

Words: 436 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Citizenship

...Citizenship Midterm Report: United States D0393920 - Robert A. Spearman What is the human rights status in your country ? use your own word, make a brief introduction to the status and / or development of equality rights and social rights of your nation. Are there things to do to make improvement for the status? Guidelines: * Equality between sexes * Racial equality * Religion equality * Classes equality * Education right * Property Right * Environmental Right * Right to Privacy The United States of America is a country where its foundation was built up by a large diversity of religion and races from all parts of the globe. A major portion of the population however, is consisted of Caucasians, or in simpler words, white people. The US history was and still is full of conflicts between different races and major disputes between people of different skin colors. One of the major issues from its past is the slave system before and during the Civil War. We also had a deep history of keeping balance between sexes and justice rights. These problems are still addressed in the present day although compared to the past being fewer, still remain occurring in the country’s barriers and are in need to be resolved. The United States is far from being a perfect country, it never was one, and still needs years to come in order to improve. One of the key topics to be addressed in this article is the abuse of the......

Words: 939 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Citizenship

...Fax: 0845 60 333 60 Textphone: 0845 555 60 Please quote ref: 00045-2007DOM-EN ISBN: 978-1-84478-883-5 PPSLS/D35/0107/14 © Crown Copyright 2007 Produced by the Department for Education and Skills Extracts from this publication may be reproduced for non commercial education or training purposes on the condition that the source is acknowledged. For any other use please contact HMSOlicensing@cabinet-office.x.gsi.gov.uk DIVERSITY & CITIZENSHIP You can download this publication or order copies online at: www.teachernet.gov.uk/publications Diversity and Citizenship Curriculum Review Review Group members Sir Keith Ajegbo retired in July 2006 as Headteacher of Deptford Green School, a multiethnic school with a strong reputation for Citizenship education. He is currently working as a coach on the Future Leaders Project, as a School Improvement Partner, and as an education consultant for UBS. He is also a Governor of Goldsmiths College and a trustee of the Stephen Lawrence Trust. Dr Dina Kiwan is a Lecturer in Citizenship Education at Birkbeck College, University of London. Previously she was seconded to the Home Office as the Head of Secretariat to the Advisory Board for Naturalisation and Integration (ABNI), carrying forward the implementation of the recommendations of the former ‘Life in the UK’ Advisory Group chaired by Sir Bernard Crick. Seema Sharma, is an Assistant Headteacher at Deptford Green School in South East London. She has been a......

Words: 37771 - Pages: 152

Free Essay

Citizenship

...about everything and will also not judge someone because they’re different to them. Teachers will also have to believe in equality and make every student feel welcome otherwise it looks bad on the school, for example there was a school that limited the time Asians could have a break because they were fighting with whites, they were all fighting each other but only Asians got punished. It is also important for public servants to believe in equality because if they don’t they will either lose their job or won’t be able to do their jobs properly. One of the biggest accusations of the police being racist is that they tend to stop black people more than any other race although it’s mainly in America were people believe this but there have been case in the UK were the police were thought of as racists, for example the death of Mark Duggan at the hands of police because they thought he was armed with a hand gun, this then sparked a protest which turned into rioting across the country. Also the importance of understanding diversity in public services like the police or ambulance is key because for them to do their job to the best of their ability they will have to understand the needs of the public. An example could be the death of Jenny-Lee who died of leukaemia along with her unborn baby Aroura because it was against her religion to have a blood transfusion. The ambulance service would then respect her beliefs and let her and her unborn child die. That example could also be a......

Words: 1207 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Citizenship

...Australian citizenship General eligibility This information is provided to help you complete the application form and guide you through the application process. Important – Please read this information carefully before you complete your application. Once you have completed your application we strongly advise that you keep a copy for your records. There are 10 steps in the citizenship application process. Step 1 Eligibility – ensure that you meet the eligibility criteria Step 2 Residence requirement – check that you meet the residence requirement Step 3 Read the citizenship test resource book Australian Citizenship: Our Common Bond for the information you need to prepare for the citizenship test Step 4 Original documents – gather your original documents and have copies certified Step 5 Complete your application form Step 6 Lodge your application form with your nearest office of the Department of Immigration and Citizenship (the department) 1300t Step 1 – Eligibility You should use this form if you meet the general eligibility criteria for Australian citizenship, that is, you: • are aged 18 years or over and under 60 • are a migrant who is a permanent resident • satisfy the residence requirement (see Step 2) • are likely to reside, or to continue to reside, in Australia or to maintain a close and continuing association with Australia, and • are of good character. The Citizenship Wizard on the citizenship......

Words: 10898 - Pages: 44

Free Essay

Philippines Citizenship

...“those born before January 7, 1973, of Filipino mothers, who elect Philippine citizenship upon reaching the age of majority.       Even if the child is born to an alien father and a Filipino mother, the Filipino citizenship of the mother will bestow natural-born Philippine citizenship upon the child PROVIDED his birth occurred on or after January 17, 1973 (date of ratification of the 1973 Constitution), otherwise he followed the citizenship of the alien father and acquired at best only an inchoate Philippine citizenship which he could perfect by election upon attaining majority age.  EXCEPT if he is born out of lawful wedlock, in which case, he will be considered a Filipino by virtue of his mother’s citizenship.       In addition, only natural-born citizens are allowed to hold constitutional offices such as the office of the President; Senators; Members of the House of Representatives; Members of the Supreme Court; and the Chairman and Commissioners of the Constitutional Commissions (Civil Service Commission, COMELEC and the Commission on Audit). NATURALIZED FILIPINO       Naturalization takes place either voluntarily by complying both the substantive and procedural requirements of the general naturalization law or by operation of law. This process may be direct or derivative.     Under the Commonwealth Act 473, a foreigner who is not married to a Filipino but seeks to acquire Philippine citizenship is required to have lived in the Philippines for a continuous......

Words: 11780 - Pages: 48

Free Essay

Citizenship

...Paper on Citizenship Introduction Citizenship is being defined as the relationship between the state and individuals. Historically citizenship is being inevitably linked with the state formation. Originally citizenship was denoting residence of people within protected walls of a city. Thus, whoever belonged to a community residing inside the boundaries was considered a citizen. Later this term has acquired a different meaning and the standards and definitions of citizenship have changed. There were many reasons that have caused such changes: history proceeded with its migrations, wars and annexation and along on its way brought new meanings to citizenship. Such change in definition, for example, can be found in suffrage granted to women and the nonpropertied classes. Paupers, convicts and soldiers are another example of how political and civil rights were once a privilege of certain classes only (Dahrendorf, 1974, p. 11). With the introduction of mass democracy and social protection as well as introduction of welfare state a need in the new conception that would look on the relationship on an individual and the state appeared consequently. The norms of citizenship, therefore, have improved with the development of state and citizenship became a multination concept, which implies different things to different nations (Dahrendorf, 1974, p. 12). According to Michael Ignatieff (1995), the introduction of the welfare state can be explained as an attempt to make citizenship “a......

Words: 5963 - Pages: 24