Premium Essay

Regressive Tax

In: Business and Management

Submitted By gallagherkl
Words 575
Pages 3
Subject: Argument for Implementing Regressive Income Tax
The primary income taxation structure in the United States should be a regressive tax structure. A regressive tax rate decreases with an increase in the tax base. This means, the lower the amount of income a person earns, the greater the share of that income will go towards paying taxes. The income tax should become a regressive tax because every tax bracket would then pay roughly the same dollar amount in taxes to the government out of income. Everyone paying the same dollar amount in taxes makes all tax payers equal. The negative impact of this is that lower income earners will pay a higher percentage of their income to taxes. This does not necessarily make a regressive income tax unfair. The main argument in favor of using a regressive tax is that every level of income would pay the same monetary amount of taxes. The dollar amount of a smaller tax on a greater income will be approximately equal to the dollar amount of a large tax on a smaller income. Thus, the regressive tax can be seen as being fair since all citizens will be paying the same amount of taxes. Another reason to convert the income tax into a regressive tax is to teach lower income earners the value of money. To explain, the government implements excise taxes in order to encourage or discourage certain behavior. For example, a higher tax is placed on alcohol and cigarettes to discourage purchase of those items. A regressive tax rate can be compared to an excise tax. If the people who earn less income are taxed at a higher rate, they might realize how important saving money is. This would teach lower income earners better money management by decreasing excess spending. The money the lower income earners will save can help them in the long run. An argument against regressive tax looks at the “fairness” characteristic from…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Fair Tax

...30-40% of our hard earned money really rubs me the wrong way. There is a very common sense solution to this serious problem that is being very seriously discussed and considered in our Congress. It is a plan called the Fair Tax. Legislative Status: The FairTax has been reintroduced for the 111th Congress. It is H.R. 25 in the House and S. 296 in the Senate. Benefits of the FairTax: The FairTax plan brings fairness, transparency, and efficiency to our unfair, complex, and confusing Tax Code. The FairTax rewards job creation, hard work, and individual responsibility. By doing away with payroll taxes, companies can afford to hire more employees and outsourcing looks less attractive. By taxing consumption instead of income, individuals are provided with a strong incentive to work hard because they keep more of what they earn. By taxing spending, the FairTax allows us to control how much tax we pay depending on our individual lifestyle choices. The FairTax ensures that all Americans pay their fair share of taxes. By placing the tax at the point of sale, no individual or special interest group could evade taxes with the help of an expensive tax attorney or well-funded lobbyist. We could stop making criminals out of ordinary Americans who prepare their tax returns incorrectly by mistake. How the Plan Works: The FairTax proposal is a comprehensive revenue plan that would eliminate most major federal income and payroll taxes, including personal, gift, estate, capital......

Words: 1526 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Tax Manual

...Chapter 01 An Introduction to Tax SOLUTIONS MANUAL Discussion Questions (1) [LO1] Jessica’s friend Zachary once stated that he couldn’t understand why someone would take a tax course. Why is this a rather naïve view? Taxes are a part of everyday life and have a financial effect on many of the major personal decisions that individuals face (e.g., investment decisions, evaluating alternative job offers, saving for education expenses, gift or estate planning, etc.). (2) [LO1] What are some aspects of business that require knowledge of taxation? What are some aspects of personal finance that require knowledge of taxation? Taxes play an important role in fundamental business decisions such as the following: * What organizational form should a business use? * Where should the business locate? * How should business acquisitions be structured? * How should the business compensate employees? * What is the appropriate mix of debt and equity for the business? * Should the business rent or own its equipment and property? * How should the business distribute profits to its owners? One must consider all transaction costs (including taxes) to evaluate the merits of a transaction. Common personal financial decisions that taxes influence include: choosing investments, retirement planning, choosing to rent or buy a home, evaluating alternative job offers, saving for education expenses, and doing gift or estate planning. ...

Words: 7204 - Pages: 29

Premium Essay

Tax Incidence

...incidence of sin taxes 2.2 The incidence of tax on pure rent in a small open economy 2.3 Tax incidence in bargaining 2.4 The general equilibrium incidence of environmental taxes 2.5 The tax system incidence on unemployment: A country specific analysis for the OECD economies: 2.6 Tax and subsidy incidence equivalence theories: experimental evidence from competitive markets 2.7 Tax incidence under oligopoly: a comparison of policy approaches 2.8 The incidence of income tax on wages and labour supply 2.9 The incidence of personal income taxation: evidence from the tax reform act of 1986: 2.10 Tax incidence when individuals are time-inconsistent: the case of cigarette excise tax 3. Conclusion References 1. Introduction: Government generally collect taxes to generate revenue and question arise here is that after imposition of taxation, which group will bear the tax burden. After implementation of tax, there would be the division of tax burden between byres and sellers which is known as tax incidence. Tax incidence is linked to the price elasticity of demand and supply. If supply is more elastic than demand then the tax burden falls upon the buyers and when the demand is more elastic than supply then the producers will bear the cost of the tax. Tax incidence is basically the analysis of the effect of taxation on the distribution of economic welfare. Tax incidence expose that which group either......

Words: 2655 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Tax Reform Paper

...Tax Reform Position Paper Taxes are necessary because they fund the services provided by government. Americans will pay trillions in taxes. Beyond funding government, the federal tax system has profound effects on the economy as a whole and on individual taxpayers, both for today and tomorrow. Taxes change people’s behavior and influence the economy by altering incentives to work, consume, save and invest. This affects economic growth and future income, therefore, future government revenues. In this paper I will highlight the pros and cons of flat tax, national sales tax, and the current tax system. Flat Tax Simplicity is considered a significant benefit of the flat tax system. One tax rate makes for easy calculation by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and straight forward payments from taxpayers. Because the flat tax taxes only one income, it is easier to understand and to report. The flat tax remains a popular idea in part because it eliminates double taxation. It eliminates the death tax, capital gains tax and taxation of savings and dividends. Fairness remains a popular feature of the flat tax. A taxpayer who makes $5000 pays the same tax rate as someone who earns $500,000. The taxpayer who makes more pays more taxes simply because their income is greater. It does not discriminate based on income; everyone pays the same percent. Some of the cons of the flat tax are that the system penalizes the low-income portion of the population. For example, if......

Words: 1697 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Ireland Plastic Bag Tax

...Table of Contents INTRODUCTION 2 I. LITERATURE REVIEW 3 I.1 Externalities 3 I.2. Environmental tax 5 II. THE LEVY ON PLASTIC BAGS IN IRELAND 8 II.1. Summary 8 II.2.The nature of the levy 10 II.3. Implementation and enforcement 12 II.4. Results and impacts 12 III. LESSON FROM PLASTIC BAGS LEVY IN IRELAND 17 III.1. Ireland’s lessons 17 III.2. Plastic bags levy in Vietnam: 19 CONCLUSION 23 REFERENCES 24 INTRODUCTION Now that people increasingly pay more attention to environmental issues, they are manifested in all areas of life. Air pollution? Do not worry. Already a car powered by electricity or eco-gasoline or even grass. Water pollution? Do not worry. Already advanced wastewater treatment technologies. So what if the pollution is caused by the consumption of plastic bags? Not easy to answer. Let’s stand in the shoes of a public economist. The consumption of plastic bags brings a lot of benefits for everyone. If you are a manufacturer of plastic bags, you will get a lot of money as your profit. If you are a consumer of plastic bags, you will be satisfied with the benefits that they bring you. They are cheap, very light and of course, very easy to throw away after used. Now the problem has arisen. Have you ever wondered where plastic bags will be after discarded? We can say for sure that they do not disappear. They stay and pollute the environment. Environment Commissioner Janez Potocnik used to say: "The impact of this plastic waste can be......

Words: 7613 - Pages: 31

Premium Essay

Carbon Tax

...A carbon tax is a tax imposed on the carbon content of fuels. It is a form of carbon pricing. Carbon taxes are a possible cost-effective means of reducing greenhouse gas emissions. From an economic outlook, carbon taxes are a type of Pigovian tax.They help to address the problem of emitters of greenhouse gases not face the full social costs of their actions. Carbon taxes can be a degenerating tax, in that it may directly or indirectly affect low-income groups disproportionately. The regressive impact of carbon taxes could be addressed by using tax revenues to favor low-income groups. A number of countries have implemented carbon taxes or energy taxes that are related to carbon content. But some are taxed on energy products and motor vehicles rather than on carbon dioxide directly. In June 2010, Julia Gillard defeated Rudd in a leadership challenge thus becoming Prime Minister of Australia. Shortly afterwards she called a federal election. During the election campaign Gillard stated that she supported a price on carbon emissions and that she would prosecute the case for action for as long as she needed to win community support. However, she also indicated that she would not introduce carbon pricing until there was a sufficient consensus on the issue, and she specifically ruled out the introduction of a "carbon tax".(Paul Kelly and Dennis Shanahan, 2010) When it was introduced on July 1, 2012 its primary goal is to reduce the country’s total emissions of greenhouse gases......

Words: 1865 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Tax and Economic

...S. Tax System The art of taxation was in the “plucking the goose so as to obtain the largest amount of the feathers with the least possible amount of hissing”, said by Jean-Baptiste Colbert, the seventeenth-century French finance minister. (Miller) From the historic perspective, current government of United States has developed a very efficient tax system of plucking its private–sector goose. While it seems this tax system indeed obtain the largest amount of the feathers, but the amount of hissing is growing. Due to a drop in individual income taxes, corporate income taxes, and estate taxes combining with the substantially change in the composition of top incomes, the U.S. tax system has became less progressive. According to the relationship between tax base and tax rate. There are three branches of tax system in the United States: proportional taxation, progressive taxation, and regressive taxation. Progressive taxation and regressive taxation are based on the proportional taxation, in which tax rate is fixed weather the taxable base amount increases or decreases. Based on the proportional taxation system, the progressive taxation is the one in which the tax rate increases as the taxable base amount increases, and the regressive taxation is opposite. Under those three taxation systems, there are kinds of taxes, primary including individual income tax, corporate income tax, estate and gift tax, and payroll tax. From the historic perspective, the overall U.S. federal tax......

Words: 1522 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Tax Acct

...History: * First tax in 1861 to fund Civil War * Repealed in 1865 * Income tax law passed in 1894 but rejected by Supreme Court * 16th amendment was passed in 1913 * 42% of revenue is raised from individual income tax * 40% from social security, 9% corporate income tax, 9% other Tax Structure: * Progressive tax structure: tax rate increases as the tax base increases * US income tax system is this way * Proportional tax structure (flat tax): tax rate remains the same regardless of tax base * Regressive tax structure: tax rate decreases as the tax base increases * Social security tax system is this way * Average tax rate: total tax paid on a certain amount of taxable income * Marginal tax rate: rate of tax paid on the highest dollar of income Calculation of Tax: Income - deductions = taxable income X tax rates = tax liability - tax payments/credits = tax refund or due with return * For TI up to $100,000 use tax tables * Use tax rate schedules for higher income * Tax rate tables are calculated at midpoint of range; rate schedules are precise Tax Forms: * 1040EZ must be: * Single or married filing jointly * Taxable income less than $100,000 * Have no dependents * May only have income from wages, unemployment and interest * 1040A must be: * Any of 5 filing statuses and have dependents * Income limited to $100,000 * May have......

Words: 1743 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Income Tax

...over 300 million citizens in the U.S, in 2009 only 53% of these people payed federal income tax, while the other 47% are paying next to nothing and in many cases profiting from the government. I strongly believe in the “American Dream”, the ideology that America is a place where any thing is possible and a man or women can earn a modest living with hardwork and dedication, it seems as though this ideology is being skewed. I’m not againist the wealthy paying their fair share of taxes, but it seems like they may be carrying the entire load. I believe that if we create programs to benefit everyone, everyone should pay into them not just the top 10%. The article points out that the financial recession of 2008 contirbuted a lot to this overall affect, and that years prior to 2009,the Bush Administartion inacted several tax laws that saved the top 10% of taxpayers million of dollars and negatively affected the middle class. The artcile also sates that federal income taxes are the #1 source of income for the government, netting an estimated $900 billion annually. With the top 10% of Americans contributing the most, I believe that this system needs to be restructured. I somewhat agree with the flat tax rate, where everyone just pays a percentage of their income without recoginizing deductions, but being as though I am a college student, those deductions greatly affect my overall federal tax return. I belive that there is a better system where everyone would benefit and pay their......

Words: 337 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Business Tax

...The possible implication of that tax system for the Malaysian economy, If implemented. The Malaysian government has to make procedure decisions on how to implement the GST. The most necessary decision about VAT is if it should be imposed as a expenditure, gross-product or income-type tax. Malaysia proposed a consumption-based GST. The use of invoices for GST provides more simplicity on how the tax is imposed. For VAT imposed as an income-type the accounting representation would be more suitable. In that case it would be based on the economic records of the company. The main advantage of a VAT is that it is a broad based system. Typically government and non-profit enterprises are excluded from the tax base. Further an important policy decision is to determine the place where GST is levy. For International Trade the place where the GST is levied is a vital matter. On the one hand the GST can be levied on the location of assembly (the origin principle) on the other it can be based on the location of the final consumption (the destination principle).The origin principle VAT is levied on value added within the state for all goods and services despite of whether they are sold within the state or export out of the state. It excludes value added personified in the goods and services that originate outside the state. The most regular is the use of the goal principle. Our analysis thus far has focused on evaluate if GST is a regressive or progressive tax and the corrective actions,......

Words: 1607 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Flat Tax vs Progressive Tax

...A flat tax system is better than progressive tax. Taxation has always been a major controversy. Just like any major corporation, the government is constantly looking to raise revenue. The easiest and fairest way to do this is by taxing the people. However, how the people will be taxed is always an issue . A flat tax would be a certain percent of gross income to be paid by all. Individuals or businesses would pay the same percentage regardless of income, with no deductions. But that would be just as illegal as the system we have now. There is no law allowing the government to collect an income tax. On the other side, A progressive tax is a tax which increases as a percentage of one's wealth. Using the federal income tax as an example, a person who makes between $0-$7,500 pays no taxes, any income between $7501 and $30,650 is taxed at 15%, up to any income above $336,551 being taxed at35%.  A progressive tax differs from what people call "regressive" taxes, like sales tax, which takes a larger percentage of money from individuals with less money .First of all, Progressive taxation is widely supported by experts in economics and political science from many different theoretical camps; in the United States and Europe, the majority of authorities supports a progressive tax and advance many arguments for it. For example, they say that progressive tax gives a government more revenue while also enhancing opportunity for its lower and middle class citizens. Without progressive......

Words: 1815 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Corruption as a Regressive Tax

...CORRUPTION IS REGRESSIVE TAXATION CORRUPTION The Merriam Webster’s collegiate dictionary of English Language says the word The word corruption originated from the Latin word rumpere meaning to break. This means that something is broken such a law or ethic, protocol or code of conduct. The World Bank and IMF see corruption as the abuse of public office for private gains. Osoba (1996) defines corruption as an antisocial behavior conferring improper benefits contrary to legal norms and normal norms and which undermines the authorities capacity to secure the welfare of the citizens. Finally Todaro and Smith (2009) sees corruption as the abuse of public trust for private gain. Corruption is a global issue which is endemic to most governments of the world. It is the biggest obstacle to development. According to Tanzi (1998) corruption is the intentional noncompliance with arms length relationship aimed at deriving some advantage from this behavior for oneself or for related individuals. However, not all act of corruption culminate into bribe taking. For example not reporting to duty for which you receive monthly salary for is an act of corruption, because you are committing economic sabotage by not giving commensurate value for your salary. A governor or president who diverts projects meant for the equal development of all regions to his town or village is an act of corruption that doesn’t involve taking or giving a bribe. Therefore corruption has no universally...

Words: 2306 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Economics of Tax

...“Tax is a compulsory levy made by the public administration for which nothing is received directly in return’’ (James and Nobes, 2011). The income tax was primarily developed in England by Pitt the Younger in 1798 to help out finance the Napoleonic Wars.’’ In earlier times, taxes were usually only levied occasionally to pay for some huge expenses such a war. Since then the British tax system has developed in a largely ad hoc and politically expedient method’’. Amendments have been made to the existing tax systems, usually when the government required more funds. Little if any planned or integrated thinking seems to have taken place. According to the Adam Smith Institute, Great Britain has the most complex tax system in the world, which is largely believed that is roughly five times as long as the German tax code (Geraint Jones, 2011) Currently, governments request to use taxation in some situations for purposes which is different than raising funds to cover up its expenditure. To begin with, the economic resources, which are accessible for the nation are limited, thus a raise in government spending usually leads to a decrease in private expenditure. In addition to this, one technique of transferring recourses from the private to the public sector is the use of taxation, but there are also further methods. One of these alternative methods is the degradation of the currency through the creation of additional money, but the main problem of this method is that it leads to......

Words: 1985 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Progressive Tax vs Flat Tax

...progressive income tax system requires a complete overhaul into a flat tax structure. Efficiency throughout all related markets would increase, reducing distortions, and creating greater than ever incentives to work and create capitalist opportunities. It also presents the potential of solving our country’s budget deficit issues. Our current system stymies innovation and the desire to persevere by forcing a higher tax bracket on those who earn more, causing more individuals to pursue avenues of evading taxation, either through legal or illegal means. Even though the flat tax appears as too burdensome to the poor – or as a contributing factor towards the establishment of a “black market” - a flat tax is simply a more equitable system that will solve the federal deficit issues in the United States. Efficiency would rise from five sources. The first is a change of the tax base from income to consumption. The second is the establishment of a more comprehensive tax base, which eliminates the differential tax treatment of various assets and forms of income. The third is the lowering of tax rates, which raises the rate of return to working, saving, and investing. It also reduces incentives to avoid or evade taxes. Next is the reduction of compliance costs , allowing companies to lower their budgets for record keeping return filing, the salaries and training of employees performing these tasks and the costs to obtain the advice of external accountants and tax lawyers. ......

Words: 1252 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Income Tax

...12.) Which is more appropriate tax rate to use to compare taxpayers’ tax burdens-the average or the effective tax rate? Why? -Effective tax rate would be the most appropriate because it provides a better depiction of a taxpayer’s tax burden. The reason for this is because it depicts the taxpayer’s total tax paid as a ratio of the sum of both taxable and nontaxable income earned. 14.) Arnold and Lilly have recently had a heated discussion about whether a sales tax is a proportional tax or a regressive tax. Arnold argues that a sales tax is regressive. Lilly counters that the sales tax is a flat tax. Who is correct? -Arnold and Lilly are both correct. The reason Lilly is correct is because a sales tax by definition is a proportional tax. As taxable purchase increase the sales tax rate (marginal tax rate) remains constant. Arnold is correct because one’s total income spent on taxable purchases likely decreases as total income increases, so the sales tax may be considered a regressive tax. 16.) What is the tax base for the Social Security and Medicare taxes for an employee or employer? What is the tax base for Social Security and Medicare taxes for a Self-employed individual? Is the Self-employment tax in addition to or in lieu of federal income tax? -The tax base for the Social Security and Medicare taxes for an employee or employer is the employee wage. The tax base for Social Security and Medicare taxes for a Self-employed individual is the Net earnings......

Words: 367 - Pages: 2