Free Essay

Proj 410 Week 3 Rfp Evaluations Discussion Questions 2

In: Other Topics

Submitted By katherineswanson
Words 469
Pages 2
PROJ 410 Week 3 RFP Evaluations Discussion Questions 2 http://homeworkfy.com/downloads/proj-410-week-3-rfp-evaluations-discussion-questions-2/ To Get this Tutorial Copy & Paste above URL Into Your Browser
Hit Us Email for Any Inquiry at: Homeworkfy@gmail.com
Visit our Site for More Tutorials: (http://homeworkfy.com/ )

RFP Evaluations (graded)
It is very common to find buyers who fail to identify the RFP evaluation criteria during the project procurement planning process, and in fact, do not define the evaluation criteria until after proposals have been received and the evaluation process is set to begin. What do you think is the risk of waiting until bids have been received to establish the evaluation criteria to be used to select a preferred contractor? Besides evaluating the risk of waiting until bids are submitted, also consider the question from the potential vendors’ point of view. Should vendors be aware of the evaluation criteria during the procurement phase, or after they have submitted their proposals/bids? Finding buyers that fail to identify the RFP evaluation criteria during the project procurement planning process would hurt schedule and scope. Besides, if you get the proposals and read them before you create evaluation criteria, you run the risk of consciously or subconsciously creating evaluation criteria based on what you’ve read which could create a bias towards one of the proposals. Finally, without having your criteria set ahead of time, there is a high risk of setting yourself up with a bias opinion on proposals and not having an even playing field for others that come in.

Ggive an example when you had a bad experience in choosing the lowest-priced contractor or vendor, if ever you experienced one. Price is one of the main evaluation criteria in most proposals. But from your experiences or from the knowledge you’ve gained from this week’s lecture, what are some other criteria that customers use to evaluate various proposals?

Please pick one of them and elaborate on it. If you can add other criteria, that will be also great. List five commonly used evaluation criteria listed in a RFP and explain why a buyer would want this information before selecting a vendor?

Three commonly used evaluation criteria listed in a RFP are overall cost or financial proposal, reputation, and experience. What can the buyer glean from this information and how can the buyer use it to make a decision on a particular seller? Qualifications are important, but so are the fees. So many companies are focused on savings, how could you not consider fees as much as qualifications? Do you feel a seller would have the right to protest a bid selection if he/she feels that the lack of information regarding the buyer’s evaluation criteria contributed to the seller’s proposal being non-responsive?…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Week 7 Discussion Question 3

...Week Seven DQ 3  Post a 150- to 300-word original response to the following discussion question by clicking on Reply and changing the subject line to read:  [Your Name]'s Response  If you own your car or house and are no longer making payments, should you still have insurance on them? Explain why or why not. I'd have to say that if you owned your house out right you'd be crazy not to have that large of an Investment cover by insurance policies... I say policies because I'd want to protect my investment against all kinds of damage. Flood insurance is almost unheard of where I live, but just last year there were houses with basements flooded because of snow melt overflowing the river that has been low for decades... A lesson I don't want to learn the hard way, and have to cover the costs of the repairs out of pocket. It was a complete freak occurance but it dosn't rule out the possibility of it happening again. So now we have flood insurance.  And with the cars the same thing. i didn't buy my car to not have it running and in good condition for as long as I can. And the other drivers on the road are just as unpredictable as the weather. So I personal don't see any reason why you wouldn't have full coverage on your vehicle. It cost just as much to insure it as when you still had to make payments on it. And most cars these days are a whole lot to fix any more. With all of the cars computers and sensors being mounted on the shell of the vehicle. The cost of repairs could......

Words: 334 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Discussion Questions Week 3

...1. What are some of the major functions of micronutrients? What are some different ways you might ensure that you get all the necessary daily nutrients? Which methods are you currently using? 2. What are some common problems that result from micronutrient deficiencies? How might these problems affect overall health and life expectancy? 3. What are some similarities and differences between macro- and micronutrients? Why is it important to understand what macro- and micronutrients are and how they work in the body? 4. How might taking vitamin supplements have both positive and negative effects on your body based on your diet? What is the general consensus among nutrition experts regarding supplements? What is your opinion on taking supplements? 5. Sam is a fast-food fanatic. For breakfast, he stops for coffee and doughnuts. Lunch is an iced tea, ham-and-cheese sub with lettuce and mayonnaise, and a cookie. Dinner consists of a soft drink, burger, and fries. Name two vitamins likely to be lacking in Sam’s diet if he eats this way every day. What problems might Sam experience because of nutritional deficiencies in his diet? 6. Why might someone with kidney failure develop a vitamin D deficiency? 7. What are some ways to deal with pressures that cause one to overeat or undereat? 8. How can one deal with setbacks in reaching weight-management goals? 9. Why are fads and trendy diets effective for the short term? 10. Why is slow weight loss......

Words: 251 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Acc 561 Week 3 Discussion Question 3

...This work ACC 561 Week 3 Discussion Question 3 includes solutions to the following question: "Identify an industry in which a job order cost system or a process cost system could be used. How might each of the cost systems be implemented within this particular industry? Does an industry exist in which the job order and the processing cost systems would not be suitable? Explain your rationale." Business - Accounting Alternative Costing Methods The text presents job and processing costing systems as virtual “polar extremes,” there are many situations where it may be best for a company to use a hybrid system that combines attributes of both systems.  Describe such a situation and discuss how the hybrid system may be better than either pure job or pure process systems. Think Twice Assume you own a business that makes two complementary products for which you allocated manufacturing overhead proportionally.  A competitor is trying to undercut your price for one of the products.  How might ABC costing help you better compete with this pending threat? Activity Base Costing- How do managers cost products or services using ABC systems? When should managers consider using an ABC costing system? How should they decide to adopt this method? Alternative Costing Methods I would like you all to select a costing method: process, job, or activity based. Describe the nature of your chosen method. What types of organizations should choose that......

Words: 375 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Abs 497 Week 3 Discussion Question 2 Development Theories

...In the file ABS 497 Week 3 Discussion Question 2 Development Theories you will find answers on the following tasks: "Select either Kohlberg Deadline: ( ), General Questions - General General Questions 1)Danny and Marion Klein were injured when an aerial shell at a public fireworks exhibit went astray and exploded near them. They sued Pyrodyne Corp., the pyrotechnic company that was hired to set up and discharged the fireworks, alleging, among other things, that the company should be strictly liable for damages caused by the fireworks display. Will the court agree with the Kleins? a.Yes, because any time a person ignites aerial shells with the intention of sending them aloft to explode in the presence of large crowds knows that injuries can occur. b.Yes, because no matter how much care pyro technicians exercise they cannot eliminate the high risk inherent in setting off powerful explosives such as fireworks near crowds. c.No, because anyone who attends a fireworks display assumes the risk for the potential of injury that may occur. d.No, because all six of the factors needed to prove strict liability was not present. 2)Blue Cross and Blue Shield insurance companies (the Blues) provide 68 million Americans with health-care financing. The Blues have paid billions of dollars for care attributable to illnesses related to tobacco use. In an attempt to recover some of this amount, the Blues filed a suit in federal district court against tobacco companies and others, alleging......

Words: 365 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Proj 595 Week 2 Discussion

...responses. Collapse All    | Print View    | Show Options   | Responses Responses are listed below in the following order: response, author and the date and time the response is posted. | | Sort by Response | Sort by Author | Sort by Date/Time* | (an instructor response) | | Question 1 ..Stakeholder Identification ?? | Professor Hiegel | 1/10/2015 3:46:03 PM | | | How does a project manager identify stakeholders for a project?orHow does a project manager know which stakeholders are more important to a project? | | | | RE: Question 1 ..Stakeholder Identification ?? | Phillip Murray | 1/11/2015 7:26:56 AM | | | If a stakeholder register has been executed as part of the initial plan then this will simplify this step greatly.  I would revisit the register and "scrub" it for a comprehensive list of internal and external stakeholders.  PMBOK chapter 13 on pgs 395-396, para 13.1.2.1 Stakeholder Analysis, describes several classification models that can be used to identify stakeholders. I also found a small article that says some of the same things in a simpler manner. http://www.projectmanager.com/identify-project-stakeholders.php | | | | RE: Question 1 ..Stakeholder Identification ?? | David Brazauskas | 1/11/2015 8:02:45 AM | | | To expand upon Phillip’s post, it is critical for a project to identify the stakeholders at the beginning of a project. Stakeholders are the people that are identified that could impact or be......

Words: 13752 - Pages: 56

Free Essay

Acc 375 Week 3 Discussion Question 2

...ACC 375 WEEK 3 DISCUSSION QUESTION 2 To purchase this visit here: http://www.nerdypupil.com/product-category/acc-375/ Contact us at: nerdypupil@gmail.com ACC 375 WEEK 3 DISCUSSION QUESTION 2 What are the three types of billing schemes? What type of proactive test is used to detect these schemes? Home Work Hour aims to provide quality study notes and tutorials to the students of ACC 375 Week 3 Discussion Question 2 in order to ace their studies. ACC 375 WEEK 3 DISCUSSION QUESTION 2 To purchase this visit here: http://www.nerdypupil.com/product-category/acc-375/ Contact us at: nerdypupil@gmail.com ACC 375 WEEK 3 DISCUSSION QUESTION 2 What are the three types of billing schemes? What type of proactive test is used to detect these schemes? Home Work Hour aims to provide quality study notes and tutorials to the students of ACC 375 Week 3 Discussion Question 2 in order to ace their studies. ACC 375 WEEK 3 DISCUSSION QUESTION 2 To purchase this visit here: http://www.nerdypupil.com/product-category/acc-375/ Contact us at: nerdypupil@gmail.com ACC 375 WEEK 3 DISCUSSION QUESTION 2 What are the three types of billing schemes? What type of proactive test is used to detect these schemes? Home Work Hour aims to provide quality study notes and tutorials to the students of ACC 375 Week 3 Discussion Question 2 in order to ace their studies. ACC 375 WEEK 3 DISCUSSION QUESTION 2 To purchase this visit here: ......

Words: 561 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Proj 410 Week 1 Dq 2

...PROJ 410 Week 1 DQ 2 To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/proj-410/proj-410-week-1-dq-2 A project manager and a contract manager are both needed to administer a procured project or process. If you were the project manager, how would you work with a contract manager to ensure a successful procurement? In answering this question, consider such issues as, at what point you would want to get the contract manager involved in the project, what areas of the contract you would want to be his or her responsibility, how much and what types of communication you would want the seller (i.e., the contracted firm) to have with the contract manager, and who would handle conflicts that might arise with costs, schedules, or scope. Please remember to answer all components of the question. What are the differences between the project manager and contract manager? What knowledge should a project manager have and what knowledge should a contract manager have to perform the jobs? What do you think about hiring a project manager (PM)? What steps might you take to find the right contractor and project manager? Price used to be the main object, now we want a “buy best value” concept where price is just one factor. We also look at past performance, management, etc. What examples do you have about the way you contract your work? What are the six steps you would take in the project procurement management? In this era of cost containment and reduced budgets, we have......

Words: 416 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Proj 410 Week 2 Dq 1

...PROJ 410 Week 2 DQ 1 To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/proj-410/proj-410-week-2-dq-1 Assume that you have made the final payment on a one-acre residential lot that you purchased years ago to build your retirement home. You are now ready to build your dream home. This will be your ongoing project for the next couple of years. Which contract structure (fixed price, unit price, reimbursable) do you think that you would use to proceed with your project? Explain your choice. What are the four basic contract pricing options? What are five options of cost reimbursable contracts? In what situation a company is best to use a unit price contract?  In what situation, a company is best to use cost-plus-percentage-fee contract? What are the differences among a fixed price contract, a time and materials contract, and a reimbursable contract in terms of how well defined a BPO contract needs to be relative to price, scope and schedule prior to the commencement of any work/services? Class, do you feel the length of the contract also has some influence on the contract type you choose? Why or why not? What are the challenges for an owner in tracking a reimbursable contract? When does a contract manager prefer a fixed fee contract over a reimbursable contract (or vice versa)? How many companies do you think go through outlining their business objectives, and then use these to guide the selection of a contract structure, rather than letting financial......

Words: 320 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Proj 410 Week 2 Dq 2

...PROJ 410 Week 2 DQ 2 To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/proj-410/proj-410-week-2-dq-2 What are the differences among a fixed-price contract, a time-and-materials contract, and a reimbursable contract in terms of how well defined a contract needs to be relative to price, scope, and schedule prior to the commencement of any work? How much control over the project scope, price, and schedule should the contractor have under each contract type? How difficult is it to handle out-of-scope work with the 3 contract types (fixed price, time and materials, reimbursable) after an agreement has been executed? What do you see as the more common mistakes made by customers/clients or their procurement representatives as it relates to project planning and contract formulation? Now that you know the differences among a fixed price contract, a time and materials contract, and a reimbursable contract, let’s discuss some of the finer points to consider. Do you think a fixed price contract requires less management attention than a reimbursable contract? Why or why not? We typically hear of clients looking for the lowest price, and rarely does the term value come into the picture? Is it assumed that the value is there and is that a fair assumption most of the time? How do you differentiate a project plan from the project definition? To continue with the relevance of the project definition and project plan (schedule) to contracts: what components of the project......

Words: 363 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Proj 410 Week 3 Dq 1

...PROJ 410 Week 3 DQ 1 To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/proj-410/proj-410-week-3-dq-1 Consider again the dream retirement home that you were building as part of the Week 2 Discussion. Assume that you are working on the request for a proposal to be bid on by some local general contractors. Using the outline of the RFP sections discussed this week, what are some specific questions or areas of detail that you would put in your RFP? What are some ways that you’d tailor your RFP to make sure that you knew if the local general contractor whom you choose will meet all of your success criteria? You would definitely want to know specifically what services will and will not be provided in this situation. I would want to have a clear understanding of what will be provided and what the cost is so I can see that difference between contractors. I can then better evaluate my budget and whether I am on track. I would also like to know what the contractors background is and what their experience level is in building a house like mine. I would also like to understand the talent level of the team that will be involved in my project. What is their experience and track record. I think these things would help you achieve success in getting house done on time. Given the content of an Request for Qualifications (RFQ’s) versus a Request for Proposals (RFP), do you feel that RFQ’s and RFP’s should both be a part of a procurement process (e.g. issue an RFQ, receive......

Words: 730 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Proj 410 Week 3 Dq 2

...PROJ 410 Week 3 DQ 2 To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/proj-410/proj-410-week-3-dq-2 It is very common to find buyers who fail to identify the RFP evaluation criteria during the project procurement planning process, and in fact, do not define the evaluation criteria until after proposals have been received and the evaluation process is set to begin. What do you think is the risk of waiting until bids have been received to establish the evaluation criteria to be used to select a preferred contractor? Besides evaluating the risk of waiting until bids are submitted, also consider the question from the potential vendors’ point of view. Should vendors be aware of the evaluation criteria during the procurement phase, or after they have submitted their proposals/bids? Finding buyers that fail to identify the RFP evaluation criteria during the project procurement planning process would hurt schedule and scope. Besides, if you get the proposals and read them before you create evaluation criteria, you run the risk of consciously or subconsciously creating evaluation criteria based on what you’ve read which could create a bias towards one of the proposals. Finally, without having your criteria set ahead of time, there is a high risk of setting yourself up with a bias opinion on proposals and not having an even playing field for others that come in. Qualifications are important, but so are the fees. So many companies are focused on savings, how could......

Words: 446 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Proj 410 Week 4 Dq 2

...PROJ 410 Week 4 DQ 2 To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/proj-410/proj-410-week-4-dq-2 How do you go about defining the proper duration for a bid procurement? Consider the time that it takes to plan for the procurement, draft an RFI and/or RFP, receive responses, and make a decision. What could you do if you needed to fast track this bid duration? The bid procurement process can stretch as much as one to two years in the federal government, especially on “mega” procurements.  Often times this is due to the multiple committees, meetings, and layers of contract administration that a RFP, bid selection process must go through.  Can you think of any ways to make the process more efficient? Using a short list of pre-approved sellers is one way to eliminate a lot of the time and effort of the bid process.  Are there any reasons you can think of why using a short list is NOT a good idea?  When might you want to go through the entire bid process? It is said that the project manager is a vital part of the project procurement process.  However, the bid duration stretches over weeks, months, and even years.  During that time, the project manager is not “managing” the project on a day to day basis.  What else is the project manager doing?  If he/she is assigned to manage another task, how can they devote enough time and energy to the bid process for this new contract? What are the factors are largely determined in negotiations in a BPO agreement? In......

Words: 311 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Proj 410 Week 6 Dq 2

...PROJ 410 Week 6 DQ 2 To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/proj-410/proj-410-week-6-dq-2 There are several ways to benchmark. The two most common benchmarking tools are performance benchmarking and best-practice benchmarking. Consider a nationwide bank that has contracted with a seller to assess its current staffing and facility locations. The goal of the contract is for the seller to produce a strategic plan that creates cost efficiencies for the bank by recommending (and implementing) areas to consolidate among staff and facilities. (One recommendation may be to close down a bank branch that is located within three miles of another bank branch.) This is a long-term contract stretched out over five years. If you were the project manager in the bank, to what benchmarks would you compare your seller? Are they performance benchmarks or best-practice benchmarks?  Benchmarking is a term that has often been used to represent “the best of the class” performance. Your text implies a slightly less “perfectionist” performance threshold, whereby you assess the performance measures for other similar vendors or services relative to your BPO services, and use these samplings to define performance measures for your project/contract. Which of these two inferences do you feel is more appropriate for supporting the development of performance measures? State your arguments in support of your selection.  Is it realistic to use a “perfectionistic” metric for......

Words: 417 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Proj 410 Week 7 Dq 2

...PROJ 410 Week 7 DQ 2 To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/proj-410/proj-410-week-7-dq-2 One of the most frustrating aspects of contract management to customers/clients is the length of time that it commonly takes to close out a project (from an administrative standpoint) after most or all of the contract scope of work has been completed. The closeout is the fourth phase in the generic project life cycle where all outstanding contractual issues are completed and documented in preparation for turning over the product or service to the customer. What are some of the activities that need to be performed as part of the contract closeout functions? What do you think are some of the factors that cause such a length in delay in the closure of the project/contract? Closeout is completed when all administrative actions have been completed, all disputes settled, and final payment has been made. Who do you think typically drags out the close-out process, the owner or the vendor? Support your answer. Another problem that often arises is that the Project Manager is assigned to a new project/contract during the close-out phase, and naturally he/she becomes more preoccupied with the new assignment. Have you heard the term “Close-out Managers” in any of your PM courses? If yes, what do you recall is the role of these managers? If you have not heard the term before, what do you think it refers to? What is a close-out function or responsibility (i.e., something......

Words: 284 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Discussion Question Week 2

...Discussion Question #2 Week 1 How might you apply ethical philosophies and principles that summarize what you perceive to be the top five ethical issues challenging health care delivery today? What I perceive to be the top five ethical issues challenging health care delivery today are the following: * Avoiding conflicts of interest * Balancing profits with quality of care * Equal treatment of all patients * Managing decision making capacity of the elderly and very young patients * Addressing nurses moral distress when providing care with minimal benefits The ethical philosophies and principles that would summarize these issues for me would be a combination of the Natural Law ethical theory, and the Utilitarianism ethical theory. These theories would summarize the top five ethical issues I perceive to be a challenge in health care today. Describe at least two ethical principles discussed in this week's reading material. Apply those principles to two examples of ethical challenges that exist in the delivery of health care today. Do these principles assist in overcoming the challenge or do they create more of an ethical dilemma? Why? Natural Law Ethical Theory- This principle of ethics is defined as the position that rational reflection on nature, will yield principles of good and bad that can guide human action toward fulfillment or flourishing. Utilitarianism- This principle of ethics is defined as acting so as to do the greatest good for the......

Words: 628 - Pages: 3