Free Essay

Privation

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By luciexo
Words 298
Pages 2
• Privation is the failure to form an attachment, this may be due to extremely poor parenting or prolonged stays away from a potential attachment figure. Possible consequences of privation are intellectual retardation, anti-social behaviour in later life an inability to form relationships and lack of guilt.
• Rutter investigated the progress of 111 Romanian Orphans who were brought to Britain for adoption. The children were raised in poor institutions. The Romanian children were tested for general cognitive levels till the age of 4. A control group of British children were also tested to see whether it was the separation from the mother or the poor conditions of the institution which led to the negative effects. The results were that after four years the two groups of children showed no significant differences in intellectual or physical development. Those who were in Britain before the age of 6 months were said to have developed greater than those who arrived
• However there is a problem with this study as we cannot assume that each of the children had the exact same treatment and amount of care meaning we need to take into account mediating factors. Therefore those who recovered at a better rate, such as the ones who arrived in Britain before the age of 6 months may have received less abuse than the ones who arrived later. Thus it may have been easier for them to recover and the age in which they discovered did not have an impact, which limits to the reliability of the results.
• This study challenges Bowlby’s hypothesis that the consequences of are irreversible if they are not helped before the critical period as although not all the children fully recovered they all showed significant improvement. Therefore it questions the reliability of Bowlby’s theory.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

History

...(possibly owing to low self-esteem or poor emotional development caused by early experiences). Evaluation... * A wide variation in relaionship formation meant that some adopted children did badly and some restored children did well. This means that individual differences are important factors. A biased sample was left at the end of the study because greater numbers of well adjusted restored children and maladjusted adopted children dropped out. The evidence suggests that early childhood experiences (including privation) can be overcome later in life, provided the conditions are right. This contradicts Bowlby's view of a critical period during which time children develop attachments that provide a model for future relationships and ensure healthy emotional and social development. Much research focuses on the negative effects of early childhood experiences. It is the factors that allow healthy development to occur in some people, despite early deprivation or privation, which need to be investigated. It is very difficult to generalise the effects of day care because the quality and types vary so widely and research studies only sample a small section of this variation. Generalisation is also difficult because most of the research is carried out in the USA, which means that the findings may not be relevant in other cultures. Furthermore, individual differences in personality, social background and family relationships will also influence the effect of day care on a......

Words: 390 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Bolwby

...(1981) points out that several indicators of attachment (such as protest or distress when attached person leaves) has been shown for a variety of attachment figures – fathers, siblings, peers and even inanimate objects. Critics such as Rutter have also accused Bowlby of not distinguishing between deprivation and privation – the complete lack of an attachment bond, rather than its loss. Rutter stresses that the quality of the attachment bond is the most important factor, rather than just deprivation in the critical period. Another criticism of 44 Thieves Study as that it concluded that affectionless psychopathy was caused by maternal deprivation. This is correlational data and as such only shows a relationship between these two variables. Indeed, other external variables, such as diet, parental income, education etc. may have affected the behaviour of the 44 thieves, and not, as concluded, the disruption of the attachment bond. Bowlby's Maternal Deprivation is however, supported Harlow's research with monkeys. He showed that monkeys reared in isolation from their mother suffered emotional and social problems in older age. The monkey's never formed an attachment (privation) and as such grew up to be aggressive and had problems interacting with other monkeys. Konrad Lorenz (1935) supports Bowlby's maternal deprivation hypothesis as the attachment process of imprinting is an innate process. There are implications arising from Bowlby’s work. As he believed the mother to be the......

Words: 487 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

To What Extent Can the Effects of Privation Be Reversed

...To what extent can the effects of privation be reversed? Privation is where you never form an attachment with the caregiver. It is different to deprivation which is where you lose the attachment with the caregiver after the bond has already been formed. Rutter in 1981 claimed that the effects of privation are more likely to be serious than the effects of deprivation. Evidence for this came from studies of children that have been carried out by different people on children who have suffered cruelty. The case of Genie is a big example of Privation that was carried out Cutiss in 1977. This reported the case of a girl who was looked in a room for 13 years by her parents and never formed an attachment. She was strapped to a potty chair for most of her childhood and was beaten if she made any noise. This led to her being physically undeveloped and could only speak to animals with animal like-sounds. After a lot of help she learned some language skills but her social and intellectual skills never fully developed. This case shows that the effects of privation can be reversed if you give the child lots of love and support. Another example of the effects of privation is the case of the Czech twin boys and that was carried out by Koluchova in 1976. This was the case where a step mother treated the twins very cruelly by locking them in a cellar, beating them up and had no toys. They were seven when they were and had rickets (bone development disease that is caused by lack of Vitamin......

Words: 582 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Privation

...Privation is defined as the lack of necessities of life, and in the context of attachment it is referred to as the lack of emotional care, such that no attachments are formed. A case study that represents privation in the form of attachment is one about a 13year old girl called Genie. From an early age she was strapped to a potty in a bare room. Her history was one of isolation, severe neglect and physical restraint, and she was punished if she made any sound. When she was discovered she was described as ‘unsocialised, primitive and hardly human’. She made no sounds and was hardly able to walk. Even after being put into a foster care, she never achieved good social adjustment or language. Another case study into privation is one on the Czech twins. The tins’ mother died during their birth and they then spent 11 months with their aunt. They then went to move with their father and stepmother, and from then they were never allowed out of the house and were kept in either a small, unheated closet or in a cellar. When they were discovered at the age of 7, the children could barely walk, were very fearful and their speech was very poor. After being put in hospital and then a foster home, excellent gains were made. The children are now adults and appear well adjusted and cognitively able. The Czech twins study supports Bowlby’s theory of attachment. This is because he stated there as a critical period for attachments, and in the twins’ case, they were in foster care and with......

Words: 455 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Section 320 Ipc – an Appraisal

...good-natured man would hardly resent, would be classed together”.3 Grievous Hurt: S 320 IPC defines grievous hurt and lists eight kinds of hurt which it lables as “grievous”. These clauses are not mutually exclusive for there can be injuries which may fall in more than one clause. However, the list is exhaustive in the sense that, the framers of the Code have used the term “only”, while listing the type of hurts which they designated as “grievous”. This positively shows that the list is exhaustive and no hurt outside the list given in S. 320 can be termed as ‘grievous hurt’.4 The following kinds of hurt only are designated as “grievous”5 First: Emasculation. Secondly: Permanent privation of the sight of either eye. Thirdly: Permanent privation of the hearing of either ear Fourthly: Privation of any member or joint. Fifthly: Destruction or permanent impairing of the powers of any member or joint. Sixthly: Permanent disfiguration of the head or face. Seventhly: Fracture or dislocation of a bone or tooth. Eighthly: Any hurt which endangers life or which causes the sufferer to be during the space of twenty days in severe bodily pain or unable to follow his ordinary pursuits. Explanation: To make out the offence of causing grievous hurt, there must be a specific hurt, coming within any of the eight kinds enumerated in this section. A simple hurt cannot be designated as grievous simply because it was on a vital part of the body, unless the dimensions or the......

Words: 5053 - Pages: 21

Free Essay

Psychlogy

...Outline and evaluate research into privation Privation is the failure to develop an attachment bond in early childhood. This can result from losing a parent at child birth. Bowlby does not differentiate between deprivation and privation. Hodges and Tizard’s study was conducted as a longitudinal study in order to collect reliable information linking to early experiences to later outcomes for the same individuals. It was also a natural experiment. The independent variable was how the attachment experience varied naturally. The study consisted of 65 children who had been placed in an institution, where there was an explicit policy against caregivers forming attachments with the children since before they were less than 4 months old, suggesting early privation. By the age of 4, 24 of the children were adopted, 15 returned to their natural homes and the rest remained at the institution. At the ages of 8 and 16, the children who were adopted and those that returned home were interview including their families and friends. Hodges and Tizard found out that the adopted children generally had close attachments to their parents and good family relationships whereas the percentage of children with close attachment with their parent in the children that returned home was much less. However both groups of children were more likely to seek adult attention and approval than the controlled children, and both groups were less successful in peer relationships. This evidence does not......

Words: 420 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Far Do Sources 1, 2 and 3 Suggest That in the Years 1945-59, the Conservative and Labour Parties Held Radically Different Views on the Nationalisation of British Industry? (20 Marks)

...How far do sources 1, 2 and 3 suggest that in the years 1945-59, the Conservative and Labour parties held radically different views on the nationalisation of British industry? (20 marks) Between the years of 1945 and 1959, there was much speculation as to whether or not there was a consensus or conflict between the Labour and Conservative parties in regards to their views on Nationalisation. Sources 1 and 3 completely disagree with each other. On the one hand, the first source is Clement Attlee, the leader of the Labour party in 1945, saying that something has to be done and that nationalisation is the way. Contrastingly, source 3 is from the Conservative party manifesto. It chooses privation over nationalisation, and therefore presents both parties as holding radically different views on the British industry, each with their own ideas. However, source 2 offers a variegated approach, with Hugh Gaitskell, the leader of the Labour party in 1959, showing the parties as having less radically different views, as he talks about a mixed economy, private and national, being perhaps a wise move on behalf of the government. Sources 1 and 3 agree, overall, that both the Labour and Conservative parties held radically different views on the nationalisation of British industry. Source 1 was taken from a speech by Clement Attlee, the leader of the labour party at the time. In 1945, the country was in economic ruin and a social divide was severely evident. Clement Attlee, alongside the......

Words: 1136 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Outline and Evaluate Research Into Privation.

...Outline and evaluate research into Privation Privation is the failure to form an attachment, this may be due to extremely poor parenting or prolonged stays away from a potential attachment figure, e.g. whilst in hospital. One famous study on extreme privation is the case study of Genie: Genie was locked in a room by her father until she was thirteen and a half years old and never fully recovered and proceeded to lack social responsiveness. Her lack of recovery may be due to the fact that she was found beyond the sensitive period or because of the physical deprivation she experienced. Additionally, another well-known case study on privation is the Czech twins whom spent the first seven years of their life locked up by their stepmother and were unable to talk. Once they were found they were then cared for by two sisters and by the age of fourteen they were socially and intellectually stable and had no problems with relationships and intelligence. The two studies both demonstrate privation; however, they both differ in terms of recovery from the privation. The negative effects of privation were more easily reversed with the Czech twins than Genie; this could have been due to the fact they went to a stable loving home which gave them sufficient emotional care. They were also younger when discovered; this may also contribute to the ease of recovery. The Czech twins were together; this means they could recover better socially as they were not alone, unlike Genie who was secluded......

Words: 363 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Discuss Research Into Privation

...Privation of attachment means failure to form an attachment. Privation usually occurs when children have been kept in extreme isolation and therefoe have never had the opppurtunity to form an attachment. There are 3 main types of evidence regarding privation and those are longitudinal studies of children in instituational care; case studies of children raised in extreme isolation; and studies of reactive attachment disorder which is a category of mental disorder attributed to a lack of early attachments. A longiudinal study of ex-institutional children was done by Hodges and Tizard in 1989, to investigate the effects of privation by following the same children over a long period of time to collect reliable information linking early experiences to later outcomes for the same individual. The participants were 65 children who had been placed in an instituation when they were less than 4 months old. There was an explicit policy in the institution against caregivers forming attachments with the children. This would suggest the children experienced early privation. By the age of 4, 24 of the institutionalized children had been adopted, 15 had returned to their natural homes and the rest remained in the institution. Assessment at the age of 8 and 16 years old involved interviewing those children who were adopted and those who had returned to their original homes. Their parents, their teachers and their peers were also interviewed. Data was also collected from a control group...

Words: 1673 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

An Evaluation of the Process of Resocialisation.

...Resocialisation can be described as the mental and emotional retraining of an individual, so they may function in an environment other to what they are accustomed to. In the case of Genie, research suggested that although some effects of privation were reversible; as she was observed forming attachments with her carers and the positive development of her social skills. It was unfortunately down to the prolonged negative cognitive effects of her privation, which ultimately ended any possibility of her resocialisation. Genie had missed the critical period according to the theory of attachment. This theory by John Bowlby a psychoanalyst, suggested that all children are born with an innate instinct to form attachments in order to survive. He believed that a child must form a monotropic relationship or else severe consequences in social development could occur. The result would be irreversible developmental problems in the form of reduced intelligence, aggression or depression. A flaw in Bowlby’s theory was the fact he didn’t recognise the differences between privation and deprivation. Treating both as an equal entity, adding doubt to his 44 thieves experiment (1944). Harry Harlow on the other hand recognised the difference between privation/deprivation. Harlow, contributed work to Bowlby’s theory, with his controversial research on rhesus monkeys. Harlow basically thought that the relationship with caregivers was an important role in a child’s development, which impacted......

Words: 504 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Miss

...caregiver (the caregiver gains pleasure from smiles etc. – reward). * The reinforcement process is therefore reciprocal (two way) and strengthens the emotional bond / attachment between the two. Definition Attachment can be defined as an emotional bond between two people in which each seeks closeness and feels more secure when in the presence of the attachment figure. Definition Attachment can be defined as an emotional bond between two people in which each seeks closeness and feels more secure when in the presence of the attachment figure. * Theories * Strange Situation  * Cultural Differences  * Disruption  * Effects of Privation  * Effects of Institutional Care  * Day Care * Theories * Strange Situation  * Cultural Differences  * Disruption  * Effects of Privation  * Effects of Institutional Care  * Day Care...

Words: 337 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Attachment

...with others. According to conclusions reached in the 44 thieves study by Bowlby (1944, as cited by Cardwell, and Flanagan in Psychology AS) he showed that the attachment relationship we have with our primary caregiver during the first 5 years of our lives is crucial to socialization, and that a disruption of this relationship could lead to a higher juvenile delinquency rate, emotional difficulties and antisocial behavior. According to McLeod, S. A. (2008). Privation and Attachment. Retrieved from http://www.simplypsychology.org/privation.html Michael Rutter (1972 as cited in his book Maternal Deprivation re-assessed) suggests that Bowlby’s term “maternal deprivation” as a concept is over simplified; he thinks there is a difference in losing something, which a person once had (deprivation), and never having something (privation). He states that in Bowly’s 44 thieves study that privation occurred, as the children had never formed an attachment due to a series of different caregivers. From his research on privation, Rutter proposes that it is likely to lead to clinging, dependent behavior, attention-seeking and indiscriminate friendliness, then with maturation of he child, there is an inability to keep rules, form lasting relationships, or feel guilt. He also found a development of anti-social behavior, affectionless psychopathy, and disorders of language, intellectual development and physical growth. Rutter argues that these problems are not only due to the lack of......

Words: 1382 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Discuss the Consequences of Privation

...Discuss the Consequences of Privation. (12 marks) Privation occurs if a child is deprived the chance of forming an attachment relationship with another person. The consequences of this can be detrimental to the child’s wellbeing and ability to develop. One consequence of privation is that it could lead to affectionless psychopathy, delinquency and low IQ, as suggested by Bowlby (1946). Bowlby conducted an experiment where he interviewed 44 juvenile thieves, asking them about themselves, their behaviour and childhood experiences. The results showed 14 of the individuals as showing signs of being an affectionless psychopath, of which 12 had been separated from their mothers for a long period of time during the first 2 years of their life. Bowlby concluded from this that delinquency is linked to childhood maternal deprivation, as the delinquents were more likely than the average population to have been deprived in their childhood. However, Schaffer and Emerson found that children develop more than one strong attachment, which contradicts the suggestion that an absent mother is the cause of delinquency. As well as this, Rutter argued that the there is no simple cause and effect relationship between delinquency and maternal deprivation. He suggested that there were other important variable that need to be considered, like the reason of separation from the mother and how the separation was handled. Another criticism is that Hodges and Tizard’s research would support the idea of......

Words: 298 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Sociology

...birth parents, posing the question is attachment just about nurture, or is nature involved too? Furthermore, the third stage is the ‘Critical Period’ this is when babies have to form the attachment with their caregiver during a critical period, this is between birth and 2 ½ years old. Bowlby said that if this didn’t happen the child would be damaged for life socially, emotionally, intellectually and physically, an example of the child not being able to bond or cooperate with other people is a disadvantage, if the child is constantly left alone or palmed off on to different random people the child wouldn’t be able to connect with anyone (this would be from birth to 2 ½ years old). Thirdly is ‘Privation’ when a child does not form any attachment with any significant person it is known as privation, for example children that have been placed in many different foster home or children who are neglected by their parents and experience no love. Bowlby developed Freud’s idea that a child’s first relationship is a ‘internal working model’ for later relationships, and he proposed that this is the first relationship that provides the infant with an attachment template. Each child forms a special mental schema to form early relationships. Relationships will be based on this; the attachment behaviours in the internal working model continue to follow the same template in the future. This is called upon when forming later relationships, so if for example a person had been neglected or......

Words: 1829 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Communist Prison Camp

...Case Study Assignment #1, Communist Prison Camps, Pages 84-85 What Specific techniques were used to bring about the destruction of self-awareness among the prisoners? Specific techniques that were used to bring about the destruction of self-awareness among the prisoners included, physical privation, prolonged interrogation, total isolation from former relationships, detailed regimentation of all daily activities, humiliation, degradation and social alienation by “thought reform” group (s). What opposite processes could be used to create the reverse process, that is, a strengthening of the self-concept? Strengthening of the self-concept could be brought on by using processes such as the five core aspects of self-awareness:   1. Core self-evaluation – Identifying the persons individual personality attributes   2. Values- Identifying the individuals personal standards and moral judgment   3. Cognitive style – Identifying information acquisition and evaluation   4. Attitudes towards change – Identifying adaptability and responsibility   5. Emotional intelligence – Identifying emotional awareness and control. These processes, as they are the very core of the self-concept can be used to work on the persons personality dimensions i.e. neuroticism, extroversion, conscientiousness, agreeableness and openness. Assume that you are charged with the orientation of a cohort of new managers in your organization. How would you help them understand their own strengths and......

Words: 288 - Pages: 2