Free Essay

Philosophical Essay Part 1

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By ahardy21
Words 1239
Pages 5
Philosophical Essay Part 1
5. Socrates asks Euthyphro, “Are morally good acts willed by God because they are morally good, or are they morally good because they are willed by God?” (1) How does this question relate to the Divine Command Theory of morality? (2) What are the philosophical implications associated with each option here?

Divine command theory is widely held to be refuted by an argument known as “the Euthyphro dilemma”. This argument is named after Plato’s Euthyphro dialogue, which contains the inspiration for the argument, though not, as is sometimes thought, the argument itself.
The Euthyphro dilemma rests on a modernised version of the question asked by Socrates in the Euthyphro: “Are morally good acts willed by God because they are morally good, or are they morally good because they are willed by God?”
Each of these two possibilities, the argument runs, leads to consequences that the divine command theorist cannot accept. Whichever way the divine command theorist answers this question, then, it seems that his theory will be refuted. This argument might be formalised as follows:
The Euthyphro Dilemma
(1) If divine command theory is true then either (i) morally good acts are willed by God because they are morally good, or (ii) morally good acts are morally good because they are willed by God.
(2) If (i) morally good acts are willed by God because they are morally good, then they are morally good independent of God’s will.
(3) It is not the case that morally good acts are morally good independent of God’s will.
Therefore:
(4) It is not the case that (i) morally good acts are willed by God because they are morally good.
(5) If (ii) morally good acts are morally good because they are willed by God, then there is no reason either to care about God’s moral goodness or to worship him.
(6) There are reasons both to care about God’s moral goodness and to worship him.
Therefore:
(7) It is not the case that (ii) morally good acts are morally good because they are willed by God.
Therefore:
(8) Divine command theory is false.
The first premise of the Euthyphro dilemma presents two alternatives to the divine command theorist: either morally good acts are willed by God because they are morally good, or morally good acts are morally good because they are willed by God. The two options offered to the divine command theorist are intended to be logically exhaustive, so that if divine command theory is true then one of the options must be the case. The divine command theorist is therefore forced to choose one of the options to affirm.
The second premise states the consequences of the divine command theorist affirming the first of the options offered to him in premise (1), “morally good acts are willed by God because they are morally good”. It states that if the first option is true then the morally good is morally good independent of God’s will. This claim is supported by an argument known as the independence problem.
The third premise denies that the morally good is morally good independent of God’s will. Of course, the critic of divine command theory does not believe this premise to be true; he believes that morality is independent of God’s will. However, the divine command theorist is committed to accepting this claim because divine command theory just is the theory that all moral truths are dependent on God’s will. Though critics of divine command theory disbelieve this premise, then, they can still use it against the divine command theorist.
The first subconclusion, (4) is the rejection of the first option offered to the divine command theorist in premise (1), “morally good acts are willed by God because they are morally good”. That this option is false follows from premises (2) and (3).
Premise (5) states the consequences of the divine command theorist affirming the second of the options offered to him in premise (1), “morally good acts are morally good because they are willed by God”. It states that if this option is true then there is no reason either to care about God’s moral goodness or to worship him. The first claim is supported the emptiness problem, and the second by the problem of abhorrent commands.
(6) states that we do have reason both to care about God’s moral goodness and to worship him. Again, this is used as a premise to which the divine command theorist is committed, rather than as a premise that the critic of divine command theory believes is true.
The second subconclusion, (7), is the rejection of the second option offered to the divine command theorist in premise (1), “morally good acts are morally good because they are willed by God”. (7) follows from premises (5) and (6). Instead of the emptiness problem and the problem of abhorrent commands, the arbitrariness problem can be used to support it, if need be.
Finally, (8) concludes that divine command theory is false. Premise (1) stated that if divine command theory were true then one of the two alternatives offered to the divine command theorist would also be true. The argument from (2) to (7) has, it is claimed, shown that neither alternative is true. It is therefore inferred that divine command theory is false.
Divine Command Theory The Divine Command Theory can be a hot topic for some people to discuss in the field of philosophy. The Divine Command Theory states that an act is permissible or obligatory if and only if that act is allowed or commanded by God. (Class notes 1/12/05) To believe in this theory is to believe that God is good in everything he commands and wills a person to do. This theory though has a few holes that can cause controversy and debate among philosophers, such as the question Socrates expresses in the Euthyphro, “Are morally good acts willed by God because they are morally good, or are they morally good because they are willed by God?” (Plato: Euthyphro) I believe that all acts that are willed by God are good and have bigger purpose than humans are willing to believe. God is the creator of the universe and all that is good and pure; it is in his nature to do good things. God created and blessed all people with a unique creaturely calling. (Genesis 1:26) If one is to believe in the Divine Command Theory, then one must believe that God has nothing but the purest and best intentions. When God created humans, they were as pure as the driven snow, but when the Fall of Humanity happened, sin was introduced to man. The Fall of Humanity means that we cannot know God’s truth and ways by reason or any means other than a personal revelation. So, in order to understand God’s will, we must trust in God’s commands. Even though we may not be able to understand why he commands or wills some things. There are many arguments that hold true to the Divine Command Theory, such as the Abraham argument. This argument states that if the Divine Command Theory is correct, then no matter what God were to will, it would be morally required. (http://courses.washington.edu/phil332) This is evident in the bible with the story of Abraham, in this story, God commands Abraham to kill his one and only son Issac.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Essay 1

...developed in part two of “Discourse of Method” for applying reason to a problem. Descartes’s came up with four following rules based on his own philosophical reasoning to a problem: 1) First, not to accept anything as true unless it is evident. 2) Second, divide any problem into greatest possible number of parts for adequate analysis. 3) Third, study in order of simplicity. 4) Fourth, constantly review the progress so that nothing has been omitted. Results: Currently, general planning process has five steps (1. recognize the problem 2. define the problem 3. develop alternatives 4. evaluate alternatives 5. implement the best option). Using Descartes’s four rules, I would like to propose in according to following tactic: * In addition of recognizing, verify and confirm the problem in step one. * After defining the problem in step two, split the problem into many pieces in step three and analyze each of the pieces exclusively. * After developing alternatives in step four, start with the most clear-cut alternatives and proceed to more complex evaluations in step five. * After implementing the best option in step six, substantiate the whole plan in step seven. Therefore, the resulting planning process, formed by integrating Descartes’ four rules into the “General Planning Process”, is as follows: 1. Recognize and validate the problem 2. Define the problem 3. Divide the problem into many parts & analyze each part......

Words: 1768 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Part 1

...apply concepts learned to a real-life simulation experience. Throughout the Course Project, you will assume that you work as a financial analyst for AirJet Best Parts, Inc. The Course Project is provided in two parts as follows: Part I – In Part I, you work with AirJet Best Parts, Inc. staff to identify the best loan options, as well as to valuate stocks and bonds. Part II – In Part II, you will provide the company with a recommendation for purchasing a new machine. You will base your recommendation on the Net Present Value (NPV) of the capital investment project using the cost of capital (WACC) as your discount rate. About AirJet Best Parts, Inc. AirJet Best Parts, Inc. is a company dedicated to the design and manufacturing of aviation and airplane technologies and parts. The company has commercial and military clients worldwide. Task 1: Assessing loan options for AirJet Best Parts, Inc. The company needs to finance $8,000,000 for a new factory in Mexico. The funds will be obtained through a commercial loan and by issuing corporate bonds. Here is some of the information regarding the APRs offered by two well-known commercial banks. Bank | APR | Number of Times Compounded | National First | Prime Rate + 6.75% | Semiannually | Regions Best | 13.17 | Monthly | 1. Assuming that AirJet Parts, Inc. is considering loans from National First and Regions Best, what are the EARs for these two banks? Hint for National Bank: Go to the St. Louis Federal......

Words: 2010 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Essay 1

...An essay is a piece of writing which is often written from an author's personal[->0] point of view[->1]. Essays can consist of a number of elements, including: literary criticism[->2], political manifestos[->3], learned arguments[->4], observations of daily life, recollections, and reflections of the author. The definition of an essay is vague, overlapping with those of an article[->5] and a short story[->6]. Almost all modern essays are written in prose[->7], but works in verse[->8] have been dubbed essays (e.g. Alexander Pope[->9]'s An Essay on Criticism[->10] and An Essay on Man[->11]). While brevity usually defines an essay, voluminous works like John Locke[->12]'s An Essay Concerning Human Understanding[->13] and Thomas Malthus[->14]'s An Essay on the Principle of Population[->15] are counterexamples. In some countries (e.g., the United States and Canada), essays have become a major part of formal education[->16]. Secondary students are taught structured essay formats to improve their writing skills, and admission essays[->17] are often used by universities[->18] in selecting applicants and, in the humanities and social sciences, as a way of assessing the performance of students during final exams. The concept of an "essay" has been extended to other mediums beyond writing. A film essay is a movie that often incorporates documentary film making styles and which focuses more on the evolution of a theme or an idea. A photographic essay[->19] is an attempt to cover a topic...

Words: 521 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Academic Essay and Its Parts

...Three Parts of an Academic Writing By: Novita Paradise Academic writing is the type of writing that students are expected to produce in response to content they learn about in an academic setting; for instance, school. It’s how they formally join the “scholarly conversation.” And it can begin at a very young age, when a child writes a report about a book he has read or a topic she/he has learned about. It is not a personal experience, nor a story, nor merely a description. Academic writing tells us what the writer thinks and what evidence has contributed to that thinking. The evidence can include the writer’s personal experiences, information found in other books or sources, or information gleaned from talking with others such as a parent or expert. Knowing how to write academic essay is essential for developing good composition skills. It gives the author an easy format for clear organization and explanation of a topic. Many literature and composition classes require academic essays because of the simplicity and clarity they bring to a specific topic and that is why understanding academic essay is important. Academic essay consists of three parts—the introduction, the body, and the conclusion—and each part plays a role that is vital to the structure and presentation of the essay. The introduction sets the foundation of the paper and is concluded with the thesis statement, which is what the rest of the paper will address. The introduction consists of one paragraph......

Words: 715 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Philosophical Sophocles Essay

...Philosophical Essay Sophocles once said that nothing in the world was more wondrous than man. Well I think the question is debatable so long as "most wonderful in the world" excludes heaven and all those ecclesiastical bodies. I do believe that humans are the most advanced organisms on the planet. We aren't at the very top of the food chain by accident. We are the smartest and really do have dominion over all over things on Earth. But, this is a double edged sword; although we are the rulers and have a partial right to most animals (like eating them for sustenance), we are responsible for their well-being. Whenever a natural disaster happens or something puts animal life at risk, it's our duty to help them. And whenever we do something that has a byproduct to the environment we are fully culpable and are required to do everything we can to right our wrong. I do believe that we are the smartest and most advanced organisms (at least as far as we know) and rule the animal kingdom; but our wonder may be outdone by the natural awe of nature. Like the power of a volcano or the full force of the ocean. To answer what we know as the truth, a classic answer would be God. But on a smaller scale we realize that we actually have proof for very few things. Can we really prove that what we see and feel aren't just figments of our imagination. There is a common theory of what if my red is your green and vice versa. Things like this we will never know or have proof of. Although we......

Words: 461 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Philosophical Essay

...Philosophical Essay (tolerance and Justice) William Touvell Ohio Christian University Ph2000 Introduction to Philosophy Van Kuiken May 9, 2011 Tolerance Tolerance is defined as the capacity for or practice of respecting and recognizing another person’s opinions, practices, behaviors, or beliefs. (editor), 1976). Tolerance can cross into many categories of life from different cultures, the type of music we like, moral issues, religion and many others. More and more these days they are teaching our children in school that we must practice tolerance with all groups of people. I have also heard it described as just agreeing not to disagree; so you avoid any arguments or hurt feelings. The other thing that tolerance can be tied into is that of ethical relativism. Nash defines ethical relativism as the belief that moral beliefs that are conflicting at times can be true at the same time in the same sense. (Nash, 1999). The problems with ethical relativism, is that it’s really confusing and it gives way to numerous paradoxical consequences. The biggest one is when one accepts this way of thinking, that there can be no moral code we use that is better than another. Nash put it this way “if there is no transcendent, objective grounds for moral criticism, no side can be more right than the other.” (Nash, 1999). Some of the other points made are that if we accept this belief than why do we strive to become better people, when no human is any better than his fellow man? ......

Words: 932 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Essay 1

...Stephen Cunningham English 101 Trotter February 1, 2015 Essay #1 The Death of an Elephant In George Orwell’s essay “Shooting an Elephant”, he spent some time in India as a policeman for the British Empire in Burma. Orwell chose a specific event from that time involving an elephant rampaging through a bazaar. Not only was property destroyed but a person, specifically a coolie, was killed. There were over 2000 Burmese watching him and wondering what he was going to do about it. He felt compelled to shoot the elephant. According to Wikipedia, Imperialism happens when a stronger nation takes over a weaker nation and dominates their social, economic, religious and cultural freedoms. There have been many nations in history that have oppressed others. For example Hitler and the Nazis oppressed many countries and tried to exterminate the Jewish population. As an Englishman in Burma, Orwell was hated by the Burmese. On the other hand, he did not agree with imperialism such as British rule over India. However, he was mocked, spit on, pushed down and made to feel like a fool. He was told by the sub inspector to go check out the event with the elephant. He took his 44 Winchester rifle just in case, even though the rifle would not do much harm against the elephant. He was curious to see what was going on. He followed the path of destruction, to find the elephant had killed a coolie in a grizzly manner. Later on he found the elephant grazing peacefully in a field. Even......

Words: 646 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Part 1

... “Ms. Mason. Ms. Mason. Open the door please.” I knew that little voice, Christine Collins the girl next door I watch. Tears rolling down her face, “Please it’s my mommy…help her.” Christine’s mother was lying on the living room floor. “Mrs. Collins? Can you hear me? It’s Beth.” I glanced at Christine whose head was berried in her hands. How do I tell an eight-year-old girl her mother wasn’t breathing? I pulled her next to me, “Sweetie” before I could talk she spoke, “Is she asleep like my daddy, Ms. Mason?” I have forgot that her father passed away less than two months ago. I just nodded, “Can I come with you?” kissing her head, “Of course you can. I can’t leave you here alone. Go get some things together.” I had no way of calling 9-1-1 so I laid a cover over her. Christine came out of her room with a book bag and a stuffed teddy bear. We went back over to my house. “Ms. mason?” I stopped her, “Christine I am only 18 you don’t have to talk to me like you do my mother honey. You can call me Beth.” She smiled, “Okay. Um Beth where is your mommy?” We got in my small two door car that looks like it could fall apart any second. It was hard to get down our street, cars where just in the middle of the road. I threw a jacket over Christine’s face. I didn’t want to see bloody people on the ground or leaning half way out of their car doors. What in the world has happened? The police stations was the exact same. Dead people were all around. I found my mother half awake at her......

Words: 1426 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Philosophical Essay

...[Name of Student] [Name of Instructor] [Course Code] [Date of Submission] An Essay on Politics, Politicians and Political Parties When the term politician is mentioned, we immediately think of a person of honor. At times, we think that the person may most likely have a criminal record especially if the politician is from a developing country. Another thought is that the person is from a royal family as a prince, king or emperor. Politicians in most cases are entangled in controversies. We tend to see them begging for votes during or around the election time. The often have many promises to the electorate being put across using slogans, posters, and sweet words. These promises give false hopes to the citizens. Almost every time after these elections, these hopes are shattered, and the people then realize they made a mistake to put the politicians in power. In addition, the issue of elections rigging is often the case diluting the effort of the people who were targeting positive change in the governance of their country. The citizens are usually the ones that are greatly affected by corrupt leadership. We, therefore, tend to ask ourselves whether the problem is with the leadership or use of the electorate. Do we lack the ability to choose good leaders? Is the political seat by itself responsible for turning all people that aspire for it to be corrupt? If there is a lack of our abilities to choose a good leader, then action should be taken to decide wisely during......

Words: 1341 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Est 1 Part 1

...customer service and quality products are the key factors for successful businesses. In company Q’s case, they are failing at both, especially when they don’t even have the support from their own community. It is probably a good thing that they closed two of their stores in higher-crime-rate areas of the city because being in a higher-crime-rate areas would drive their customers away even more so. Even though Company Q can care less about the social responsibility, maybe we can still recommend few pointers to help them improve the business. First, Company Q needs to understand that their manager doesn’t have the best interest in the company. I believe that the company should either let him go or let him know that they would love to be a part of their community and start respecting their wishes. In order to gain the respect from the community, the company should have the manager apologize sincerely to local food bank for the previous incident and make a big donation. Second, Company Q should definitely keep health-conscience and organic products and maybe even have varieties of it to make that their “thing”. This is another way to please the local customers since they have been requesting these products for years. It will put the company’s name out there after people start recognizing that the company changed their ways for the better and for their customers and possibly develop a good image for the company. Company Q should also have the store manager make fliers and......

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Part 1

...Mod 6: Discussion Questions Actions for Mod 6: Discussion Questions Part 1 Read the article People Can Equal Profits or Problems. Briefly identify the author’s position on personal relationships in the workplace. Do you agree with the author's position? Why? Why not? Have you encountered similar dilemma at your job, school, or other settings? How did you resolve it? Part 2 How do you see American society today in terms of class relations and social mobility? Do you see the American education system as reinforcing the opportunity for social mobility or perpetuating the class division in this nation? Why? Part 3 Referring to your readings in Mor Barak, what is the most prominent cultural style and relational mental model at your workplace or other organizations to which you belong (e.g. school) Part 1 In the article “People Can Equal Profits or Problems” by Joseph Schmitt, I believe that the author is against the personal relationship in the workplace, and he also points out that having a great leader is important for attracting good people. According to the article, “If companies have people problems, they probably have a problem with the leadership that is administering the people programs. If companies want to attract good people, then the first step they need to take is to be certain great people lead them. Worse than bad hiring processes, layers of nepotism and cronyism send clear messages that who you know and to whom you are related are much more important......

Words: 616 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Business Essay Part 1

...arise. On the other hand, some providers, including ourselves, provide cloud storage with unlimited bandwidth, so be sure to ask your provider if bandwidth will be measured.  Even with bandwidth charges, many industry experts still believe that this platform offers cost savings over more traditional storage options. * Data Security– As data is stored remotely, some concerns surround the possibility of data commingling with other organizations. And, some professionals are concerned about the general security and privacy of information stored in these remote locations. To alleviate these concerns, we at W-CONNECT Inc. suggest you choose a partner that encrypts your data. Five defining characteristics of cloud computing: Characteristic 1: Dynamic computing infrastructure Cloud computing requires a dynamic computing infrastructure. The foundation for the dynamic infrastructure is a standardized, scalable, and secure physical infrastructure. There should be levels of redundancy to ensure high levels of availability, but mostly it must be easy to extend as usage growth demands it, without requiring architecture rework. Next, it must be virtualized. Characteristic 2: IT service-centric approach Cloud computing is IT (or business) service-centric. This is in stark contrast to more traditional system- or server- centric models. In most cases, users of the cloud generally want to run some business service or application for a specific, timely purpose; they don’t want to get......

Words: 1571 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Philosophical Life Essay

... 1) Choose a topic or question. If you're an undergraduate, you may find that the question will be set, or you may have to pick from a set of questions. If you're doing higher level work, you'll need to pick a topic which may then be formed into a question. * Writing about a subject you're passionate about always proves easiest. What subject speaks out to you? (Beware of not having an open mind or not enough distance when choosing a subject you care about.) If you're having difficulty choosing which questions to answer in an exam or homework situation, for each question, ask yourself the question "how difficult would it be for me to answer this question?", and choose a number between zero and five. Put the number next to the questions on the exam paper or homework sheet and then choose the highest ranked questions. 2) Work out how to answer the actual question. Too many people fail in academic situations because they don't answer the question on the page. The question is set specifically to get you to think in a certain way, not so you can spot a name or theory you know and just write out everything you know about that person or idea. In an exam or homework type situation, you need to answer the question that has actually been set, not the question you wish had been set - the two are often quite different. * Many questions will start with a quote followed simply by the word "Discuss." There are two possible things you need to do here: firstly, it may be asking you......

Words: 1821 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Parts of Essay

...Parts of an Essay [pic]Essays, like sandwiches or burgers, are divided into different parts. These parts are the: ▪ Introduction ▪ Body ▪ Conclusion The Introduction The introduction opens the essay. It is a short paragraph – usually about THREE sentences. In an argument essay, it usually describes or summarizes both sides of the present situation and says what you are going to do in your essay. Read more about Introductions here. The Body The Body is the main part of the essay. In an argument essay, it is divided into two or three paragraphs, giving your opinion and reasons. Each paragraph in the body is between FIVE and SEVEN sentences long. Read more about the Body of the essay here. Conclusion The Conclusion is the end of the essay. It is a short paragraph – about THREE sentences. It often has the same idea as the Introduction, only in different words. Some people think of the essay as a sandwich. The Introduction and Conclusion are the bread, and the Body is the filling in the center. If the introduction looks good, people will carry on to the body. Hopefully, the conclusion will leave them with a nice taste in their mouth… | | |There are three main parts of an essay paper. | |  ...

Words: 363 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Part 1

...camera phones, and other wireless communication devices. Online shopping is a regular part of their lives. Their functional areas of the business that they currently use information resources would include things such as; payroll, inventory ordering for food stuffs, scheduling, ticket sales, and the intranet that they have set up for their employees. Currently the two owners of Club IT have worked through the issues that have come to them as needed but, according to Appendix D, the back office is being run in a cramped office space with dial up internet service. The owners are currently using multiple suppliers to bring in all of the goods that they need and have the ability to order a portion of the goods on line and other cannot be. The second use of management that they are using is the booking of the entertainment for the club. The owners currently use telephone and in person sales to promote concerts that they host. The owners have asked to have an evaluation done to see what types of information technology can be incorporated to help streamline the process and make the club more profitable. The first thing that was noticed was the slow speed of the internet connection that they have in place. The starting point of the revamp plan would include high speed internet, along with the need for a dedicated office space that would be big enough to work comfortably. From there the next part of the plan that I would offer is working to see if we could find vendors that could......

Words: 729 - Pages: 3