Premium Essay

Performance of an Existing Duty in Itself Is Not a Sufficient Consideration

In: Other Topics

Submitted By RachelCN
Words 820
Pages 4
The Performance of an existing duty is not in itself sufficient consideration to legally enforce a promise.

Valuable consideration is the essential element to the formation of a valid contract. In Currie v Misa, Lord J stated that a valuable consideration, in the sense of law, may consist either in some right, interest, profit or benefit accruing to the one party, or some forbearance, detriment, loss or responsibility given, suffered or undertaken by the other. In other words, it is ‘the element of exchange in a contract’ or ‘the price paid for a promise’. Performance of an existing duty is one of the general rule of valid consideration. Where a promisee already owes the promisor a legal duty, then in theory performing the duty should not in itself be consideration. Existing duties fall into various categories which are public duty, contractual duties to the promisor and contractual duties to a third party. Where a person is merely carrying out duties they were obliged to perform such as police officer protecting citizens or a jury listening to the evidence, it cannot amount to consideration for a promised award. In Collins v Godefroy, the defendant promised to pay a fee to the plaintiff who had been summoned to give evidence in a court action. It was held that he was obliged to give the evidence. Hence, doing so could not be consideration. However, where a person is under a public duty, but does something goes beyond what they are bound to do under that duty, that extra act can amount to consideration. As in the case Glasbrook Brothers v Glamorgan City Council, the defendants were the owners of a coal mine who promised to pay police for protection during the strike. After the strike, they refused to pay claiming they were obliged to give protection. The police officers brought an action against the owners for the payment, arguing they did more than what…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Fiduciary Duties

...FIDUCIARY DUTIES AND OTHER RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATE DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS Morrison & Foerster LLP Christopher M. Forrester Celeste S. Ferber RR DONNELLEY EZ START XBRL We Tag. You Validate. We File. With the release of the proposed rule, the SEC will require the use of XBRL for financial reporting starting as early as 2009 for some companies. RR Donnelley is uniquely qualified to give you guidance on how your company can prepare for the SEC mandate. As the market leader in XBRL filings, we have been helping leading companies successfully tag and file XBRL financials since the inception of the SEC Voluntary Filing Program. RR Donnelley’s proven EZ Start XBRL full-service solution is designed to save you crucial time. With EZ Start, we do the initial tagging for you, reducing the time spent mapping and validating XBRL tags to under ten hours. Our goal is to transfer knowledge to your financial team to ensure a firm understanding of the taxonomies, mapping process and SEC requirements. To learn more, visit FIDUCIARY DUTIES AND OTHER RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATE DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP Christopher M. Forrester Celeste S. Ferber RR Donnelley Global Capital Markets Copyright© 2008 Morrison & Foerster LLP (No claim to original U.S. Government works) All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic...

Words: 49138 - Pages: 197

Premium Essay

Production Performance of the Existing Equipment

...It is of decisive significance for the correct portfolio building and its successful management. Part of the questions you have to answer, in order to make a successful selection and build a product portfolio that is stronger compared to the individual products or services and that has long term market advantages, are: What stage of their life cycle are you products in? Do you produce the necessary products to place your company in the desired position on the market? Do you have "useless" products? What do you do when your competitor brings a new product on the market? How do you decide whether to take a product off the market or introduce a new one? The main criteria used to form a company´s portfolio are: production performance of the existing equipment unoccupied market niches opportunities for quick profit. However, you have to be always aware of the role and share of each product in your company´s portfolio. The logical portfolio consistency shows how the products are integrated - production technologies, required knowledge and skills, benefits for customers, methods of marketing and selling. If your portfolio contains products resulting from accidental opportunities that the company did not want to miss, but they do not have direct relation to what you offer to your customers, you have to stop and think. And after that take them out of the portfolio unhesitatingly. This will reduce your costs and optimize processes in your business in a most natural and......

Words: 552 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Segregation of Duties

...Segregation of Duties One element of IT audit is to audit the IT function. While there are many important aspects of the IT function that need to be addressed in an audit or risk assessment, the fundamental element of internal control is the segregation of certain key duties, especially as it relates to risk. The basic idea underlying segregation of duties (SOD) is that no single employee should be in a position both to perpetrate and to conceal errors or fraud in the normal course of their duties. Similar to traditional SOD in accounting functions, SOD in IT plays a major role in reducing certain risk, and does so in a similar fashion as well. Duties that should be segregated include: 1. Custody of the assets 2. Authorization 3. Recording transactions If adequate segregation of duties does not exist, the following could occur: 1. Misappropriation of assets 2. Misstated financial statements 3. Inaccurate financial documentation (i.e. errors or irregularities) 4. Improper use of funds or modification of data could go undetected 5. Unauthorized or erroneous changes or modification of data and programs may not be detected As the figure 1 shows, there are some of the key roles and functions that need to be segregated. 1. IT Duties vs. User Departments The most basic segregation is the segregation of the duties of the IT function from user departments. Generally speaking, this means the user department does not perform its own IT duties. While a department......

Words: 2548 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Consideration Law

...Consideration Student Name Instructor Name University Affiliation Date Abstract Consideration is the price that the promisor asks in exchange for their promise, that is, the price of a given promise. Consideration is not a significant part of a contract in a number of jurisdictions. Once parties have reached a binding agreement, that becomes sufficient. Nevertheless, the common law requires that for agreement to be binding, the person to whom a promise is made (promisee) must offer consideration (maybe in monetary terms) for the promise given to him (Lorenzen, 1918, p.28). Hence, most gratuitous promises are never enforced because of a few exceptions. There are different types of consideration and they include: Executory consideration Executory consideration is a type of consideration where the promise has not yet completed the requirements of the consideration. Therefore, executory consideration will exist in cases where the promisor’s promise is made in return for a counter-promise from the plaintiff. For instance, A makes a promise of delivering some products to B at a future date and B promises to make payment for the goods once he receives the shipment. B can sue A for breach of contract if A fails to deliver the goods (Carter et al., 1996, p. 312). Executed consideration Consideration is termed as executed when the consideration is issued at the time the contract is made. Therefore, an executed consideration will only come into existence when the......

Words: 1833 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...Consideration is one of the elements that are required to form a contract. In consideration, both parties must promise to give or do something for the other. (Note: if a contract is made by deed, then consideration is not needed.) In other word, consideration can be described as the mutual rights and promises made by the parties to a contract. This can be either a promise to do something that a person not legally obligated to do, or a promise not to do something that a person have the right to do (often, this means a promise not to file a lawsuit). There are a lot of rules that must be taken in order to govern consideration. One of them is consideration can be present or future, but not past. Present consideration is executed when the consideration is performed at the time the contract is made. As an example, Lin offers RM100.00 reward for the return of her lost handbag, if Alex finds the bag and returns it, Lin's consideration is executed. Meanwhile, future consideration will happen when there is an exchange of promises to perform acts in the future. For example, Mei promises to deliver goods to John at a future date and John promises to pay on delivery. If Mei does not deliver them, this is a breach of contract and John can sue. However, past consideration is not a valid consideration and has no legal value.  Past consideration arises when a promisee’s action has happened before the promisor made his promise. This can be proved in the Roscorla v. Thomas case. In this......

Words: 1251 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Sufficiency of Consideration

...Essentially, consideration is one of the sixth elements of contract which will be discussed in this essay. According to Lord Pollock, in Dunlop v Selfridge Ltd, consideration is ‘an act or forbearance of one party or the promise thereof, is the price for which the promise of the other is bought, and the promise thus given for value is enforceable,’ Some elements of consideration which also will be discussed are it must be sufficient in the eyes of law, it need not be adequate, it must not so vague, it can be present or future, but cannot be past. In this essay, I am going to discuss about consideration needs only be sufficient, not adequate and to consider whether there is a sufficient consideration in situations where there is pre-existing legal or contractual duty, and in situations as in Williams and Roffrey Bros or practical benefit. Consideration need only be sufficient, not adequate. It means the court has no interest in determining whether the consideration for a promise is equal to the value of that promise. As long as there is some consideration provided for the promise, the court will enforce that promise. Furthermore, it can be divided into 4 parts. The first part is consideration must have value in the eyes of the law. It means the price does not necessarily to be right as long as there is a value, and the court will not process any further. The case that illustrates this concept is Chappel & Co. v Nestle Co. Ltd. Nestle offered the opportunity to purchase......

Words: 1668 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...Consideration is considered to be the third element of contract law that needs to exist to form a contract. There is an exchange of promises between two parties a promisor and a promisee where each party either have a benefit or suffer a detriment, which is referred to be a consideration. Sir Frederick Pollock defined consideration as "An act or forebearance of one party, or the promise thereof, is the price for which the promise of the other is bought, and the promise thus given for value is enforceable" authorized by Lord Dunedin in Dunlop v Selfridge Ltd [1915] AC 847. In the sense of law, consideration should value something (Thomas v Thomas) (1842)and doesn’t include any promises of affection or feelings or other moral/gratuitous promises. Consideration can also be any type of advantage to the promisor while it often is an amount of money paid. Even though, there is an advantage or a disadvantage to either a promisor or the promisee, there are no exact amount or value. Until and unless there are some, courts aren’t bothered about the adequacy of the consideration as both parties are allowed to bargain their liberty of contract that’s good for themselves with no obstacles from courts. (Harvey, 2013). Consideration is a significant part of a lawfully enforceable contract, as the absence of it would restrict the law from enforcing the promises made by the promisor during an agreement made or contract formed. However, the existence of consideration doesn’t itself solve......

Words: 1426 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Justifying Fiduciary Duties

...McGill Law Journal ~ Revue de droit de McGill JUSTIFYING FIDUCIARY DUTIES Paul B. Miller* Fiduciary duties are critical to the integrity of a remarkable variety of relationships, including those between trustee and beneficiary, director and corporation, agent and principal, lawyer and client, doctor and patient, parent and child, and guardian and ward. Notwithstanding their variety, all fiduciary relationships are presumed to enjoy common characteristics and to attract a core set of demanding legal duties, most notably a duty of loyalty. Surprisingly, however, the justification for fiduciary duties is an enigma in private law theory. It is unclear what makes a relationship fiduciary and why fiduciary relationships attract fiduciary duties. This article takes up the enigma. It assesses leading reductivist and instrumentalist analyses of the justification for fiduciary duties. Finding them wanting, it offers an alternative account of the juridical justification for fiduciary duties. The author contends that the fiduciary relationship is a distinctive kind of legal relationship in which one person (the fiduciary) exercises power over practical interests of another (the beneficiary). Fiduciary power is a form of authority derived from the legal capacity of the beneficiary or a benefactor. The duty of loyalty is justified on the basis that it secures the exclusivity of the beneficiary’s claim over fiduciary power so understood. Les obligations fiduciaires sont essentielles......

Words: 25852 - Pages: 104

Premium Essay

Existing Brand Research Report

...Name: University: Course: Tutor: Date: Existing Brand Research Report Urban Outfitters Urban Outfitters brand was introduced by Urban Outfitters, inc. which is a multinational clothing corporation that has its distinct brand and has its headquarters in Philadelphia in the United States. It operates in United States and in Europe serving a dynamic market and also controlling a significant market share. The promise of the brand is to provide for its consumers relevant trends that will make them unique and stand out in a fashion industry that is experiencing complex and dynamic levels of competition. That means that an understanding of the tastes and preferences needed in the market is not enough as the brands need to act as trend setters (Urban Outfitters 2014). Urban Outfitters have a diverse inventory which includes clothing, house wares, and foot wares. The trends incorporated include kitschy, vintage, hipster, bohemian, and ironically humorous styles. Urban Outfitters brand has been associated with several other brands due to their relation to the company Urban Outfitters, inc. and the other brands include Terrain, BHLDN, Free People, and Anthropologies. Urban Outfitters brand in terms of persona it represents a unique style to young members of the society which makes individuals distinct and sets them apart from others. It links trendy fashion to music and lifestyle through presentation of products from famous designers in the modern society (Urban Outfitters......

Words: 2370 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Performance Management Plan

...Landslide Limousines: Performance Management Plan N’Jheri N. Price HRM/531 Bradley Stonefield, the business owner of Landslide Limousines; a luxury car service in Austin, Texas started his business with 25 employees and expected $50,000 in annual profits. He intends to gain an increase of 5% over the next few years. His expected turnover rate is relatively low for the size of his organization (10%). However, in order for Mr. Stonefield to attain a level of success he wishes for his new business, and perhaps significantly lower his turnover rate, he must establish a set of guidelines to facilitate his efforts. This guide is a performance management plan. The performance management plan is a guide that will enable a high level of success and provides means to measure the effectiveness of business operation or employees. The performance management plan is a key component to the success of any organization usually established by the executive staff. In this case Mr. Stonefield and his business colleagues are at the executive level. They will outline key performance strategies, financial needs for operations, align goals and responsibilities for individuals in the company, and collect performance data from the different departments. The performance management plan is important as it can collect data and analyze the information against predetermined guidelines, goals, or objectives; usually specific to the task or function being reviewed. Individual goal and......

Words: 1876 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Cultural Considerations

...Cultural Considerations AJS/504 July 27, 2015 University of Phoenix Cultural Considerations This paper is going to discuss different culture concerns, and what the influences are in today’s society within the criminal justice system. Also, this paper will talk about how to attend to different culture concerns, security administration, and how influences affect the criminal justice system. Some of the other points that are going to be touched up on are contemporary methods that are used in societies of assorted cultures, how these different influences and considerations related to and affect nondiscrimination practices within the criminal justice system. Last but not least, this paper is going to go over Sir Roberts Peel’s nine principles, and how they coincide within today’s police forces. The military employment across the countries in the Middle East and Europe has brought police forces into question. The local police forces have their own way of training that is similar to the military training. The military is helping individuals that are being abused by the hands of the police. In most of these cases where military law is present and security is more existing the police appear to be more on the military side than working for the countries government or community. This abuse does not happen within the United States, but the problem within the United States that is going on with the police and the security with the employment. With all of these different......

Words: 1608 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Directors Duties and Responsibilities

...Limited, Centro Property Trust and Centro Retail Trust (collectively referred to as Centro). Financial statements are essential for the accurate assessment of risks faced by any company. The decision in the Centro case clearly emphasises this point. Directors should be well equipped with basic accounting knowledge and be conscious of their duty to properly assess and review financial statements. It was also highlighted that directors should be warned against simply delegating financial reporting obligations to other qualified and trusted professionals. ASIC is seeking that each of the defendants pay pecuniary penalties and be disqualified from managing corporations. The pessimists of the world have interpreted Justice Middleton’s message as a rise in expectations of the duties and responsibilities of directors, making the role of a director next to impossible to perform. Others are not surprised by the outcome and believe it is positive in providing clarity on the responsibilities of directors. The underlying message of the case is to increase awareness of the existing legislation, and to remind directors of the duty they owe to their shareholders. The situation proposed in this case is unique and with an increased awareness, an oversight of this magnitude is unlikely to reoccur. 2. The Impact of the Centro Case Judgment ________________________________________ Implications for Directors The level of understanding required in reviewing and......

Words: 2605 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Duties constructions. Many home builders order prefabricated roof trusses from a manufacturer and have them delivered to a building site because building roof trusses is labor intensive and prefabricated roof trusses save time, materials, and money. 5 Advantages to using Roof Trusses: 1. Carpenters with less experience can set trusses, lowering labor costs. 2. Fewer interior load bearing walls are needed due to the trusses’ longer free span. 3. Shorter lengths of stock 2×4 are used to build trusses, reducing material prices. 4. Structural engineers design and certify roof trusses. 5. Trusses can usually be set in 1 day, meaning the interior of the home is exposed to the weather for a minimal amount of time. Roof Truss Considerations When considering roof trusses for your home, they should not be chosen based on looks alone – an experienced architect, engineer, or truss designer usually helps to determine the roof truss design best suited to the building under construction. Someone with training specific to roof trusses will be able to make the most use of the room in your home, giving it the desired amount of space you are looking for. For example, a different type of roof truss design can be used in various areas of your home, making it possible to customize the look you want in different rooms, while still maintaining the same exterior appearance. Another thing to be aware of is that some roof trusses may be practical for the weather in a particular......

Words: 4631 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Forgiving a Director’s Breach of Duty

...Forgiving a Director’s Breach of Duty: A review of recent decisions By Steven Wong1 1 Senior Associate, Corrs Chambers Westgarth, Perth. The author can be contacted at 4980429v3 Forgiving a Director’s Breach of Duty: A review of recent decisions Introduction Amid fears of a global recession, directors may well be concerned that their conduct will be scrutinised should they be involved in a corporate collapse. Honest directors risk becoming embroiled in litigation and face “the associated reputational damage and the potential for ultimate financial ruin”2. A director must make commercial decisions. These decisions often involve some form of commercial risk and are sometimes made on the basis of limited information. It would be unjust to hold directors personally liable for a breach of duty, regardless of the situation. Section 1318 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) provides some protection for company officers3 against the consequences of a breach of duty in limited circumstances4. The section confers a discretionary power on courts, which reads: If, in any civil proceeding against a person to whom this section applies for negligence, default, breach of trust or breach of duty in a capacity as such a person, it appears to the court before which the proceedings are taken that the person is or may be liable in respect of the negligence, default or breach 2 John Story, Chairman of Suncorp and Tabway quoted in the......

Words: 10736 - Pages: 43

Free Essay

Ethical Considerations

...describes itself as an independent organization dedicated to protecting human rights by exposing violations and trying to end abuses (Human Rights Watch, N.D.). Their 2005 study of three American meat packing plants revealed what they claim to be unsafe working conditions; intimidation of union organizers; denial of worker’s compensation claims for on the job injuries; and the exploitation of worker’ immigrations status to prevent complaints (Gonzalez, 2005). As a result of their investigation Human Rights Watch (2005) arrived at several recommendations they assert will address the problems they found. These recommendations include: new federal and state laws to reduce production line speeds; stronger state regulations to halt underreporting of injuries; stronger worker compensation laws; stricter enforcement of anti-retaliation laws; U.S. labor law compliance with international standards on workers' freedom of association; and new laws ensuring workers' safety regardless of their immigration status. The existence of existing laws and regulations that address the same areas as the Human Rights Watch report begs the question if these recommendations are worthy of support. Denial of Problem and Recommendations As can be expected, the meat packers deny the Human Rights Watch claims and see no need for further regulation. The American Meat Institute’s J. Patrick Boyle said it would take as many pages to dispute the falsehoods in the report as the report itself. Boyle......

Words: 1780 - Pages: 8