Premium Essay

Malaysia Company Fraud: Cooking the Book

In: Business and Management

Submitted By yongchen
Words 5312
Pages 22
International Journal of Business and Social Science

Vol. 4 No. 13; October 2013

Cooking the Books: The Case of Malaysian Listed Companies
Fathilatul Zakimi Abdul Hamid Rohami Shafie Zaleha Othman Wan Nordin Wan Hussin Faudziah Hanim Fadzil School of Accountancy Universiti Utara Malaysia Sintok, 06010 Kedah Malaysia.

Cooking the books refers to fraudulent accounting activities undertaken by a business to falsify its financial statements. Thus, the objectives of this study are to investigate what the cooking-the-books activities carried out by businesses consist of, how they conduct them, and what the impact is on the business and its shareholders. The case study sample companies are two Malaysian companies that had received various awards from reputable third-party organizations. On the other hand, the activities undertaken in both companies have caused them to be labelled as Malaysian mini Enrons. We employ a qualitative research methodology as most prior research employs a quantitative methodology to investigate the determinant factors in businesses’ cooking-the-book activities. The result of the study shows that the managers have used their positions, prior experience, and regulatory loopholes in their activities. Furthermore, the financial report restatement and higher reported earnings are the early warning signals of their activities. As a result of this, the Malaysian Securities Commission has revised the corporate governance code, and among others incorporated the Audit Oversight Board, known in the US as the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. Key words: Cooking the Books, Financial Statement Fraud, Earnings Management, Malaysia, Developing Countries

1. Introduction
Belkaoui defined accounting as “the process of identifying, measuring and communicating economic information to permit informed judgements and decisions by the…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Top 10 of Malaysia Company

...Top 10 of Malaysia takes a brief look at some top Malaysian companies on the back of trials and tribulations experienced on a global scale last year. In 2011 many countries have been hit by challenges brought about by natural disasters, financial crises and political upheavals. Malaysia, as an emerging market, is expected to be still attractive to many investors, be they local or foreign. The start of 2012 has brought with it a myriad of new aspirations and resolve for companies in Malaysia. Maybank remained the company with the highest market valuation on Bursa, standing at RM62 billion while CIMB, at the number 2 spot in December 2011 with a market valuation of RM55 billion then, went down to the 4th spot on the current list after shedding some RM4 billion in market value. It was upstaged by Sime Darby and Petronas whose market valuations stood at RM55 billion and RM53 billion respectively. Maxis and Genting too, stood above Axiata which retreated about RM2 billion in its market value. Petronas hopes to improve its bottom line where natural gas is concerned with the operation of its gas import terminal at Melaka which is scheduled to be in operation in August this year and the acceptance of its proposal for a gas pricing mechanism. JCY International, a hard disk drive manufacturer, is again the top company in the technology sector with a market capitalisation of RM2.7 billion. Its share price has doubled in just over two months in recent......

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cooking the Books

...States. In addition, they were the second-largest long distance carrier in 1998 and 2002. How the Fraud Happened So what happened? In 1999, revenue growth slowed and the stock price began falling. WorldCom's expenses as a percentage of its total revenue increased because the growth rate of its earnings dropped. This also meant WorldCom's earnings might not meet Wall Street analysts' expectations. In an effort to increase revenue, WorldCom reduced the amount of money it held in reserve (to cover liabilities for the companies it had acquired) by $2.8 billion and moved this money into the revenue line of its financial statements. That wasn't enough to boost the earnings that Ebbers wanted. In 2000, WorldCom began classifying operating expenses as long-term capital investments. Hiding these expenses in this way gave them another $3.85 billion. These newly classified assets were expenses that WorldCom paid to lease phone network lines from other companies to access their networks. They also added a journal entry for $500 million in computer expenses, but supporting documents for the expenses were never found. These changes turned WorldCom's losses into profits to the tune of $1.38 billion in 2001. It also made WorldCom's assets appear more valuable. How it Was Discovered After tips were sent to the internal audit team and accounting irregularities were spotted in MCI's books, the SEC requested that WorldCom provide more information. The SEC was suspicious because......

Words: 509 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Audit Summary for 3 Companies in Malaysia

...s in Ma AUDIT SUMMARY LETCURER SIR AMIRUL HAFIZ MOHD NASIR GROUP MEMBERS MUHAMMAD IQMAL HISHAM BIN KAMARUDDIN (1100141) NUR ADILA AYUB (1100720) HALIMAHTUN SAADIAH BINTI ZAKARIA (1100138) NUR FAHANA ZAHARI (1100730) MOHD ZULKEFLI BIN HASAN (1100731) AUDIT ASSURANCE AND SERVICES MAD 3013 COMPANIES BACKGROUND NAME OF COMPANY | FAST TRACK SOLUTION HOLDINGS BERHAD | FLONIC HI-TECH BERHAD | FOKUS DYNAMICS TECHNOLOGIES | BACKGROUND | Fast Track Solution Holdings Berhad, was incorporated in 2003, which is an investment holding of multiple subsidiaries in Malaysia. Throughout our various subsidiaries we are involved and provide activities like R&D, Marketing & Distribution in enterprise hardware and software solutions. In addition, we also provide online games development, publishing, marketing and distribution. | Flonic is a global leading manufacturer of critical & precision cleaning system for all kinds of industries. For more than 20 years, they have been supporting companies ranging from Fortune 500 to small-medium sized enterprises across the globe. With their highly advanced technology available on hand, we are able to cater to virtually any types of cleaning requirements for any industry. | Focus Dynamics Group is a fast developing international business specializing in Energy Efficiency Solutions, LED Lighting, Industrial Control Systems and Products. | YEAR | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2009 | 2010 |...

Words: 1100 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Enron Fraud

...Accounting fraud case Halliburton, one of the world's largest providers of products and services in the oil and gas industries, had several lawsuits brought against them and its former CEO, Vice President Dick Cheney. The allegations claim that Halliburton illegally overstated its revenues in order to hide losses the company had experienced because of under estimating costs for construction projects, and a downturn in the oil industry. The claim also states that the company violated U.S. securities laws and defrauded stockholders. Halliburton settled the lawsuits for $7.5 million although the SEC continues its investigation of the accounting allegations. (SEC Charges Halliburton and Two Former Officers for Failure to Disclose a 1998 Change in Accounting Practice) Halliburton accomplished the alleged fraud by making changes in the way it accounted for its costs from its numerous construction projects. Much of Halliburton's business comes from big construction projects, like natural gas processing plants, which sometimes run over budget. The company failed to account for any of the over budget costs. Instead of counting the excess costs as losses, Halliburton began accounting for them as revenues based on the belief that the funds would eventually be paid by the subcontracted firms. Over six reporting periods, spanning approximately 18 months covering 1998 and 1999, Halliburton failed to disclose its change of accounting practice. These lead investors into believing......

Words: 872 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Financial Statement Fraud

...The cooking recipes. 14 The finished dish 15 6.0 Conclusion 17 Appendix 18 Bibliography 19 Abstract Financial statement fraud is a very costly type of fraud and has a significant financial impact on the company businesses and also individuals, as well as influence investor confidence in the markets. In this project, our group will going to present on a case study in Financial Statement Fraud by a company that we choose. First of all, in this report we will investigate on our background of the Case Study Company which is MEMS TECHNOLOGY BHD. In the case study, we will determine the current status of the company and how the financial statement fraud will give impact to the organization by referring to the company’s annual report 2009. Hence, in this report we will give some practical guide on the different schemes and components that are used for detection on the Financial Statement Fraud that might be probably incurred in the company annual report 2009. 2.0 Introduction Financial reporting frauds and earnings manipulation have attracted high profile attention recently. The generally accepted definition of the financial statement fraud is the deliberate, misrepresentation, misstatement or omission of financial statement data for the purpose of misleading financial statement users and also creating a false impression of an organization's financial strength. The purpose of this financial statement fraud......

Words: 3772 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Fraud Case

...CASE 4: ACCOUNTING FRAUD AT WORLDCOM Betty Vinson: victim or villain? Should criminal fraud charges have been brought to her? How should employees react when ordered by their employer to do something they do not believe in or feel uncomfortable doing? In discussing whether Vinson should been charged with criminal fraud, it can be analyzed from ethical perspective which can truly judge whether she was morally responsible for the wrong or not. In order to determine whether Vinson was morally responsible for the fraud, these three criteria should be fulfilled first: causality, knowledge and freedom. The causality criteria can be referred as whether that individual caused or helped cause the wrong, or failed to prevent it when she could and should have. The knowledge criteria then requires the individual to did so knowing what she is doing while freedom criteria requires the individual did so own her free will before being morally responsible for causing the wrong. Examining the cause of the fraudulent activities, Vinson initially been pressured by Yates, Myers and Sullivan to aid in painting the financial result of the company only one time and assured by Sullivan that he would take full responsibility for the action. Being a senior manager worked under them and believing in Sullivan’s words, Vinson did as told accordingly. However, she decided against quitting when been asked to continually carry out the wrong as she justified herself as the main supporter of her family.......

Words: 1208 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Fraud Homework

...According to our book, Fraud Examination, fraud is defined as “a generic term that embraces all the multifarious means that human ingenuity can devise, which are resorted to by one individual, to get an advantage over another by false representations. No definite and invariable rule can be laid down as a general proposition in defining fraud, as it includes surprise, trickery, cunning, and unfair ways by that another is cheated. The only boundaries defining it are those that limit human knavery” (Albrecht, 2012). Derek's employer is committing fraud by “selling” Derek as an SAP expert because this is a misrepresentation of his abilities and it is under false pretenses. The client is paying for and expecting and expert on the software, but little do they know, Derek as never seen SAP and possibly has not even heard of said software. This is a great example of fraud because the choice of assigning Derek was done “with intent and for the purpose of gaining advantage over another through false pretense” (Albrecht, 2012). The firm Derek represents intentionally placed him in that position fully knowing that he was not qualified for such a task. Derek may be sharp enough and able to do this task, but he is certainly not qualified to head up the project of implementing SAP. The article mentions that Derek was selected using certain criteria, but perhaps he was intentionally selected for another reason. Maybe the firm believed that Derek would just be a “drone” and not......

Words: 1350 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethics- Fraud

... Gregory Podlcuky, Chief Executive Officer and Founder of Le-Nature, a Pennsylvania soft drink company, was accused of fraudulent activity costing investors, venders, and lenders around $684 million between 2000 and 2006. Podlucky received over $800 million in financing by falsely overstating the company’s revenues. This cooking of the books made Le-Nature seem more successful than it truly was, prompting outsiders to invest in its growth. Podlucky spent most of this investment money on his lavish lifestyle though, instead of on his company. Founded in 1992, and originally named Genesis Inc., Le-Nature was re-named in 2002 and considered itself an innovator in the bottling industry. Problems came to light in 2003, when the chief financial officer as well as to other highly ranked financial managers resigned unexpectedly. The fraudulent activity was difficult to figure out because it had many layers of fraudulent loan agreements. These loans created a false perception of a successful company. Characterized as a Ponzi scheme, the fraud was using newly invested money to pay off earlier debt obligations. Le-nature falsified invoices, checks, account statements, and other financial documents to verify business transactions and activity that never actually occurred. This falsely inflated the value of the company to banks and investors, who saw the business as a successful company that needed additional capital to expand its productions. According to one of the lawsuits,......

Words: 869 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Book Company Case Study

...I. Introduction: Chinese cuisine is served anywhere , even in our own homes. Even at our simple gatherings we usually include Chinese cuisine in our entrails. Chinese cuisine is introduced in the Philippines as early as the 10th century. From appetizers to main curses like dim sums, noodles, meat dishes like sweet and sour, asado, roasted and many more. We Filipinos love to eat Chinese foods. Most Filipinos loved Chinese foods because Chinese influences them to their cuisine. Filipino cuisine is influenced principally by China, Spain, and the United States, integrated into the pre-colonial indigenous Filipino cooking practices. When restaurants were established in the 19th century, Chinese food became a staple of the pansiterias, with the food given Spanish names. The "comida China" Chinese food includes arroz caldo rice and chicken gruel, and morisqueta tostada fried rice. When the Spaniards came, the food influences they brought were from both Spain and Mexico, as it was through the vice-royalty of Mexico that the Philippines were governed.In the Philippines, trade with China started in the 11th century, as documents show, but it is conjectured that undocumented trade may have started even two centuries earlier. Trade pottery excavated in Laguna, for example, includes pieces dating to the Tang Dynasty. The Chinese trader supplied the silks sent to Mexico and Spain in the galleon trade. In return they took back products of field, forest -......

Words: 4443 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Astro Malaysia Holdings Company Valuation

...INTRODUCTION ASTRO MALAYSIA HOLDINGS BERHAD is the region's top cross-media administrator with direct-to-home (DTH) satellite TV benefits in Malaysia and Brunei. It is likewise the essential business radio supporter in Malaysia and a noteworthy distributer of TV aides and way of life magazines in the area. Astro has made joint ventures in different nations to dispatch new television, sight and sound and Internet administrations. The Group has vital concurrences with top programming engineers and substance fabricators to mutually create both innovation and substance to give satellite-conveys, broadband, IP upgraded mixed media and intuitive administrations over different stages, including telephony, over the Asia Pacific area. (Astro, 2015). Astro was established in the United Kingdom and registered in England and Wales on 22 July 2003 under the United Kingdom Companies Act, 1985 and is enlisted as a foreign business in Malaysia under the Companies Act, 1965. The Company was recorded on the Main Board of the Bursa Malaysia Securities Berhad on 1 October 2003. The recorded cost is on the site with a delay of 180 seconds, the last value review was on 23th July 2015 at RM 2.990 for the day. The volume of outstanding shares is 5.2 Billion (The Wall Street Journal, 2015). This research paper will analyze and discuss the internal and external economic standings of the company and will provide an in-depth analysis of the global positioning of the company as well. The paper will......

Words: 4300 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Book Review Signs of Love Fraud

...The book I read, “Red Flags of Love Fraud” was written by Donna Andersen, published in 2012, and has 235 pages. Donna Andersen is merely a freelance author of two books and a creator of the website “” She was wooed by a sociopath and married him. She catalogued all the information she discovered about sociopaths from her own experiences, and those of other people, and then wrote a guide to tell if you’re dating, married to, or interested in a sociopath. This book is all about the concept of “love fraud” and the people who commit it, named sociopaths. The contents of this book are firsthand stories of people who were with a sociopath. The author was married to one for years and she tells her story as well. This book also gives the “Red Flags” of Love fraud which are Charisma and charm, Sudden soul mates, Sexual magnetism, Love bombing, Blames others for everything, Lies and gaps in the story, Intense eye contact, Moves fast to hook up, Pity play, and Jekyll and Hyde personality. This book also lists the traits of a sociopath being: Lying, Exploitation, Entitlement, Shallow emotions, Dominance, Irresponsibility, Need for Excitement, and Antisocial behavior. This book also lists those who a vulnerable to being preyed upon by a sociopath. Those who are Wounded, Need love, Lonely, Empathetic, Low self-esteem, Want a relationship, Trusting, Need assistance, Single parent, and those who are in Grief are all vulnerable to sociopaths. Being in a relationship with a......

Words: 1614 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...happened in Malaysia. Second, it is to discuss some major causes of these corporate scandals; and third, it is to recommend the possible actions and preventive measures to curb these scandals. 1. Introduction In the recent years, the public and business community have been surprised with the exposure of many corporate scandals and accounting fraud by the managers of the company. It disappoints many stakeholders as after the financial crisis in 1997, many efforts have been initiated and implemented to strengthen the business control and foundation of the company. One of the important lessons learned from the financial crisis in 1997 is the weaknesses in the governance of the company such as too much power is given to a single person in managing the company, weak internal control and poor work of the directors that leads to the failure of the company. Due to this, a total regulatory and governance were embarked all over the world. Just to name a few, in the US, the Sarbanese Oxley Act was established, while in the UK the Code of Corporate Governance was extensively revised to stop all these corporate diseases from spreading and becoming a cancer for the global business community. However, all this effort has seemed fruitless as after the heavy debate and discussion and huge struggle by the regulator and market administrator, these corporate scandals are still returning but with more scaring facts. 1.1 What do we mean by Fraud and Misconduct • Fraud is a broad......

Words: 3562 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Earnings Management, in Exchange Listed Companies, Is Not Fraud but a Case of Caveat Emptor for Investors ‘’ Up708386

...‘’Earnings management, in exchange listed companies, is not fraud but a case of caveat emptor for investors ‘’ UP708386 ‘’Earnings management, in exchange listed companies, is not fraud but a case of caveat emptor for investors ‘’ UP708386 708386 Corporate governance, Financial Crime, Ethics & Controls for Finance Pathways (U234479) 708386 Corporate governance, Financial Crime, Ethics & Controls for Finance Pathways (U234479) ‘’Earnings management, in exchange listed companies, is not fraud but a case of caveat emptor for investors ‘’ This essay is intended to evaluate different views on a case whether the earnings management in exchange listed companies is consider as a fraud or caveat emptor for investors. One of the first mentions of earnings management has been given by Shipper where she described it as ‘’disclosure management, in the sense of purposeful intervention in the external financial reporting process, with the intent of obtaining some private gain.’’ (Shipper, 1989). In other words the managers are adjusting profits or losses on final accounts to mislead the stakeholders and to encourage them from investing. Earnings management become a problem for investors as it generates fake impression about companies success and misguide them into making wrong investment decisions which often leads to a making a loss. Another problem arises with incorrect financial reporting which is insincere for investors and resulting in making a capital......

Words: 1754 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Cooking the Books

...Cooking the Books ACC 201 Abstract The key to the article “Cooking the Books” is to cover the business ethics of an accounting manager ordering one of his accountants to falsifying a company’s accounting ledger. The Generally Accepted Accounting Principle of expense recognition was not followed. The accounting manager was attempting to commit fraud for personal gain, he does this by manipulating the books to show higher revenue in order to meet the volume for management bonus. The accounting manager also created a hostile working environment by threating his accountant’s job security if he didn’t comply with his orders. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act will also be explored to see if there was a violation due to the unethical behavior of the company’s management and the inaccuracy of the company’s financial information. Keywords: Integrity, Ethics, Sarbanes-Oxley, Fraud Cooking the Books The problem is that the accounting manager has ordered his employee to falsify the books so that the company can show higher revenue in their current year in order to meet volume for a management bonus. These actions are unethical, fraudulent and may violate the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. Basis of violation Business ethics comes in to play for the mere reason that as soon as the company starts to manipulate the books in order to get a bonus, the company’s trust is lost. If they will do this then what else will they do in order to make themselves look better? The accounting manager openly admitted that...

Words: 1055 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Determinants of Capital Structure for Listed Industrial Product Companies in Malaysia

...1 CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background of the Study Financial strategy is the largest corporate financial decisions that are made by the financial management committee and it is the most crucial for all organization or company for their strategy to make profit to their firms. Financial strategy also will influence the capital structure. The theory of Capital structure is closely related to the firm’s cost of capital. It is one of the effective tools of management to manage the cost of capital. Capital structure is the mix of the long-term sources of funds used by the firm. The primary objective of capital structure decisions is to maximize the market value of the firm or achieving the maximization of shareholders wealth through an appropriate mix of long-term sources of funds and an optimal capital structure is reached at a point where the cost of the capital is minimum. To design the capital structure, the element that should consider is first, the wealth maximization is attained and second, is the best approximation to the optimal capital structure. In finance, capital structure refers to the way a corporation finances its assets through some combination of equity, debt, or hybrid securities (Saad, 2010). In short, capital structure is a mixture of a company's debts (long-term and short-term), common equity and preferred equity in financing its assets. Capital structure is essential on how a firm finances its overall operations and growth......

Words: 10584 - Pages: 43