Premium Essay

Is Selling Body Parts Ethical?

In: English and Literature

Submitted By AntiHero650
Words 1586
Pages 7
Is Selling Body Parts Ethical?
Charles Collins
ITT Technical Institute

Is Selling Body Parts Ethical? There is a market out there for everything. This even includes a market for human and even bone marrow. Some of these organs are from donors who have voluntarily given up their organs. Most donations come from people who are still alive and received some type of gratuity. Now comes the question is the selling of body parts an ethical idea. Alternatively, should it be condemned as something immoral and wrong? On the other hand, should we see this as another way to help those who are in need? Now what would be a moral route to help those in need of organs? In general donating one`s organ is seen as praiseworthy. This route is accomplished by “willing” benefit of others after one`s death. A person may decide to dispose of his or her body by allowing it to be used to replace parts needed by the sick and suffering. This is seen as useful, morally irreproachable and even noble to most people “…we consider it noble to donate organs freely. It is better to give them away than receive compensation for them” (Mullin, D. 2013). In addition, such donation would not cause harm to the person, as they are already deceased and have (prior to death) stated the wish to have the organs harvested to help others. “… Most of us acknowledge the difference between giving something freely and exchanging it for monetary gain”, as said by Daniel Mullin (2013) philosopher, recent PhD, and a former adjunct professor. When it comes to the selling of body parts, “… it's a seller's market” or at least it is according to Barry Jacobs (2014) an ex-Virginia physician. Barry had planned to establish an international brokerage company dealing in body parts. Doing so would be an ethical way for the selling of organs to others. The donor would of course get a healthy paycheck, the recipient…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Building an Ethical Organization Part 1

...Building an Ethical Organization Part 1 My organization supplies support services to children and families going through abuse situations to help them recover or become free of an abusive pattern. We provide services for sexual abuse victims, domestic violence, adolescent substance abuse, teen crisis and intervention and parental alienation. The organizations team is comprised of seasoned clinicians including psychologists, certified alcohol and drug counselors, licensed clinical social workers, licensed clinical social work interns and marriage and family therapists. Services are low cost or free of charge depending upon client’s income and ability to pay. We never turn anyone away based on their inability to pay for services. We believe in providing wrap around services to ensure that our clients are getting the level of care and support that they need in every way possible. Our support services are designed to lend special services and needs to our clients while they are going through unfortunate life experiences. Outreach and education is an extremely important priority for my organization. Prevention comes from education and therefore they go hand and hand. Our education programs are designed to reach out to the community and give community members the tools that they need to keep their families safe. Equipping children with safety strategies and skill sets that work to prevent them from putting themselves in harm’s way can be what someday saves their lives. ......

Words: 612 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma Part 2

...Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma Part 2 Gary Bigge, Diana Hanakahi, Jennifer Lockwood, Sheryl Murray, Alex Warkenthien Grand Canyon University Ethics NRS 437V Linnette Nolte March 3, 2013 Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma Part 2 As a continuation of a previous study, the Grand Canyon University Team White Ethics Committee further examines the dilemma of euthanasia. Four individual personal interviews were conducted and the results are included below. The Team White Ethics Committee has been tasked with the challenge of comparing similarities and differences between the cases we have studied and making a recommendation on each case based on our interviews and personal beliefs. The first case was Dax (Busada, 2011) and the second case was Terry Schiavo (Springs, 2009). Interview #1 To receive a spiritual leader’s perspective about euthanasia, Pastor Sandy Ash of Harbor Chapel Community Church in Moss Landing, California was interviewed. The interview started by giving Pastor Ash a brief background regarding both the Dax and Terry Schiavo stories. When asked about her view on euthanasia, Pastor Ash stated, “If it’s a person who doesn’t want to live then there’s still hope and they shouldn’t give up since there is no machine keeping them alive. There’s a lot to live for” (Ash, 2013). Pastor Ash also added, “It depends on what stage. If there’s a machine then the person should let them go if they want to go, if that’s their wish” (Ash, 2013). With Terry’s case,......

Words: 2233 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Individual: Building an Ethical Organization Part 1

...Week 7 Assignment 2 HSM/230 Individual: Building an Ethical Organization Part 1 Family Helping Families is a program located in Northeast La and is one of ten non-profit resource centers all centers are. Operated by its own govern Board of Directors each staff and Board members is made-up of individuals and members with disabilities families helping families covers twelve parishes that is made-up of Region 8. I have seen family helping families help many of people in high school I would totally us the organization because children with disability are over looked and not given the same rights has others. In high school my mother fined this organization when she was trying to locate help for other classmates of mine I would never forget this ladies name her name was Lori. She was completely helpful with going beyond her call they even got in touch with the school and to give more assists to the family and the child. Their Mission and Vision was to provide information and referral, education and training and peer to peer support to all individuals living with disabilities and their families. Their Vision is to strengthen and support and empower the individuals and their families while providing home and the community inclusion. Point of information and Referral when a family is referred to the offices for Citizens with Developmental Disabilities they will determined to see their eligibility for the services and for their own they will referred to Families Helping Families......

Words: 1074 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Building an Ethical Organization Part I

...Building an Ethical Organization Part I Michele Compston HSM/230 Ethical Issues in Human Services Organizations 8/18/13 Carrie Cooper Here at the Lakeside Serenity Behavioral Health Center, we provide mental health services to the local community to enhance the emotional well-being for the people we serve. We help individuals the chance to lead healthier and independent lives. Our focus is placed on helping the people we serve to strengthen their recovery for a better tomorrow. Our treatment is compassionate and innovative in treating issues that affect behavioral healthcare in the community. An agency provides psychiatric intervention for adults by providing them with medication, education and nursing services. Our clients receive referrals to the specialist that best fits the type of assistance needed. They type of assistance determines what program the client is enrolled in and the duration of the program. This ensures that our clients receive the right type of assistance and that they receive individualized time with their counselors. Lakeside Serenity also provides assistance for children struggling with their emotional and behavioral health. This is an outpatient service at our facility that is very intensive. We offer basic living skills and social rehabilitation......

Words: 1049 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Building and Ethical Organization Part 2

...Building an Ethical Organization Part 2 Holly Regan HSM/230 January 12, 2014 Vicki Grant Building an Ethical Organization Part 2 Establishing and sustaining a successful ethical organization with a solid morally and ethically envisioned foundation takes continuous effort by all members of the organization. Every member has a particular role to be played which contributes to the organization’s mission of improving the quality of life of homeless teens and their families and the ethical obligation of earning the community’s trust. Royalty House is a non-profit organization that is staffed and governed by an experienced, professional, diverse group of volunteers whose target population are homeless youth ranging in age between twelve and eighteen; with the exception of some clients which continue in the program until the age of twenty-one. The exception is made either when particular clients require further mentoring to provide them with the skills required by law to live independently and also for the aging out of foster care population. The services Royalty House provides to the homeless youth population are 24 hour emergency shelter, transitional housing, residential substance abuse treatment for clients and their families, parenting classes, shelter for teen parents and their children, anger management classes, educational programs to obtain a GED, workshops to learn a trade, classes to earn a degree, basic behavioral health services, and referral services for...

Words: 2142 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Building an Ethical Organization Part 2

...Building an Ethical Organization Part 2 Karen Carey HSM/230 August 4, 2013 Angela Murray Building an Ethical Organization Part 2 Catherine’s House is a non-profit human service agency that provides temporary shelter to lesbian, gay, bi-sexual, and transgender persons who are victims of intimate partner violence and any minor children that they may have primary custody of. Residents may remain at the shelter for 6 to 12 months depending on the evaluated need. Catherine’s House also offers counseling services by licensed professionals, provides food and clothing, transitional housing, employment resources, transportations needs to those that are employed or students, provides legal advocates to assist with obtaining protective orders, and when necessary provide state to state relocation and protective services in conjunction with law enforcement agencies. Catherine’s House is dedicated to Mrs. Catherine Sudderth-Tucker (1933-2013) who was an educator, human rights advocate, and strongly believed in equality of all persons, regardless of race, religious beliefs, gender, physical challenges, or sexual orientation. This organization is dedicated to keeping her legacy alive through the advocacy of social justice, community relations, and education. The mission statement of Catherine’s House is “FROM VICTIMS TO VICTORS”. The mission statement supports the organization’s intended goal is, it sends a message of resilience and hope to the community and its members. ...

Words: 2160 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Building an Ethical Organization Part 1

...introductions.] Quality Life Services is one Human Service organization within the Human Service Field striving to provide services and supports to individuals with intellectual disabilities and their families. This organization was founded in 1988 and is redeveloping its foundation in the Brownsville East New York area of Brooklyn New York. The organization is a nonprofit organization that is overseen by a board of Directors also known as a governing body whom are Health Professionals, Community activist and parents of children with intellectual disabilities. The mission of Quality Life Services is to provide services to individuals with intellectual disabilities and their families that will enhance the quality of life and care for these individuals while integrating them into the local communities. This mission statement informs the community that these individuals are within their communities and there are services available for them. It informs the community that Quality Life Service organization believes that these individuals are a part of our lives and our future. The mission statement lets the community know that this organization acknowledges these individuals and the assistance that is needed to care for them and meet their needs as well as their families. [What is your source for these ideas? If you have used outside sources, please cite them. Anything that is not common knowledge requires a citation. (See the Plagiarism Guide in the Tutorials & Guides section......

Words: 1288 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

What Part of the Human Body Is Most Sensitive

...Nathan Coulson What part of the body is most accurate for testing the temperature of a baby's bath water? Your hands are very unreliable at measuring temperature, one reason is because you can become used to extreme temperatures on your hands more readily than other parts of your body. For example, when you first put your hand in water it might feel very hot or very cold, but then as you keep your hand under water, you get used to it, and the water begins to feel more moderate than it really is. This is a very bad thing if you are trying to avoid scalding your baby! Scientists and doctors have proven that the elbow is the most reliable to test your babies bath water because the skin cells on the end of the elbow are more sensitive than any other part of the skin. If you test your baby’s bath with the end of your elbow you are less likely to scald them. What's the structure of the skin? The skin is the largest organ in the body. It has three main layers, the epidermis, the dermis and the subcutaneous layers. The epidermis is an elastic layer on the outside that is continually being regenerated. The dermis is the inner layer that includes the following Epidermis Dermis sweat glands- they produce sweat that travels through the sweat ducts Hair follies- are pits where hair grows. Hairs also play a part in temperature regulation. Source A Subcutaneous layer The subcutaneous layer under the dermis is made up of connective tissue and fat (a......

Words: 807 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Donation of Body Part

...Dead Body Donation: “Awareness to overcome shortcomings” Saima Mushtaq,Ms Hua chuntai, Hubei University of Chinese Medicine, China ABSTRACT Dead body donation is useful for medical research, education and also beneficial of needy (injured/diseased) living persons. In medical educational sector, usually medical students study anatomy, which deals with the study of composition of human body. Understanding of human anatomy requires indepth knowledge about human body organs, tissues, cells, which requires teaching based on cadaver dissection. Cadavers and donated bodies remain a principal teaching tool for anatomists and medical educators teaching gross anatomy. Hands on experience on dead body helps learn various medical concepts and nature of human body. There is ever increasing demand of cadavers for anatomy dissection. Apart from educational uses, dead body donation may also include specific organ donations which could be required for saving life of severaly injured or diseased living beings as well. Even then people are reluctant to donate their bodies after death due to various reasons. This research is made in order to know these factors which results in opposition to dead body donation. Study also suggests ways to actually increase awareness in our society about dead body donation. In this study report we present a survey (attached in Annex- A) regarding potential whole-body donors in china. 100 random people (age range 18-75 years) answered a questionnaire,...

Words: 1966 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Building an Ethical Organization Part One

...Building an Ethical Organization Part 1 I have just been appointed director of a new human service organization. It is going to be called The Hampton Roads Complete Care Center. I am proud to say that he citizens of my community had a huge hand in helping with the name. When I found out I was going to be the new director of a brand new organization, I thought it would fun for everyone to be able to put in their suggestions and to my surprise, it was more of a success than I could have imagined The organization is going to be a complete wellness and care facility. The first priority will be to provide residents with the proper care that they need. We will be a non-profit and will rely on government grants, donations and volunteer workers who can hopefully be able to eventually move into paid positions. We are also hoping to be able to employ the disabled and elderly to give them a feeling of accomplishment and being needed. We will service the elderly, disabled, homeless, low-income, pregnant women, veterans, anyone who needs our services and we will provide services for those who have been denied help elsewhere. We are going to be a full service care center and will also be able to help those with mental disabilities. Eventually as we grow and with more funding we would like to have many doctors and counselors on board as there are many people in my community that could benefit from mental and health services. We will provide pregnancy testing as well as birth control......

Words: 1122 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Does God Have Body Parts?

...IF GOD IS spirit, that is, He has no flesh and bones, then why does the Bible mention of God having body parts? For example, in Exodus 31:18, "... the tables of stone, written with the FINGER of God" and in Genesis 32:30, " ... For I have seen God FACE TO FACE..." Editor's reply: The Lord Jesus Christ said that God is spirit (Jn. 4:24; 17:1, 3). This means He has no flesh and bones or, in other words, has no material form (Lk. 24:39). And, it is in this sense that God is invisible (I Tim. 1:17). While the Bible contains some passages that mention God as having body parts, such passages do not contradict the truth that God does NOT have material form. In Exodus 31:18, it says that the Ten Commandments were written with the finger of God. It would seem here as though God had fingers as we, human beings, have. However, the other verses in the Bible do not support such conclusion drawn from a literal understanding of the passage in question. The explanation lies within the Bible itself. In Psalms 8:3, the Bible says the heavens are the work of God's "fingers." In what sense the heavens are the work of God's "fingers" is clarified in Jeremiah 10:12, which says: "He has made the earth by His power, He has established the world by His wisdom, and has stretched out the heavens at His discretion." (New King James Version) Therefore, the phrase, "God's fingers" refers to the power and wisdom of God by which He created the world. In the same sense, the Lord Jesus Christ was......

Words: 518 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma Part 1

...Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma Part 1 Grand Canyon University April 26, 2013 Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma Part 1 Voluntary and assisted euthanasia have been and will continue to be one of the most controversial ethical debates in the medical field. Euthanasia stems from the Greek language: eu meaning good and thanatos meaning death. The practice of voluntary euthanasia is when the patient requests to die but someone else has to perform the act, for example removing the patient from all life-sustaining equipment or giving a lethal injection. Where as the definition of assisted suicide is a physician prescribes a lethal dose of medication and the patient on his or her own will have to perform the act of consuming the medication to cause death. There are many ethical implications that arise from either option. “In the balance are crucial issues: personal autonomy, dignity, compassion, ending suffering, protection of the vulnerable, promotion of good palliative care, and redefinition of the role of the physician in death and dying” (Van Norman, (2012). It is imperative for nurses to be conscious of their obligations professionally, educated on the laws surrounding the issue, who the stakeholders involved are, the impact on social values/morals, and the ethical theories and principals involved. Nursing Obligation According to the American Nurses Association nurses are never allowed to have any part in euthanasia, such actions would be a direct violation of......

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Cjs 211 Ethical Scrapbook Part 1

...Ethical Scrapbook Part 1 Johnathan Hendricks CJS/211 October 19th, 2015 Leesa A. McNeil Ethical Scrapbook Part 1 Good Samaritan Acts- Oprah Winfrey The bulk of Winfrey’s giving has gone to educational causes, including charter schools, programs that support African-American students, and the Oprah Winfrey Leadership Academy in South Africa. According to Forbes, Winfrey had given away approximately $400 million to educational causes by 2012, including nearly 400 scholarships to Morehouse College, and more than $40 million in operating support for the Oprah Winfrey Leadership Academy in South Africa. She’s also given at least $10 million to A Better Chance. Its mission is to improve access to quality education for students of color, and has given $1 million or more to at least nine different charter school organizations in a number of different areas throughout the country (, 2015). Princess Diana Diana’s interests were reflected in the organizations of which she was Patron or President. These included the Great Ormond Street Hospital for Sick Children in London and the Royal Marsden Hospital, which specializes in the treatment of cancer. Her patronages also included Centrepoint, an organization working with the homeless, The National Aids Trust and The Leprosy Mission.  The Princess's love of the arts was underlined by her involvement as Patron of the English National Ballet. During her lifetime she was at some time......

Words: 3359 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Ethical Consumerism - Body Shop

...Contents ABSTRACT 3 1. INTRODUCTION 4 2. DEFINITION ETHICAL CONSUMERISM 5 3. BODY SHOP ETHICAL CONSUMERISM 6 4. MARKETING RESEARCH SURVEY QUESTIONAIRE 10 5. CONCLUSION 13 6. REFERENCE LIST 15 ABSTRACT A business intervention and technology advances the urge for ethic and corporate responsibility has gained vast attention. Consumers are more educated about what impact products have on human, animal and environment protection, hence the urge for ethical consumerism increases. In this report the ethical consumerism of the Body shop who is a subsidiary of LOreal groups was examined, critically analysed. Some of the various products that are categorised as ethical products are identified and discussed. The approaches that were used by Body shop to becoming more socially conscious business, linking these elements with the ethics and values of Body shop. A short survey was conducted to gain understanding of consumer buying behaviour was carried out to give a transparent view on the consumer buying behaviour toward Body shop. Finally a conclusion is made on the findings from the research conducted using the annual report of Body shop and other related articles to design an overall perception of the findings. 1. INTRODUCTION Body shop is one of the leading skin and hair care product distributer in the United Kingdom with more than 2,600 store in 66 markets globally selling over 1,200 products with Anita Roddick at the head of its......

Words: 2739 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Body Parts

...BODY SIZE AND BODY FORM I. Analyzing Faces and Heads: Physiognomy and Phrenology To evaluate the outward appearance of the body and to read the mental and moral capacities of the person. Leaders of all 4 of these movements were highly educated. A. Physiognomy and facial observation –from greek, physio = nature, nomen = judge, judgement of human nature. Believed you could judge one’s mental and moral character by looking at one’s face. A ton of phrases today still show the judgement of character based solely on face (high brow, snooty, shifty eyed). 1. Giovanni Battista della Porta, Italy, De Humana Physiognomia (1586) –wrote first book on physiognomy. Porta was in Naples, Italy, a scientist and mathematician. Based his ideas on animal characteristics. In his book, he compared certain human faces to certain animal characteristics, and then associated the characteristics of the animal to the human. 2. Johann Lavater (1741-1801), Germany, Von der Physiognomik (1772) –Popularizes physiognomy, from Zurich, Switzerland, and then moved to Germany. Trained as a pastor. Makes physiognomy a science, through the publication of his work, “essays on physiognomy”. In the book, he laid out 100 physiognomy rules, where a look is associated with a trait. 3. General theory –The belief that mental and moral traits (character) can be determined and judged by one’s outward facial structure (their appearance and expressions). One trained in physiognomy could diagnose character by......

Words: 3381 - Pages: 14