Premium Essay

International Contracts Between Common Law and Civil Law: Is Non-State Law to Be Preferred? the Difficulty of Interpreting Legal Standards Such as Good Faith

In: Social Issues

Submitted By changwanbi
Words 18580
Pages 75
Global Jurist
Advances
Volume 7, Issue 1

2007

Article 3

International Contracts between Common Law and Civil Law: Is Non-state Law to Be
Preferred? The Difficulty of Interpreting Legal
Standards Such as Good Faith
Giuditta Cordero Moss∗



University of Oslo, g.c.moss@jus.uio.no

Recommended Citation
Giuditta Cordero Moss (2007) “International Contracts between Common Law and Civil Law:
Is Non-state Law to Be Preferred? The Difficulty of Interpreting Legal Standards Such as Good
Faith,” Global Jurist: Vol. 7: Iss. 1 (Advances), Article 3.
Available at: http://www.bepress.com/gj/vol7/iss1/art3
Copyright c 2007 The Berkeley Electronic Press. All rights reserved.

International Contracts between Common Law and Civil Law: Is Non-state Law to Be
Preferred? The Difficulty of Interpreting Legal
Standards Such as Good Faith∗
Giuditta Cordero Moss

Abstract
Most commercial contracts are nowadays written on the basis of English or American contract models, irrespective of whether the legal relationship that the contracts regulate is governed by a law belonging to a Common Law system or not. These contract models are drafted on the basis of the requirements and structure of the respective Common Law system in which they were originally meant to operate. These models may therefore be in part ineffective or parts thereof may redundant, if the governing law belongs to a Civilian system. To overcome this tension between Common and Civil Law, it is sometimes recommended to subject international contracts to non-state sources of law (also referred to as transnational law, lex mercatoria, soft law). This article analyses the tension between the Common and the Civil Law of contracts, and to what extent non-state sources may represent a satisfactory solution to such tension. This is made by analyzing the role that good faith and fair dealing…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

International Law

...:Introduction of International Trade Law Outline  Definition of ITL  The Scope of ITL (调整范围)  History of ITL  Comparison of ITL and In. Business Law  Sources of ITL( 渊源) Question How to understand the word “international law” here? What is International Law?  “A rule… that has been accepted as such by the international community.”  Includes :Customary international law. International treaties and agreements. General principles common to major legal systems. Public vs. Private International Law  Public International Law. – Involves relationships between countries and applies “norms regarded as binding on all members of the international community”  Private International Law. – Is described as conflict of laws or “domain of rights, duties, and disputes between and among persons from different places. Part I Definition 国际贸易法:调整跨越国界的货物贸易、技术贸易和服务贸易关系以及这些贸易关系有关的其他关系的法律规范和规则的总和。 (a) The body of norms and rules – Private law: governs transnational Relationships of Private Persons ( International transaction Law) e.g. the law of international sales, trade finance, licensing agreement etc. – Public law: laws that make up the legal framework within which international business takes place. e.g. the treaties of EU, GATT agreement, NAFTA (b) the scope of ITL(调整范围) Trade in goods, Trade in service,Trade in technology,other international business field Part III History of International Trade Law • Customs and usages Law......

Words: 14385 - Pages: 58

Premium Essay

Law Contract

...CONTRACT LAW 2012/2013 CONTRACT LAW Content: Formation of contract. Vitiating factors. Terms. Privity of contract. Discharge of contractual obligations. Remedies. Limitation of actions. BEA1003/BEA1003A 2 Contract FORMATION OF CONTRACT A contract was defined in the 19th century by Sir Frederick Pollock as “A promise or set of promises which the law will enforce”. The requirements of a valid contract are: 1.Agreement. 2.Consideration. 3.Capacity . 4.Intention to create legal relations. 5.Form. 6.Legality. Sir Frederick Pollock BEA1003/BEA1003A 3 Contract FORMATION OF CONTRACT 1. AGREEMENT There is agreement when one party (“the offeror”) makes an offer which the other party (“the offeree”) accepts. An offer: Is a clear statement of terms on which the offeror intends to be bound. Can be made to a specified person, a group of people or to the general public. Must be communicated before it is effective. Must be distinguished from an invitation to treat. An invitation to treat is where one party holds him/herself out as being ready to receive offers which s/he may then accept or reject. BEA1003/BEA1003A 4 Contract FORMATION OF CONTRACT The following are examples of invitations to treat: Bidding at an auction . The display of goods in a shop window Fisher v Bell (1961) and on a supermarket shelf Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain Ltd v Boots (1953). Advertisements (including goods/services advertised in emails and on www pages):......

Words: 6626 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

International Law

...EXAMPLE 1 International litigation is often difficult to seize because of different procedures used by States and principles laying down procedures. These principles are related to the judicial conceptions that States have adopted. This point will be adressed latter in this introduction. On the other hand, International Convention, in a general or a specific view in relation to civil and commercial matter are enacted by States in order to uniform and harmonize body of rules applicable to international commercial litigation. For example, Lugano convention harmonized rules in order to determine competence of jurisdiction, or the Convention of Vienna on international sales of goods determines competence of jurisdiction and the law applicable. In order to explain which criterion is more important in the construction of private international law concerned with international commercial litigation, it will be relevant to focus this study on the rules of competence of jurisdiction. Besides the general system of conventions, as explained above, judicial traditions of countries can explain debates around the best ways to enact rules on international trade, and especially international litigations arise from commercial relationships between actors. Indeed, on one hand, common law countries focus on the role of the judge for the creation, the interpretation and the application of law rules. Some authors argue that the predominance of the judge in common law judicial system...

Words: 8424 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Law of Contract

...13 MBA 16 – Business Law & Practice Module 01 - Law of Contract Coverage of: • Law of Contract: Definition, Essentials • Types of Contracts • Offer – Definition & Essentials • Acceptance - Definition & Essentials • Consideration – Definition & Essentials, Exceptions • Capacity of Parties • Free Consent • Quasi Contract • Legality of Object • Performance of Contract – Termination of Contract – Remedies for Breach of Contract Case Studies 1 The Indian Contract Act, 1872 The Indian Contract Act consists of the following two parts:  General principals of the Law of Contracts – covered under section 1 to 75; the principles apply to all kinds of contracts irrespective of their nature  Special kinds of contracts – covered under section 124 to 138 ; These special contracts are Indemnity & Guarantee (u/s124 to 147), Bailment & Pledge (u/s148 to 181) and Agency (u/s 182 to 238) in Chapter X – refer next Module 2) Section 76 to 123 – repealed by Sale of Goods Act, 1930 (refer Module 4) • • Section 239 to 266 – Chapter XI has been repealed by the Indian Partnership Act , 1932 ( not being covered separately; but major issues under different modules) The act does not affect any usage or custom of trade (u/s 1) – these prevail if reasonable & not illegal; an unique feature of this Act – most important branch of business law Some of the contracts not dealt with by the this Act are those related to Partnership, Sale of Goods (refer module 4),......

Words: 15475 - Pages: 62

Premium Essay

Contract Law

...Contract Law  LAW OF CONTRACT Name: Institution:   A contract can be simply defined as an agreement made by parties that is legally binding by its nature. It can also be defined as legally binding set of promises or promises (Lawrence & Elizabeth, 2007). A breach of any aspects of the agreement or a promise that constitutes a contract will lead to a subsequent remedy from the party that has been accused of the breach. The law of contract as shall be later discussed has provided for such remedies. The obligation to perform the duties that the law recognizes the contractual document or agreement specified. This defining characteristic of the contract is broadly known as enforceability. A contract is thus an agreement that is deemed enforceable. However, it is worthy to point out that while it is generally acceptable that all contracts are agreements, the reverse is not true. Not all agreements constitute a contract. The law of contract may classify contracts as follows: specialty or written contracts, contracts that are evidenced in writing, contracts that are under a seal and simple contracts. Specialty contracts are contracts, which the law specifies that they must be written. A formal structured document embodies a specialty or written contract. Examples of contracts that the law classifies as specialty contracts include insurance contracts like marine insurance, lease and hire purchase agreements and the contracts that will put in place proceedings that......

Words: 1685 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Law, Tort Law, Criminal Law, Contracts, and Civil Procedure

...Running head: Law, Tort Law, Criminal Law, Contracts, and Civil Procedure | | | Law, Tort Law, Criminal Law, Contracts, and Civil Procedure In defining the term law, tort law, criminal law, contract and the sources from which law derives, I will use a case that took place in 1929 “Donoghue v Stevenson” to demonstrate the these laws which will show a successful negligence suit, as well as defenses a defendant presenting evidence to refute a plaintiffs evidence. J.G. Holland said it best! In the words of J. G. Holland “Laws are the very bulwarks of liberty; they define every man’s rights, and defend the individual liberties of all men”. Laws are derived from the United States Constitution; Constitutional law is the body of law which defines the relationship of different entities within a state, namely, the executive, the legislature and the judiciary. Established Constitutional and administrative law govern the affairs of the state. Constitutional law concerns both the relationships between the executive, legislature and judiciary and the human rights or civil liberties of individuals against the state. Most jurisdictions, like the United States and France, have a single codified constitution with a bill of rights. A few, like the United Kingdom, have no such document. A "constitution" is simply those laws which constitute the body politic, from statute, case law and convention. Law is defined as a system of......

Words: 1720 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Contract Common Law

...about Contracts: -common law/UCC uniform commercial code. UCC is for buying and selling goods, common law contract is for everything else, Party, subject matter, price,delivery, payment terms – all neds to be listed in common law Party and subject matter – 2 things for UCC- everything else is filled by the judge based on the reasonableness. Contract is a promise or set of promises for breach of which the law gives a remedy, or the performance of which the law in some way recognizes as a duty. Contract is a set of voluntary promises that the law will enforce for private parties. Sources of Contract Law:/ Law that governs contracts 1) Common law * First law of contracts * Law decided by the judges and they used statutory law to interpret the common law * Common law applies to contracts that have land or services as their subject matter. Eg employment, home etc * Party, subject matter, price, delivery, payment terms * General treatment of the common law for contracts can be found in Restatement of Contracts 2) UCC – uniform commercial code * Common law lacks uniformity * Businesses experienced great difficutly and expense when they contracted across state lines because of differences in state contract common law * To address the need for uniformity, the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws and the American Law Institute worked to draft a set of commercial laws appropriate for business people, lawyers, and law......

Words: 544 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Crucial Judicial Developments and Legislative Reforms Within Each of the Traditions of Common Law, Civil Law, Islamic Law and International Law

...This paper will explore crucial judicial developments and legislative reforms within each of the traditions of Common law, Civil law, Islamic law and International law and how the key elements have forged the evolutionary journey towards uniformity of rules. Similarities and stark differences in the approach of the four abovementioned legal systems will be noted in an effort to verify which, if any, of the legal systems have achieved uniformity of rules. The extent to which uniformity of rules was lacking originally will also be examined. To inform the analysis of ‘uniformity of rules’ the Oxford Dictionary definition for uniform will be used. ie ‘not varying; the same in all cases and at all time’.[1] Therefore by extrapolation the understanding of ‘uniformity of rules’ will be taken to mean that the same rules should be applied to the same or, perhaps similar set of circumstances and by so doing the same outcomes should be achieved. This broad yet specific and quite literal conjecture will be used as a frame of reference for the following discussion. In England prior to the Norman Conquest of 1066 AD local customary law prevailed. At this time customary law could be viewed as perhaps being uniform to the extent that it was the type of law applied throughout the land however, customs differed from one locality to the next. Subsequently, there was no consistency in customary rules across the board per se, nor in how they were applied.[2] Cook et al suggest......

Words: 1762 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Common Law

...Common Law Your Name Course Number Due Date Tutors Name Common Law Introduction In order to effectively interact with the legal department and staff, everyone must have some knowledge in respects to various areas of the law and the legal concepts that one will encounter on a day to day basis. Concepts and examples of common law, when it began, how it is used and where it is used as well as the sources will be discussed. The importance of precedent to the judicial decision-making process is also tied in with common law and how it is used when making court decisions and lastly, but just as important, knowing what equitable remedies means and how it is used in court decisions so as the Manager it is important that everyone is prepared to understand and have the ability to interpret the meanings of each concept.  Common law Common Law is also called Anglo American Law or precedent. It emerged in England in the Middle Ages and it did not originally consist of substantive rights but procedural remedies. The English common law was developed from custom judges rather than legislatures in the English and U.S. courts. Common law, are laws based on court decisions in similar cases in the past. Although law and precedent originated in England they are being used in what used to be English colonies including this country.  All other countries use a statutory system which is the theory behind the common law that should be reliable and predictable whereby, without it......

Words: 1739 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Contract Law

...Aspects of Contract and Negligence for BusinessUnit Code: Y/601/0563Credit Value: 15 Credits | Student Name | Assessor Name | Mukaram Khan Swati | Salman Haider | Date Issued | Completion Date | Submitted On | Validity | 7th October,2013 | 4th November,2013 | | 1st Oct, 2013-31st Jan,2013 | Assignment Title | Contract and Negligence | Assignment Number | 05AOCANFB- Y/601/0563-13 PKISL7002 | Hand In Policy You must complete this assignment on time. If u experience difficulties, you must inform your tutor accordingly. Late Work Policy Consideration will be given to students who have valid reasons for late submission (eg, Illness) Plagiarism In case of plagiarism, college regulations will be applied. You must declare that this assessment is your own work by signing the following statement: Learner Declaration | I certify that the work submitted for this assignment is my own and research sources are fully acknowledged.Student Signature: Date: | Table of Contents Acknowledgement 6 Research Method 7 Aims and Objectives 8 Literature Review 9 Abbreviation List 10 Introduction 11 Task 1 12 Essential Elements of a Contract 12 1. Offer and Acceptance 12 2. Lawful Consideration 12 3. Intention to Create Legal Relationship 12 4. Capacity of Parties 12 5. Lawful Object 13 6. Certainity of Meaning 13 7. Not Expressly Declared Void 13 8. Legal......

Words: 5420 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Contract Law

...Contracts Agreements between two entities, creating an enforceable obligation to do, or to refrain from doing, a particular thing. Nature and Contractual Obligation The purpose of a contract is to establish the agreement that the parties have made and to fix their rights and duties in accordance with that agreement. The courts must enforce a valid contract as it is made, unless there are grounds that bar its enforcement. Statutes prescribe and restrict the terms of a contract where the general public is affected. The terms of an insurance contract that protect a common carrier are controlled by statute in order to safeguard the public by guaranteeing that there will be financial resources available in the event of an accident. The courts may not create a contract for the parties. When the parties have no express or implied agreement on the essential terms of a contract, there is no contract. Courts are only empowered to enforce contracts, not to write them, for the parties. A contract, in order to be enforceable, must be a valid. The function of the court is to enforce agreements only if they exist and not to create them through the imposition of such terms as the court considers reasonable. It is the policy of the law to encourage the formation of contracts between competent parties for lawful objectives. As a general rule, contracts by competent persons, equitably made, are valid and enforceable. Parties to a contract are bound by the terms to which they have agreed,......

Words: 12598 - Pages: 51

Premium Essay

International Law

...unnoticed. Economic globalization has been instrumental in the creation of free market flows, thus in the process, enabling development or increased productivity in developing countries. With this, it means that the developing countries will benefit from both foreign market and an international market. Additionally, through economic globalization, international investors are attracted to a given area with the potential for growth but this is only possible if the legal framework of the country of interest is clear on the investment policies that should be undertaken. Specifically, Shanghai has shown the significance of economic globalization owing to the number of investors who are attracted to invest in the country. As a legal counselor for DFW, a firm that is interested in venturing in Shanghai, understanding Chinese investment policies are critical in determining the business structure that the company will have, as well as, the various incentives, and the means of resolving disputes should any arise. There are two main types of business structures that can be used in Shanghai; these can be Limited Liability companies and Representative office. The Limited Liability Company is independent legal entities that bear responsibility for their actions. Another definition for the limited liability Company is provided for under Article 3 (2). LLCs are usually independent from the shareholder and the individual investor. Investment in the LLC can be by an overseas company or by an...

Words: 3968 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Contract of Law

...INTRODUCTION TO THE LAW OF CONTRACT DEFINITION  A contract may be defined as a legally binding agreement or, in the words of Sir Frederick Pollock: “A promise or set of promises which the law will enforce”. The agreement will create rights and obligations that may be enforced in the courts. The normal method of enforcement is an action for damages for breach of contract, though in some cases the court may order performance by the party in default.  CLASSIFICATION  Contracts may be divided into two broad classes:   1.    Contracts by deed A deed is a formal legal document signed, witnessed and delivered to effect a conveyance or transfer of property or to create a legal obligation or contract. 2. Simple contracts Contracts which are not deeds are known as simple contracts. They are informal contracts and may be made in any way – in writing, orally or they may be implied from conduct.   Another way of classifying contracts is according to whether they are “bilateral” or “unilateral”. 1. Bilateral contracts A bilateral contract is one where a promise by one party is exchanged for a promise by the other. The exchange of promises is enough to render them both enforceable. Thus in a contract for the sale of goods, the buyer promises to pay the price and the seller promises to deliver the goods. 2. Unilateral contracts A unilateral contract is one where one party promises to do something in return for an act of the other party, as opposed to a promise, eg,......

Words: 54394 - Pages: 218

Free Essay

International Law

... This is the sixty-ninth in the series Hot Topics: legal issues in plain language, published by the Legal Information Access Centre (LIAC). Hot Topics aims to give an accessible introduction to an area of law that is the subject of change or public debate. International law 1 overview What is international law? – difference between international law and domestic law – Why do States obey international law? – subjects of international law – How do international law and domestic law interact? 4 sources of international law Jus cogens – international conventions and treaties – Australian treaty practice – custom – general principles of law – judicial decisions and writings of publicists – ‘hard law’ and ‘soft law’. 8 states What is a State? – rights of States – self-determination – creation and recognition of new States – case studies. AUTHOR NOTE: Jane Stratton currently leads corporate social responsibility programs in a leading Sydney law firm, teaches law students at a Sydney university and independently, undertakes community development projects in Western Sydney. Her work has included legal and policy roles in the Public Interest Advocacy Centre, the Australian Human Rights Commission, UN High Commission for Refugees and the ICTY. She has experience in litigious and political advocacy. Jane holds qualifications in law (Honours) and in Arts (Honours) from ANU and a Masters of Law from New York University. ACKNOWLEDGMENT: The......

Words: 23627 - Pages: 95

Free Essay

Public International Law

...International Law and Municipal Law Issues: • Does domestic law override international law? • Does international law apply domestically? 1 Theoretical Issues • Monism: Essentially exponents of natural-law theories; consequently, they regard all law as part of the same universal normative order, with municipal law deriving its binding force by way of delegation from international law. Thus, monists consider international law a part of domestic law. • Dualism: Essentially exponents of legal positivists – therefore, they have an essentially consensual view of international law, believing that international and municipal law were two separate legal orders. International law must be incorporated into domestic law, for it to apply domestically. • Harmonisation: Assumes that international law forms part of municipal law but acknowledges that on occasions when there was a conflict between the two systems, a municipal judge would be bound by the jurisdictional rules of the domestic domain. 2 Primacy of International Law 1 Municipal Tribunals Whether international law has primacy over municipal law depends on each particular country’s constitution. In Australia, there is no express incorporation of international obligations in Australia. Implementing legislation is required for both treaty and customary international law to apply. See below for further information. 2 International Tribunals A State cannot invoke domestic laws as an excuse for......

Words: 34402 - Pages: 138