Premium Essay

How to Discuss an Paper

In: Business and Management

Submitted By liuj92
Words 360
Pages 2
Each class you are required to present a critical review of one assigned research article to the rest of the class. You will have about 20-25 min to present, and 5-10 min to answer questions from other students and the instructor. You should review each article by summarizing and criticizing each of the following dimensions. It will be a good practice to prepare your presentation in PowerPoint. You should submit your PowerPoint to the Instructor and share it with other students in the class.
Key issues to discuss:
1) What is the phenomenon or problem being studied?
2) Why it is important to study the problem or phenomenon?
3) What motivated the research? What are the research gaps or inconsistencies identified?
4) What are the research questions?
5) What is the theory or theories or theoretical frameworks used?
6) Are the theories adequately described? Are the theories appropriate for the problem?
7) Is the literature review complete? Relevant? Up-to-date? Logically organized?
8) What is the research model? Is it interesting? Is it innovative?
9) Are the research hypotheses or propositions clearly articulated? Logical? Evidence based? Related to research questions?
10) How are data gathered? Unit analysis adequate relevant to research question and theory?
11) What is the research method? Is the method adequate relevant to research question and theory?
12) How are the hypotheses tested? Propositions articulated?
13) What are the main findings?
14) How do the findings contribute to the extant theory related to the phenomenon?
15) How do the findings contribute to the extant practice related to the phenomenon?
16) What are the limitations of current study? How can they be addressed in future studies?
17) How would do this study given all of the facts you know? Where do you improve specifically and why?
18) Is the overall structure of the paper…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

How to Wirte a Research Paper

...How to Write a Research Proposal.      Most students and beginning researchers do not fully understand what a research proposal means, nor do they understand its importance. To put it bluntly, one’s research is only as a good as one’s proposal. An ill-conceived proposal dooms the project even if it somehow gets through the Thesis Supervisory Committee. A high quality proposal, on the other hand, not only promises success for the project, but also impresses your Thesis Committee about your potential as a researcher.      A research proposal is intended to convince others that you have a worthwhile research project and that you have the competence and the work-plan to complete it. Generally, a research proposal should contain all the key elements involved in the research process and include sufficient information for the readers to evaluate the proposed study.      Regardless of your research area and the methodology you choose, all research proposals must address the following questions: What you plan to accomplish, why you want to do it and how you are going to do it.      The proposal should have sufficient information to convince your readers that you have an important research idea, that you have a good grasp of the relevant literature and the major issues, and that your methodology is sound.      The quality of your research proposal depends not only on the quality of your proposed project, but also on the quality of your proposal writing. A good......

Words: 1437 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

How to Write a College Paper

...ite aHOW TO WRITE COLLEGE RESEARCH PAPERS Mayland Community College S.O.A.R. Program 2004 As a college student you will be required to write research papers for many of your classes. A research paper is an in-depth report on a particular topic. It involves seeking sources of information that may include facts, statistics, historical writings, etc. The topic is usually one that you select, although the instructor may assign a topic area. This module is divided into two sections. The first section deals with the basics of developing and writing research papers. The second section covers information on different types of papers. You will learn how to approach writing assignments, how to find and document resources, how to prepare an outline, how to present your papers, and how to avoid plagiarism. Section One covers the following topics: 1. Getting Started 2. Brainstorming Your Topic 3. Beginning Your Research 4. Outlining Your Paper 5. The First Draft 6. Writing the Paper 7. Proofreading and Revising 8. Documenting (Citing) Your Sources 9. Delivery Section Two covers: 1. 2. 3. 4. Book Reports Term (Research) Papers Short and Long Reports Avoiding Plagiarism 1. GETTING STARTED The first step in any research paper assignment is to decide on your topic. Be sure your topic is manageable, meaning you can cover it adequately; it is appropriate to the topic; and it is interesting to you. For example, in Sociology class you may be studying changes in society. The broad theme...

Words: 5086 - Pages: 21

Free Essay

How to Write a Paper

...Title. This should say as much as possible about the content of the paper, in as few words as possible. Abstract. This is a brief (usually one paragraph) summary of the whole paper, including the problem, the method for solving it (when not obvious), the results, and the conclusions suggested or drawn. Do not write the abstract as a hasty afterthought. Look at it as a real exercise in cramming the most information in one paragraph. The reader should not have to read any of the rest of the paper in order to understand the abstract fully. Its purpose is to allow the reader to decide whether to read the paper or not. A reader who does not want to read the paper should be able to read the abstract instead. When you write an abstract, remember Strunk & White's admonition, ``Omit needless words.'' Introduction. Tell the reader what the problem is, what question you will try to answer, and why it is important. It might be important for practical reasons or for theoretical (or methodological) reasons having to do with the development of a scholarly discipline. Don't neglect either type of reason. If the problem is a very basic one, you may state the problem first and then review what has already been found out about it. If the problem is one that grows out of past literature, review the history of how it arose. But do not forget to mention the basic issues behind the research tradition in question, the practical or theoretical concerns that inspired it. (Sometimes there don't......

Words: 1539 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

How to Write a Paper to Be Published

...Outlines for Paper Writing Assignment 1. Find or search (Google it) for the most recent/current/contemporary/latest issues/problems/pitfalls ( regarding and within MANAGEMENT) 2. Choose your Topic: finding the topic which should be new and latest. 3. Finding 25 or above articles related to the topic. (The article/journal paper must be academic and of 2007 onwards). 4. Create your Title using these 25articles (showing the relationship, reviewing, impact on etc...) 5. Writing the paper a. Abstract (Written at the end) i. Why the topic is important (significance of the topic) ii. What have you done in the report iii. Summary of the conclusion b. Keywords: Write the keywords (must be between 3-5 keywords) c. Introduction: briefly mention the purpose and introduce the topic and main points about the report (some citations are needed) d. Literature review/Body: discuss the sources, points made, how do they relate, do u differ or relate to what has been discussed before (citation is necessary and must for this paper writing) e. Discussion (to critically discuss whatever has been discussed in the report) (Not to use the terms; I, WE, MY), write like: This paper/article/research f. Conclusion (briefly restate the main argument and direct ur ideas) g. References (use APA format) The......

Words: 293 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How to Write Reflection Paper

...How to Write Reflection Essay Posted by Splice, Essay Tips Chief Writer How to Write a Reflection Essay. Basically, writing a reflection essay is a good exercise to sharpen your critical thinking skills. You have to understand what it is that you have to reflect on before proceeding with the essay, otherwise you will only lose track of your ideas or, worse, you will not be able to write anything that will make sense. Keep in mind that a reflection essay is more like a journal where you jot down your thoughts or how you feel about a certain topic. Your topic may be a film, a book, an event, or just about anything. Before starting with your reflection essay, ask yourself a couple of questions, such as: how do I feel about this topic? How does it affect me, if it does at all? If it doesn't affect me, why? Notice that the questions are all personal. That is because a reflection essay asks you to express your insights. Knowing the answers to these personal questions can help you begin your reflection essay. Do not limit yourself to these three questions. Explore more that asks you to state your opinion. Leave out the facts first. Concentrate on your insights. After having the answers to the personal questions stated above, list your answers. Thereafter, summarize them into a single sentence. This will be your main controlling idea or central thesis which will guide you throughout the rest of your reflection essay. With your thesis statement, identify the arguments or ideas that......

Words: 539 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

How to Write a Research Paper

...A Guide on How to write a research paper 1. Establish Your Topic * Genuinely interests you. * Read and think about what you'd like to do. * Narrow it down to something more manageable (e.g.: Too general: Ancient Egypt. Revised: The building of the pyramids of Ancient Egypt. * Brainstorming to get ideas. 2. Identify the goal of the paper * An argumentative research paper: argues for one point of view. The issue should be debatable with a logical counter argument. * An analytical research paper: offers a fresh look at an important issue to persuade audience that it is important. 3. Look for Sources of Information *  Books, magazine articles, and internet articles. * A research paper should use at least four sources. * The academic credibility of a source could be considered. * Make note of page numbers, URLs, and quotable passages for citation. 4. Read Your Sources and Take Notes * Use index cards to relate ideas from different sources. * Keep source information on the other side of the cards. * Use quotation marks for “copy/paste” to avoid PLAGIARISM. * Organize your note cards by subtopic to make an outline. 5. Write a First Draft * Table of contents. * Introduction (let the reader know what the topic is, inform the reader about your point of view, arouse the reader's curiosity to read more). * Body (Limit each paragraph to one main idea, prove your points continually by using......

Words: 697 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How to Write a Research Paper

...6: findings Section 7: discussion Section 8: conclusion Section 9: references / works cited/ bibliography Section 1: abstract 1. a short summary (150-125 word) helping readers decide whether the article is relevant to their interests and whether it needs to be read in its entirety 2. fairly impersonal in tone talks about what the paper does rather than about what the author did “This article considers…”, “This article proposes…”, “This article examines…” 3. need for brevity more complex in syntax than the actual article mentioning all the sections of the paper drawing the ideas for one sentence or two from each of the article’s main sections 4. the content of an abstract 1) research objective 2) methodology (research subjects/research instrument / methods of statistical analysis) 3) research results and major conclusions 4) the significance of the findings Section 2: key words Investigate / investigation? (which one is preferred?) Using noun instead of verb 4---6 words min: 2 words max:10 words Chosen from the title and abstract writing & punctuation Section 3: introduction a crucial part of the paper ,the hardest part to write Function: to draw readers into the topic, to make them see why it is important and what you have to say about it is new and interesting three steps Step 1: to establish the general territory in which you are working One traditional way to begin : emphasize the importance of the general topic by briefly......

Words: 1112 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

How to Wrie a Paper

...Personal Responsibility in Education Angela M. Roberson Foundations for General Education/GEN200 Professor Sundra Kincy August 21, 2014 Personal Responsibility and Education Personal Responsibility can be defined as the act of being held accountable or taking ownership of one’s actions. It can also relate to the freedom and the power to create what happens in your life. It’s your life and you must take charge of it. In this paper I will discuss personal responsibility and how it related to your educational goals. I will give examples of ways to take responsibility of your educational endeavors and how to implement them into your everyday life. There will be a discussion on the benefits as well as the disadvantages of taking personal responsibility of your education. I. Deciding to pursue higher education is a big decision and it has responsibilities along with it. A. You must have a plan. B. Long and short term goals. II. You must decide how you are going to pay for school. A. Scholarships and Financial Aid. B. Tuition Reimbursement. III. Lifestyle changes are very necessary when embarking on educational advancements. A. Time Management B. Maintaining a schedule. C. Balancing family time. D. Making a calendar. IV. Higher education has its advantages. A Higher pay C. Career advancements D. Better lifestyle. V. Disadvantages A. Less time for extracurricular activities B. Less time for......

Words: 263 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How to Write a Research Paper

...RUNNING HEAD: TEN SIMPLE RULES FOR WRITING RESEARCH PAPER Rules for Writing a Research Paper Gwendolyn Burnett Webster University Gern: 5690 Dr. Gray Graves December 07, 2014 Abstract Most everything that has to be done and done right follows some type of procedure, guideline or rule. This holds true in writing research papers as well. There are rules for writing research papers, Zhang focus on ten of those rules: This paper will emphasize on the process that guides writers to writing professional and successful papers. Good research is vital to writing a good paper. This process will include the attitude of the writer and the principles he/she should uphold to establish the foundation of a well written research paper (Zhang, 2014). Writing should have a” driving force where research and writing are paired; less is more, less paper but more information with more meaning, you should know your audience, the paper needs to make sense have logic, a research’s cornerstone is a complete paper, the paper should be to the point (concise) yet simple, use a thesaurus to keep the paper from being boring and present a creative paper, format paper correctly, your attitude towards your paper is important be honest with yourself, is the paper a good job, revise over and over and over again, or you ready to test your paper by the opinions of others, be ready to accept constructive criticism, confer with others on your work, don’t get personal with their opinions...

Words: 978 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

How to Right a Term Paper

... How to Write a Term Paper I. Choosing a Topic: For this paper you get to choose your topic, so pick something that interests you. Once you have decided what you want to write about in general terms, refine that general idea to a specific topic for your paper. Keep in mind that you have a maximum of 12 pages of text to work with, so your topic is going to have to be pretty narrow in its focus. Also bear in mind that this is a research project, not a high school report; it should center around a thesis that you will prove in your paper. Example: I am interested in World War II, but I’m pretty sure that I can’t cover six years of global warfare in fifteen pages of text. Let’s see...I’m more interested in the War in Europe than in the Pacific, so that narrows that down some, but I need something tighter. I like airplanes, so something about the air war would be interesting, and there was this documentary on the History Channel about the Battle of Britain last month...but even the Battle of Britain is too big for twelve pages. Right, have to narrow it down some more here...do a little preliminary research and reading. Ah, here it is: the German Air Force started out trying to destroy the Royal Air Force by bombing RAF airfields, but then switched to targeting British cities. This decision cost them the battle, because it let the RAF rebuild its fighter strength and shoot down enough German bombers to force the Germans to call off the offensive. Wait a minute....

Words: 4172 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

How to Format Your Paper

...|How To Format Your Academic Paper Using Microsoft Word™ 2007 | I. MARGIN, DEFAULT FONT SIZE AND TYPE a. Create new document b. PAGE LAYOUT > MARGINS > NORMAL c. Margins should be set at 1” on all sides d. HOME > FONT > Font: Arial or Calibri > Size: 11 II. SURNAME, TITLE, PAGE NO. in HEADER a. INSERT > Header > EDIT HEADER b. HOME > Click ALIGN RIGHT c. Font: Arial or Calibri > Font Size: 10 d. Type your SURNAME / Essay Title / Alt+Shift+P (for auto page no.) III. TABLE FOR STUDENT INFORMATION a. INSERT > Table > 2x1 b. Right click on the table > Select AUTOFIT > Autofit to Window c. Click the table’s LEFT cell. Press CTRL+L d. Type your NAME COURSE / STUDENT NO. SUBJECT / SECTION e. Click on the table’s RIGHT cell. Press CTRL+R f. Type DATE OF SUBMISSION (Month DD, YYYY) Type of Requirement (Midterm, Final, Reaction Paper) Word Count: (count only the word count in the essay body) g. Highlight the essay’s body and locate WORD COUNT quick link at the lower left corner of the window. IV. MAKE YOUR TABLE LINES DISAPPEAR a. Highlight the table b. Right click > BORDERS AND SHADING > BORDERS TAB > Select NONE > Click OK V. FORMATTING THE TEXT OF THE ESSAY a. TITLE 1. Immediately after the table, press once and type your essay’s title 2. Highlight the...

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How to Write a Position Paper

...How to Write a Position Paper The purpose of a position paper is to generate support on an issue. It describes a position on an issue and the rational for that position. The position paper is based on facts that provide a solid foundation for your argument. In the position paper you should: • Use evidence to support your position, such as statistical evidence or dates and events. • Validate your position with authoritative references or primary source quotations. • Examine the strengths and weaknesses of your position. • Evaluate possible solutions and suggest courses of action. Choose an issue where there is a clear division of opinion and which is arguable with facts and inductive reasoning. You may choose an issue on which you have already formed an opinion. However, in writing about this issue you must examine your opinion of the issue critically. Prior to writing your position paper, define and limit your issue carefully. Social issues are complex with multiple solutions. Narrow the topic of your position paper to something that is manageable. Research your issue thoroughly, consulting experts and obtaining primary documents. Consider feasibility, cost-effectiveness and political/social climate when evaluating possible solutions and courses of action. The following structure is typical of a position paper: • An introduction • Identification of the issue • Statement of the position • The body • Background information •...

Words: 381 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

How to Write a White Paper

...Steps to writing a proper white paper… Use a Linear, Logical Approach: a white paper must be educational, not promotional in tone. And should posses the following objectives: It must attract the right audience. White papers are highly audience specific, it is better to write white papers tailored toward different groups of stakeholders. Must engage the reader; engage by showing them that you understand their problem and that you can “relate”. Or by quickly showing mastery of the subject, through good clear writing. It must inform your reader. Written more like an objective magazine article than a sales brochure. they should objectively present a problem, the business case for solving the problem, and alternative ways of solving the problem. Therefore, the reader gains knowledge from having invested the time to read the paper. Ultimately the reader feels informed, not sold. It must convince your reader; to convince reader to give your organisation consideration based information that you have presented. Example, if your product has a high up-front cost but lower maintenance costs, your paper might include an analysis of ongoing “hidden” costs and a ROI model that shows how a high initial investment might actually be more cost-effective over the life of the purchase. Your Title Is Key to Success of Paper: A creative, meaningful title drives readership, whether you promote your paper online, distribute it at a conference, or pitch it to trade magazine editors. The......

Words: 854 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

How to Write Term Paper

...quite simple. Student example papers can be of different types (example essay papers, example term papers, example research papers, example theses and example dissertations) and students can use example papers in almost all academic subjects. Most commonly example papers online turn out to be APA example papers, MLA example papers, and MBA example papers. Whenever there is a need of student example papers, a simple research can show you a load of free downloads, but you should know that it is all risky and you should not drive your academic career to a dead end. As a matter of principle student example papers such as example essays, example research papers, example term papers and example theses/dissertations can never inspire students to work harder. But custom written papers give students ideas and they can attempt to write the paper with little effort. Only specially written papers, but not free examples of papers, can give you guidelines on how to write your own papers. It is strongly believed that when students look through example papers, none of the new thoughts or ideas can be further generated on the topic. Thus such practice is claimed to be unsuccessful. Example papers (whether it is an essay paper example, research paper example, example of a term paper, thesis paper example or example of a dissertation) create work thieves not geniuses. For custom written or customized papers this is true to a great extent that such papers generate a sense of......

Words: 355 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Discuss How Castles Sees Mulitculturalism

...“Discuss how Castles Multiculturalism” The emergence of multiculturalism as prominent term in Western discourse concerning ethnic diversity, conflict and management coincides with increasing awareness in the Western industrial societies, especially over the last two decades, that ethnic groups had not lost their saliency in the lives of large numbers of people. Their earlier perceptions about such a loss of saliency coincides with the 19th century emergence of modern-industrial states, where social theorists such as Durkheim, Weber and Marx, theorised that status based social differentiation was replaced by the social class as the driving force in society. Ethnicity and racial differences were viewed as surviving anachronisms, dating from pre-modern, traditional societies. This analysis was shared by social commentators and policy-makers who operated with an often implicit view that assimilation of minority groups had either occurred, or was in progress. The trend towards global cultural homogenisation, typified by the metaphor of the "global village ", presaged a quickening of this type of development. Even in those industrial nations such as Australia, Canada or the USA which continued to receive large numbers of immigrants, assimilation was viewed as the inevitable process. By the 1960s, the ethnic rights movement and unrest in a number of the Western industrial countries led to increased questioning of assumptions that ethnic differences were of declining......

Words: 1643 - Pages: 7