Free Essay

Group Debate Analysis Paper

In: Business and Management

Submitted By jtatum90
Words 415
Pages 2
Group Debates Analysis Paper
11/10/2013

XBCOM/275
Colette Franklin

A debate is an art of reasoning and clever wording to persuade an audience of an individual or group opinion regarding the interpretation of facts and ideas (Gamble, 2012). Debates can be performed individually or in groups, there are both benefits and drawbacks to a debate and how they are performed. Group debates consist of more than two people on both teams; affirmative and negative. There are more benefits and drawbacks when analyzing a group debate. A group debate has its benefits and they are extensive, from expansive knowledge to comradely. When there is more than one person on a debate side all the different ways one opinions is expressed can make the viewpoint more clearly for any persons “sitting on the fence”. All of the opinions put together can give a broad spectrum of information on the given topic, allowing for each team member to see the topic in a different light. With more people on a team there is more knowledge that can pooled together to pick which bit of information is more relevant and can be a stronger hitting point for the opposing team, also each person can be given a specific job based upon their strengths to help the team collect information and deliver their statements. Not every person on the team will have come from the same education lesson or background so they can have different perspectives on how the topic is perceived. Knowing there is such a variety of knowledge and views on the same concept can send off a sense of confidence which will allow for the team to exude an upper-hand. On the opposing side of the subject, there are definitely drawbacks when having a group debate. The major issue with a group debate is tunnel vision, with such strong opinions and biases it is easy to lose the concept of the group and become an overbearing voice for the team. It is easy for people to get lost on a team if they do not possess strong qualities such as opinions, voice, or personality. This can lead to a feeling of insignificance, leading to the person to keep their information to themselves, when it could be the bit of information that makes the winning statement. Another big issue is lack of communication, if the team cannot communicate effectively they will not be able to get the information into a statement and delivered effectively.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Debate Analysis

...9/18/2013 Intelligence Squared Debate Analysis COMS 305 Abolish Minimum Wage Debate I thought both sides debated the case well, and they all showed interest in the case. The main issue being debated was to abolish minimum wage which is a policy claim. All of the debaters had a clear claim which made me easily interested in both sides regardless of what side I took before the debate. The reason the claims were clear was because they each had verification proving what they were arguing. The debaters had strong poise, and both teams presented their case with assurance and compassion. They each spoke intelligently about their side. There were some key points though. One was whether minimum wages hurts or improves the lives of the poorest American families. Another was that minimum wage destroys jobs as well as job opportunities. In addition, social mobility was discussed, as well as reverse stimulus. The team that was for abolishing minimum wage pointed out that minimum wage takes away any alternatives and that alternatives force employers to treat employees well and specifically said, "most of us don't need legislation to protect us in the labor force" (Roberts). The best examples that were given was employers taking their business over seas and replacing workers with machines. For a specific example, they pointed out how Walmart no longer has baggers (Roberts). The cashiers do it. They also used the example that Hong Kong has never had a minimum wage and they rose up......

Words: 741 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Debate Paper

...Learning Team Debate Paper Team C BCOM/275 September 23, 2013 Kai Hintze Learning Team Debate Paper Entering into an armed military conflict with another country has few positive results. Unfortunately the US intervening in the Syrian Civil War may be a necessary evil to preserve the long standing belief that the use of chemical weapons will not be tolerated in warfare. Many will argue that there is no proof the Syrian government was responsible for the chemical weapons attack near the capital city of Damascus. In contrast to these beliefs U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. Samantha Power said "The technical details of the U.N. report make clear that only the regime could have carried out this large scale chemical weapons attack,"(Fox News, 2013). Also according to intelligence analysis, conducted by several countries and the Human Rights Watch group (BBC News 2013), the evidence collected does point to the Syrian government using chemical weapons in the attacks near Damascus. The supposed use of chemical weapons by the Syrian government may not completely justify US intervention but it may help to deter further use of chemical weapons in future conflicts. Another benefit of US intervention in the Syrian Civil War would be increased credibility for the US and the Obama administration. Last year President Obama declared the use of chemical weapons a “red line” that would force him to rethink his “calculus” about that country’s conflict. (Crowley, 2013). If the US......

Words: 518 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Debate Paper

...Associated with Group Debates Competitive debate in any format sharpens the ability to research and analyze problems, think and listen critically by expressing thoughts clearly and fluently. It increases your confidence and poise and provides constant intellectual stimulation. Group formatted debates gives each debater an active role, members are generally randomly placed into groups of only two or three on each team, resulting in four to six debaters for each topic. When debates are set up in a group manner, people who make up the audience benefit from critically evaluating of each debaters on content, involvement, language, and speech; fishbowl discussions used in the fields have demonstrated positive learning opportunities for participates. Some drawbacks to these type of debating style are more reserved people are less likely to actively participate and there a tendency for males to be more comfortable than females in adversarial environments and the preference of some cultural groups for harmony over open opposition. This debate format has been criticized for oversimplifying complex issues into dichotomous options. The use of groups debating in front of the rest of the class allows for diverse evaluation of the issues by the student listeners, who are observing the debaters. The people who are listening are less focused on winning or losing the debate and can offer critical evaluation of the arguments presented. During the discussions following the debate......

Words: 363 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Debate Paper

...Debate Paper Jason Emilio Cotto/Jason France Business Communication and Critical Thinking- BCOM/275 2 December 2013 Instructor: Todd Breton We have all noticed that in all news outlets the rise in violence amongst the youth of the United States is out of control. Whenever a rise in violence happens people are always looking to blame someone. Back in the 1950’s Elvis and Rock and Roll were to blame. In the 1960’s and 1970’s it was blamed on drugs. Now in the age of information technology the new scapegoat is the video game entertainment industry. To understand video games and it’s inception we must first know the history of it’s predecessor, the computer. People believe that computers and the information age are a new concept, but most would be surprised that computers have been around since 1936. Mr. Konrad Zuse created the first programmable computer that would change the world forever in the decades to come. The real turning point for the history of computers came in 1983. The first home computer was created. This allowed people the flexibility to purchase and work from home. There were video game systems out in the 70’s, but it wasn’t till 1983 that it really hit mainstream. That was the year that Japan released the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES). It took the entertainment value of computer games with the graphics of the computer to create the perfect combination. Arcade consoles were wildly popular and Nintendo realized a niche in being able to bring that......

Words: 1865 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Debate Paper

...human rights abuses perpetrated by the military. These pro-interventionists conclude Assad continues his oppressive actions because he doesn’t believe anyone will take action to stop him. Assaults on Syrian civilians are documented by many sources. Since January 2011 it is estimated over 100,000 citizens protesting against the Assad regime have been killed by military forces (Table, 2013). A report commissioned by the UN in June 2013 estimated 5,000 were killed each month since July 2012. This number exceeds reported deaths in Iraq at the height of war in 2007. In a September 2011 report many atrocities against children were documented. Over a hundred children were killed in connection with protests, many others reported injured. A group of children in the town of Dara’a, as young as 8, were taken into custody in connection with anti-government graffiti on a schoolhouse wall. These children were still unaccounted for at the time of the report. Other children were reportedly subjected to torture and rape while in custody (United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child, 2013). May 19, 2011 in a Middle East policy speech President Obama recommended the Assad regime adopt democratic principles and embrace the changes his people were calling for or “get out of the way” (Gollust, 2011). The Arab League called for Assad to step down and hand over control in January 2012 (Hassan & Zavis, 2012). On December 2, 2012 President Obama delivered the following warning to......

Words: 2628 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Debate Paper

...Gun Control Team Debate Paper BCOM/275 May 7, 2013   Gun Control Gun control is a hot topic in the United States with primarily two sides of the conversation advocating for either more control of guns or more freedom of guns. The current laws on gun control or gun rights are disagreed upon by these individuals essentially based on the interpretation of such gun control laws. Firearms and the effects of gun rights has many cases that call for the strictest form of gun control. Some of these instances involve elementary school shootings, shootings at theaters, and even shootings on military installations by military members. The 2nd Amendment in the constitution has long been the proof of rights for citizens to bear arms to defend themselves from tyranny. Gun rights supporters say firearms should be unrestricted as it allows for self-defense in the case of another individual holding a weapon. Gun control supporters state that less regulation on gun control does not allow the government to provide its role of security because of it. The statistics for gun ownership in America are interesting to look at. For example, in the United States the average gun ownership per 100 people is 88.8, the highest of all other countries. Both sides of the argument have valid points, however it is important to dive deeper into each argument to analyze the logic and statistics involved in each argument. Major Gun Control Arguments Every day there are a countless instances that show......

Words: 2155 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Debates Analysis Prper

...Group Debates Analysis Paper Myrnia Brown XBCOM/275 June 15, 2014 Velvalee Wiley Group Debates Analysis Paper A debate is an art of reasoning and clever wording to persuade an audience of an individual or group opinion regarding the interpretation of facts and ideas (Gamble, 2012). Debates can be performed individually or in groups, there are both benefits and drawbacks to a debate and how they are performed. Group debates consist of more than two people on both teams; affirmative and negative. There are more benefits and drawbacks when analyzing a group debate. A group debate has its benefits and they are extensive, from expansive knowledge to comradely. When there is more than one person on a debate side all the different ways one opinions is expressed can make the viewpoint more clearly for any persons “sitting on the fence”. All of the opinions put together can give a broad spectrum of information on the given topic, allowing for each team member to see the topic in a different light. With more people on a team there is more knowledge that can pooled together to pick which bit of information is more relevant and can be a stronger hitting point for the opposing team, also each person can be given a specific job based upon their strengths to help the team collect information and deliver their statements. Not every person on the team will have come from the same education lesson or background so they can have different perspectives on how......

Words: 377 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Debate Paper

...Allowing women the option to have an abortion up until twenty four weeks gestation. Leading the way for other states to change their laws governing abortions. This brought about a whole new issue as to whether abortion should be legal or not. Prior to Roe vs. Wade an abortion could not be performed unless the mother’s health was at great risk. After the case, many states reevaluated their laws so that mothers could have an abortion for various reasons including “just because they weren’t ready to settle down.” This decision divided the American people as to whether it was ethically and morally right for a woman to choose abortion. In 2013, there were over one million abortions performed in the United States. We will examine both sides of the debate from an ethical and moral stand point as well as the pros and cons. Pro-life activists state that abortion is morally wrong because it takes the life of an innocent child. The belief is that a life begins at the moment of conception. Therefore having an abortion is the same thing as murder. In society, it is not acceptable to allow one human being to commit murder to another without there being a punishment and abortion should be no different. Pro-life advocates promote adoption as an alternative to taking a life. The argument is that if the child is unwanted the mother can place the baby in the care of foster parents until a family who cannot have children or would like to adopt more, adopts the child. Abortions are considered......

Words: 1827 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Debate Paper

...Debate Paper XBCOM/275 February 8, 2015 Debate Paper Prayer in our schools today has almost died out completely. Prayer is a solemn request for help or expression of thanks addressed to god or an object of worship. As it states in the First Amendment that it protects the right to freedom of expression from government interference. Although prayer in school may focus on religion, violate the first amendment, and separation of church and state, there are some good things and bad that come out of prayer in schools. Being that we are an unequal society and everyone has his or her own personal opinion on prayer in our schools; it still remains one of the most controversial issues today. Just like the different types of religion. The decision to take prayer out of public schools has become one of the most controversial issues throughout our society. The argument of whether prayer should or should not be allowed is so misunderstood. When determining whether or not prayer should be allowed in public schools, it is important to consider both the advantages and disadvantages. In our society, 90% of America’s children attend public schools. The children that attend public schools come from homes that use a fluctuation of religion or don’t practice religion at all. The good and bad of prayer in public schools are not a cut and dry issue. There are many outlets to this matter. The arguments of the people that want to banish prayer in the school system are not......

Words: 2023 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Group Analysis

...Group Debate Analysis Paper Kenneth McDougald XBCOM/275 April 12, 2015 Lorelle Davies Group Debate Analysis Paper There are many benefits associated with group debates, but there are also many drawbacks. Let us talk about some benefits first. Different perspectives are brought into play when there is a group involved. These perspectives tend to yield more information especially when they are coming from different positions of the argument. Diversity in the group can add to these different perspectives. Someone who was raised in an upper class family in the suburbs would have different experiences and views than someone from an impoverished inner city area. Debating in groups can also improve one’s communication skills. It also gives the debaters the opportunity to show off there listening skills. If one cannot properly listen to the arguments being presented or the questions being asked it will be difficult to present an argument that is substantive. Communication is something that is important in many aspects of business and personal communication. It is important to be able to communicate eloquently and respectfully. Part of respect is self control. Controlling one’s emotions in a debate is the best way to be taken seriously. There are also a few drawbacks to group debates and many of us have seen them first hand. Political debates are a great example. How many times have you seen a presidential primary debate with 4 candidates get away......

Words: 385 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Group Debate

...Group Debate Analysis Paper Rachel Hammond August 29, 2015 COM 275 Lorelle Davies   A formal school debate, the advantages are many. The student gets to improve his or her speaking skills. They get to learn to use words that are more technical, but are not considered jargon. They have learn how to use proper grammar, or else their adjudicators will criticize them. Debaters learn how to expand the points they have to fit a specific period. Another important advantage of a debate is that they learn how to think outside the box. In a debate, failure to anticipate what the opposition's points will be is a sign of narrow mindedness. You must always have better, unanticipated by the opposition rebuttals, and debate helps develop this. In British Parliament format, there are two teams within a house, and the closing team will have to provide 'new light' to the opening team's government. Providing "new light" on a subject is easier said than done, because the opening goes first, and they will have all easy arguments and closing would have to think of something better. Debaters who think critically will successfully rebut the opposition's points. Debating helps students become creative when it comes to making points for frequently debated topics. The debate also teaches students how to research better, as they need this to make points and arguments. Debating also enhances teamwork and friendly competition. Debating teaches students how to act under pressure and how to...

Words: 376 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Debate Paper

...Group Analysis and Debate Paper University of Phoenix XBCOM/275 Fredrick Dean September 13, 2015 The topic of debate might sometimes hold a negative connotation, as people associate having a debate with having an intense argument with an individual or group or individuals. However having a debate can sometimes be very beneficial, as it is as a way to see a belief or idea from other’s perspectives. A debate is a formal discussion on a particular topic in a public meeting or legislative assembly, in which opposing arguments are put forward. It is an essential tool for developing and maintaining democracy and open societies. Having a debate can be done individually or in a group setting. When debating with a group, it can have both benefits and drawbacks. Having a debate enables individuals to think critically and analyze situations in order to formulate new ideas. The biggest difference between one-on-one debate and group debate is the number of different viewpoints. However, this is a benefit as well because you get the opportunity to see things from other vantage points. In this respect, an open mind is needed, as it makes it easier to receive information and evaluate it. Group debates are also an excellent way to exercise critical thinking skills, communication skills, and active listening. Group debates also allow the opportunity to exercise self-control, as you have to allow others the opportunity to express themselves without interruption, and also not to get......

Words: 360 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Debate Paper

...Debate Paper MBA 5600 Human Resource Management Debate Paper Introductory Statement & Overview of position Controversial Position The controversial position of Scott’s organization, can tell employees what to do on the companies times and property and an employee’s own time. Traditional Position Companies have the right to tell employees what to do on company’s time and property, but at home employees can do what they want. As Jim Lowe “started each day with two doughnuts. Lunch was pair of Whoppers and fries. Nighttime involved a bag of chips, a couch, and a clicker”(Conlin, 2007). My Position My overview position is traditional position I believe that Organizational or Companies have the right tell employees what do on company’s time but at employees can do what they wish at the privacy of their own home. Argument # 1 Controversial Argument Corporations find new ways to save money, as Scotts Miracle-Gro Co. and other organization are banning employees from smoking, regardless of whether it is done on company or personal time. Scotts believes if you work of us you are band from certain things. Traditional Position Rebuttal Some times in a job you must bring your work home; organizations are saying you must bring their rules and regulation home. Many organizations such as Scotts is trying to control people personal life outside of work. Such organization that help employees outside of work as NWI(National Work Rights Institute), is......

Words: 3441 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Debate Paper

...(Camarota, 2011). Why is the government giving our money away? The elderly, the physically handicapped, and the mentally handicapped, need the government’s financial help. Americans have paid into social security throughout their working life and rely on this assistance as he or she enters retirement. However, statistics are showing they will get nothing in return. Our nation’s money is being given out to immigrants entering into our nation illegally and using our hospitals, medical centers, and our government assistance programs. Most illegal immigrants have access to welfare benefits due to the fact that his or her children were born in America. America is the great melting pot and we are a nation of many different cultures and ethnic groups. However, back in the early 1900’s when the great immigration took place, those immigrants made it on their own. They did not rely on our government to make ends meet. They worked hard and made a clean honest living for themselves. In order for U.S. Citizens to work hard and not rely on our government for assistance, we require a fair wage. The Washington Times recently noted, “When labor is genuinely scarce, and too many employers are chasing too few workers, businesses typically bid wages up in the competition to fill jobs. When too many workers are chasing too few jobs, employers typically cut wages, confident that beggars can’t be choosers. Labor Department data reveals that the wage-cutting scenario is exactly......

Words: 1985 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Debate Paper

...Women of Wal-Mart debate University of Phoenix Axia College Women of Wal-Mart Debate This article is about a sex discrimination against Wal-Mart. Three women started a lawsuit against Wal-Mart about not being paid as much as men for the same position. According to (Young, 2011) nearly 23 of women make up hourly wages and 13 of management are women but (Young, 2011) states that disparities, the complaint argued, can be explained only by bias, which this may be true but I do not believe that the women that work at Wal-Mart can make up a story like this. I never worked at Wal-Mart to know how they treat women or even if they get less pay then men but when you have about 120 women or more it might be true how Wal-Mart treats women. What I do not understand is how these women cannot be able to state their problem with Wal-Mart without bias or how Wal-mart cannot state their statement without bias. One thing I do agree with is that other companies are bought into the lawsuit by the equal employment opportunity commission. I do not think any company should get away with sex discrimination. Well not just sex discrimination any discrimination is bad for a company. I feel that no company should not discriminates against anyone whether if it race, religion or sex. According to (Young, 2011) 25 years ago men were the breadwinner and women were the homemaker but now times are different women are more likely to work and men are more likely to be more involved in......

Words: 442 - Pages: 2