Premium Essay

Evaluate the Operation of Courts and Vcat in Resolving Civil Disputes.

In: Other Topics

Submitted By hge97
Words 449
Pages 2
The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal and the court are both independent dispute settling bodies presided over by a legally trained experts in the law. Tribunals provide a cheaper and less formal method of dispute resolution for civil disputes, whereas process used in courts are formal and hearings follow strict rules of evidence and procedure.
The operation of courts in dispute resolution means that courts can adjudicate on a range of disputes and cases, whether criminal or civil, minor or major. The courts have a doctrine of precedent that applies in the court, which brings a sense of predictability, certainty and consistency to the way in which disputes are resolved. The use of legal representation ensures both parties are on equal footing, as they both have expert representation who understand the legal system as their advocates in court. The court treats both parties fairly and equally by enforcing the strict rules of evidence and procedures in the courtroom. Courts that resolve civil disputes gives parties opportunities to appeal to higher courts if they can establish ground of appeal if they are dissatisfied with the decision made for their case.
The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal system has a low cost of resolving disputes unlike the courts. VCAT is a faster dispute resolution method as parties avoid the delays associated with going to court. VCAT operates within its own specialised jurisdiction. Resulting in the tribunal personal developing expertise in resolving disputes in that particular area. The decisions of VCAT are binding and are legally enforceable on the parties.
Although the courts can adjudicate on a range of disputes and cases, the courts are a very time consuming method of dispute resolution. Their delays are very common and the high courts are usually involved with the court proceedings, partly due to the need of…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Alternative Dispute Resolution

...techniques are often central to resolving conflict and as a basic technique these have been around for many thousands of years. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) refers to a variety of streamlined resolution techniques designed to resolve issues in controversy more efficiently when the normal negotiation process fails. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is an alternative to the Formal Legal System. It is an alternative to litigation. It was being thought of in view of the fact that the Courts are over burdened with cases. The said system emanates from dissatisfaction of many people with the way in which disputes are traditionally resolved resulting in criticism of the Courts, the legal profession and sometimes lead to a sense of alienation from the whole legal system- thus, the need for Alternative Dispute Resolution. With the spread of ADR programs in the developed and developing world, creative uses for and designs for ADR systems are proliferating. Successful programs are improving the lives of individuals and meeting broad societal goals. There is a critical mass of ADR experience, revealing important lessons as to whether, when and how to implement ADR projects. The Concept & its efficacy: “It is the spirit and not the form of law that keeps the justice alive.” LJ Earl Warren The concept of Conflict Management through Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) has introduced a new mechanism of dispute resolution that is non adversarial. A dispute is......

Words: 3549 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Alternate Dispute Resolution Mechanism

...Alternate Dispute Resolution Mechanism The Concept & its efficacy: “It is the spirit and not the form of law that keeps the justice alive.” LJ Earl Warren The concept of Conflict Management through Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) has introduced a new mechanism of dispute resolution that is non adversarial. A dispute is basically ‘lis inter partes’ and the justice dispensation system in India has found an alternative to Adversarial litigation in the form of ADR Mechanism. New methods of dispute resolution such as ADR facilitate parties to deal with the underlying issues in dispute in a more cost-effective manner and with increased efficacy. In addition, these processes have the advantage of providing parties with the opportunity to reduce hostility, regain a sense of control, gain acceptance of the outcome, resolve conflict in a peaceful manner, and achieve a greater sense of justice in each individual case. The resolution of disputes takes place usually in private and is more viable, economic, and efficient. ADR is generally classified into at least four types: negotiation, mediation, collaborative law, and arbitration. (Sometimes a fifth type, conciliation, is included as well, but for present purposes it can be regarded as a form of mediation Need of ADR in India: The system of dispensing justice in India has come under great stress for several reasons mainly because of the huge pendency of cases in courts. In India, the number of cases filed in the......

Words: 3624 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Alternative Methods of Resolving Legal Disputes

...A legal dispute is a disagreement over the existence of a legal duty or right. Usually most legal disputes are resolved in a court of law. However, there are alternative methods of resolving legal disputes other than by a court. Such methods include Tribunals as well as Arbitration. There are different Tribunals which exist to resolve a variety of disputes. Generally, a tribunal is known to be any person or institution with the authority to judge, to pass that particular judgment, or to determine claims or disputes. For example the industrial tribunal sits to dertermine statutory employment law disputes such as wrongful dismissal, unfair dismissal and redundancy. However industrial tribunals serve to resolve many more disputes than these. These tribunals handle the majority of employment law disputes between employers and employees. Advantages | Disadvantages | Cheaper | Unfair imbalance between represented and unrepresented parties | Speedy, Informal and Flexible | The no-costs rule and lack of legal aid penalize poor litigants | Accessibility | May become complex over time | Freedom from technicality | May lack some of the perceived independence of the judiciary | Specialism | May result in ill founded claims | An Arbitration is a legal technique for the resolution of disputes outside the courts, where the parties to a dispute refer it to one or more persons, known as the arbitrators, arbiters or arbitral tribunal, by whose decision (the "award")......

Words: 607 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Settlement of International Commercial Disputes

...Electronic Arbitration ii Dispute Settlement NOTE The Course on Dispute Settlement in International Trade, Investment and Intellectual Property consists of forty modules. This module has been prepared by Mr. O. Cachard at the request of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD). The views and opinions expressed in this module are those of the author and not necessarily those of the United Nations, WTO, WIPO, ICSID, UNCITRAL or the Advisory Centre on WTO Law. The designations employed and the presentation of the material do not imply an expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or areas or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. In quotations from the official documents and the jurisprudence of international organizations and tribunals countries are designated as reported. The United Nations holds copyright to this document. The course is also available in electronic format on the UNCTAD website (www.unctad.org). Copies may be downloaded free of charge on the understanding that they will be used for teaching or study and not for a commercial purpose. Appropriate acknowledgement of the source is requested. UNCTAD/EDM/Misc.232/Add.20 Copyright © United Nations, 2003 All rights reserved 5.9 Electronic Arbitration iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Note What you will learn 1. Dispute Resolution Methods in......

Words: 25410 - Pages: 102

Premium Essay

List and Analyze Methods of Alternative Dispute Resolution and Determine Which Would Be Most Effective in Resolving Genuine Disputes That Arise with Consumers Who May Make Purchases from Businesses That Provide Links Via Social Media

...prevalence of social media continues to rise, consumers are recognizing ways in which social media can direct them to better sources for purchasing. As a result, businesses are now jumping on the social media bandwagon at a rapid pace, embracing social networks to achieve their marketing and business goals. Identify one (1) of the major social media outlets and write a three to four (3-4) page paper in which you: 1. Discuss the four (4) components of a legally astute social media marketing manager who utilizes social media outlets for consumer transactions and how each component can mitigate the risk involved in doing business in cyberspace. 2. List and analyze methods of alternative dispute resolution and determine which would be most effective in resolving genuine disputes that arise with consumers who may make purchases from businesses that provide links via social media. 3. Since consumer transactions on social media can occur across state lines, determine how the federal government can best control these transactions. 4. Examine the three (3) branches of government and discuss which can effectuate the most significant impact on regulating consumer transactions via social media outlets. Support your decision. 5. Explain whether or not the agency relationship exists on social media sites between the social media provider and businesses that utilize the site for advertising. Support your answer. 6. Use at least three (3) quality......

Words: 414 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Alternative Dispute Resolution

...Alternative Dispute Resolution Name: Institution Affiliation: Introduction Alternative dispute resolution is a method for settling parties' disagreements outside of court's antagonistic setting. Today, ADRs are greatly compelling to the point that courts frequently oblige parties to seek after this plan B before disputing their cases. Both arbitration and mediation may be court-requested. Settling one's dispute through components outside to the court structure may spare one time and cash. In the last twenty-five years, since Australia held onto multiculturalism as an approach, issues of intercultural correspondence have ended up more noticeable in the working environment. On the other hand, until as of late, little had been composed on these issues, and even now, numerous authoritative managers have no preparation. They as well have no learning of how to manage correspondence problems, despite the fact that most workplaces are staffed by individuals of diverse cultures. The report examines these three issue areas and shows that a considerable lot of the difficulties confronted by migrants in the workforce are caused by the absence of awareness of, and preparing in, intercultural correspondence. Why clients should be encouraged to use ADR and Implications Clients ought to be encouraged to make use of these alternative methods for solving conflicts for a number of reasons. ADR can permit access to justice. Case in point, as there can be cost......

Words: 3050 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Court History

...Court History and Purpose Leon White CJA/224 January 6, 2015 David Hernandez Court History and purpose The American court system is a vital part of the criminal justice system. Courts are part of the judicial branch and serves as an instrument of social control. A court must have proper legal authority and are entrusted to make decisions that are binding within the adjudication process. The court system has the task of punishing wrongdoers who commit heinous crimes against society. The courts also have the job of determining which behaviors may or may not be acceptable as well as which sanction to hand down and the severity of the sanction as well as settling disputes in civil case. The U.S. operates on a dual-court system, which consist of a federal branch and a state branch. Each branch operates under it own jurisdiction but work towards a common goal. U.S. District Courts The U.S. district courts are described as federal trial courts, and serves as an entry point into the federal judicial system. This is where federal civil cases are decided and where individuals who are charged with violations of federal laws are put on trial. According the Schmelleger “The district courts are the workhorses in the federal system. As we have indicated, they are the trial courts where most disputes are resolved.”(Schmelleger, 2011) As of today there are 94 district courts a majority of federal cases held and resolved at the district level. However, only a small......

Words: 1133 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Court History

...Court History and Purpose Leon White CJA/224 January 6, 2015 David Hernandez Court History and purpose The American court system is a vital part of the criminal justice system. Courts are part of the judicial branch and serves as an instrument of social control. A court must have proper legal authority and are entrusted to make decisions that are binding within the adjudication process. The court system has the task of punishing wrongdoers who commit heinous crimes against society. The courts also have the job of determining which behaviors may or may not be acceptable as well as which sanction to hand down and the severity of the sanction as well as settling disputes in civil case. The U.S. operates on a dual-court system, which consist of a federal branch and a state branch. Each branch operates under it own jurisdiction but work towards a common goal. U.S. District Courts The U.S. district courts are described as federal trial courts, and serves as an entry point into the federal judicial system. This is where federal civil cases are decided and where individuals who are charged with violations of federal laws are put on trial. According the Schmelleger “The district courts are the workhorses in the federal system. As we have indicated, they are the trial courts where most disputes are resolved.”(Schmelleger, 2011) As of today there are 94 district courts a majority of federal cases held and resolved at the district level. However, only a small......

Words: 1133 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Labor and Management Disputes at San Miguel Corporation: Its Resolutions and the Implication in the Business Operation

...Republic of the Philippines SOUTHERN LEYTE STATE UNIVERSITY Sogod, Southern Leyte Philippines LABOR AND MANAGEMENT DISPUTES AT SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION: ITS RESOLUTIONS AND THE IMPLICATION IN THE BUSINESS OPERATION A Final Paper presented to The Faculty of the Graduate Studies Southern Leyte State University In partial fulfilment of the course MM 505 : Management and the Law Summer 2015 RIZA MAE B. FORTUNA Master in Management Student TABLE OF CONTENT Cover Page Page 1 Table of Content Page 2 I. Introduction Page 3 A. Objectives B. Company Profile, Mission & Vision Page 4 II. Antecedent facts of the case Page 6 III. Resolutions, Findings and Decision of the Labor - Page 7 Management Problem IV. Recommendation and Observation Page 8 V. Appendices Page 9 Whole Case citation Page 9 Nature of the Company Page 16 References Page 17 I. NAME OF COMPANY AND ITS PROFILE INTRODUCTION Corporation is defined as the most common business organization which is formed by a group of people. It has rights and liabilities separate from those of the individuals involved. It may be a non-profit organization engaged in activities for the public good; a municipal corporation, such as a...

Words: 5029 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Identity and Explain the Alternative Method of Resolving Civil Disputes Other Than by Taking Action Through the Courts and Consider the Advantages and Disadvantages of Each of These Alternatives.

...Civil disputes are cases of disagreement in self-interest between individuals, large corporation or organization under the circumstance that no breaking of criminal laws (Maclntyre, 2010). Cases are mainly to do with torts, contract matters, probate of wills, trusts, property and deceased estates. The verdict of litigation is largely by means of financial compensation to the winning party that includes court costs as well. It is encouraged to resolve disputes of the above-mentioned through mediation, conciliation, arbitration and tribunals nowadays. As any litigation takes lots of time and money, these alternatives can concurrently improve efficiency and save money as well as time. Mediation involves a third party to phase in the negotiations of disputants is regarded as Mediator whose position is neutral and has no self interest in the case (Hibbert, 2008). Mediator is skillful in the technique of communication who will structure schedule aimed to keep matters simple and to identify the key issue of the dispute. Disputants will be guided to narrow their differences to come to a consensus for a mutually satisfactory outcome acceptable to both parties concerned. Mediation schemes are in The Court of Appeal and the Commercial Court. Manchester Court Mediation Scheme is available in all county courts (Hibbert, 2008). Conciliation is a scheme which is quite similar to mediation. However, Conciliator plays a relatively active role by proposing solution to disputants......

Words: 961 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business Dispute

...October 29, 2015 Patrice Carrington, Instructor Business dispute We realize the civil lawsuit of Rose Hills filed against Grupo Deco California in California State court. Grupo Deco California’s legal structure is recognized as Limited Liability Company and Rose Hills has a Corporation legal structure. Rose Hills has a variety of business which includes the operation of Funeral homes and cemeteries in southern California. Rose Hills gets an agreement to lease one of their Funeral homes (San Fernando Funeral Home) to Grupo Deco California. Legal form of Business Both Grupo Deco California and Rose Hills have a Corporation as their legal structure. A Corporation is one of the most common corporate structures we currently have. The Corporation is owned by stockholders and it is legally considered a separate entity. Due to the fact that is legally separated, the stockholders are totally protected from creditors. According to Leonard, David, Marilyn, and Gwendolyn (2006) “A stockholder's personal liability is thus usually limited to the amount of investment in the corporation.” (p. 174). Some advantages of a corporation is that a corporation’s life continues regardless of what may happen to its shareholders or officers. Raising Capital can be easier with this type of legal structure by borrowing, selling stocks. Also, a shareholder may transfer his or her ownership of the business without interrupting operations. And probably the most important, a corporation is......

Words: 1204 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Evaluate the Claim That the U.S Supreme Court Is an Imperial Judiciary

...Evaluate the claim that the U.S Supreme Court is an Imperial Judiciary The Founding Fathers established the Federal Supreme Court in Article III of the Constitution as the ultimate judicial power, claiming “The judicial Power of the United States, shall be vested in one supreme Court”. Despite being put into power in 1789, The debate still exists as to how powerful the Supreme Court truly is, some say it is an imperial power with too much influence over U.S Politics, whilst others argue against this claim stating the Supreme Court is imperilled in many respects. The two main claims that the Supreme Court is still powerful lies in their power of Judicial Review and the fact they have a security of tenure, meaning they cannot be fired and are not subject to elections like other government officials, meaning they can act as they wish and with great freedom. Justices are not completely free to exercise power as they wish, they are of course bound by the constitution (subject to interpretation) and have a responsibility to interpret it correctly. Furthermore, they can be subject to impeachment by the Senate if they act in a manner not fitting that of the highest lawmakers in the land. The United States government is made up of 3 supposedly co-equal branches of Government, a system of checks and balances designed to make the perfect democratic system. However, with the surge of partisanship on the hill coupled with a progressive Executive branch addressing some of Americas......

Words: 1830 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Chances to Adopt Adr in Administrative Disputes

...Chances to adopt ADR in administrative disputes (Explaining on tax dispute instance) Chuluuntsetseg Ochirjantsan* (Member of Mongolian Bar Association, Senior teacher at Law school of NUM) I. II. III. IV. V. VI. Introduction The origin and development of ADR in Mongolia Concept and stages of administrative proceeding Necessity to adopt mediation procedure on Mongolian tax case and dispute Conclusion References Abstract Tax law covers a significant presence in administrative law sectors. Tax dispute and cases are part of the administrative law disputes and resolving tax dispute and cases through ADR is much peaceful mechanism. Despite the mediation procedure on tax cases and dispute is occupying great position in the national legal systems of countries, international level dispute resolution based on the principles of mutual trust is a flexible and effective method. Countries tend to implement mediation procedure on tax cases in accordance with their legal culture, consciousness level and characteristics of the population regardless of their legal family. Reconciliation and mediation on tax cases and dispute is system which settling cases by parties making dialogue to find mutual consent that can fit to the actual situation without getting restricted by a tight law regulation. Therefore the necessity to resolving tax cases through reconciliation and mediation is seen as a pressing problem in many countries. Key words: Reconciliation......

Words: 4815 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Civil Court Cases

...In civil law court cases, the court in which the case is first heard is known as the court of first instance. Depending on how much money the claimant is holding the defendant liable for will determine the track the case will be put in to. The tracking system was introduced by Lord Woolf in order to make the court process more efficient. There are three main tracks used in the civil law procedure. The first track is known as the small claims track in which the claimant is asking for an amount of money below the cost of £5000, and for an amount below £1000 if it is a personal injury or housing claim. Although small claims have been given a track, cases involving these claims aren’t conducted as full trials in the court of law. The second tracking system is known as the Fast-track. Fast track claims are worth £5000 - £25,000 and to be held over a period of 30 weeks, and the actual court date to be done within one day due to the long procedure building up to court date. The introduction of a protocol by Lord Woolf allowed both parties to communicate before the trial and obtain information to see if a settlement could be reached outside of the courts in order to help the courts. The final tracking system is known as the multi track for cases above the value of £25,000. These are similar to fast track cases, although they are not given a trial deadline as they deal with more serious matters. The High Court is the civil court of first instance for cases involving more......

Words: 875 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Settlement of International Commercial Disputes

...factors ……………………………………………… 3 3. International Dispute …………………………………………. 4 4. The Dispute Settlement Understanding ……………………... 7 5. Main types of international court ……………………………. 10 6. World Trade Organization ….……………………………….. 13 7. Examples - Settlement of international Commercial disputes ………………………………………….. 16 8. Conclusion …………………………………………………….. 18 9. References …………………………………………………….. 19 Introduction: There are various types of disputes. The appropriate way of resolving most disputes is by adjudication. In the event of such cases, the most important question would be whether litigation or arbitration is the appropriate procedure and if the issues for adjudication can be clarified or narrowed in any useful way. Negotiation or mediation can be used for the solution of other disputes. The assistance and dynamism of a neutral third party who may introduce carefully devised procedures for examining and where appropriate perhaps evaluating the issues, for exploring interests, concerns and options, for dealing effectively with emotional and hidden factors, and for generally assisting the parties towards settlement, may well facilitate and expedite resolution. In finding a solution for dispute, the nature and implications of the disputes have to be properly understood. Many commercial and investment disputes are entirely appropriate to be resolved by adjudication. In domestic disputes, the debate about the advantage to arbitrate......

Words: 5422 - Pages: 22