Free Essay

Ethics for Prosecutor and Defense Attorney

In: Other Topics

Submitted By wilandj
Words 304
Pages 2
Assignment 1: Ethics for Prosecutors and Defense Attorneys Due Week 4 and worth 140 points
Research the Internet or the Strayer Library for two (2) separate criminal cases where a: a. Prosecutor violated the Attorney Professional Code of Conduct. b. Defense attorney violated the Attorney Professional Code of Conduct.
Write a three to five (3-5) page paper in which you:
1.Summarize the facts of the cases, analyzing the roles of the prosecutors and defense attorneys, and detailing what violations of code of conduct were alleged to have occurred.
2.Determine which duties were breached and what the prosecutor and defense attorney should have done to comply.
3.Deduct the professional and / or personal ramifications of the alleged shortcomings.
4.Research and cite at least four (4) peer-reviewed sources in addition to the text. Access to the Strayer Learning Resource Center is available to students, including Lexis-Nexis and EBSCO. Note: Wikipedia and similar Websites do not qualify as quality resources.
Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements:
•Be typed, double spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all sides; citations and references must follow APA format, including in-text citation. Check with your professor for any additional instructions.
•Include a cover page containing the title of the assignment, the student’s name, the professor’s name, the course title and the date. The cover page and the reference page are not included in the required assignment page length.
•Note: Information on how to avoid plagiarism is included in the Resource Center.
The specific course learning outcomes associated with this assignment are:
•Analyze the role of prosecutors and illustrate prosecutorial misconduct.
•Use technology and information resources to research issues in U.S. Courts.
•Write clearly and concisely about issues in U.S. Courts using proper writing mechanics.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Criminal Defense Case Analysis

...Criminal Defense Case Analysis Paper Brandy Alston University of Phoenix Criminal Law CJA/343 Professor Joseph Wade March 1, 2012 Criminal Defense Case Analysis Paper Many individuals are aware of the process that lawyer go through to convict an individual. The prosecution has to prove a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty of a crime, the accused does not have to present evidence for the innocent. The Fifth Amendment is the United States constitution states a defendant is not compelled to under oath criminate themselves, however in most cases the defendant want the chance to prove their innocent in court by having a defense. Criminal law is define as a code, rules, or statute that prohibits the conducts this is prohibit in region or state, federal government. However, when laws results in violations where the individual charged with the crime and haul off to jail. Although once the individual charged, they have the right to defend themselves in court with legal representation. This paper aims to examine and identify the different kind of criminal defense used in a criminal trial. This paper will discuss the two common defenses used in our justice system legal I did it but and factual I did not do it, the defense I did not do it means presumption of innocent and the defense I did it but means guilty with reason. Factual defense is the legal defense offers two group defense excuse and justification that has six categories for them. In......

Words: 1029 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Calling Your Bluff: How Prosecutors and Defense Attorneys Adapt Plea Bargaining Strategies to Increased Formalization

...Calling Your Bluff: How Prosecutors and Defense Attorneys Adapt Plea Bargaining Strategies to Increased Formalization by Deirdre M. Bowen People have long debated whether plea bargaining is the best way to handle felony cases in the justice system. This article focuses on a reformed, institutionalized way to plea bargain. The author researches the King County Prosecutors rationalized approach to the way the Early Plea Unit handles their cases. Ms. Bowen states in her article that all authors reviewed agree that, “plea bargaining under an imbalanced system does not achieve justice, much less arrive at something that resembles empirical or legal truth, institutionalized plea bargaining best resembles the criminal justice system’s desire to create efficiency, calculability, predictability, and control in the processing of defendants, and that reform should work to balance the power between the prosecutors and defense team.” (Bowen) Each reviewed author had a little different way to achieve that balance. Uviller (2004) thinks that the system should resemble at factory type approach. The first stage is the charging stage. The case enters the system and is reviewed for the most obvious, easy to prove, and reasonable charges. It then would move to the adjudication. In this stage the negotiating attorney would attempt to make a deal with defendant in order to get a guilty plea. If a deal cannot be reached, the case would then be transferred to the trial team in......

Words: 1319 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Prosectuion vs Defense

...Prosecution versus Defense William J Brenengen CJS/220 Feb 10, 2012 Harvey Smith Prosecution versus Defense One would hope the time to retain an attorney will never come. Life has a way of throwing things at us, and it’s up to us to be prepared. If the time should happen to come, it helps to know a little about the prosecutor and the defense attorney. A defense attorney is the person who will provide legal representation if you are ever arrested and charged with an offense. Another reason to have a defense attorney would be if your name is ever mentioned or brought up in a lawsuit. The primary role of a good defense attorney is to represent their client and defend them in any type of lawsuit. If you ever get charged with a crime you will be represented by a criminal defense attorney. Crimes range from rape, murder and driving while under the influence. It is the defense attorney’s job to protect your rights and to above all, represent you. “The criminal defense attorney may assist with appeals as well” (Nogara, 2013). When a person’s name is brought up in a lawsuit a civil defense attorney will be representing them. This attorney will again provide all legal representation and offer reasons why you should not be held liable. Their job is to review all the information provided in the case and work with you the defendant to establish a good defense. A prosecutor on the other hand has three major roles to play. The first being the investigation of the......

Words: 572 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethics for Prosecutors and Defense Attorney's

...Ethics for Prosecutors and Defense Attorneys Phillip C. Moore U.S. Courts Professor Shenia C. Kirkland, Esq. January 29, 2013 Ethics has been defined in many ways, but one true definition remains elusive when attempting to obtain a clear and concise meaning of ethics. For this paper, ethics will be defined as rules of conduct in regard to specific actions as administered by a particular group of people; i.e. medical or Christian ethics (Webster, 2012). The purpose of this paper is to address two cases in which the prosecutor and defense attorney violated the Attorney Professional Code of Conduct. This paper will summarize the facts of the case and detail the duties of either the prosecutor or defense attorney; determine which duties were breached and what should have happened to bring them in compliance; and will deduce both the personal and professional ramifications of their actions. The first case to be discussed will be one that the Innocence Project appealed on behalf of Ralph Armstrong in Dane County Wisconsin. Ralph was convicted of the rape and murder of college student Charise Kamps in 1981. For the duration of his twenty eight year incarceration, Ralph maintained he was innocent. An internet search of the trial proceedings and how the jury reached their verdict of guilty in the original trial proved to be a dead end. However, the Innocence Project website and several news agencies provided the information on how the prosecutorial......

Words: 1151 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Prosecutors and Defense Attorneys

... | |Comparison and Contrast of Prosecutors and Defense Attorneys | |[Comparison and Contrast] | | | | |January 27,2013 | |In this paper I am discussing the differences of a Defense Attorney and a Prosecutor | In the court system there are two types of attorneys, the defense attorneys and the prosecutors. The defense attorney is there to prove their client is innocent while the prosecutor is there to make sure that the defendant is found guilty of the charges that he is facing. While the defense attorney is trying to prove the innocence of their client the attorney or attorneys must find errors in a case to try and get a mistrial or try and build up evidence that the defendant was nowhere near the crime at the......

Words: 418 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Defense Paper

...Defense Paper Peyton Rumbo CJS/220 Amanda Eicher 28 July 2013 A prosecutor and a defense attorney are different in a lot of ways. The prosecutor works for the plaintiff and the state's case, and they show the gathered evidence that proves that the person accused of the crime is guilty of committing it. The defense attorney's job is to give evidence that proves that the accused is not guilty. If you are accused of a crime, you will share a table at the trial with the defense attorney. The prosecutor tries to prove your guilt, while the defense attorney does their best to prove that you are innocent. The defense attorney works on their own for you, but the state pays the prosecutor. A person can, and would, hire a defense attorney, but never a prosecutor. Even though public funds are paid to prosecutors, they are not employed by the government. The person who they defend pays the defense attorney – the prosecutor is responsible for representing the government when they bring a suit against an accused criminal. The prosecutor's job title is different in each jurisdiction, but they are often called the district attorney, county attorney, state attorney, city attorney, or United States attorney. The prosecutor is charged by the public with punishing people who commit crimes, so that they can protect law-abiding citizens. The defense attorney has to protect the rights of people who are accused of a crime. If I was to become a lawyer I would definitely want to be the......

Words: 424 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...Rachel Silvia October 2nd, 2013 Professor Karen Bond Engl0096 Attorneys All around the world people are setting in a court house waiting for their turn in court. Many different situations and outcomes from court will be dealt with. All cases that will be heard attorneys of all kind will be needed. Criminal attorneys handle cases that consist of an individual or company that are charges with breaking the law and Civil attorneys handle cases that consist of disagreements of contracts, property, child custody, divorce, and personal and property damages. Criminal lawyers defend a person or company that is charges with breaking the law. Criminal lawyers deal with the issues surrounding the arrest, a criminal investigation, criminal charges, sentencing, appeals and post-trial issues. Criminal lawyers may also help a person before charges have been filed by a prosecuting attorney. A person may hire a defense attorney to help with counsel and representation dealing with the police or other investigators and perform their own investigation, Should there be a violation of a person’s Constitutional right, such as unlawful search and seizure; a defense attorney is used to prepare for a trial. A defense attorney helps with any proposed settlement agreements between the client and prosecutor. A lawyer who specializes in civil law is known as a civil lawyer. Civil law has many fields including business laws, corporate laws, intellectual property laws, family laws,......

Words: 407 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Criminal Defenses

...Criminal Defense Case Analysis Paper Nikisha Rayford CJA/354 February 10, 2014 Gary Weil Criminal Defense Case Analysis Criminal Defenses One of the greatest rights afforded to the America people is the right to be considered innocent until proven guilty in the court of law. It is the job of the prosecutor to prove to the people, to the jury, and to the court that the accused is guilty of a crime. If the prosecutor has a valid case, the accused, either on his or her own or accompanied by a skilled attorney, can present various defenses to argue why they acted in the manner they did. According to Criminal Law Today, “A defense consists of evidence and arguments offered by a defendant and his or her attorneys to show why that person should not be held liable for a criminal charge” (Schmalleger 2010, pg. 114). This paper will discuss various forms of criminal defenses and how they are used in court.  Justification Defense The courts usually require that the prosecutor prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty of a crime, the defense can take an offensive role in their trial by taking an affirmative defense. Instead of sitting back and waiting for the prosecuting attorney to attempt to prove the defendant’s guilt, the defendant can fight back with defenses. The following are types of affirmative defenses: Necessity The defense of necessity claims that the defendant believes it was necessary to......

Words: 908 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...Carter, Romeoville, MI, for Appellant. Wayne Shapiro, M. Anne Hannigan, Law Office of Wayne Shapiro, Chicago, IL, for Appellee. Justice McDADE delivered the judgment of the court and the following opinion: Plaintiff, American Management Consultants LLC, filed a complaint against defendant, Geaniece Carter, pursuant to section 9-209 of the Illinois Code of Civil Procedure (the Code) on forcible entry and detainer (735 ILCS 5/9-209 (West 2006)) seeking past-due rent, utilities, and late charges totaling $1,002.73; possession of apartment 316C in Riverstone Apartments, 308 Woodcreek Drive, Bolingbrook, Illinois; and attorney fees and costs. Following a hearing, the circuit court of Will County entered judgment in favor of plaintiff and awarded it $1,190.62 in unpaid rent for the months of July 2007 and August 2007, including a $35 late charge for August rent; $500 attorney fees; and $203 costs; and it also ordered that defendant turn over possession of the apartment to plaintiff within two weeks. The court denied plaintiff's request for unpaid utilities. For the reasons that follow, we reverse. BACKGROUND The parties entered a 12-month written lease agreement in March 2007 for apartment 316C in plaintiff's apartment complex in Bolingbrook. The lease agreement stated defendant's monthly rent as $675 per month. The agreement also provided that in consideration for entering a 12-month lease, plaintiff granted defendant a deduction of $112 per month from the rent from March 2,......

Words: 924 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Legal Ethic

...History of Ethics: 1908 – Canon of Ethics 1969-70 Model Code 3 parts: 1. ethical considerations → what lawyers should do. 2. disciplinary rules → what lawyers must do. good 3. BAR _______________ acceptable set minimum conduct bad 1983 – Model Rules – most states follow. Set forth rules & comments akin to DR (set forth minimum conduct acceptable) 2000 – Ethics 2000 Commission ▪ California Rules of Professional Conduct – the only state to reject the ABA’s model rules or code. ▪ Ethics are governed by the highest court in the profession, not the legislature ▪ Vast majority of states, state bars (looking to ABA rules, not CA though) come up with the rules. 1. Licensing and Bar Admissions ▪ Regulated by the states. Most jurisdictions have chosen to test as a means of acceptance to the bar. ▪ Residency Requirement: 1. Out of State Residents - May the state discriminate against who gets into the BAR on the basis of residency? No. Supreme Ct v. Piper – woman applied to NH bar, lives 400 yards from NH border & application denied. Piper was admitted despite the state’s claims that non-residents were less likely to be familiar w/ local rules, lawyers not living in NH can’t be trusted, and out of state lawyers are less available for in state proceedings. Rule: State bar cannot discriminate on the basis of residency. 2. Geographical Restriction – some states permit waiver of the bar exam – ex: if...

Words: 17547 - Pages: 71

Premium Essay

Ethics of Undercover Operations

...or the necessity to pursue any corruption vigorously. At the same time, we must recognize that undercover operations directed against lawyers and judges, if inadequately controlled, could have an even more severe impact on the administration of justice than whatever corruption exists. 1 . Monroe H. Freedman is Professor of Law and former Dean of Hofstra University Law School. He has testified on several occasions before the Judiciary Committees of the United States Senate and House of Representatives, and has qualified as an expert witness on lawyers' ethics in federal and state proceedings, serving in one case as an expert on behalf of the United States Department of Justice. He has been chairman of three committees on legal ethics, and a member of the Governing Board of the District of Columbia Bar. He was also Reporter and principal draftsman of the American Lawyers' Code of Conduct, and his book, Lawyers' Ethics in an Adversary System, won the American Bar Association's Gavel Award Certificate of Merit. Professor Freedman also served as legislative consultant to Senator John L. McClellan. 74 The Journal of the Legal Profession I would like to be able to say that undercover operations are unnecessary because the bar is effectively policing lawyers and judges. That is not so. For example, the Code of Professional Responsibility is in force, substantially, in most jurisdictions in the United States. Disciplinary Rule 1-103(A) of that Code requires a......

Words: 7943 - Pages: 32

Free Essay


...Phoenix Material Prosecutors Scenario Ethical Issue: Prosecutors Officers Nixon and Rook decided to arrest the husband for driving under the influence. He is taken to the station for processing. During processing, the husband is visibly agitated. He keeps mumbling to himself and rocking back and forth in his chair. His wife comes to the station and reports that her husband had some bad experiences while in Somalia. She requests that he be allowed to return home with her after processing. The police officers, already at the end of their shift, readily agree. Officer Rook is designated to write the report and deliver it to the prosecutor’s office. P. Ross Acute is the issuing deputy district attorney. He is reviewing this police report to decide whether to file charges against the husband. The report accurately depicts the facts. While he is reviewing the report, Officer Nixon comes into his office. Officer Nixon tells the prosecutor that the police report had been mistakenly dropped off before being signed off by a supervisor, which is required under city policy and procedures. Officer Nixon swaps the previous report for a new report, explaining that the new report was signed off by a supervisor and is more complete. D.D.A. Acute notes that the main difference between the old and new reports is that it states that the officers observed the husband driving and then parking the blue station wagon as the patrol car pulled up at the residence. What should the prosecutor......

Words: 254 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Prosecution Versus Defense

...Prosecution versus Defense University of Phoenix CJS/220 Patricia Brickhouse Lacey Martz December 11, 2011 In many ways, when it comes to comparing defense counsel to prosecution there are several similarities. The role is very different, but they are both considered to defending individuals. The prosecution role is to protect the people, the victims by putting their cases together with the mind frame of keeping justice fair. This is a must, to maintain what we want and need as a civilized society. While protecting the individuals or parties their innocents they must prove the guilty is guilty. Prosecutors can do this by taking a fair chance of embarrassing the individuals just to find the truth, as long as personal feelings do not interfere. Where with the defense attorney, are the ones that protect our rights when we have been accused of an action? They make sure that the legal rights are fair so that the client is not prosecuted unjustly or even falsely tried. Defense attorneys are not well trained for the all the verities of cases that must be hard. When a case is failed the defense attorney takes the chance to open another door to set another date for another hearing or even send the guilty to the death sentence. Each lawyer, the prosecutor and the defense attorney does the same job within our society and that is to protect our people whether they are innocent or guilty. The individuals give our protectors in the court room an opportunity to fight......

Words: 791 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Criminal Defenses

...Criminal Defenses One of the greatest rights afforded to the America people is the right to be considered innocent until proven guilty in the court of law. It is the job of the prosecutor to prove to the people, to the jury, and to the court that the accused is guilty of a crime. If the prosecutor has a valid case, the accused, either on his or her own or accompanied by a skilled attorney, can present various defenses to argue why they acted in the manner they did. Schmalleger (2010, pg. 114) states, “A defense consists of evidence and arguments offered by a defendant and his or her attorney(s) to show why that person should not be held liable for a criminal charge”. This paper will discuss various forms of criminal defenses and how they are used in court. Justification Defense While the courts usually require the prosecutor to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defense is guilty of a crime, the defense can take an offensive role in their trial by taking an affirmative defense. Instead of sitting back and waiting for the prosecuting attorney to attempt to prove the defendants guilt, the defendant can “fight” back with defenses. The following are types of affirmative defenses: Necessity The defense of necessity claims that the defendant believes it was necessary to commit the criminal act in order to prevent or avoid great harm (Schmallege, 2010 pg 116). An interesting case that was upheld as a good defense of necessity was people vs. lovercamp (1974) where......

Words: 1113 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Defense and Prosecuting Attorneys

...trial the Ku Klux Klan shows us and a huge riot starts outside of the court room. The head of the Ku Klux Klan is killed in the riot. Freddie and some others from the Ku Klux Klan start burning crosses throughout the town. One of the crosses that they threw burns down Jake’s house. Luckily he and his family were not at home. Because of the riot and the surge in criminal activity, the National Guard shows up to keep the peace during the rest of the trial. During the trial one of the Ku Klux Klan members is seen following Ellen around. Later that night she is attacked and kidnapped. The bound her to a pole and leave her for dead. She is later rescued and taken to the hospital. She survives. The final day of the trial Jake gives a huge final defense and convinces all of the jury that Carl Lee should be a free man. The crowd outside is completely quite and a little boy comes running out of the court room yelling “Innocent! He is innocent!” The crowd roars in cheers! An ethical dilemma that Carl Lee has is whether or not to kill the men that beat and raped his daughter. He decides to kill them at the beginning of the movie. He decided that if the men got away with their crime and walked the street it wouldn’t be right. He then decided to handle it himself. Carl Lee’s ethical framework was that he believed that the two men would not be held accountable for their actions, so he decided to take the matter in his own hands. The ethical framework did not work out for him because he......

Words: 1394 - Pages: 6