Premium Essay


In: Business and Management

Submitted By hasanali213
Words 895
Pages 4
who deserves a good deal of the credit for it, is a hero of air travel. Last week, writing about the Justice Department's move to block US Airways' planned merger with American Airlines, Mother Jones blogger Kevin Drum highlighted a novel counterargument. Mr Drum says that it is still "an open question whether deregulation was such a boon for the flying public in the first place," and points to a 2012 article by Phillip Longman and Lina Khan.

In that piece, published in the Washington Monthly (where I was once an intern), Mr Longman and Ms Khan argue that airline deregulation has slowly killed mid-sized airports and the cities that depend on them. Here's the thesis:

Over the years, most Americans have adopted a pretty standard line about the results [of airline deregulation]. On the one hand, complaining about the indignities of flying—overbooked, late, or cancelled flights; surly flight attendants; and, more recently, terrible in-flight food service and high fees for checked baggage— has become a staple of American life, much like complaining about Internet providers or health insurance companies. On the other hand, we’ve told ourselves, at least the increased competition has made air travel cheaper. And at least most of us can still get where we need to go by air.But now we find ourselves at a moment when nearly all the promises of the airline deregulators have clearly proved false. If you’re a member of the creative class who rarely does business in the nation’s industrial heartland or visits relatives there, you might not notice the magnitude of economic disruption being caused by lost airline service and skyrocketing fares. But if you are in the business of making and trading stuff beyond derivatives and concepts, you probably have to go to places like Cincinnati, Pittsburgh, Memphis, St. Louis, or Minneapolis, and you know firsthand how hard it has become…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Deregulation of Trading Hours

...has deregulation resulted in 24-hour, seven days a week trading for most retailers in these jurisdictions. 282 AUSTRALIAN RETAIL INDUSTRY As the SDA points out, in a deregulated environment some retailers may choose to trade less, rather than more: It is significant to note that in some areas where trading hours restrictions were removed and retailers responded by extending their opening hours, they are now actually cutting back on their hours of trade. … Where trading hours have been liberalised, many employers, especially in the discretionary spend areas, do not utilise all of the opening hours available to them. (sub. 18, p. 5) The absence of trading hours restrictions does generally imply more flexibility and greater variability in opening hours, as retailers more closely align their opening hours with consumer demand: retailers open when there is demand for the products they sell. In essence, the Australian experience suggests deregulating shop trading hours is not about operating 24 hours a day, seven days a week but simply being able to open to meet the needs of consumers, at times when the retail outlet can also trade profitably. But as discussed in chapter 11, some retailers have expressed concerns (albeit disputed by the SDA) that with the penalty rate regime associated with the new harmonised award, they will not be able to trade profitably at all the times demanded by consumers. Hence the actual hours that a retailer opens following deregulation may......

Words: 15543 - Pages: 63

Free Essay

Airline Deregulation

...Administration. (FAA) Before deregulation, innovation and change by the airline industry was smothered. It took years for airlines to petition and the CAB to approve new routes. Rates were strictly controlled. It was virtually impossible for new airlines to enter the market. Since deregulation airlines are cheaper to fly, safer, while at the same time the number of passenger miles has dramatically increased. A few facts are illuminating. Price Reductions The average fare per passenger mile is about 9% lower since deregulation. Crandall and Ellig [1] report savings of $19.4 billion per year for consumers. Contrary to conventional wisdom, the Government Accounting Office (GAO) [2] reports that, ``The average fare per passenger mile, adjusted for inflation, has fallen since deregulation about as much at airports serving small and medium-sized communities as it has at airports serving large communities.'' The theoretical possibility that deregulation would be a boon to major markets at the expense of smaller communities has proven ill founded. Improved Service Quantity Reductions in fares spurred middle class families, previously priced out of the air flight market, to fly. In 1997 airlines flew 5.7 billion miles compared to 2.5 billion in 1978. This improved service was not limited to large markets. The GAO reports that, ``The quantity of air service, as measured by the number of both departures and available seats, has increased since deregulation for all three airport......

Words: 525 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Effect of Deregulation on Airline Industry

...Since deregulation, the number of low cost carriers (also known as LCCs) has steadily increased to a point in which they have become a major component in the air transportation industry. There are many attributes that make a carrier a low cost carrier and allows them to operate cheaply and efficiently. Two important ones are having employees working multiple roles and fast turnaround times. With employees working multiple roles, there is less of a need for specialized staff and training. If a flight attendant can also work as the cleaning crew, there is not a need for two different employees on the company payroll. This consolidation leads to greater efficiency and lowered cost to the company. Indirectly these multi-purpose employees also contribute to faster turnaround times. In the example of flight attendants that also assist in cleaning the cabin, at the end of a flight, instead of having the flight attendants get off the aircraft have the cleaning crew come and clean, the present staff can do the task reducing time on the ground. Like in many businesses, airlines equate time to money. The more time an aircraft is on the ground the less money these carriers are going to make. Faster turnarounds means more legs are able to be flown in a day and a better perception of customer service (because customers are not sitting around waiting to board). One article that looks closely at Southwest Airlines (a now popular low cost carrier) reported that Southwest airlines has “the...

Words: 331 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Transportation Deregulation

...Dean A DeFrank Transportation Principles Embry Riddle University Module Two Deregulation All modes of travel have experienced great changes through the years. Those changes were the government getting out of the travel management business and allowing the free market to determine the course of these modes of travel. The following will describe in simplistic form the effects of deregulation on each mode of travel. Airline Deregulation: The Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 removed government control over fares, routes and creation of new airlines. The Civil Aeronautics Board (the governing body on airlines during regulation) powers of regulation were removed thus allowing the industry to be exposed to market forces. The Act, however, did not remove or diminish the regulatory powers of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) over all aspects of air safety. Airline deregulation has enabled more competitive pricing and increased carrier flexibility. Prior to deregulation, airline pricing was regulated by the Civil Aeronautics Board. Additionally, air routes were also controlled tightly. With more freedom, carriers can offer more effective options to those who wish to use airfreight as a means of shipment. Railway deregulation: Railroad Revitalization and Regulatory Reform Act of 1976 eased regulations on rates, line abandonment, and mergers. Four years later, Congress followed up with the Staggers Rail Act of 1980. The most important features of the Staggers......

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Impact of Deregulation on the Airline Industry

...The Impact of Deregulation on the Airline Industry The aviation industry in the United States was facing several problems such as falling productivity, high inflation, rising labor costs, higher fuel costs and low economic growth. These problems led to the deregulation of the airline industry in 1978 with the Airline Deregulation Act that removed the various controls that influenced the decision power of the companies. The deregulation lasted about three years and the main objective was to increase competition between airline carriers and lower service prices. The deregulation began with the easing of tariffs and liberalization of routes. During the regulations, customers paid high rates and hadn’t many options because there weren’t many airlines companies. After the deregulation, increased competition, new companies have emerged due to lowering barriers entry of new airlines industries and the price decreased. In this competitive environment, the company has increased its investments in quality and marketing as well as the efficient use of its fleet in order to attract more consumers. Also, the cost control has become a major factor in the management of airlines. However, the rapid growth of the airline industry has triggered some problems like congestion at some airports, travel delays and low runway capacity especially during peak hours of travel. These problems are caused due to increased demand and the lack of investment in some airports. The opening of foreign......

Words: 1307 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Has Banking Deregulation Contributed to the Current Economic Crisis and If so How? Can Advertising (or) Marketing (or) Public Relations Help Restore Trust in the Banks?

...Has banking deregulation contributed to the current economic crisis and if so how? Can advertising (or) marketing (or) public relations help restore trust in the banks? Most of the world has been affected by what has been called the global recession. Banking deregulation is undeniably the main cause of the financial crisis. This essay is going to demonstrate why this is by covering key events, which have lead to the crisis, and highlighting some possible marketing solutions to the trust issue that has resulted from it. The Great Depression in the 1930s provoked the US government to introduce new regulations in order to reform banks and ensure that there would never be another crisis of its type again. These reforms came under the name of the banking act of 1933, commonly referred to as the Glass-Steagle act. Crucially most of the new laws meant that retail and investment banks were to be kept separate and investments could not be made if a return was unlikely. However, over 50 years later these laws became more relaxed as the banks were always pushing to be privatized, as they knew they would be able to make more money (Robert Weissman, 2009). It was then believed that the financial world had changed so much since the Great Depression that the regulatory rules were outdated and that the banks would be able to manage themselves, the decision was also influenced by $300 million of lobbying (PBS, 2003). The Glass-Steagle act was revoked in 1999 by president Clinton, this......

Words: 1538 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

U.S. Airline Industry Regulation

...development, with every stage it has its own pros and cons, the stages of development I will discuss are the regulation, deregulation, and re-regulation stages in the aviation industry. The airlines industry during the regulation era, Civil Aeronautics Board was created and had the power to price tickets and the the routes airlines flew, with the goal of serving the public interest. The main factor driving to those pros were the limited markets served, limited competition on routes, high ticket prices, and limited city-pair frequency.(Wensveen). The issues with aviation industry regulation is putting the industry in the hands of lawmakers with no experience in the business is a risk. That will cause higher costs and higher prices, because it reduces all competitor to the level of the least efficient company. Government regulations increased taxes on the airlines which resulted in reduced airline services. In a deregulated environment, government controls like entry and price restrictions for air carriers are removed allowing airlines to serve any given route and freely compete with other carriers.(Wensveen). The deregulation move realized that a politically controlled economy served no continuing public interest. Many benefits for the airlines happened after the deregulation act. Low-cost carriers challenged the legacy carriers in the airline industry. After deregulation, airlines reconfigured their routes and equipment, making possible improvements in capacity......

Words: 589 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Voip – Deregulation Versus Anti-Competitive Conduct

...Introduction This paper will focus on Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and the deregulation versus anti-competitive conduct. In Section I we will discuss the history of VoIP and how it has developed into a standard communication device using traditional telephone lines and tech savvy software. This will be an overview of what the primary intentions for inventing the software and who the pioneers were that patented and launched this successful tangible apparatus, which is used by over 6 million in the United States and an undefined number throughout the world. Section II is a thorough analysis of economic implications for two popular VoIP services companies in the United States: Skype, Internet based software free to users who have a personal computer and Comcast, a telecommunications corporation that has become the leader in offering bundled services that includes VoIP. The discussion will revolve around the issue of regulation and deregulation of the service and the economic impact that it has on consumers and today’s market. Sections III & IV are a detailed comparison and contrast of the regulation and deregulation for the United States versus India, Canada and the Philippines and the affects of VoIP from an economic standpoint. This will be an analysis of the proponents and oppositions of regulation competitive value and how regulation is allowing states to make decisions and maintain control over VoIP. Section V is the conclusion that will......

Words: 4392 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Effect of Deregulation of Pol Products

...among the people. In the run-up to complete deregulation, there are instances of increase in the domestic price of POL products that are proportionately more than the rise in their international prices. In the most recent instance (of 13th September, 2012), the diesel price was raised by Rs.5 per litre at one go, even without any rise in international prices. These steps are being taken to eliminate the government subsidy on these products in a step-by-step manner. Deregulation of the POL sector is bound to eliminate the direct or indirect subsidies completely. And reduction in subsidy, according to the government, is the need of the hour in order to reduce the fiscal deficit as proportion to GDP. Deregulation is also necessitated in the current neo-liberal environment because if the government keeps subsidizing the public sector owned oil marketing companies (OMCs) like Indian Oil, Hindustan Petroleum and Bharat Petroleum, then the private companies like Reliance and others would not get a ‘level playing field’ and they would not be able to compete in price. In this way, the present subsidy regime indirectly restricts the private players from entering the oil marketing sector. Hence, if the priorities of the government in power are the reduction of subsidies and ensuring a ‘level playing field’ for private players rather than containing inflation and generating employment and growth, it would opt for a policy of deregulation. “A market-determined pricing system for......

Words: 3693 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Airline Deragulation

...Interamerican University of Puerto Rico School of Aeronautics Airline Deregulation a Failure Jose Manuel Lopez Team 4 AWCS 2000 Prof. Ocasio Airline deregulation is a failure while the commercial airliner industry has sky rocketed in safety, lower fares. But the industry itself has seen many companies merge and this has made the top 5 airline companies have more power in the market than before the 1978 Airline deregulation act. If we look at them now their control in the market is at an 80% with normal traffic fares and the International fares all together. This make it so the top 5 airline companies have more control than they did before giving these airlines more control of routes and this created a series of unforeseen problems at the time the high congestion of air traffic, delays of flights, overcrowded airports that made the airports targets for terrorist attacks which made air travel more difficult, how this would affect the workers of these companies in making, and customer unsatisfactory, and “The limited Reemergence of monopoly power” stated by Alfred E. Khan Professor of Political Economy, at University of Cornwell, and former economic advisor to President Carter and chairman of the Civil Aeronautics Board. Airline deregulation while it blossomed in some areas it started to create a growing problem where companies started to exclude competition and this would create an industry that more and more airlines would have to merge with the bigger companies...

Words: 325 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Journey from Deregulation to Regulation

...The Journey From Deregulation to Regulation - Are We Walking In Circles? Executive Summary This paper attempts to explore the cycle from deregulation to regulation against the backdrop of events from 2001 to 2008, with some reference to later laws such as Dodd-Frank. The context is against the quote from Aristotle that “law is order, and good law is good order”. A Brief history of Deregulation: Regulations have been considered a blessing and a curse since time immemorial. It could be argued, especially with those of a theological mindset, that religions introduced the first forms of regulations. The penalty for deviations were well laid out, and often times had precedent, but exceptions were always sought and loopholes were often explored. Modern economics, regardless of which school of thought is followed, can be compared to a religion1. There are tenets, or commandments. There are different religions, from Keynes, to Marx to Milton. Without extending this analogy, it is relevant to point out that economic theories either rely on governments to participate wholeheartedly in the state of economic affairs by regulating businesses, corporations and industries, or to let the system weed out the weaker in favor of the stronger. In the United States, bitter past experience shaped the regulations surrounding businesses. The Great Depression was the first indicator that the system needed to be made more robust, which in turn led to regulations that formed the base of what our......

Words: 3982 - Pages: 16

Free Essay


...Codi Feuerzeig  Economics 104  Professor Robert Pollin  TA: Evelyn Kwakye  May 7, 2015     Deregulation       During the 1970s and 1980s the United States government went through a period of  deregulation.   Deregulation is a reduction of government involvement and control within an  industry.  Did this deregulation lead to the 2008 financial crisis?  This is a hot button topic that is  highly debated and causes a great deal of controversy.  The financial crisis of 2008, known as the  Great Recession, impacted the entire country and practically every individual citizen.  Many  politicians, such as Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, look for an easy blame or a scapegoat,  for example, the deregulation by the Bush Administration.  Pelosi has been quoted saying ​ "​ the  Bush Administration's eight long years of failed deregulation policies have resulted in our  nation's largest bailout ever, leaving the American taxpayers on the hook potentially for billions  of dollars" (Gattuso).​   The issue with that statement is that the economic deregulation she speaks  of did not take place during the Bush Administration, but many years prior and the laws of that  time are not controversial in today’s economic situation.  Rather more recent regulatory laws are  to blame for the financial crisis of 2008.      Why did we Regulate in the First Place?    The Great Depression is unopposed when it comes to economic downfalls in the United  States.  The financial h...

Words: 1874 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Regulation and Deregulation of the Financial Industry

...In recent months and years, there has been much debate about regulation of industries and markets.  Especially in financial markets, this is an issue that has come up after the collapse of the housing, financial, and financial derivatives market last year.  Take the financial industry and imagine being a manager of a bank, insurance company or investment fund.  What are the main reasons in favor and against regulating this industry?  What are the economic benefits and dis-benefits of either approach?  What are the micro vs. the macro considerations of selecting an approach of governmental oversight and monitoring?  How much regulation do you favor in this industry?  What are your personal views on this matter? The importance of good regulation in the financial sector is necessary as 1. Companies can seek capital in the markets confidently to get on doing business without paying a significant market risk premium 2. The businesses of financial industry may operate profitably and efficiently and across the borders, while treating customers honestly and fairly. 3. All market participants can start understanding their obligations. 4. The consumers and investors participation can be in confident manner by taking use of trustworthy and reliable information to make decisions. The disadvantages of regulation would be 1. The customers would be affected negatively because of higher transaction costs due to requirements of clearing and reporting. 2. The......

Words: 322 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...hunted down the legal loopholes in California and took advantage of its new deregulating market. Deregulation As a disciple for deregulation, Ken Lay convinced government to loose limited in energy market. Also, Enron was established by deregulation helping. Actually, economic deregulation started at 1970s including transportation, financial, energy and communications industries. Apparently, to liberate business from the government’s regulation increase more opportunities and profits (Winston, 1998). In the case of California’s electricity crisis, Enron exploited gap from energy deregulation to make money and lead another energy company bankruptcy. Sarbanes–Oxley Act of 2002  After a series of corporate and accounting scandals such as Enron, WorldCom and Adelphia are on the surface. American government had to be confronted with losing popular confidence and shocking securities market. Therefore, “An Act to protect investors by improving the accuracy and reliability of corporate disclosure made pursuant to the securities laws, and for other purposes.” was enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled. Obviously, Enron’s scandal not only reflected its own corporate culture, but also related to country’s latent dangers. The damages are made by Enron didn’t disappear within its gone. Regulation or Deregulation still needs to find a balance way to apply. People who suffered from Enron’s actions......

Words: 592 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How Did the Deregulation of Air Transportation in Europe Foster Entrepreneurial Behavior and Innovation in the European Airline Industry over the Last Twenty Years

...How did the deregulation of air transportation in Europe foster entrepreneurial behavior and innovation in the European airline industry over the last twenty years? Case studies: SAS Airline & Ryanair Master Thesis in Entrepreneurship and Dynamic Business Contexts Spring 2007 Supervisor: Håkan Bohman Entrepreneurship Master Program Authors: Gilles Helterlin and Nuno Ramalho Acknowledgements We would like to express our gratitude to all who have contributed to the realization of this Master Thesis. A warm thank to our supervisor, Håkan Bohman from USBE (Umeå School of Business), for his guidance, his precious help and his advises during the last months. To Mr. Lundvall, from LFV (Luftfartsverket), Mr. Valinger from Scandinavian Airline and Mr. Wilsberg from SAS Braathens, Jessica Eriksson and Thomas Pettersson from USBE, thank you for your availability, willingness in answering our questions and for their so precious collaboration with interviews, comments and suggestions. Thank you also Sweden for the wonderful moments we have spent here. We will never forget your nature (your elks), your cold winter (-30°C), your long nights in winter and your short nights in late spring!! It has been a great experience and adventure up there in Northern Sweden!! We will miss you… Finally we would like to thank particularly the Studentexpedition for its kindness, without forgetting our family and friends (from Sweden, France, Portugal and Greece) for their everlasting daily......

Words: 79741 - Pages: 319