Free Essay

Conformity: a Concealed Identity

In: English and Literature

Submitted By mlcsweetie143
Words 1367
Pages 6
Andrea Marshall
Kim Palmore
English 1B
30 May 2012
Conformity: A Concealed Identity
Society is made up of predominately heterosexual people. Our instincts tell us in order to repopulate the world; a man and a woman must reproduce offspring. This is considered to be a social norm; mankind’s very survival depends on it. More recently, society has given people the ability to express themselves in ways they never thought possible. The American Gay Rights Movement in 1924 sparked animosity throughout the nation creating discrimination toward the gay community. This movement brought about significant change; unfortunately, not all people were willing to accept it. People’s resistance to change is usually based on ignorance or the desire to conform in an attempt to avoid becoming an outcast. In the novel, Stone Butch Blues, written by Leslie Feinberg, Jess Goldberg becomes an outcast because of her resistance to conformity. Since Jess was brought up in a straight environment, she grew up confused, without the understanding of her true nature. Her parents rejected her differences due to the fact that they were so focused on society’s view of the social norm. Having no one to confide in, Jess was forced to set out on her own to find people she could connect with and help her to explore identity. This book demonstrates both society’s demand for conformity and the pressures that queer people face in an unjust world; Jess’ success in battling this social pressure inspires people to fight against discrimination and to ensure their pursuit of happiness.
At a very early age, Jess noticed that she stood apart from many of her peers. She desired to indulge in young boys’ fashions and rigorous activities. Her sister, on the other hand, conformed to wearing dresses and participating in more feminine interests. At first, Jess’ parents accepted her behavior, while under the assumption that it was a phase. As time went on, Jess began to attract attention causing her parents a great deal of embarrassment. “I’m sick of people asking me if she’s a boy or a girl…Everywhere I take her, people ask me” (Feinberg, 19). Her parents then began enforcing their conformed beliefs and demanded that Jess act as a lady. Her father insisted, “Young lady, I spent $4.90 for this Annie Oakley outfit and you’re going to wear it” (19). Contrarily, Jess began trying on her father’s clothes, and after being caught, her parents became desperate and admitted her to a psychiatric hospital.
At the age of eleven, Jess felt extremely scared and alone. She felt that her parents had abandoned her and that she had become an alien to society. While in the hospital, her discovery of a library of poems changed her forever. These poems had been left by previous queer patients, which instantly gave her a sense of belonging. Jess finally had discovered that she was not alone. She knew that what her parents were doing was wrong.
“I didn’t care anymore if my parents didn’t love me. I had accepted that fact in the three weeks I’d survived alone in this hospital. But now I didn’t care. I hated them. And I didn’t trust them. I didn’t trust anyone. My mind was focused on escape. I wanted to get out of this place and run away from home” (22).
After receiving three weeks of treatment, she returned home harboring ill will and resentment toward her parents. As soon as she came home from the hospital, Jess’ parents threw her into charm school, hoping things would turn around; it turned out, it had the opposite effect. “Charm school taught me once and for all that I wasn’t pretty, wasn’t feminine, and would never be graceful” (23). She returned to school, only to be tormented, raped, and stripped of her dignity. This caused a lot of emotional turmoil for Jess. Being rejected from her parents and having no one to turn to caused her to suppress her emotions. At the age of sixteen, she dropped out of school and ran away from home in search of people who understood her and who truly cared for her.
In the 1960s, queers were not widely accepted in society. They faced ridicule, discrimination and abuse. People had not yet accepted the fact that some people desired same-sex relationships; these types of relationships were unheard of. Much of this was due to religious beliefs and the social norm. Now that Jess was on her own she not only had worry about protecting her identity, she had to worry about survival. Since she was not properly educated, she was forced to take a low end job. Because of this, she was not exposed to people with ambition and stability; instead her role models were people with little to no education. Because of society’s inability to accept Jess for who she really was, this ultimately resulted in less opportunity for her. She had been denied the chance at a good education and a solid career.
The beliefs in the 1960s caused a lot of pressure for Jess. It made it hard for her to express her true identity. She soon found a community of queers that she felt she could trust. She portrayed herself as an experienced butch in order to fit in and be respected. Once she surrounded herself in the gay community, she had to deal with much oppression and abuse from authority figures. Cops would bust the local gay bars and arrested both femmes and butches. Cops would use physical and sexual abuse on these innocent queers, as if they had been criminals. “There are times, the old bulls told me, when it’s best to take your beating and hope the cops will leave you on the ground when they’re done with you. Other times your life may be in danger, or your sanity, and it’s worth it to try to fight back. It’s a tough call” (56). This maddening abuse of authority portrays the misconception that society has towards the gay community. After suffering through so much torment and maltreatment, Jess was determined to make a difference and ensure that queer people were acknowledged and given the same liberties as all others.
In the end, Jess is finally able to present herself in front hundreds of people. After battling years of social pressure, oppression, and violence, she is able to stand up for herself and represent the gay community. At a Lesbian-Gay rally in the streets of New York, she speaks to hundreds of people about her experience. “I’m a butch, a he-she…there’s a lot of us on the outside and we don’t want to be. We are getting busted and beaten up… I don’t know what it would take to change the world. But couldn’t we get together and try to figure it out?” (296). The audience responded with applauds and cheers, affirming their encouragement and support. This event signifies Jess’ impact in society and portrays how one person’s life can make a difference.
Some people may argue that conforming to society is more beneficial than being able to express your true identity. Society has revered the classic relationships between men and women for generations. To take a stand against it, results in severe costs. Those who choose to protest conformity suffer rejection and persecution. Jess’ parents, for example, must have wanted to spare Jess from such heartache. Although Jess’ parents may have had good intentions, they ultimately hindered her from expressing herself; this would eventually prohibit her from the opportunity to find self-worth.
In conclusion, Stone Butch Blues shows the many struggles and social pressures that queers are constantly faced with today. They are subjected to a bias society where conformity is expected. They encounter discrimination and are denied the liberty that they deserve. The speech that Jess makes at the rally inspired many people of the gay community to stand up for their beliefs and to protect their rights to pursue happiness. Jess’ resistance to conform shows how one person’s stand can make a difference, and her story provides inspiration for all people to fight against injustice.

Works Cited
Feinberg, Leslie. Stone Butch Blues. Alyson Books: Los Angles, 1993.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Conformity

...According to Leon Mann, conformity means "yielding to group pressures". Everyone is a member of one group oranother and everyone expects members of these groups to behave in certain ways. If you are a member of an identifiable group you are expected to behave appropriately to it. If you don"t confirm and behave appropriately you are likely to be rejected by the group. Like stereotypes, conforming and expecting others to conform maintains cognitive balance. There are several kinds of conformity. Many studies of conformity took place in the 1950"s which led Kelman to distinguish between compliance, internalisation and identification. Compliance is the type of conformity where the subject goes along with the group view, but privately disagrees with it. Internalisation is where the subject comes to accept, and eventually believes in the group view. Identification is where the subject accepts and believes the group view, because he or she wants to become associated with the group. Leon Mann identifies normative conformity which occurs when direct group pressure forces the individual to yield under the threat of rejection or the promise of reward. This can occur only if someone wants to be a member of the group or the groups attitudes or behaviour are important to the individual in some way. Apart from normative conformity there is informational conformity which occurs where the situation is vague or ambiguous and because the person is uncertain he......

Words: 1378 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Conformity Essay

...Summary on Conformity, Defiance, and Crime In the book Essentials of Sociology in the 6th chapter tells us what conformity, defiance, and crime are, among other things of that nature. Conformity is falling in line with what the given rules and normal behavior society accepts. Defiance is exactly the opposite, its defined by the book as “nonconformity to a given set of norms that are accepted.” So doing anything most people in that culture wouldn’t see normal. It’s a very broad subject. Anything from wearing a long sleeve shirt in the middle of the summer to a murder can be seen as deviant behavior. Edwin Lemert told us that he viewed the first act of deviance as primary deviance; this is the one act that gives the individual the label as a deviant. Then there was secondary deviance in which the individual accepts the label of deviant and starts to relapse committing these deviant acts, the acts progressively getting worse. Sometimes groups do these deviant acts together, this is called a deviant subculture. These form when there is a group of people whom all have the same values and practices, just something’s they do are seen as deviant. If that’s not clear an example of this would be the Heavens’ Gates Cult, who believed the world was doomed and the only way to survive was to commit suicide and have your soul saved by a UFO. Most people reading this would find that very odd and not normal to believe, well that makes then deviants and since they’re a group it’s a deviant......

Words: 2106 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Concealed or Not

...Concealed weapons in the workplace have been a legal issue in the business field for quite some time. Citizens shouldn't be permitted to carry a concealed weapon to their workplace because this would cause more danger than it would protection in the workplace. Besides the dangers it will cause, on the civilian side there are also liability issues that have arisen concerning employee rights and workplace safety. There are laws passed at both the state and federal levels that allow United States citizens to carry concealed weapons as long as they retain a permit to do so. However, many businesses do not allow their employees to carry weapons on their persons, in their vehicles, or in their offices. The purpose of this paper is to state why citizens should not be allowed to carry concealed weapons in their workplace, the regulations that allow both employees to obtain weapons at work and the laws that refrain them from doing so. A common issue with concealed carry permit holders is deciding whether or not you can/should carry your gun at work. One’s place of employment is typically one of the top 3 places where you spend your time. There are also many issues that can affect other people’s decisions to turn violent (money issues can lead to desperation or anger in some people and situations). While the issue is extremely complex, you can usually boil the issue down to three factors. Does the law allow you to carry at work? The law usually leaves that decision up to the employer...

Words: 1621 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Influences of Conformity and Obedience Paper

...Conformity and Obedience Psych/555 May 11, 2013 Dr. Anthony Conformity and Obedience Humans are known as social animals as they live life together while forming a variety of groups and try to improve their relationship within groups. Interaction with others is a natural consequence of residing in society. During this process the interaction of society and its rules has social implications of each. If the people face no social impact, like peer pressure, a large portion of them to demonstrate compliance by modifying their behavior, thoughts, decisions, as expected. This paper will discuss the issues of conformity & obedience. Compare and contrast the concepts of conformity and obedience. Conformity is well observed when people are in groups, which exerts pressure in their lives on things they do not normally do in their routine life. When an individual is compatible with group of self, it presents the devotion of the individual to group norms. Gender, culture, personality & other factors have great influence on how individual recover in a group (Fiske, 2010). Conformity has a wide impact, as it refer to people who have a common behavior with peers, and these people are thought to help some social rights to their behavior. In groups, people also believe that correspond to group as their behavior is often inspired by the principal group members. (Martin & Bull, 2008). The chances of people who responded, can only be determined when they are all alone, experience......

Words: 1789 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Concealed Weapons

...Concealed weapons in the workplace have been a legal issue in the business field for quite some time. Besides the dangers it will cause, on the cilivain side there are also liability issues that have arisen concerning employee rights and workplace safety. There are laws passed at both the state and federal levels that allow United States citizens to carry concealed weapons as long as they retain a permit to do so. However, many businesses do not allow their employees to carry weapons on their persons, in their vehicles, or in their offices. The purpose of this paper is to state why citizens should not be allowed to carry concealed weapons in their workplace, the regulations that allow both employees to obtain weapons at work and the laws that refrain them from doing so. The majority of the research was gathered from secondary sources mainly articles on the Strayer campus site ,elibrary and the internet. There are many states in the United States that have enacted laws to allow their citizens to carry concealed weapons in public but not in the workplace. However, the employer may not prohibit the employee from carrying a concealed weapon in the employee’s own motor vehicle, even when the motor vehicle is driven or parked on the employer’s property or while the vehicle is used in the course of employment. For employers who choose not to prohibit their employees from carrying concealed weapons, the law includes a provision granting immunity to the employer for liability arising......

Words: 964 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Conformity

...Research Report Conformity due to Social Pressure _________________________________ ABSTRACT- Social influences can be a strong cause in conformity. The more people doing a particular thing, the harder it is for more people not to conform. This study explored whether more people would turn another direction if there were only one person facing that other direction and if there were three people facing that other direction. _________________________________ The hypothesis that my group and I tested was that if three or more people were faced another direction in an elevator rather than one person turned a different direction that they were more likely to conform. The independent variable in this experiment would be the control groups of one or three people standing in the elevator that were in on the experiment and the dependent variable would be the people in the elevator conforming due to the independent variable. I think the independent variable (one or three people) will influence the dependent variable (people conforming) by people conforming more to the group of three people rather than the group of one person because there is more social group pressure to conform to more and more people doing it. Experiments have shown that the most people will conform in an experiment with 3-5 people doing it and usually levels off around 10 people. Sometimes in an experiment unanimity will happen where one brave person will resist to the group pressure and if that......

Words: 1877 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Conformity

...Jeffrey Joseph Adam Levy Social Psychology 31 January 2014 Conformity: Do We Really Have A Choice? It’s Wednesday night. A Duke basketball game is on. I’m sitting on the couch, surrounded by my old roommates, watching the game. Dylan is the only one among us who is a Duke “fan”, but there is nothing else to do on a Wednesday night. The question came up. It always does. Someone asks Dylan, “Why are you a Duke fan? You don’t live anywhere near Duke.” Dylan, upon hearing the question, quickly and defensively answers, “uh…my family always liked them.” No one says anything and we continue to watch and give our critique on the game. I barely paid attention to his answer. I wasn’t interested. I already knew what he was going to say. How did I know what he was going to say? Did I just know him that well? Well, that’s a little bit of the reason, but mainly I knew because there is such a cliché response to that particular question that it is almost automatic. See, there’s this unwritten rule in society that you have to live physically near a sports team to be able to appreciate them and call yourself a true fan. I know, it makes no sense, but since when did society have to make sense? The point is that unless you live close to the team, it’s your alma mater, you or one of your relatives played or does play on the team, you lose all credibility as being a “true fan.” So, Dylan, not having met any of these criteria, took the cliché escape root…the only “get out of jail free” card.......

Words: 695 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Conformity

...Conformity as it pertains to the Military Baker College 1.0 Introduction Conformity is the practice of involving attitudes, opinions and behavioral characteristics that are applicable to a specific group, in this context the military. It entails the application of these norms to match the culture embedded in the military society. The conduction of such habitual traits assumes the control by the environment and social stimuli. These stimuli manipulate the way in which the military society conditions its performances. The military not only practice conformity in their society, but also to the general public. Conformity pertinence in the military acts a guide to military sociology by enforcing their obedience to the governments in which they serve and to how their conduct their training and operations in their role of ensuring international security of global territories. Conformity is instilled into soldiers in the advent of their recruitment in the forces and the control of their social relations in the military society. 2.0 Indoctrination Process The indoctrination process involves the inculcation of ideologies and attitudes towards a certain notion to change a person’s behavioral characteristics. In the military context, soldiers are stripped their previous personalities and develop new personalities by internalizing new values. Several techniques are applied during the indoctrination process in relation to the social......

Words: 1882 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Legalizing Concealed Weapons

...Jasmine Anthony Mrs. Kenney English 112 April 29, 2014 Legalizing Concealed Weapons: Research Synthesis Many times people confuse whether or not allowing gun laws actually reduces the crime rate. As gun rights is a natural born right of citizens, some believe that should be banned, and many others believe that the law should be extended to lawful citizens. Based on my own experiences there have been several instances where I wish a legalized weapon was in arms reach. There was an instance about 7 years ago where my little brother and I were the only two in the house and an intruder broke in while we were there. No one was hurt or injured but it was traumatic for two children as it happened right after my mom had went to work. I would have felt more secure and confident if I was to know that a legalized weapon was around for our protection. Through research, why concealed carry laws should be implied into every state's legislation will be debated and each point of view will be expressed. As this topic applies to everyone, every citizen should have the opportunity to exercise their rights. Many people are victims to crimes that they could have gotten away from. How many rape cases could have been avoided? How many school shootings could have been prevented before the shooting began? All of the latter mentioned cases are incidents that could significantly reduce our crime rate if concealed carry laws were in effect in every state. Also included in this essay will be a......

Words: 5643 - Pages: 23

Free Essay

Pressure of Conformity

...Anissa Nehls The Pressure of Conformity Throughout history, society's conception of women and their attributed behavior has changed quite frequently. Popular culture enforces idealistic views, pressuring girls to conform into stereotyped portrayals of the female gender. Seduced by these commonly approved ideals of beauty, many adolescents struggle to fit in with the "cool crowd". Mentally tormented by loss or confusion of personal identity, female teenagers strongly desire the feeling of belonging to a certain group of friends. This usually harmless concept of peer pressure can lead to a teenagers demise, by ultimately including hazardous actions, such as drug and alcohol misuse, teen sex, and even criminal conduct. This dangerous clash of adolescent inexperience and youthful yearning for adventure and danger is portrayed in the two teen movie "Thirteen" and "Mean Girls". Cady and Tracy, the protagonists from these socially critiquing movies, both deteriorate to the prevalent teen royalties, hence destroying relationships with true friends and family. Thirteen year old Tracy is an exceptional student, gets along with her family and has never been in any sort of trouble before. Although living a fulfilled life, the young girl desires to be friends with Evie, one of the cool girls at school. The urge to fit in and to experience the exhilarating lifestyle Evie seems to lead, Tracy blindly follows and familiarizes with boys, alcohol and even drugs. All these......

Words: 992 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Conformity

...Outline and evaluate explanations of conformity. (12 marks) Normative social influence says people conform because they feel they need to be accepted and belong to the group. They accept the majorities’ views publicly, but privately they disagree – this type of conformity is compliance. The majority control the other group members, and use the fear of rejection to get others to conform. This is because humans are a social species and need companionship and are afraid of rejection. Research to support this explanation comes from Asch’s experiment, where participants knew the group was wrong privately but chose to conform in order to be accepted. This suggests that normative social influence is a valid theory of why people conform as it states we conform to be part of a social group, not because they believe the group to be right. On the other hand, in real life they aren’t part of that social group so don’t fear rejection, so factors other than the group may influence conformity. Another explanation of why people conform is informational social influence, where the individual changes their opinion both publicly and privately, which is described as internalisation. They do this as they believe the group are right. Conformity tends to increase when the situation is ambiguous, in matters of crisis or if they feel others are better qualified to make decisions. Fein et al found that participant’s opinions of political candidates in a debate were influenced by the......

Words: 488 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Concealed Campus

...4 December 2015 Fostering a Concealed Campus In 2007 during the Virginia Tech Shooting, a boy’s best-friend’s brother was there, in one of the classrooms that the gunman targeted. He escaped but this information gave him chills. That boy’s name is Jeff. Why is it that issues don’t matter until a horrifying story has a personal connection to its readers that it causes them to fully gasp the situation? There are many alternatives to students carrying weapons on campus. Advocates for guns on campus say that it will make the environment safer, but in reality only the students and faculty can make a campus safer. If someone sees something, they should say something. Responsibility is the first method of defense, not guns. There are over 4,400 colleges and universities in the United States, the majority of these do not allow students or faculty to carry guns on campus. The states that allow students and faculty to carry firearms on college property are Arkansas, Colorado, Kansas, Mississippi, Oregon, Utah and Wisconsin. Only Utah and Colorado have explicit laws about allowing concealed firearms on campus, but leave the ultimate decision up to schools to decide whether to allow guns on campus or not. Twenty other states allow schools to decide on allowing guns of any type on campus. This leaves students confused where they can and cannot carry firearms across America. In 2001, the U.S. Department of Education conducted a study that determined that the homicide rate at......

Words: 1769 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Concealed Carry

...CONCEALED CARRY WEAPON Introduction Protecting ourselves and family from this violent society by use of guns. Law enforcement response to emergency call most of the time are unsatisfactory, not enough first responder to go around. It’s up to us to hold the port down until they arrive. Concealed weapons permit in the United States are increasingly becoming popular. Fearing on influx of violence in our society, some individual are exercising their second amendments right to the full extent of its meaning. Ongoing debate about nonmilitary or law enforcement trained individuals about handling their weapons safely. Increases in mass shooting are making some people paranoid about their safety. [First main point (strongest)] A. Does carrying a concealed hand gun prevent a major atrocities such as mass shooting that are happening all around us? Will such individual stop the bad guys and perhaps minimizing the death and destruction of what that perpetrator causes? San Bernardino Ca. shooting, suspected terrorist husband and wife that killed 12 and wounded 22 others, Radicalized Islam. Will an armed citizen in that group could have prevented this? T-Mobile store shooting in Chicago IL. Two armed men enter a store with a gun drawn only to be shot by the clerk on duty who was carrying a concealed weapon. This prevent the store from being rob and also perhaps preventing the clerk from being harm. B. Gun Laws, will it stop criminals from obtaining a weapons? What about the...

Words: 546 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Conformity

...for Oxygen Microbes have diverse requirements for O2. Aerobes require O2 for metabolism, while anaerobes do not. Many anaerobic microbes are killed by O2. Bacterial facultative anaerobes actually grow better in the presence of O2, but they can grow in its absence. In clinical microbiology, knowledge of the O2 requirements of bacteria is required, as any bacteria suspected of being anaerobes must be transported and cultured under anaerobic conditions (Figure 2.2). Genetic Information The genetic information of all cells is stored in molecules of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). Genes are segments of the DNA molecule. Each type of organism has its genetic characteristics encoded in DNA molecules that confer its species identity. Thus, DNA acts as the hereditary material for cellular organisms (and DNA viruses). What Makes a Microbe? Algae and some fungi are macroscopic; hence, “microscopic” is not an absolute characteristic of microbes. Similarly, the term unicellular does not apply to those algae and fungi that are macroscopic and clearly must be multicellular. There are even macroscopic bacteria, like the recently discovered “monster bacteria” Epulopiscium fishelsoni and Thiomargarita namibiensis (Box 2.1). Microbes are sometimes described as “simple” because many consist of only a single cell or are less than a cell (viruses and prions). Consider, however, that this single cell must fulfill all the functions of life. Hence, single-celled organisms,......

Words: 1814 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Influences of Conformity and Obedience

...Influences of Conformity and Obedience Jamie Tyler University of Phoenix Social Psychology Psych555 Prof. Kimberly Kinsey May 7, 2012 Influences of Conformity and Obedience “Social influence broadly encompasses any changes on beliefs, attitudes, or behavior that result from interpersonal interaction” (Fiske, 2010). There are several concepts that aid in the analysis of social influence. Two of these concepts are conformity and obedience. Conformity is the influence of the majority on an individual and obedience is the influence authority has on subordinates. Conformity and obedience are related in the fact that they both have the ability to persuade an individual or group of individuals to change his or her thoughts, actions, and behaviors, regarding a particular situation. Conformity and obedience are also related in that they can change the way individuals view others within a certain community, culture, ethnic group or environment. This paper will evaluate the effect of group influence on the self using both classical and contemporary literature, compare and contrast concepts of conformity and obedience and analyze individual and societal influences that lead to deviance from group norms. Conformity and obedience are important factors in groups because they command members of a group to follow societal norms. Conformity is a needed concept of social influence because it can enhance members of a group sense of belonging, as well as, self esteem. Conformity can......

Words: 1695 - Pages: 7