Premium Essay

Compstat

In: Computers and Technology

Submitted By bazdaman01
Words 951
Pages 4
Predictive Policing
A study shows, crime rates in New York City in the years between 1990 through 1998, crimes such as murder has decline by over 70%, theft by over 60 %, and violent acts by over 50%. These reductions were the largest ever recorded in the history of crime in New York City.
There were three ideas develop by individuals who were part of the study to implement a strategy that reduces crimes (2001).
First idea was to have a problem solving technique. This advance proposition was a theory by Professor Herman Goldstein. He strongly believed, police officials have had disconnect between incidents versus problems. Professor Goldstein wanted to reverse that theory and detect an incident that can turn into a problem. The second idea was introduce by Professor James Q. Wilson and George Kelling. These two individuals believed, creation of public disorder were failure by police officers in which they could not control minor offenses. Therefore, these two authors believe police officers can impact the community by responding to social controls and take charge from that aspect. This implementation was a good method to reduce neighborhood fear and prevent crimes (Broken Windows).
The third idea was implemented by Commissioner William Bratton. The Compstat program started by a management team in New York in which commissioner William Bratton was appointed as head of the police department to incorporate the Compstat model. The model was a basic process on how to collect abstract information and analyze data. He invested in his staff to devolve both resources and decision-making to higher management. This will make commanders get together for weekly planning’s, in which precinct commanders had to identify and provide solutions to incidents. Based on their conclusion, the police department will be accountable for their decisions measured by all…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Compstat

...COMPSTAT: A HELP OR A HURT? Nekia Kelly CJMS600-9040 TurnItIn Score:1% October 2, 2012 INTRODUCTION CompStat, since 1994, has been used to assist in police performance and reduce acts of crime. It is used to collect, analyze and map crime data in order to hold commanding officers responsible for their districts performance. (Peak, 2008, p.75) However, we all know that numbers can be adjusted in one’s favor as to make it appear that all is well, but how is that going to deter the fact that actions speak for themselves. Are police commanders really using CompStat reports to assist with how they shall proceed on crime in their jurisdiction? Or is it being used to make it appear that performance levels are at good standing? Also in conjunction with these reports what are they doing or will do to correct the issues. We shall take a look at the pros and cons of CompStat over the years to see where it has been beneficial to our law enforcement, how it hasn’t helped and what could or should be done to fix it. SUMMARIES In the aspect of numbers being made to look like all is well; the NYPD has been under scrutiny for such and a survey conducted in September 2008 was used to determine just how bad it really was. The department not only reached out to current commanders but also retirees to get their perspective on how things worked under their command. When the results were collected, Paul J. Browne, the department’s chief spokesman at that time did everything to dispel...

Words: 1820 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Compstat

... Information Technology (IT) is the technology side of an information system. In order for police departments to be able to manage their resources in combating crime in their areas they will have to adapt to new technologies. One of these technologies is CompStat which stands for comparative statistics. CompStat made its first appearance in 1994 in New York City. Since then many police departments have implemented the CompStat system. Once a police officer makes an arrest they have to fill out a report. This report must be as accurate as possible because the information that is obtained from this report will be entered into the CompStat system. The CompStat system has aided many police departments in the reduction of crimes in their areas. The way CompStat is used by the police departments is based on the type of information that is entered into the data base. They enter all types of information into this system which basically is who, what, where, and when. The system is designed to take this information, and predict where the next crime will possibly take place. This to some people is nothing more than an educated guess which putting it in layman terms is, but it really is more than just that. The CompStat system can maintain all of this information and produce a more timely and accurate report on where these crimes will occur next. This system can be very useful to the police departments as long as they keep putting accurate information into the system. ......

Words: 1310 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Predictive Policing

...cameras to enforce speed. The use of these cameras has given police forces the ability to use their officers more effectively. “CompStat- or COMPSTAT-(short for COMPuter STATistics or COMParative STATistics) is the name given to the New York City Police Department's accountability process and has since been replicated in many other departments.  COMPSTAT is a management philosophy or organizational management tool for police departments, roughly equivalent to Six Sigma or TQM, and is not a computer system or software package.” (State of CA, 2010) However, if I were to compare it to an information system (IS) the (4) COMPSTAT Principles would easily parallel the (4) basic IS functions. (4) basic IS functions | (4) COMPSTAT Principles | Input | Accurate and timely intelligence – know what is happening | Processing | Effective tactics – have a plan | Output | Rapid deployment – do it quickly | Feedback | Relentless follow-up and assessment: If it works, do more. If not, do something else. | The first basic IS function, input, closely is easy to compare to COMPSTATS first principle because “at the core of each activity is the use of computer-generated and other statistical data that are gathered in as close to real time as possible and subsequently presented in various formats in hard copy and electronically at CompStat meetings; formats include charts, graphs, maps, command profiles, and crime snapshot reports. The analysis of this information by......

Words: 1562 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Predictive Policing. Compstat

...use of COMPSTAT (Computer Statistics) approach could be simply stated as the systematic use of Information Systems Technology processes and Law enforcement capabilities to implement procedures to prevent crimes. This process Involves systematic data collection, crime analysis, and improved accountability in the pursuit of Criminals and ultimately, crime prevention. This paper will give an insight on the application of Predictive Policing in today’s environment, and factors to be considered when adopting this approach, as against previous non-technological traditional approaches. Predictive Policing Compare and contrast the application of information technology (IT) to optimize police departments’ performance to reduce crime versus random patrols of the streets. The positives of adopting a proactive Predictive policing approach cannot be over emphasized. The ability to detect a possible crime zone and deploying officers to that area so as to prevent the occurrence of a crime in real-time is a brilliant approach. Sometimes crimes occur in very quick successions, so if there is a method that can assist the Police to identify these hot spots, providing them a time frame or interval in which crime is likely to occur, then they will have adequate energy and resources used the best possible way. The Police will be better prepared to handle these situations and apply themselves more effectively. More so, the introduction of Information Systems to a tool like COMPSTAT makes......

Words: 1330 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Compstat

...CompStat Reflection I think every American would benefit from attending CompStat, as I am confident the things I heard in that meeting would dispel every negative stereotype about police officers that exist. I was amazed by the humility of the officers and more importantly, their dedication to specific cases and individuals. Contrary to the sensationalized image of aggressive and egotistical police officers, the officers and chiefs were quick to praise one another and express gratitude. This created a team like environment and I felt every man and woman in that room was working together for a common good. I was surprised to learn how many people are involved in just one case-the arresting officers, detectives, street outreach workers, probation officers, to just name a few-and how seamlessly these individuals work together. I was especially impressed by the lengths the department is willing to go to protect at-risk individuals, such as the young drug dealer who was recently shot. The street outreach woman was particularly interesting, as she knew the drug dealer and his family when none of the officers did. To me, this demonstrated the importance of police departments collaborating with individuals and/or organizations that can offer essential insight to a community and its members. Lastly, it genuinely warmed my heart to hear about the various activities the NHPD offers neighborhood children. The Youth Police Initiative is a great way to introduce young men to a......

Words: 407 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Predictive Policing

...implementation of a data driven management model named COMPSTAT the crime rate dropped tremendously. In fact New York, the city that never sleeps, is said to be the “safest big city in America” according to an article by Dave Grossi [ (Grossi, 2008) ]. COMPSTAT is short for computer statistics or comparative statistics and is a data driven model used by police to manage and reduce crime. COMPSTAT began under “the Rudy Giuliani administration and was overseen by Commissioner William Bratton and Deputy Commissioner Jack Maple” [ (Grossi, 2008) ]. Police Commissioner, William Bratton introduced COMPSTAT to the New York City Police Department in 1994. COMPSTAT was created to change how police view crimes. It was created as a tool to not just respond to crimes after they were committed but as proactive step to preventing crimes from happening in the first place. COMPSTAT is not a software program but rather tracks and takes stats of high crime activity. Once this is tracked the organizational management tool is then used to actively target crime in the areas that it is most needed. COMPSTAT has many different advantages such as accountability, information sharing, and encourages public communication. The way COMPSTAT forces accountability is by holding commanders and other police force responsible for knowing the details of the crime as well as devising a plan to rid the crime. The second advantage was through information sharing. COMPSTAT encourages information sharing......

Words: 1515 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Information for Decision Making

...the responsibility of patrolling particular areas of town where crime would most likely occur; also, they were dependent on citizens reporting crime. CompStat was adopted to help police officers become more aware of crime in a particular area without necessarily doing their normal patrols in particular areas of town. CompStat helps many police departments to utilize different sources and place necessary resources in areas where crime is more common; whereas, many police could not to respond in a timelyto the time. By usg the CompStat system they have a statistical chance of being where they need to be at the right time. COMPSTAT (COMPuter STATistics) is used as a law enforcement crime fighting strategy by the New York City Police Department. CompStat uses Geographic information system (GIS) to map the locations of where crimes occur, identify: hotspots”, and map problem areas. CompStat has amassed a wealth of historical crime data which are used by Mathematicians to design and develop algorithms for predicting future crimes. The CompStat process can be summarized in one simple statement: "Collect, analyze, and map crime data and other essential police performance measures on a regular basis, and hold police managers accountable for their performance as measured by these data(The CompStat Process, 2003). a. Input CompStat is an information-driven managerial process. Accurate and timely information is important. The basic information necessary for prudent, informed......

Words: 1160 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cis 500

...with the help of technology, mobile phones have the capability of acting like a computer and so forth. So with the creation of the program COMPSTAT, there was numerous years of data that was added into the database with new daily information added to predict which areas would have the highest rate of crime based on what has happened in the past (Goode, 2011). Before COMPSTAT, the officers would patrol spots that they thought might be a high area of crime based on their experience in the field (Goode, 2011). This allows the police officers to be able to target the crimes when they are taking place to prevent them from occurring based on the presence of the police officers. This also allows for officers to catch people in the act to be arrested and possibly file more charges against the criminal. This advantage allows for time to be used more wisely to go off of the data that is known for trouble spots to keep the crime down in those areas. The disadvantage of the program would be that if there was not any crime occurring in the area that the officers were sent to that it would be the same as patrolling as they would be wasting time until they were dispatched to take care of something else. With the patrolling of the streets, it more likely that the officers are waiting for a crime to take place and then they pull someone over . With COMPSTAT, it is more like a stakeout where they wait until the crime takes place and they move in. Another disadvantage would be that since......

Words: 1361 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Predictive

...gov/journals/266/pages/predictive.aspx) A component of information technology system that law enforcement utilizes to fight and reduce crime is CompStat. “In 1994, Police Commissioner William Bratton introduced a data driven management model in the New York City Police Department called CompStat, which has been credited with decreasing crime and increasing quality of life in New York City over the last eighteen years.” (http://www.compstat.umd.edu). CompStat is a database that is used by law enforcement, which produces projected crime scenes. CompStat database is updated with Geographical Information System maps that identify previous crime scenes and potential future crime scenes, which law enforcement is able to implement predictive policing. This allows law enforcement to serve and protect in the pro act mode versus the react mode, once a crime is committed. Also CompStat allows for law enforcement to realign resources to better serve the community, coupled with reduce its annual budget. The success of predictive policing can provide future site for new drug locations, early identification of young criminals, criminal hotspots, sex offenders and reoffenders to name a few. CompStat is an information system that consists of four basic functions. The four functions are: 1. Input 2. Processing 3. Output 4. Feedback “The CompStat model is a management process within a performance management framework that synthesizes analysis of crime and......

Words: 1123 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Predictive Policing

...fingerprint and criminal databases. CompStat is an information technology strategy that was adopted in New York City in 1994. It allows the police department to map areas where crimes occur, identify problem areas and “hotspots” within the city. It essentially predicts a crime before it happens. This allows the department to place officers in the proper areas, so that arrests can be made or so that crimes can be avoided. Police officers are more equipped to fight crime with information technology just performing random patrols of the streets. CompStat gives officers specific details so that they know exactly where to direct their attention. Simply patrolling the streets allows officers to have more of a community presence and build relationships with citizens of the city. CompStat’s output is based on past crimes, so patrolling the streets would make officers more accessible to adrress crimes that are happening for the first time. Compstat takes control of the streets away from the patrol officers and places it in the hands of the command staff. In random patrolling, the patrol officers are the decision makers. “The impact of CompStat, like that of previous technology, is contingent on how it interacts with the existing technical capacities, work practices, management styles and cultural values of police departments” (Willis, Matrofski, and Weisburd, 2003). The ultimate goal for both CompStat and random patrolling is to decrease crime. “Compstat has now become......

Words: 1158 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Compstat

...MANAGING CRIME AND QUALITY OF LIFE USING COMPSTAT: SPECIFIC ISSUES IN IMPLEMENTATION AND PRACTICE By Dr. Vincent E. Henry* I. INTRODUCTION The highly effective management model or paradigm that has come to be known as Compstat was first developed within the New York Police Department in 1994 as a process for managing crime and quality of life in New York City. Compstat was developed in response to a very specific set of immediate needs confronting the NYPD at that time: the compelling need to bring spiralling rates of crime and disorder to within manageable bounds and to refocus the NYPD on its primary mission of effectively ensuring public safety by reducing crime and violence. Since its introduction in early 1994, Compstat has proven to be highly effective in achieving the goals for which it was initially intended. Over time it has also evolved and grown from a basic and fairly rudimentary process involving the collection and analysis of crime data as well as a mechanism for ensuring accountability and information-sharing into a more complex, more nuanced, and eminently more effective management paradigm. As Compstat grew and changed over time, so too did the issues and problems challenging the NYPD. As crime and public disorder offences declined to within more manageable limits, the agency had the luxury of turning its attention to a range of other management problems and issues. While reducing crime and disorder and increasing public safety have never lost their......

Words: 11197 - Pages: 45

Premium Essay

Predictive Policing

...crime. Now faced with the many options offered to the police through predictive policing, it is simple to see how patrolling the streets are an archaic way of thinking. COMPSTAT is short for computer statistics, comparative statistics or computer comparison statistics and is a data-driven model used by police to manage and reduce crime. COMPSTAT is a management philosophy or organizational management tool for police departments, roughly equivalent to Six Sigma or TQM, and is not a computer system or software package. (State of CA, 2010). In 1994, Police Commissioner William Bratton introduced a data-driven management model in the New York City Police Department, which was credited with decreasing crime and increasing quality of life in New York City. Due to its success in New York, COMPSTAT has diffused quickly across the United States and has become a widely embraced management model focused on crime reduction. COMPSTAT facilitates accurate and timely analysis of crime and disorder data, which is used to identify crime patterns and problems. Based on this analysis, tailored responses are implemented through rapid deployment of personnel and resources. The COMPSTAT process is guided by four principles, which are similar to the basic four, information system (IS) functions. Four basic IS functions | 4-COMPSTAT principles | Input | Accurate and timely intelligence – know what is happening | Processing | Effective tactics – have a plan | Output | Rapid deployment – do......

Words: 2074 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Predictive Policing

...technologies to become more effective when it comes to reducing crime. The oldest technology that has been used is COMPSTAT formerly known as Computer Statistics. COMPSTAT has been around to implement strategies in law enforcement on stopping crime before it starts. COMPSTAT builds onto the UCR (Uniform Crime Report) to analyze which crime is being mostly committed, the county (or city), which age group and ethnicity is committing those crimes. COMPSTAT relies on human recognition patterns based on past crimes (Goode, 2011). In 1994, COMPSTAT was developed within the New York Police Departments. The New York Police Department used COMPSTAT to manage crime. COMPSTAT has been proven to be extremely effective within the New York Police Department. It has become a great success in controlling crimes and its disorder within the police jurisdiction. COMPSTAT is used for strategic decision-making when targeting crime in areas of the city. COMPSTAT is a database that includes daily crime counts by each precinct (Henry, ). In the beginning, police officers of the New York Police Department hand wrote crime complaint reports and the clerical personnel of the precinct typed every single data that was found. The data was viewed by the department supervisors. COMPSTAT has also been used for crime-mapping technology to determine location where crime was taken place (Henry, ). Just like COMPSTAT, police officer uses Predictive Policing to also reduce crime. Predictive policing is there......

Words: 1524 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Predictive Policing

... Understanding Predictive Policing Christian Turner CIS 500 - Information Systems Decision Making Dr. Edwin Otto 10/23/13 In today's fast-paced world, we are always looking for ways to improve the processes that we have in place. Not only to make these processes more efficient, but to also have a more effective way to complete tasks from the smallest detail to the largest project. With the influx of importance on information technology in our society, it is no surprise that we can use software for process improvement as well. Predictive policing is a perfect example of this combination of a proven process and information technology coming together to create an effective tool. Compstat (COMPuter STATistics) is one such tool that has optimized police departments abilities to predict and reduce crime when compared to random street patrols. Our society is sophisticated on many levels and crime is no different. Just as we have advancements on the positive aspects of life, the negative aspects are advancing right alongside. Predictive policing, "taking data from disparate sources, analyzing them and then using the results to anticipate, prevent and respond more effectively to future crime", can and has been a great positive advancement for mitigating and in some cases stopping crime altogether. Pearsall, B. (2010, May). "Predictive policing entails becoming less reactive. "The predictive vision moves law enforcement from focusing on what happened to focusing on what will happen...

Words: 1349 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Predictive Policing

...analysis. • They use Geographical Information System (GIS) to map the location of where the crime occurs. This feature is not available with the street patrolling. • Using the GIS and the prediction of where the crime might occur, reacting to the crime is faster. With street patrolling this might not be fast as they might not be close to the location where the crime has occurred. COMPSTAT as an information system (IS) COMPSTAT stands for COMPuter STATistics. COMPSTAT is a police administration and management model. The COMPSTAT crime control model is the brainchild of William Bratton who during tenures in executive positions in New York and Boston developed a synthesis of police strategies and managerial concepts aimed toward crime reduction. A rapid result in crime reduction is a focal point in the COMPSTAT system. COMPSTAT uses four basic functions that an information system basically uses. The four basic functions are as follows: Input: Data and information about business transactions are captured or collected by point-of-sale (POS) scanners and Web sites and received by other input devices. COMPSTAT uses the previous crime data as input. Example, For the Santa Cruz trial, eight years of crime data were fed into the computer program, which breaks Santa Cruz into squares of approximately 500 feet by 500 feet. New data is added each day. Processing: Data is transformed, converted, and analyzed for storage or transfer to an output device. .By leveraging the back end......

Words: 1579 - Pages: 7