Free Essay

Comparison Matrix Paper: Doctoral Identity

In: Social Issues

Submitted By Claudia23
Words 397
Pages 2
Doctoral Identity
For years researchers have study the change in the identity of the doctoral student through their social and academic environments. It is believed that their identity has been developed by the educational environment where they studied, and that the introduction of the Internet created a community of change. Distance education was introduced and the opportunity to teach critical thinking strategies was becoming the norm of the classrooms. Today socialization is the main force in the development of one’s academic identity, the role of the scholar and becoming critical thinkers.
Presented in this paper is a comparative analysis of three articles: “Socialization of Doctoral Students to Academic Norms” by Weidman and Stein (2003); “Developmental networks and learning: toward an interdisciplinary perspective on identity development during doctoral study” by Baker and Lattuca (2010); and “Critical thinking distance education and traditional education” by Visser, Visser and Schlosser (2003).
Comparison of Research Questions
The three articles studied presented a look at the relationships between the faculty instructors and the students and what can be done to help in the socialization of the students.
Article one ask the question regarding the preparation of the students for a scholarly role or the role that a student is expected to have after they have earned their doctorate degree. It explores the socialization of the doctoral student to the academic norms of research and scholarship (Weidman, 2003) and what effect that it has on the development of the student’s scholarly role. While Article Two focus on the development of the academic professional identity, it ask the question how does developmental networks and sociocultural perspectives of learning assist in the development of the identity and academics of the student. Like Article One, Article Two looks at how and what the doctoral student learn during the graduate journey by looking into the roles of the faculty and how they prepared the students for their professional careers. Article Three question is how instructors help students to become critical thinkers. The article also explore the role that critical thinking plays at the graduate level and if the instructors are helping student to become critical thinkers at this level.
All three articles as they pose their question toward the instructor role in the development of the student identity as a professional and what can they do to help in the socialization of the students.
Comparison of Literature Reviews…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Comparison Matrix Paper

...Comparison Matrix Grand Canyon University: PSY_801-0105 September 12, 2012 Introduction The purpose of this paper is to review the comparison matrix of three empirical research papers and make a comparison of the information provided. This qualitative assessment will help in preparing for doctoral journey by comparing, contrasting and synthesizing what each researcher has stated in their research papers. Article 1 was a research on workplace bullying that focused on individuals and situation predictors that engaged in bullying others. The purpose of the research was to examine the reason that perpetrators in the workplace bully their co-workers. Article 2 focused on trait anger and anxiety that may relate to individuals being labeled as victims of workplace bullying or what is the relationship between the acts of bullying. The purpose behind this study was to determine what influences are in place that causes a victim in the workplace to be bullied. Article 3 related to how employees are coping to workplace bulling and how the effects of bullying are affecting their job performance. The main purpose with this study was to determine the role of human resource management in coping with bullying in the workplace. Comparison of each matrix research questions Although all articles focused on one thing that was common and that was individuals who are being bullied; there were however, some differences in the research questions. For......

Words: 1207 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Comparison Matrix Paper

...Comparison Matrix Marquita S. Henderson Grand Canyon University: PSY-801 July 10, 2013 Comparison Matrix A Comparison Matrix is a grid created specifically to display information in a structural format. In week two of the PSY-801 course, students were presented with the task of completing a comparison matrix, consisting of empirical articles and details of their content. The intent of this particular document is to revisit the matrix from week two and compare the provided findings on a deeper level. The following qualitative assessment will serve as a tool of preparation for the doctoral program. The purpose of developing and reviewing a comparison matrix is to ultimately compare, contrast, and synthesize researchers’ discoveries and conclusions in their works. The comparison matrix in reference, focuses on different facets of bullying in professional environments. The first article, titled, “Individual and situational predictors of workplace bullying: why do perpetrators engage in the bullying of others?” is an examination of the explanation(s) that aggressors tend to intimidate their co-workers. The second article, “Does trait anger, trait anxiety or organizational position moderate the relationship between exposure to negative acts and self-labelling as a victim of workplace bullying?” highlights traits relative to whether or not an individual is indeed a victim of bullying and the correlation between bullying actions. The emphasis is on influences and......

Words: 1317 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Comparison Matrix Paper

...This essay will compare two articles that will conclude how personality and skills are essential in being a good leader. The premise for each article all had the same hypothesis in mind, with regard to effective leadership. The studies that will be compared will be “Personality traits, management styles & conflict management in a military unit” by Salimi, Karaminia, and Esmaeili (2011) and “The leadership skills strataplex: Leadership skill requirements across organizational levels” by Mumford, Campion, and Morgeson (2007). A comparison of the research questions, sample population, and limitations will be discussed. Salimi and colleagues (2011) investigated personality traits with regard to management styles. They wanted to find out if personality traits had any affect on a leader’s management style and conflict resolution. They found that extraversion and when conscientious leaders were more successful. Northouse (2010) in regards to personality traits gave perfect examples on how personality traits in fact can affect how leaders resolve issues and tribulations. Northouse (2010), stated how leaders are more tolerant for uncertainty, openness, and curiosity. When leaders are confident they are more inclined to be helpful in sudden situations that involve conflict. Mumford and colleagues (2007) addressed the skills needed by a leader to help perform their daily job functions within an organization. They suggest that cognitive, interpersonal, business, and strategic......

Words: 1162 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Comparison Matrix

...University of Phoenix Material Unix® and Linux® Comparison Matrix Directions: Choose three different versions of the UNIX® or Linux® operating systems to compare. Insert the three chosen versions and fill out the requested information in the Components column. UNIX® or Linux® operating system version: Fedora |Components |Your response | |Role of shell |Gives a command line with built in commands | |Three features and roles of each |Security-there is a firewall tool provided with a task bar that lets the user know of any | |feature |security issues. Shell- Is environment friendly for the user and has functions that run like | | |a PC. Rescue-This feature which is in the disk of the program, can unlock a system to let the| | |user continue their work. | |Comments on security |This is a main important feature for the OS | |Comments on administration |It is easy for ADMIN use and the tools are not as difficult | |Comments on networking |Networking is ok even though the security firewall is good ...

Words: 446 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Comparison Matrix Paper

...COMPARISON MATRIX RESEARCH STUDY PAPER December 18, 2013 Gloria Knox LDR 802 INSTRUCTOR: Dan Gilbert COMPARISON MATRIX RESEARCH STUDY PAPER Introduction The first article: Leadership as Situational Factor on Personality-Performance Relationship: An Empirical Study of The Taiwan’s Office Machinery Sales Force. By Kuang-Hui Chiu Tsai Chen The second article: Leadership and Organizational Culture: Linking CEO Characteristics to Cultural Values. By Tomas R. Gilberson, Christian J. Resick, Marcus W. Dickson, Jacqueline K. Mitchelson, Kenneth R. Randall and Malissa A. Clark. The third article (from reference list of the first article): The Big Five Personality Traits and Individual Job Performance Growth Trajectories in Maintenance and Transitional Job Stages. By Carl J Thoresen, Jill C. Bradley, Paul D. Bliese and Joseph D. Thoresen Chiu and Chen, (2011), in their research explored Taiwan’s business environments and the methods of hiring and retention of well skilled and well trained employees (p.2). Only a few research studies have been done...

Words: 1182 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Comparison Matrix Paper 2

...Doctoral Journey Learner Self-Assessment Writing Preparation T F 1. My writing is always clear, consistent, and free from grammatical errors. T F 2. My professors have told me I need some extra support in the area of writing. T F 3. I always proofread my submissions and use extra support that is offered. T F 4. My skills with word processing allow me to use most features that help with writing. T F 5. I am able to use 6th edition APA manual correctly and rarely need help with citations. Research Preparation T F 1. I am comfortable with researching in online libraries. T F 2. I know and understand the difference between quantitative and qualitative research methods. T F 3. I am comfortable with using SPSS or other data formatting programs. T F 4. I have written graduate-level literature reviews. T F 5. I am comfortable assessing Web sites for their accuracy, authority, objectivity, and coverage. T F 6. I can readily identify an empirical article. Personal Preparation T F 1. I have talked to at least one other doctoral student and/or have read at least one other dissertation. T F 2. I am comfortable with learning in an online format. T F 3. I have identified the hours in my day where I will need to be active in the course room and working on my assignments. T F 4. My friends and/or family are supportive of me taking this journey. T F 5. I have a dedicated space set aside for my computer, books, and......

Words: 300 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Comparison Matrix Paper

...Comparison Matrix Paper James Trent Grand Canyon University RES-811 October 8, 2014 Research Questions Customer service satisfaction and leadership, what do they have in common? Can you have poor leadership and great customer service satisfaction? Can you have great leadership and poor customer service satisfaction? Are there commonalities in the two? Are there any major differences in the two? Are there metrics that can be used to improve poor customer service? Is it possible to have one without the other? Every business in today’s society depends on customer service. For many customers it’s the most important thing to determine if there will be repeat business or not. The three studies that I’ve been asked to compare and contrast touches on the questions mentioned and provides strong arguments for both scenarios. One article states the following: “Customer satisfaction depends, to a large extent on the attitude of customer contact personnel (Emery. Pg. 77, 2007). Another article states that “Delivering quality customer service has emerged as a strategic imperative, one that is increasingly tied to a firm’s information technology resources and capabilities (Ray. Pg. 625, 2005). When looking over the three articles, they approach questions in a different way. Instead of asking direct questions in the study, each article takes the same approach and proposes several hypotheses. After the hypotheses is ...

Words: 1501 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Comparison Matrix

...Comparison Matrix Paper: Doctoral Identity Albina Ortiz Grand Canyon University College of Doctoral Studies Comparison Matrix Paper: Doctoral Identity Doctoral scholars make up a very limited populace with requirements and apprehensions in many cases that are out of the ordinary in several ways, especially in the areas of academia and oneself. Nevertheless, marginal study has been steered on the subject of doctoral students’ socialization throughout their scholastic careers, nonetheless the research that has been accomplished does bring into line and review the demands and certification of scholastic achievement in harmonization with doctoral students’ development and socialization within their targeted areas. The intention of the studies completed within the following articles; Socialization of doctoral students to academic norms. Research in Higher Education, 44(6), 641., Weidman, J.C., & Stein, E. L. (2003)., Developmental networks and learning: toward and interdisciplinary perspective on identity development during doctoral study. Studies in Higher Education, 35(7), 807-827., Baker, V., & Lattuca, L.R. (2010), Critical thinking distance education and traditional education. Quarterly review of Distance Education, 4(4), 401-407., Visser, L., Y.L., & Schlosser, C. (2003)., is the examination of standpoints on learning and their approach to facilitating ones preparation to becoming a doctoral student, as well as doctoral students’ satisfaction within their...

Words: 1097 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Comparison Matrix Paper

...c Comparison Matrix Paper Barry Fontenot Grand Canyon University: RES-811 October 10, 2015 Comparison Matrix Paper During the last few years there has been a need to research and investigate the role of social support and the doctoral degree completion. This research will explore the effects of stress management, feeling of isolation, and networking with in the doctoral experience. Doctoral students may perform at higher rates when they participate and socialize in positive academic environments The intent of this research the role of a doctoral student seems to have been studied from the inception of time. Countless scholars have attempted to classify and identify the parts in which a doctoral scholar, and where they fit within society as well as in the realm of academia. They have also studied how social or non-social activities would have on influencing the doctoral scholars on their journey through academia. The three articles that were used further to enlighten the readers about the role and identity of doctoral did an excellent job in providing ample evidence. All three articles produced solid research questions, excellent literature reviews, substantial sample populations, and comparison of limitations, comparison of results, and definitive recommendations as well as future studies. Vickie L. Baker and Lisa Lattuca conducted this study in 2010. Development networks and learning: Toward an interdisciplinary......

Words: 1677 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Comparison Matrix

...Comparison Matrix Paper: Doctoral Identity Courtney Sims Grand Canyon University: RES811 October 9, 2015 Comparison Matrix Paper: Doctoral Identity Who am I and what have you done with my identity? This is an age old question that has played a prevalent role for over the past five decades. This paper will explore the importance of socialization, professionalism, and developing a scholarly identity through the comparison of the three following articles: “Socialization of Doctoral Students to Academic Norms” by Weidman and Stein (2003) whose purpose was to examine the relationships among the perceived informal structures of the climate in academic departments associated with the socialization of doctoral students to the scholar role; “Developmental networks and learning: toward an interdisciplinary perspective on identity development during doctoral study” by Baker and Lattuca (2010) whose purpose was to develop a deeper understanding on how doctoral programs shape teachers and researchers including the preparation of graduate students for academic careers and the development of an academic professional identity; and “Critical Thinking in Distance Education and Traditional Education” by Visser and Visser (2003) whose purpose was to establish a clear explanation of “critical thinking” and express opinions on the variations in student learning based on whether it was on campus or by various means of distance learning. The comparison of the three articles will include......

Words: 2246 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Doctoral Identity

...Doctoral Identity Wolverine is Logan Grand Canyon University: RES 811 2015 Doctoral Identity Like the proverbial rat in a maze, the doctoral learner must learn to navigate the transition from lay learner to academic scholar. The transition from being a “learner” to a “critical thinker” requires the doctoral student to ascertain an individual perspective of how best to obtain and synthesize knowledge for the purpose of creating new knowledge. The purpose of this paper is to determine how important developmental social networks (both academic and non-academic) and critical thinking are to new doctoral students. Weidman and Stein (2003) analyzed the effect of the social climate between students and faculty at academic departments on the overall development of professional identity among Ph.D. students. Baker and Lattuca (2003) analyzed developmental network theory and the theory of sociocultural perspectives on learning to theorize that an interdisciplinary approach of learning and socialization was the best model for promoting positive professional identity development. Visser, Visser and Schlosser (2003) examined the importance and impact of social networks in the development of critical thinking skills among students by contrasting distance learners with traditional classroom learners at the university level. Comparison of Research Questions In their studies, the authors tackle how doctoral students can best prepare for a doctoral education and how developing......

Words: 2009 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Res 811 Wk 4 Comparison Matrix , Outline and Paper

...RES 811 Wk 4 Comparison Matrix , Outline and Paper Click Link Below To Buy: http://hwcampus.com/shop/res-811-wk-4-comparison-matrix-outline-and-paper/ Before beginning the synthesis process, it is important to become acquainted with the analysis and comparison of empirical articles. In this assignment, you will engage with the Comparison Matrix, a tool for analysis and comparison of empirical articles. You will also prepare an outline for a paper to be written based on the information gathered during your interaction with the matrix. General Requirements: Use the following information to ensure successful completion of the assignment: • Locate and download "Comparison Matrix." • Locate: Weidman, J. C., & Stein, E. L. (2003). Socialization of doctoral students to academic norms.Research in Higher Education,44(6), 641. Available athttp://library.gcu.edu:2048/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com.library.gcu.edu:2048/login.aspx?direct=true&db=ehh&AN=11092904&site=ehost-live&scope=site • Locate: Baker, V., & Lattuca, L. R. (2010). Developmental networks and learning: toward an interdisciplinary perspective on identity development during doctoral study.Studies in Higher Education,35(7), 807-827.http://library.gcu.edu:2048/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com.library.gcu.edu:2048/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=54329722&site=ehost-live&scope=site • Locate: Visser, L., Visser, Y. L., & Schlosser, C. (2003). Critical thinking distance education and......

Words: 543 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Comparison Matrix and Outline

...Comparison Matrix and Outline Grand Canyon University: RES811 March 2, 2016 Comparison Matrix | Article 1 | Article 2 | Article 3 | Title/Author(s) | Critical Thinking In Distance Education and Traditional EducationVisser, L., Visser, Y. L., & Schlosser, C. (2003) | Developmental Networks and Learning: Toward an Interdisciplinary Perspective on Identity Development During Doctoral Study. Baker, V., & Lattuca, L. R. (2010) | Socialization of Doctoral Students to Academic NormsWeidman, J. C., & Stein, E. L. (2003) | | | | | Persistent GCU library link | http://lopes-idm-oclc-org.library.gcu.edu:2443/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=12620957&site=ehost-live&scope=site | http://lopes-idm-oclc-org.library.gcu.edu:2443/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=54329722&site=ehost-live&scope=site | http://lopes-idm-oclc-org.library.gcu.edu:2443/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=ehh&AN=11092904&site=ehost-live&scope=site | | | | | Purpose of the studyWhat is the author’s rationale for selecting this topic? Does he build a strong case? | The purpose of the study of this article is to explain whether current teaching practices require higher order thinking. | The purpose of the study of this article is to explain the differences between types of learners from different countries and whether the learner does better with a network of support around them from......

Words: 1480 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Doctoral Identity

...Doctoral Identity EuRhonda Morgan Grand Canyon University June 8, 2016 Doctoral Identity When reproduction occurs and more than one egg is fertilized, it usually results in twins. If they are from the same egg, they are considered identical. If the egg splits, they are known as fraternal. Whether they are identical or fraternal, each should have their own identity. Identity can be defined as “who one is” or “who one sees in the mirror.” When one enters a doctoral program, he or she embarks upon a new identity, generally known as the “doctoral identity.” Mentors, faculty, family, coworkers and cohort members all play a critical role in fostering the doctoral identity. “Developmental Networks and Learning: Toward an Interdisciplinary Perspective on Identity Development during Doctoral Study by Baker and Lattuca, (2010) discusses and links two theories – developmental networks and sociocultural perspectives on learning and to foster the interdisciplinary approach of doctoral education as a Segway to the professoriate. Weidman and Stein (2003) in “Socialization of Doctoral Students to Academic Norms” addresses socialization of doctoral students to the academic norms of research and scholarship. They are joined by Visser, Visser and Schloasser’s “Critical Thinking Distance Education and Traditional Education” (2003), emphasizes the importance of critical thinking to traditional and distance education. These three articles are so intertwined, that it would be futile......

Words: 1550 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Res 811 Wk 4 Comparison Matrix , Outline and Paper

...RES 811 Wk 4 Comparison Matrix , Outline and Paper Click Link Below To Buy: http://hwcampus.com/shop/res-811-wk-4-comparison-matrix-outline-and-paper/ Before beginning the synthesis process, it is important to become acquainted with the analysis and comparison of empirical articles. In this assignment, you will engage with the Comparison Matrix, a tool for analysis and comparison of empirical articles. You will also prepare an outline for a paper to be written based on the information gathered during your interaction with the matrix. General Requirements: Use the following information to ensure successful completion of the assignment: • Locate and download "Comparison Matrix." • Locate: Weidman, J. C., & Stein, E. L. (2003). Socialization of doctoral students to academic norms.Research in Higher Education,44(6), 641. Available athttp://library.gcu.edu:2048/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com.library.gcu.edu:2048/login.aspx?direct=true&db=ehh&AN=11092904&site=ehost-live&scope=site • Locate: Baker, V., & Lattuca, L. R. (2010). Developmental networks and learning: toward an interdisciplinary perspective on identity development during doctoral study.Studies in Higher Education,35(7), 807-827.http://library.gcu.edu:2048/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com.library.gcu.edu:2048/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=54329722&site=ehost-live&scope=site • Locate: Visser, L., Visser, Y. L., & Schlosser, C. (2003). Critical thinking distance education and......

Words: 543 - Pages: 3