Free Essay

Compare and Contrast “so Mexicans Are Taking Jobs from Americans by Baca& “American Dream” by Schwarnegger

In: Historical Events

Submitted By tobyaura
Words 779
Pages 4
“So Mexicans Are Taking Jobs from Americans “by Jimmy Santiago Baca, the narrator explains in immigrants come to America and try to take make living for their families but society discriminate against them because they are different .American Dream” by Arnold Schwarnegger is an interview with Schwarzenegger detailing how a man tries to pursuit his dreams as a bodybuilder, never giving up no matter what. Even when he placed second times in competitions, he became successful in America. In other words, these two narrators give examples of how immigrants come from other countries, trying to pursuit dreams in another land, making better living for their children, and becoming leaders in many different ways. Society discriminates against them due to look. The optimistic tone of schwarnegger’s interview is in stark contrast to Baca’s poem, underlining American society’s preference for immigrants to European versus Latin-American descent.
First, some people successfully sneak across the border but do not mean they will successful once they get to America. “So Mexicans Are Taking Jobs from Americans” by Baca gives a mental picture of where a lot of immigrants are coming from, and gives an understanding as to why they would choose to risk their lives coming to America. “The rifles I hear sound in the night are white farmers shooting blacks and browns whose ribs I see jutting out and starving children” reflects the bitterness he has towards Americans for the violence that occurs with border patrol. Also he gives the image of money that represents a bad economy and it means that name people who live in poverty are drowning or struggling, to stay alive before they are crushed by the pressures of the economy: ‘Below that cool green sea money, millions and millions of people fight to live”.However,”The children are dead already. We are killing them, that is what Americans should be saying: on TV, in the streets, in offices, should be saying, “we aren’t giving the children a chance to live”. In other words, the American society spends too much time critizing Mexicans for stealing jobs but they have bigger problems. One of their problems is their inability to take responsibility for their own mistakes and bad judgment. Furthermore, most people that are jumping border do so because they have a lower standard of living than people in America.
Second, people become leaders in many ways and have demonstrated enough skill and knowledge so they are able to emerge into leadership role. “American Dream” by Arnold Schwarzenegger gives the reality of life, a person who is determined to be a winner, never loses sight of his goal until he achieves it.This is the philosophy of a winner as he calls it; “Wining is a very important, there is one that achieves what he wanted to achieve and there are hundreds of thousands that failed. It singles you out: The Winner” ,it gives the message people can always achieve dreams or wishes if they try with all their efforts step by step without being influenced by their surroundings. Moreover, “Three, four months before a competition, I could not interfered by other people problems. This is sometimes I called selfish’.Here the narrator shares advice that people should follow if they wish to achieve a goal in life; they have to block negativity that surrounds them n order to overcome all obstacles. Additionally, “I am stronger believe in Western philosophy, the philosophy of success, of progress, of getting rich. The Eastern philosophy is passive, which I believe in maybe three percent of the times, and the nine seven percent is Western, conquering and going on. It’s a beautiful philosophy and America should keep it up”. The quote sets the example to follow or try the Western philosophy and see how people could become successful in anything they want in life.Schwarnegger’s past and present leadership roles will predict some possibilities he may be capable in any future positions.
In conclusion, these narrators explain how people’s thoughts could be negative but there are many ways to block negativity, to avoid interruptions in goals. Baca gives the reality of how Mexican immigrants will take labor intensive jobs and work for pennies, giving an understanding why immigrants risk their lives to feed their families while White Americans would rather be on welfare. In contrast, Shwarneggers has had multiple successful careers that gave him a well-rounded background and enabled people from multiple cultural, educational, and occupational backgrounds to look to him as a leader in many aspects. The optimistic tone Schwarzenegger’s interview is in stark contrast to Baca’s poem, underlining society’s preference for immigrants of European versus Latin-American descent.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

The American Dream

...The American Dream Assignment 1: Text 2 interprets the American dream as something every man or woman can achieve if they have the right attitude. “Everyone is the architect of his own fortune” is a common used speech of many immigrants in America. According to this belief everything is possible to archive if you just work hard enough. In text 2 Arnold Schwarzenegger also describes his travel from Austria to the big U.S.A. According to Arnold the travel was about fulfilling his dreams instead of simply being an ordinary police officer in Austria like his old man. Schwarzenegger is a great example of the opportunities and possibilities that lies in the American dream; he succeeded and became a great and sought actor and later was elected governor of California or the “the golden state” as people call it. Text 3 has a more negative view on the American dream. Anya Kanentz, the author of the text thinks the American dream is wounded or even dead. In her opinion money in it self do not make you happy. Instead she elucidates the “real” American dream, where people spend more time on their family than their occupation. She also beliefs that people today are to materialistic thinking, they are more preoccupied by their jobs than their families. Like text 3, text 4 also takes a skeptical stance towards the American dream. The author, David Wallechinsky, argues that people should be able to live a comfortable life without worrying too much about things like money. He claims that......

Words: 714 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

So Mexicans Are Taking Jobs from Americans

...AMATEUR ANALYSIS So Mexicans Are Taking Jobs from Americans “So Mexican Are Taking Jobs from Americans” is a poem written by Jimmy Santiago Baca. From the way the poem is written, we can infer that the author, himself, is the speaker, and the White, American population is his audience. We can gather this information because of his wording, for example, within the first few lines when he writes, “And do you, gringo, take off your ring, drop your wallet into a blanket spread over the ground, and walk away?” The words "you", "your", and "gringo" imlpy that he is speaking to White Americans. The tone of this particular poem seems, to me, to be very bitter in nature. Words and phrases that gave me this impression of bitterness can be found in lines 24-29 when he exclaims, “I see the poor marching for a little work, I see small white farmers selling out to clean-suited famers (referring to businessman) living in New York, who’ve never been on a farm, don’t know the look of a hoof of the smell of a woman’s body bending all day long in fields”. What I took from these lines is that he is of the opinion that the Mexican immigrants work just as hard as, if not harder than, White Americans, yet they reap little benefit from their efforts. This is different from the American mentality that we should be entitiled to a reward for our hard work. Other phrases that contribute to this association with bitterness are available in lines 20-23, which read, “The rifles I hear......

Words: 632 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The American Dream

...The American Dream Give an outline of how the American Dream is interpreted in texts 2, 3 and 4. Text 2: The text is about how foreigners look at the American Dream and their expectations to it. The whole text is built on how Arnold Schwarzenegger experienced the move from Austria to USA and fulfilling the American Dream. How like many other foreigners he came from nothing and moved to the states and then fighting to get his American Dream fulfilled. In the text Schwarzenegger puts the emphasis on foreigners to work hard to fulfill their American Dream. They should not just accept the handouts but work hard to be greater and help the American society to be greater. Text 3: This text tells us a different version of the American Dream. It emphasizes more on the social side of things. The writer describes how more and more people are getting demoralized and more pessimistic than ever seen in the last half-century. People cannot afford family life if they also think about money. The young people in society have completed some surveys, in which one found out that they want more time with their families. The writer predicts that “even more young people are going to choose - or be pushed into - a smaller-scale, downshifted lifestyle where they make do with less stuff and trade more money for more time”. Then the writer comments on how the American Dream is changing from being materialistic to being more focused on social life. The writer also says “but it’s more sustainable...

Words: 877 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The American Dream from the Great Gatsby

...of the"American Dream"? The American Dream is a myth that people struggle to achieve each day of their lives but will never achieve. It cannot be achieved because it is an endless race for perfection .In Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby; all the characters are attempting to become happier. The characters are divided into two groups: the rich (upper class) and the poor (lower class); though the main characters only try to make their lives better, but they are ruined by the harsh reality of life. America is founded on the principle of liberty, the notion that everyone is free to say and write what they want and that everyone is equal. Some people assume that since so much freedom is allowed, at least one person is exercising that freedom to its fullest. They work their whole lives to try to be like that person, but that person does not exist. They want to be as rich as him, and as powerful as him. These people are called the wealthy. The Great Gatsby illustrates the story these people, and how they are corrupted by the potential of seemingly limitless freedom. Tom and Daisy Buchanan, the rich couple in East Egg, seem to have everything they unhappy and seek more wealth. Tom drifts on "forever seeking a little wistfully for the could possibly want. Though their lives are full of anything they could imagine, they are dramatic turbulence of some irrecoverable football game"(Fitzgerald 10) and reads "deep books with long words in them"(Fitzgerald 14) just so he has......

Words: 889 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The American Dream

...The American Dream 1. Text two In text two, Arnold Schwarzenegger describes his American dream. He carefully gives an outline of how to succeed the dream. Arnold Schwarzenegger points out, that it is very important to blend into the American culture. To blend in, you should, among lots of things, learn the language and take responsibility as an American by doing good and needed things for the local society. It is also essential to participate in politics. Finally Arnold Schwarzenegger concludes, that once you have become an American citizen, you will have better opportunities to create a good life in America. Text three Anya Kamenetz writes in 2008 an article about the American Dream. She is very sceptic about the American Dream and it’s continuing. Anya Kamenetz finds it hard to believe that the American Dream is still the same as it was in the past. The financial crisis has made it difficult for a lot of people, because of the high prices for energy and the housing crises. The idea of the dream is a high living standard, which includes a lot of money and an ownership of material goods. The family life is also wounded by the development that is passing though America. Two working parents make it hard to have a complete family life. Finally indications show that the global warming is dangerous to our planet. If other countries, like USA, increase the amount of fast food eating, driving and shopping, the planet will suffer a great loss of resources. The American......

Words: 1045 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The American Dream

...The American Dream Immigrants—often coming from smaller or poorer countries—settle in America in order to achieve their lifelong goals and to start a better life. This new life that individuals try to create is called the American Dream. The United States is the land of opportunity and success, and one can achieve this through hard work. However, others say the American Dream has become expansive over time, and it is slowly diminishing. Despite those who oppose the idea of this Dream, the American Dream exists as long as one puts forth effort and strives even when they fail. The idea of the American Dream creates two key characteristics in an individual: discipline and persistence. According to Lesonsky, “reaching that dream isn’t easy”. Any individual will encounter highs and lows while on a journey to success, and mistakes will come along the way; however, learning and improving from those mistakes will allow an individual to reach his or her dream. Surely, reaching the Dream is not an easy task, but taking small steps at a time and avoiding shortcuts will end with positive results. Furthermore, some may argue that the Dream is a made up concept, but the idea that “tomorrow would be better than today” has been around since the creation of man (Meacham). Any time an individual has a bad day, he or she knows the next day is a chance to start fresh; similarly, immigrants or citizens of this country know they can always improve or have an opportunity for a better life. This......

Words: 642 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The American Dream

...is the American Dream”, a background essay from The Library of Congress Learning Page website, 2002. “Arnold Schwarzenegger Recalls Lessons From 25 Years as a U.S Citizen – Learn English, participate in Politics, and give Back”, a comment from U.S News & World Report website, 2008. Both texts discuss the thought of the “American dream”. The texts have various opinions, but also different style and language. Arnold Schwarzenegger’s text is written in an informal language compared to the other text. In Arnold Schwarzenegger’s text the noun often comes before the verb. For instance “I became, I will, I came, I worked” This makes the language seem enumerating. He talks directly to the reader in active sentences and there are traces of spoken language in the text, for instance: “That made me feel so good, speaking only a little English”. The language is ordinary and easily understandable. The text is personal and directed towards the feelings of the reader. In the other text the language is formal. There are many passive sentences which make the text seem professional. The words are various and complex, which signals a better language. In short Schwarzenegger’s text is meant to hit the reader on a personal level. He talks about his own experiences in his life and this makes him seem sympathetic and human to the reader. The other text has a better language. This text is not supposed to touch your feelings but instead be informative, practical intellectual. Taking a......

Words: 803 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The American Dream

...The American Dream: Alive and Thriving Everybody is entitled to their own dreams and ambitions no matter their race, color, or gender. When the term “American dream” is heard, most people visualize an enormous house with a stunning car and a beautiful family. Others may think more simplistic, like a simple God given right: freedom. Everyone has their own definition of the American dream, but I have a different perspective. I see it as how I want my life to be in the future, and the steps I will take to get there. The American dream is about opportunity, and there are plenty of opportunities in this nation. To pursue a bright future, one must obtain education and acquire a satisfactory job. This nation provides people with exactly what they need, and as knowledge is obtained; changing, growing, learning and becoming the person that we want to be is taking effect. America is a place where the people are nourished and have the freedom to chase their dreams, which clearly means the American dream is still alive. In 2007, the president of Purdue University, Martin C. Jischke delivered a speech to a graduating class concerning the American dream. Jischke explained how difficult it was way back in the day to get an education and become successful. He also went on to explain the Great Depression. During that time there was hardly any money to afford an education, let alone be sent to college. When Jischke had the opportunity, he took it without hesitation and received......

Words: 1074 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Compare and Contrast 2 American Decade

...Women Fashion in 1900s and 1990s Fashion is the indispensable part of women nowadays as well as the previous periods. Clothing is not only the stuff to cover or keep warm women’s bodies, but also the tool to display their characteristics. Choosing women’s outfits is based on their wearing purposes and personalities. So, there were many innovations in women fashion during the twentieth century. Even though they made a lot of diversities especially between the 1900s and 1990s, there were some related points in fashion to the first and last periods of the century. The biggest difference in women fashion between two decades is appearance. Although, there were some revolutions in fashion industry in 1900s, women fashion was still influenced by the Victorianism. Thus, women clothes kept on containing a lot of complex details and accessories. According to the article “The 1900s: Fashion: Overview”, “The S-shaped silhouette formed by a corset, petticoats, and a small, heavy bustle, remained the dominant look for women.” On the other hand, the 1990s is a period of soften and less constructed garments. Knit tops, cotton khaki pants, T-shirt and bell-bottom jeans are the most common suits of women in this decade (“Overview”). The next point is fashion trend. The reason of the discrepancy between two decades is the style in 1900s based on the Gibson Girl’s images. The Gibson Girl is a drawing of illustrator Charles Gibson which is a symbol of fragile and voluptuous lady with a tiny...

Words: 723 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

American Dream

...the so-called ‘American Dream’ dead, alive or on hold?” He believes that the ideals and values of the American Dream are very much alive even though many people have lost confident in the Great Recession. Under the difficult economic circumstances today, Brandon redefines the American Dream as the potential to work for an honest, secure way of life and save for the future according to the more intense spending habits of Americans. In order to living the American Dream, Brandon lists solutions to three main problems, inequality, economic insecurity and eroded faith in the American Dream. In sum, he believes that though existing, inequality is not a reason for the lost of American Dream in the poor and supporting the top businesses would help the recovery of economy. He also highlights the values and rules of the American Dream, which would help living and inheritance of this spirit. From my perspective, I agree with the main problems he concludes but for some of his solutions, I stand on the opposite site of the author. I think narrowing the income gap is very significant and so do supporting businesses, while the dependence of the spirit itself is in the less important position. Following are my analysis of each argument. According to the article, inequality is regarded as the most worrisome problem by many people. In contrast with economists like Robert Reich and Paul Krugman who believe that the concentration of wealth at the top would not help living the American Dream......

Words: 1225 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Mexican-American

...The Mexican- American History May 22, 2014 History 1. The first picture caught my eye was Pedro Infante was a famous Mexican actor during the golden age of Mexican cinema. I consider Pedro an important contributor to society because he brought a whole new meaning to the movie making of Mexico Pedro mostly played the role of a Mexican Rancher but worked out for him very well because he soon became one of the best actors of his time along with Jorge Negrete and Maria Felix. 2. María Félix was a Mexican film star whose extraordinary beauty and force of personality made her a living myth to Mexicans and a symbol of glamour and sophistication to fans throughout the world. Her entire period, she reigned as the supreme goddess of Spanish language in cinema. She became so powerful that she exerted great influence over fashion and as actor in Mexico and other few countries. 3. Mexican American joins the military during World War II for a better opportunity for their life. One was to improve their low socioeconomic status as lack of jobs opportunities. Other to improve their education and manhood. The Mexican American saw to enjoy the military was the only alternative opportunity to enjoy the military to be the only way to succeed in life. 4. Guy L. Gaba ldon was important during the World War II he was a Mexican- American soldier served in the Pacific, his main mark was in the battle of Saipan he fought with the Japanese soldier. The knowledge he......

Words: 2123 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Mexican Americans

...Mexican Americans Mexican American population has increased dramatically over the years. According to the New York Times, The Mexican population grew fastest from 1990-2000. The head count for Mexican Americans would not be accurate on the United States Census bureau because illegal immigrants not accurately accounted for. When referring to the United States census bureau and monster fact.com census the number of Latinos did not represent a large percentage. According to the New York Times Mexican American alone accounted for 60% of the Latino/ Hispanic group. Mexican is the largest Hispanic group In the United States. The percentage of college graduate is significantly lower than other minority group. Many young Mexican American teens are learning the language just as quick as the other minority group. It is far more important for the children of immigrant parents to be proficient in the English language because long term, the later generations linguistic skills are needed to integrated in American society. For many Mexican American second generation, Spanish is still their first language. Therefore, the Bush "No Child Left behind Act" is a very important political step for the Mexican Americans. Mexican Americans are very family oriented, and family is everything to them. (Conover, 1991). Mexican Americans is deeply religious and predominantly Roman Catholics. Many Mexican immigrants arrived to the United States with very little skills. Most of them usually are low income......

Words: 2243 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

The American Dream

...The American Dream 1. Give an outline of how the American Dream is interpreted. Arnold Schwarzenegger writes that with hard work and determination he managed to make his dream come through in America. He says, that he understands the immigrants yearning for freedom and opportunity, but that to get those and to get success you have to work hard and give something back to America. He thinks, that one of the most important things to do to be able to fit in and blend in to the American culture is to learn the language. Not out of duty, but to be able to be a part of the everyday life in America and get the best out the cultural life of America. The second thing, he thinks, is important to get a good life in America is to participate in the democracy and to be involved in how America ended out to be, as it is today. The last thing, that he considers important, is to give something back to the America who has been welcoming you. It doesn’t have to be much; just something that helps people or something that makes a difference, small or big, in other people’s lives. Arnold Schwarzenegger believes, that your dreams can come true in America and that everything can be achieved, but not without hard work. Anya Kamenetz claims that the “old” American Dream is wounded. She is of the belief that the young Americans need a new and edited American dream, where the assumption of the dreams aren’t money and material things but a dream based on a social safety net, more time for the......

Words: 1066 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

American Dream

...American Dream: It is a well-known fact that the term “American Dream” first mentioned by James Trusslow Adams in 1931 (Wright 197) explains the model of an individual’s ideal existence, which is applied exclusively to the US – the country full of freedoms, possibilities, and opportunities. Nowadays the fame about the American dream reached all continents, and more and more people take the concept for granted dreaming about moving to America and spending the rest of their lives in a more favourable environment compared to their own. As many US citizens, they usually ignore the fact that hard work has always served as a background in the given concept (Warschauer) and look forward to gain all amenities of existence at once. Now I would like to express my commitment to the idea of American dream and briefly describe my negative work experience. Some may think of this experience as of something providing a push toward the perspective future, some may not agree. In any case, this is our contemporary reality that forms our perceptions of what we pursue and what we would like to achieve. Some years ago, I spent my summer vacations working as a sales assistant in a large food store that offered a full range of products. I was responsible for the department mostly with fresh and frozen meat. My duties included cutting, chopping, wrapping, and placing labels on the products, each specifying the product type. My uniform was pretty awkward: a green T-shirt and a white overall that......

Words: 1561 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mexican American

...Mexican Americans There are many ethnicity cultures and race in the world. One of such ethnic groups is Hispanics. Hispanics can be identified or categorized in such ethnic groups. Hispanic Americans are Mexican with origin in a country of Latin American and countries in Europe such as Portugal and Spain. Under the Hispanic sub group we do find Mexican American who are Americans with Mexican decent. The median age of Mexican American is 24 years, which makes them the youngest Hispanic groups. In fact, 71 percent of the Mexican- Americans population is under 35. (U.S Bureau of the Census. , March 1989). The average size of the Mexican- American household is at 4.1 persons is the largest among the Hispanic groups. Through the early 1900’s Mexican Americans were mainly in rural and agricultural people, but today 90% of the populations is estimated to live in metropolitan areas. 73% of them lived in California and Texas in the 1980’s. Mexican American are the least well educated group among both major Hispanic groups and among the total U.S population. The dropout rate among Mexican American students is estimated at 40 percent or more. (Valdiveso, 1988). Lack of education probably contributes to the fact that as a group, Mexican Americans have lower status occupations than does the U.S populations as a whole. They concentrate on farm work and service occupations. Lower status jobs translate into lower income and higher poverty rates. The median family income of Mexican......

Words: 470 - Pages: 2