Premium Essay

Blue Cross V. Marshfield

In: Other Topics

Submitted By micker8
Words 774
Pages 4
Blue Cross v. Marshfield

Blue Cross/Blue Shield v. Marshfield
Michael Stapleton
Micker8@aol.com

Content

Introduction………………………………………………………………….page 2
Jury and Government Findings……………………………………………...page 2
Concepts Relevant to this Case……………………………………………...page 3
Conclusion…………………………………………………………………..page 4
References…………………………………………………………………...page 5
Blue Cross v. Marshfield

Introduction The Marshfield clinic is a health care system founded in 1916 comprised largely in Wisconsin (Marshfieldclinic.org, 2012). It has 2 hospitals, 53 community care centers, and has about 800 physicians in more than 80 medical specialties and subspecialties-from cardiology, to neurology, to dentistry - provide care at over 50 locations throughout northern, central and western Wisconsin. In 1995, Blue Cross and Blue Shield United of Wisconsin brought a suit against the Marshfield Clinic and Security alleging violations of sections 1 and 2 of the Sherman Act, a federal antitrust statute (Meili & Sarskas, 1996). The Sherman Act of 1890 sections 1 and 2 outlawed restraints of trade (for example, collusive price-fixing and dividing up markets) as well as monopolization (McConnell, Brue, & Flynn, 2012). It argued that the Marshfield clinic used its monopoly power and engaged in collusion with competitors to charge supra-competitive prices for health care services in the region.
Jury and Government Findings In December of 1994, a jury found Marshfield clinic in violation of the Sherman Law and awarded Blue Cross and Blue Shield $48 million on the grounds that it had engaged in anticompetitive, monopolistic practices to restrict the health care market in northern and central Wisconsin (Lutes & Vanderbilt, 1995). Upon appeal, however, the amount of the award was reduced to $17 million and in a written opinion, the court described the damages awarded by the…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield Conversion

...Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield: Non-profit to profit status INTRODUCTION Empire Blue Cross and Blue Shield was one of the most popular and respected insurers of last resort in the United States of America. The fact that this insurance organization was a non-profit company enabled it to offer highly subsidized health insurance covers to the New York population; this greatly benefited low income earners who could not afford to pay the hefty insurance premiums charged by other for-profit organizations in New York. However, on 26th September 1996, Empire Blue Cross and Blue Shield made an official announcement that it was planning to convert from a non-profit organization to a fully-fledged for-profit company. This meant that the huge number of New Yorkers who had obtained individual health insurance cover from Empire Blue Cross and Blue Shield would have to seek alternatives which would more or less expose them to greater health risks. (Robinson, 2003) The only subscribers who wouldn’t be affected by Empire Blue Cross and Blue Shield conversion were the 850 policy holders who had permanent disability. This marked the start of an extensive legal, community and political tussle pitting the various stakeholders who had different kinds of interests in Empire Blue Cross and Blue Shield. Experts argued that this conversion plan was a......

Words: 4691 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Blue

...The History of the Blues * In my Assignment I will be mostly taking about the ways that the blues has influenced culture. So what did the blues influence…? Everything. The blues influenced nearly every genre of music that came after it. Jazz in all of its various styles and flavors. From just a basic 12bars you get everything that you need in order to play great music. It’s not like without the blues we would not have any current music actually it’s a lot like that. The influence of blues can even be seen in the classical music of the later Romantic period as well as in various aspects of Contemporary classical music. Literally every style of music that’s come out in the past eighty or more years has once or a few times borrowed something from the blues. To think the whole world would of changed if there was not the blues, or slavery for that matter. To think we would not even have big band music or loud electric guitars, or a guy going yo yo into a microphone. * When you think of the blues, you think about misfortune, betrayal and regret. You lose your job, you get the blues. Your mate falls out of love with you, you get the blues. Your dog dies, you get the blues. * While blues lyrics often deal with personal adversity, the music itself goes far beyond self-pity. The blues is also about overcoming hard luck, saying what you feel, ridding yourself of frustration, letting your hair down, and simply having fun. The best blues is visceral, cathartic, and......

Words: 967 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Herrick V. Wild Blue Berry

.... S. HERRICK CO. v. MAINE WILD BLUEBERRY CO. Supreme Judicial Court of Maine, 1996. 670 A.2d 944. BACKGROUND AND FACTS E. S. Herrick Company grows and sells blueberries. Maine Wild Blueberry Company agreed to buy all of Herricks 1990 crop under a contract that left the price unliquidated. Herrick delivered the berries, but a dispute arose over the price. Maine Wild sent Herrick a check with a letter that stated the check was the final settlement. Herrick cashed the check but filed a suit in a Maine state court against Maine Wild, on the ground of breach of contract, alleging that the buyer owed more. The court awarded Herrick some, but not all, of the damages sought. Both parties appealedHerrick contended that it was owed more, and Maine Wild that it owed less. Question* * * [A]n accord and satisfaction is created by cashing a check that is accompanied by a letter bearing restrictive language. * * * * Maine Wild considered the check to be the final payment. Herricks president admitted that he read the letter that included the language regarding final settlement but interpreted it as a statement made by Maine Wild not as a condition between them. He admits that he cashed the check, but that it did not occur to him that by cashing the check he was surrendering any claim under the contract.  * * * The language in the letter, however, was unambiguous. It represented final settlement, and there is no exchange of correspondence of such a nature as to create doubt as to what......

Words: 318 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Blues Paper

...The Blues: “Music that Reflects Our Ancestors Cry” Mable Osemwegie Table of Contents Introduction…………………………………………………………………..3 Congo Square(past and present)……………………………...……………...4 Story of Storyville/ The Chitlin’ Circuit…………………………………….5 Blues Personality Profile……………………………………………………..6 Words of Blues Song…………………………………………………………7 Blues Instruments…………………………………………………………….8 Jazz Personality Profile……………………………………………………..9 Words of Jazz Song…………………………………………………………10 Original Blues Song…………………………………………………………11 Afterword……………………………………………………………………12 Introduction Blues has its deepest roots in the work songs of the West African slaves in the South. During their back-breaking work in the fields of the Southern plantation owners, black slaves developed a "call and response" way of singing to give rhythm to the drudgery of their servitude. These "field hollers" served as a basis of all blues music that was to follow. Although the lyrics of many blues songs are soulful and melancholy, the music as a whole is a powerful, emotive and rhythmic music celebrating the life of black Americans. The lyrics of the songs reflected daily themes of their lives including: sex, drinking, railroads, jail, murder, poverty, hard labor and love lost. Congo Square (past) Congo Square was a market area where African slaves could sell their wares on “free days.” Though legally slaves were forbidden from owning any kind of property, gathering in large groups, or......

Words: 1970 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Blue

...Blue At all times people have been curious about whether there is a life after death. Nobody knows exactly what happens after you die. We can only guess making up stories and building theories. Tim Pears’ story “Blue” describes the events of three days after Joseph Howard’s death. The narration is unusual. The author uses a limited omniscient narrator. The main character of the story, Joseph Howard, is an observer. “He knew he’d died at three o’clock in the afternoon of Wednesday, July the 27th, 1988, the moment he woke up in the room that he’d come to hate”. Here we also get to know how the disease began to attack his body. He was declining in the starched sheets of his bed. He gradually lost his huge appetite, he lost weight turning into “a skinny wraith whose ribs where showing for the first time in 50 years”. The pain moved around his body “like a poacher in the night searching for a vulnerable deer in the pinewoods”. It had first attacked him in his heel, then in the neck, back… The pain was what had wrecked him cause he always thought he was impervious to pain. He knew it was a lung cancer, “since he’d smoked 40 untipped cigarettes a day since the age of 15”. Now the only way to get rid of this increasing pain was using drugs and putting himself in the world with no sensation, with no sense. The next day his doctor, Dr. Buckle, paid him a visit checking his condition and stating it was an impressive respite of disease. So Joseph went to the garden just......

Words: 541 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Blues

...Finding Light through the Darkness In James Baldwin’s short story, “Sonny’s Blues”, the narrator which is Sonny’s brother, James attempts to understand the life of his younger brother Sonny. Through trials and tribulations both brothers see the light through the darkness that surrounds both of their lives. From childhood to adulthood, both brothers go through experiences, which would have an everlasting effect on their lives. The story is set in Harlem, New York City approximately after the Korean War. The brothers' military service plays an important role in the socio-historical context of the story. The narrator refers to being "home on leave from the army" during the war; he remarks that his father "died suddenly, during a drunken weekend in the middle of the war, when Sonny was fifteen", and he informs the reader that both he and Sonny served in the military. It is important to notice and understand these references to the military service of the brothers. The characters in "Sonny's Blues" reflect this tendency: As a teenager, Sonny yearns to enlist in the army or navy because it would take him away from the "killing streets" of Harlem and give him the opportunity to get a college education on the GI Bill. The narrator, too, has struggled in spite of his military service to his country to attain success and safety at home. He fought the war, returned home to become an algebra teacher, and a productive member of the middle class, and yet because of......

Words: 333 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Blues

...investigar las distintas facetas del Blues y cómo este fue evolucionando a través de la historia. Una vez presentada la interrogante es posible definir los objetivos principales que fundamentalmente consisten en que el músico logre obtener las herramientas para desarrollar el sonido y lenguaje del Blues y saber aplicar los conocimientos obtenidos para transformar un tema de cualquier estilo en un Blues. La forma de trabajo consiste en realizar escuchas de exponentes del estilo para luego transcribirlas y analizarlas. Luego, se procederá a realizar ejercicios de frases y técnica para finalmente llevar a cabo la modificación de un tema pop, rock, jazz o folclórico en un Blues. ÍNDICE DEDICATORIA AGRADECIMIENTOS RESUMEN I- INTRODUCCIÓN II- BLUES, LA MÚSICA DEL DIABLO 2.1 Estilo y Estructura 2.2 Etimología III- ANTECEDENTES QUE DESENCADENARON EN EL BLUES 3.1 Tiempos de Esclavitud 3.2 Cantos de trabajo y Hollers 3.3 Inserción de una nueva religión 3.4 Llega la libertad IV- DIFERENCIACIÓN DE ESTILOS SEGÚN LA ÉPOCA Y UBICACIÓN GEOGRÁFICA. 4.1 Blues Rural. • Delta Blues • Texas Blues • Louisiana Blues 4.2 Blues Urbano. • Blues Urbano Acústico • Invención de la Cápsula Eléctrica • Blues Urbano Eléctrico V-EJEMPLOS DE LICKS BLUES VI- EJERCICIOS TÉCNICOS EN BASE A LOS ESTILOS ANALIZADOS. VI- ADAPTACIÓN AL BLUES DE TEMAS......

Words: 16049 - Pages: 65

Free Essay

A Blue

...Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue Blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue blue......

Words: 360 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cross

...Non-Verbal Communication: The “Silent” Cross-Cultural Contact With Indonesians A. Non-Verbal Communication This paper reviews key issues in cross-cultural communication; verbal communication and non-verbal communication. Verbal communication is defined as spoken communication, including the use of words and intonation to convey meaning. On the other hand, non-verbal communication is “silent” communication, including the use of gestures, postures, position, eye contact, facial expressions, and conversational distance. The issue of non-verbal communication is related to the teaching of Indonesian to speakers of other languages. The learners studying Indonesian should not only be equipped with the language itself but also the Indonesian culture because “……………to know another’s language and not his culture is a very good way to make a fluent fool of one’s self”(Brembeck, Winston:1977) and “Culture hides much more than it reveals, and strangely enough, what it hides, it hides most effectively from its own participants”(Hall, Edward T:1959). The paper will limit itself to non-verbal communication or speaking without words, not verbal communication. It will put emphasis on the importance of non-verbal communication concepts, because without them, a real communication can not be conducted smoothly and successfully. Moreover, the paper is also going to explore the similarities and differences of non-verbal communication between Indonesians and non-Indonesian......

Words: 1634 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Blues vs. Country Music

...Blues vs Country music According to Etta James in an interview with American Chronicle: "The Blues and country are first cousins ... What I look for in a song is for the story to be for real. I like a blood and guts kind of thing. That's what you find in the lyrics of country music." Blues and country music both developed in the 19th century in the Southern United States. They share a similar history. For this reason, they share many of the same musical and lyrical characteristics. Read more: How to Compare Blues & Country Music | eHow.com http://www.ehow.com/how_5888119_compare-blues-country-music.htInstructions 1. * 1 Learn the history behind blues and country music. They are both forms of American folk music influenced by earlier styles brought overseas. Blues music grew out of field hollers and chants sung by African slaves. Irish and Scottish balladeers borrowed the guitar and banjo of blues and thus created "country". According to Reebee Garofalo in "Rockin' Out: Popular Music in the USA", "Terms like country and blues are only used to separate the same kind of music made by blacks and whites ... designations like race and hillbilly intentionally separated artists along racial lines and conveyed the impression that their music came from mutually exclusive sources." Country is an offshoot of blues. They are essentially the same thing. In the PBS special, "Rhythm, Country and Blues," country is referred to as "white man's blues." * 2 Listen......

Words: 13547 - Pages: 55

Premium Essay

Virgin Blue

...EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This Virgin Blue will be discussing about Virgin Blue history and when it began, its establishment as the first low fare airline in Australia. This report will also examine about Virgin Blue’s business model their advantages, in the market as a low fare airline and their financial circumstances that the airline industries have faced during their operation. In Australia first low fare airline, the report will analyze how they are keeping their position in the competitive market airline and what are their plans for expansion. Virgin Blue’s marketing strategy will be included to analyze their “no thrills” method. Further on the marketing strategy, the report will analyze how Virgin Blue manages their operations in a way to expend their target market across Australia effectively. This report will further examine how their future plans can give them the opportunity to take on the big competitor in the Australian airline industry like Qantas, Jet airways and Tiger. As summery of Virgin Blue’s financial report will be discussing how their profit and loss margin is performing and the risks that the Virgin Blue could be facing on their restructuring scheme. By anticipating, Virgin Blue’s plan, the report will discuss how the plan will be implement and how effective and efficiently will this approach be internationally. 1. HISTORY (Marketing Situation) I. AUSTRALIAN AIRLINE HISTORY : The idea of passengers flying between cities in Australia was......

Words: 2260 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Blue

...Blue is the colour between violet and green on the optical spectrum of visible light. Human eyes perceive blue when observing light with a wavelength between 450 and 495 nanometres. Blues with a higher frequency and thus a shorter wavelength gradually look more violet, while those with a lower frequency and a longer wavelength gradually appear more green. Pure blue, in the middle, has a wavelength of 470 nanometres. In painting and traditional colour theory, blue is one of the three primary colours of pigments, along with red and yellow, which can be mixed to form a wide gamut of colours. Red and blue mixed together form violet, blue and yellow together form green. Blue is also a primary colour in the RGB colour model, used to create all the colours on the screen of a television or computer monitor. The modern English word blue comes from Middle English bleu or blewe, from the Old French bleu, a word of Germanic origin, related to the Old High German word blao.[2] The clear sky and the deep sea appear blue because of an optical effect known as Rayleigh scattering. When sunlight passes through the atmosphere, the blue wavelengths are scattered more widely by the oxygen and nitrogen molecules, and more blue comes to our eyes. Rayleigh scattering also explains blue eyes; there is no blue pigment in blue eyes. Distant objects appear more blue because of another optical effect called atmospheric perspective. Blue has been used for art, decoration and as a clothing dye since......

Words: 543 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Billy's Blues

...Hear When I Listen to Billie Holiday’s “Billie’s Blues” Tyler Brady Intro to Music: Term Paper Dr. Burns In the 19th century, a very prominent genre and musical form emerged from the Deep South of America; often defined as a repetitive and poetic music structure derived from jazz, blues music became an influential role in the astounding American identity. On the basis of originality and artistry, Billie Holiday is noted as one of the most influential jazz and blues singers. Throughout a dark life of poverty, drugs and adversity that arose from sexism and racism, Billie Holiday turned to her passion of music and singing. One of “Lady Day’s” most well-known pieces was recorded in 1936 and was titled “Billie’s Blues” This piece is structured as a 12-bar blues piece with a short introduction and six choruses. Throughout this blues song, there is a repetitive and invigorating harmonic pattern present. “Billie’s Blue’s” reflects a very laid back style through Holiday’s signature “lazy” style using many jazz embellishments such as blue notes; moreover, these melodies sung by Billie Holiday, as well as the two improvised solos performed by Bunny Berigan and Arty Shaw, are extremely artistic and original. In despite of a poverty stricken life filled with drug abuse and adversity, Billie Holiday was able to establish herself as a prominent blues and jazz singer; she was able to display this in “Billie’s Blues,” a 12-bar blues piece, with exceptional use of harmony and......

Words: 1778 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Origin of Blues

...Origin of Blues Blues played an important role in the history of music as it heavily influenced many types of music, particularly jazz and rock. It originated around the 1890’s from the Afro-American slaves’ folk music, work songs and spirituals and was typically performed with one person both playing the guitar and singing. The music consisted of stories of family, struggle, sexuality and rural life. The beginning of the blues-singing period was during the Civil War in America. In 1863, President Lincoln adopted the Emancipation Proclamation into Law, which gave the slaves the freedom not to be bought and sold as slaves, to send their children to school, to be able to live with their families in a house rather than a slave cabin, to attend church and the opportunity to become teachers, preachers, politicians and landowners. This gave them a new attitude towards life. They began to sing openly without concern of white mans punishment, which also allowed them to explore and experiment with white 8 and 16 bar songs. Blues in its early days was a direct decent of African question and answer phrases but now it started to develop when it adopted the 3 line stanza (AAB) then furthermore into 12 bars. Although the blues music was influenced by European music the essential blue chords (I, IV, V) were from American music culture, which was most likely originated from their religious music. In between 1911 – 1914 W.C. Handy made blues popular. He released “Memphis......

Words: 349 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Blue Ocean

...be divided into two segments: the red ocean and the blue ocean. The red ocean is comprised of existing market segments and this space contains all things in existence today. The competition in this space is fierce. Conversely, the blue ocean represents all things not in existence today or the opportunity to reengineer an established industry. The framework for formulating a Blue Ocean Strategy is explained in the following paragraphs. The first principle is reconstructing market boundaries. When creating a Blue Ocean Strategy, an entrepreneur must look within an existing industry and think beyond the current boundaries. Reengineering an established practice within an industry or creating something new will enable an entrepreneur to create a new market segment or maybe even a new industry. The company should look across alternative industries, consumer groups, and at other products or services that may help complement their own. By utilizing this cross-cultural approach, opportunity is created for the growth and development of a new market. The second principle when initially creating a strategy is for an entrepreneur to focus on the big picture and not the details. If the big picture is understood, the details will be easier to put into place. Without a big picture focus, creativity and innovation could get lost in the details. Corporate strategy must include big picture thinking. Breaking into a blue ocean market requires companies to look at the......

Words: 558 - Pages: 3