Premium Essay


In: Film and Music

Submitted By biancacardona
Words 2425
Pages 10
A killer whale at its center, Blackfish is the first documental since Grizzly Man to show the reality of these captivated animals. This documental was released July 18, 2013; directed by Gabriela Cowperthwaite, what she presents to us is just something that needs to be presented to all the people from the planet. She went to the park and met the chief zoological officer Andrews, he’s been in the park since 1986 and he explains “that while part of the goal is entertainment, SeaWorld's aim is to use the shows to educate and inspire visitors, as a way to help conserve the environment and support wildlife.” There are a lot of people that are making interview and giving their opinion for SeaWorld to close and one of theme is the 81-year-old primatologist Jane Goodall said “whales and dolphins should never be held in captivity, and that the entertainment company known for its orca shows should be shuttered.” This film exposed the misery endured by SeaWorld's trained orca and the dangers posed to trainers working with stressed-out carnivorous whales. But to continue with my argument let me explain to you what is the documental of Blackfish.

Movie Summary Report John Hargrove and Samantha Berg, a former SeaWorld trainer, tell why they decided to work with these animals, other trainers continue telling their story about how the decided to be a trainer for killer whales. They just fell in love with these creatures and they knew that was their future. To become a trainer of these or other sea animals they have to be in a good shape, be a professional swimmer, have personality, be prepare for all type of situation since you don’t know what could happened in the moment. To enter to the water with them the trainer have to trust the animal and the animal have to trust you, is like there are about to become your best friend. They can sense if the person is…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Biases Present in Blackfish

...Blackfish is a documentary that tells the story of Tilikum, a "notoriously aggressive" orca who has been linked to the deaths of three individuals while being kept in captivity. The film, told largely by five former SeaWorld trainers, uses highly emotional footage to portray Tilikum as an animal that has been negatively impacted by his life at SeaWorld. Blackfish is advertised as a documentary but, in reality, is little more than propaganda, and rather than providing impartial and balanced information, the film uses inaccurate and deceptive facts in a clear example of how bias is used in the media to portray a certain view to the audience. The film misrepresents the orca species as a whole by saying that "they're amazingly friendly and understanding and intuitively want to be your companion." This implies that killer whales are naturally amicable and respectful to humans. Blackfish shows footage of an orca interacting with a dog to justify this statement, but does not explain that the orca shown in that video was an abandoned juvenile named Luna who had been living in Nootka Sound for five years, where he was constantly exposed to human presence and activity. The interactions with Luna that are shown in the film are not an accurate representation of the average, well-adjusted, pod-dwelling orca. This footage is shown out of context and makes the false claim that killer whales, as a whole, are more wary of human presence and generally keep to themselves in natural......

Words: 1192 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Killer Whales in their pods it could result in hyper aggression (Blackfish). Killer whales are meant to be free in the ocean swimming with their pods and families, not to be separated and used as show animals or research animals. Many people believe orcas should be in captivity for educational and scientific purposes, but to help better the killer whales they need their natural habitats. At the same time, being in captivity has caused these whales to actually look like killers, but that is not the case with these astounding creatures. Jack Hanna is a Wild Life Expert and board member for SeaWorld-Busch Gardens Conservation Fund says, “If we were to take killer whales out of captivity they would not survive being in the wild for more than two or three days at the most” (Anderson). Hanna also says if anyone was knowledgeable about whales, people would know that it is impossible to put a whale back into the wild after thirty years (Anderson). A SeaWorld trainer, Michael Scarpuzzi refutes about the documentary Blackfish. The articles says how many efforts that were done by SeaWorld were not recognized, and not one trainer spoke a bit about education (Scarpuzzi). Scarpuzzi says “Not one word about the thousands of ill, orphaned and injured animals rescued by SeaWorld or the millions of dollars we dedicated to supporting conservation and research” (Scarpuzzi). The solution is very simple we create sanctuaries for these animals. Blackfish is a documentary produced by Gabriela......

Words: 1408 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Contrast and Compare

...efforts have focused on paying all legitimate claims stemming from the accident and supporting two of the region's most vital industries - tourism and seafood." BP is using its website to admit that it had made a huge mistake and is taking the necessary actions it must to try and "right it’s wrong." The landing page of their website is set up to show the public that its first priority is the environment. This gives the emotional impact of BP’s commitment. BP is a company that still has the job of getting higher profits, but now operates in a manner much better for society and the environment.\ SeaWorld has been the center of attention in a negative way because of an independent documentary made about them called "Blackfish". The documentary's makers feel that the size of the whales tanks, the whales being separated from each other socially and the separation of calves from their mothers at birth is negatively effecting the whales behavior. Over the past several years the whales have acted out against their trainers. SeaWorld Parks and Entertainment has a website audience comprised primarily of families looking for entertainment. On July 25, 2012 a accident at the park located in Orlando where a killer whale killed a trainer by drowning her in front of a live audience. This incident may have turned the caused SeaWorld’s website to be visited by others more interested in the story rather than a vacation. SeaWorld addresses the......

Words: 2033 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Free Tilikum

...argued and scientifically proven that no human being has ever been killed by a killer whale, or orca, in the wild. On the other hand, there at least a dozen documented deaths due to killer whales throughout the world. The main reason this is said to be true is because killer whales, which can grow to be more than 30 feet long and weigh up to 6 tons, are not meant to be kept in tanks and modules that are 20 feet wide and 35 feet deep. These tight living confinements have been proven to cause certain psychoses in animals. (Allen & Flannery 2014) They are essentially giving up the whole ocean for a bathtub. Since Brancheau’s death in 2010, Tilikum has been kept out of the spotlight and has lived a very lonely life. The 2013 documentary, Blackfish, documents Tilikum’s journey since the day he was captured off the coast of Iceland in November of 1983 at around 2 years of age. Since that day, Tilikum has been responsible for three humans’ deaths. He was moved to Sea World in Orlando from San Diego to become their prize stud after a female trainer died after her foot slipped and she fell into the pool with Tilikum in 1991. In 1999, a man had stayed in the park after hours and took a swim with Tilikum. His naked body was found draped over Tilikum the next morning. Dawn’s death in 2010 brings Tilikum to a total of 3 deaths where he was involved. (Rose 2013) When first hearing about the tragic story of Sea World trainer Dawn Brancheau, it is easy to assume that Tilikum acted......

Words: 1835 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...and expects a high performance from staff members. Employees are put through rigorous training to unsure service delivery is of the highest standard. That being said, there is no evidence in the case to suggest that employees are motivated through incentives or a reward system. There does not seem to be well defined criteria against which, performance can be measured. 2.3.8 Director 3 Part B 3.1 External pressures 3.1.1 Environment and social responsibility Sea World is under immense pressure from animal activists due to keeping animals in captivity. Sea World announced its 2014 Quarter 1 earnings, reporting a 13 percent drop in visitor numbers , a notable dip in the wake of the controversy stirred by the documentary “Blackfish” and the park’s captive orcas. The company also reported that its revenue fell 11 percent year-over-year to $212.3 million (Cronlin, 2014). 3.1.2 Health and Safety It has been noted that no attacks on humans by Orcas in the wild; whereas dozens of people have been attached by orcas in captivity. External pressure has resulted in decreased trainer-orca contact which was previously a hugely popular draw card for customers. (National Geographic, 2013) 3.1.3 Negative Publicity from past employees Past employees are publically disclosing actual working conditions and practices which differ from claims by management. It is alleged that: * There is minimal on the job training ant that one does not need to be qualifies to......

Words: 1852 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Industry Aanlysis - Theme Park Industry of Orcas being held in captivity in the well known park, SeaWorld. Through the widely talked about documentary, BlackFish, several hundreds of people had their eyes open to the dreadful truth of SeaWorld and it’s stars. As expressed through the film “[SeaWorld] is a multi-billion dollar corporation that makes its money through the exploitation of Orcas.”(Blackfish) and for this reason many of its customers have turned their back on SeaWorld. This particular controversy will not only be a major threat for SeaWorld but all theme parks that use animals for entertainment purposes. Even though SeaWorld has been known for years as the place to go and see a live show with such majestic creatures, it only takes one incident to change the precipitative of people. For SeaWorld it was the death of orca trainer, Dawn Brancheau, that lead to the creation of Blackfish. In the film it explicitly shows the depressing lives these beautiful creatures live through footages provided from years ago and some from today’s time. Through the wide success of the documentary, large non-profit organizations such as PETA have stepped in and given their two cents on the matter. The combination of well known organizations and the negative perspectives society has can cause for SeaWorld to take a major hit in addition “It will have a ripple effect to the whole industry.” (Blackfish) People see theme parks as a getaway from reality a time to sped with friends and family, not a time to worry if......

Words: 6753 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Black Fish

...attraction to profit off of. Theme parks across the world force these animals to preform tricks for viewer’s amusement, all while living contained in an area the size of a large bathtub. While many parks provide the jobs that come with the experience to see these animals, the conditions in which these animals are kept is really disturbing. After watching the film Blackfish and seeing how brutally these animals are treated it really changes ones perspective of these “amusement” parks. However some parks do rescue sick and mistreated animals for rehabilitation only to release them once the treatment is finished, but ones like SeaWorld take advantage of these beautiful creatures. In the documentary Blackfish director Gabriela Cowperthwaite does an astounding job of portraying this evidence of the Orca whales being taken and abused within the “care” of SeaWorld. Her purpose for creating this film is to increase awareness of the captivity of the Orca whales and the effect it has on the whales and their trainers, also to inform the audience of how SeaWorld misleads the public about the captivity and care of the whales. Blackfish documents and exposes the treatment of Orca whales and their trainers as well as the secretive SeaWorld Corporation. Gabriela Cowperthwaite’s audience was mainly anyone who is concerned about this problem or just wanted to know more on what is really happening to the Orcas at SeaWorld. Her use of diction is how she targets her particular audience. She......

Words: 1101 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Mammal vs. Marine Captivity

...gorilla named Jabari tried to escape by jumping over the walls and moats of his enclosure, only to be fatally shot by police”(PETA). It was later investigated and concluded through a witness that Jabari was placed under extreme distress after being tormented by teenagers who threw large rocks directly at him for an extended period of time. The only ethical permit to allow the existence of zoos should be one that makes the well being of a species present and future a priority. Zoos have lost their purpose and direction. Instead of zeroing in on the needs of their animals, the executives who sit behind a desk and control the money are more focused on the financial and entertainment aspect the zoo has to offer. Just recently the documentary, Blackfish, caused uproar among society by exposing to the inhumane and unjust treatment of sea life at SeaWorld. This single documentary has created one of the largest movements SeaWorld has ever faced; SeaWorld’s corporation is facing the possible loss of every park and any strings attached as a result. Although the potential release of these creatures is great and many marine animals will be rightfully saved, society also needs to open their eyes to zoos as well. SeaWorld and state zoos are shockingly similar with the exception of one holding marine life and the other land mammals. Dr. Jason Watters, Vice President of Wellness and Animal Behavior for the San Francisco Zoo will argue that “Yes, we [San Francisco Zoo] work really hard......

Words: 870 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Black Fish Sources

...Steinman Black fish Summary-This article is a rebuttle to Blackfish’s thesis. It claims that Seaworld is actually not as villainous as Black fish makes them out to be, citing a statement seaworld made about how it rehabilitates animals, is a respected zoological foundation, and donates to conservation research. Despite this, even the writer of the article points out the easily disputable and vague statements which are cited in a message from seaworld to CNN to support the idea that Seaworld is not so terrible to it’s whales and humans. This makes for a weak rebuttle. Importance-This article is a terrible rebuttal. Characteristic of it’s failure is the fact that even the author of the article could not keep a straight train of thought to cement a solid counterargument. What this goes to show is that the counterargument truly is a weak one. Perhaps one of the only good points, presuming its true, that this article has to offer is the one to do with Sea World's monetary contributions to conservation. With Sea World going down the drains due to it’s poor orca practices it will obviously not be able to contribute to conservation, as it’s money is being drained in bad publicity and lawsuits. This will have some impact environmentally presuming that Sea World really was contributing in some meaningful......

Words: 535 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...captivity has proven detrimental to the health and safely of trainers. On Christmas Eve of 2009, Keto a male orca, killed whale trainer Alexis Martinez. Keto stood as a loan on SeaWorld to Loro Praque, in Spain. Only two months later, on February 24th, 2010, trainer Dawn Brancheau killed by a orca named Tilikum, a whale involve in two other human fatalities. ME reports show massive trauma in both fatalities. Neither of these deaths by accident. Keto killed Alexis by mechanical asphyxiation due to compression and crushing of the thoracic abdomen(Blackfish). ME official reports of dawns death avulsion of the scalp, fracture of the 7th cervical vertebra, fracture of the sternum, complete avulsion of the left upper extremity, dislocation of the left elbow, dislocation of the left knee, fracture of the proximal left humerus, fracture of the mandible, hemoperitoneum (500 mL), liver lacerations, softening of the underlying spinal canal, and more (Blackfish). Both are portrayed as accidental and drownings, despite the official reports on how brutal each death was..“Tilikum is not an evil animal – he is a highly intelligent, emotionally complex mammal. And we’ve made him psychotic," says ex-trainer Sam Berg (Boniface). In captivity, more than 70 incidents have been recored of a whale injuring someone. There are more than 100 documented attacks in captivity, but not a single human death has been recored in nature. Although popularly seen as one of the most deadly marine creatures,......

Words: 1212 - Pages: 5

Free Essay


...denticle herring bonytail chub, loosejaw; peladillo sand goby. Ayu whiff Lost River sucker yellowtail snapper pygmy sunfish. Rohu codlet blackchin Redhorse sucker Oregon chub, muskellunge staghorn sculpin; Australian prowfish yellowtail clownfish, flounder. Smalltooth sawfish pikeperch striped bass deepwater cardinalfish, trench rocket danio. Pikehead longjaw mudsucker coho salmon grunion snailfish kahawai mail-cheeked fish electric ray. Albacore crevice kelpfish freshwater flyingfish, white shark roanoke bass, flagfin pelican gulper--grunt luderick rivuline Arctic char, Australian prowfish. Crocodile shark swallower, "blackchin combtail gourami char; temperate perch smoothtongue American sole, blue danio." Sábalo round herring Sacramento blackfish chub tetra, beluga sturgeon worm eel flagfin Old World knifefish deepwater stingray; flathead catfish? Shiner, North American freshwater catfish dwarf gourami largenose fish squirrelfish. Straptail South American darter freshwater herring mud minnow. Spotted dogfish gray mullet sawtooth eel. Ropefish; leaffish tui chub suckermouth armored catfish fusilier fish sand dab swordfish killifish john dory. Old World knifefish, bream, "peacock flounder, lake whitefish Cornish Spaktailed Bream northern clingfish?" Sawtooth eel shark silver driftfish Atlantic cod mouthbrooder, freshwater flyingfish featherfin knifefish woody sculpin; candlefish bullhead Siamese fighting fish longfin dragonfish redside. Pike characid spearfish,......

Words: 743 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Devastating Consequences of Captivating Killer Whales

...We often go to watch killer whale shows without thinking twice about what really happens behind the scenes. As an audience, we simply enjoy the show, and then leave. But behind all the tricks and splashes, lies an ugly truth about the state of killer whales at theme parks. In the documentary Blackfish, directed by Gabriela Cowperthwaite, killer whales are naturally affectionate, harmless to humans, and strongly family-oriented. However, when held captive in unnatural environments, killer whales will show a malfunction in behavior, causing injuries and deaths of trainers. The techniques used to show this are communicative function and illumination theory of truth. To begin, the first technique used in this documentary is communicative function. Communicative function is implemented to inform viewers of the message the documentary is trying to convey. In the context of the documentary, the evidence and statistics prove the danger that comes with captivating killer whales. For example, Tilikum, the famous orca at SeaWorld, killed three killer whale trainers. This technique is used to inform the viewers of the violent behavior demonstrated by captivated killer whales. This technique allows us to observe the aggressive behavior shown by the orcas towards its trainer. In this documentary, an OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) expert stated, “what we learned, is that they are amazingly friendly and......

Words: 819 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Captivity Breeds Agression

...Captivity Breeds Aggression Lucas Terry Colorado Technical University March 1, 2015 In human history, captivity, slavery, and colonization resulted to uprisings, revolts, and revolutions elsewhere in the world. The numerous human histories on this matter can be equated to how animals in captivity resort to aggressive actions that even escalate to killings. In the documentary movie entitled “Blackfish,” no matter how the lawyers and spokespersons of Sea World argue against the idea that the killings of trainers were caused by the aggressiveness of the killer whales, it always boils down to the philosophy that the oppressed creatures naturally fights back. And if the killer whales fight back, pitiful are the trainers who will get victimized. “Blackfish” is a documentary of how ORCAs like Tilikum were captivated in various environments and put to captivity to be trained for animal shows. The documentary presents the owners of the animal show businesses like Sea World as the villains while the former trainers of Sea World who disclosed issues about the killings of their colleagues, and all the informants who told the truth are the heroes. The good thing about the documentary is that they have variety of sources. They even spoke to the diver that who explained how ORCAs are captured. That person was even one of those who captured Tilikum. The documentary also put in the film how the killer whales were trained and tamed by specialist who used their knowledge on......

Words: 805 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...El efecto "Blackfish": ¿llegará el fin de los parques acuáticos? Jaime GonzálezBBC Mundo, Los Ángeles, @bbc_gonzalez 26 marzo 2014 Dawn Brancheau era una experimentada entrenadora de orcas cuando en febrero de 2010, frente a un numeroso grupo de espectadores, falleció durante un espectáculo en el parque acuático SeaWorld de Orlando, en Florida. Brancheau, de 40 años, murió después de que la orca Tilikum la agarrara en sus fauces y la arrastrara en repetidas ocasiones al fondo de la piscina en la que estaba realizando el show. Pese a que Tilikum -un macho de siete metros de longitud y 5.400 kilos de peso- ya había estado involucrado en la muerte de otras dos personas, en esa época seguía siendo una de las principales atracciones de SeaWorld. ¿Qué llevó al animal a matar a Brancheau? ¿Fue culpa de la entrenadora, como dieron a entender los responsables del parque en los días posteriores a su muerte? ¿Tuvieron algo que ver las condiciones en las que las orcas son mantenidas en cautividad o simplemente se trataba de un espécimen agresivo? Todas estas incógnitas fueron las que llevaron a la cineasta estadounidense Gabriela Cowperthwaite a embarcarse en la producción "Blackfish", un documental que desde que se estrenó a principios de 2013 en el Festival de Sundance ha desatado un encendido debate en Estados Unidos sobre la manera en las que las orcas viven el los parques acuáticos. El filme -que ha tenido una amplia repercusión después de que el canal CNN lo emitiera en......

Words: 1914 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Statistics for Business and Economics

...sector and within the "adventure travel" niche of that sector. Alternative 2: Attempt new Types of Marketing Greywell has a unique marketing opportunity of using the newly developed media (TV, Internet,and so on) that are tearing down the walls of geography, enabling companies to create entirelynew businesses and tapping markets they could never have reached before. This implies aproliferation of services unimagined in the past. Alternative 3: Move to Another Location In Greywell's business, there are basically three kinds of scuba diving available: beach diving,boat diving, and wreck diving. Beach diving involves moving into the surf or off jetties at pointsproviding up to 10-20-foot visibility. Lobsters, crabs, striped bass and blackfish are plentiful insome spots. Boat diving involves Greywell arranging trips to take divers to unique locations. Wreck diving involves visits to vessels long since sunk, at depths ranging from 35 to 110 feet. The wrecks are now home to all sorts of sea life, including lobsters, and provide interesting glimpses of seafaring life of other eras. Wreck diving requires a higher level of diving certification and various precautions. Whether or not Greywell would find similar locations that offer what he already has is moot. Before suggesting an alternative, it is wise to consider Greywell's current cash position as shown in the Case Study's balance sheet.   CORAL DIVERS RESORTIntroduction Coral Divers Resort had a comfortable niche in......

Words: 2050 - Pages: 9