Free Essay

Being the Judge

In: Other Topics

Submitted By Yes15
Words 1252
Pages 6
BEING THE JUDGE: WEIGHING EVIDENCE

Student’s Name

Prof’s Name

Course Title

Date

The case involves Ms. Cluster and her neighbors who live in the next to her. Ms. Cluster secretly takes the photo of her friends without permission using the wrist watch camera. In the pictures, they show the neighbor relaxing and reveal a pet that is playing. She goes ahead to use the photos in her book known as the ‘My Neighbor'. On seeing this, Ms. Cluster’s neighbor sues her to the court of law for invading her private life without permission. She claims that the aim of Ms. Cluster was to invade her secret life by the photo exhibition in her book ‘My Neighbor'. Ms. Cluster claims that the photos had no justified expectation of privacy under any circumstances. She claims that the photograph did not show any intimate moments in the lives of the resident. With the case presented the judge gives the jurisdiction of the case. The modern technology has come with a lot of inventions. The wrist watch camera or the spy cameras are one of the most improved and current technology. The wrist watch camera is a fashionable watch and a surveillance device with durable materials. Its stylish design enables it to be worn in any situation. They are undetectable mini pinhole cameras that allow the device to shoot videos and cameras. The surveillance wrist watch camera is mostly used in crime investigation and business negotiation. In our case, Ms. Cluster used the device to her neighbor and captured some photos privately. The camera allows one to explore someone without their conscious or noticing. They also give room to exploit someone's private life. It is not easy to notice someone is capturing your movements. The device maintains high secrecy in its investigation (Edward Thompson, 1985). According to this case, Ms. Cluster’s neighbors hold a claim against her neighbor. She claims on the secret photograph taking, privacy life interference, neighborhood interference and use of the private device for investigating her. According to the law, one is only allowed to use wrist watch cameras under certain circumstances. The device are used if investigating a court case or business issues. However, this is not the case with Ms. Cluster because her reasons for using the device were not justified. She did not have any filed case against her neighbor or any business matters she was investigating. Although she claims that she had not captured her intimate moments, the court finds it liable to file a case for Ms. Cluster for violating the right to privacy of her neighbor (McKinney, W, 1996). According to the law, it is unethical for an individual to interrupt to one's private life unless they are investigating a case. Private exploring is acceptable whereby one have a filed crime against someone. In this instance Ms. Cluster took photographs without consent from her neighbor, and she had no filed case against her neighbors and therefore, she had not right to invade her life and capture private pictures without her consent. According to the law, she is liable to punishment for invading her neighbor's life and captures photo that she afterward put in her book. As a judge, Ms. Cluster's neighbor had the right to claim that her neighbor had interfered with her life (Edward Thompson, 1985). The issue of taking private photographs has become very frequent in the public places, in homes, schools and even in transportation. Many people are accused of taking pictures to people without consent. Due to the alarming cases of secret photos, police are ordering people to stop taking these photos. Those who fall victims the law is on them. In this case, Ms. Cluster is accused of taking photographs of her neighbors without her consent. This is seen as an offense before the law. She was not supposed to take those photographs without the permission of her neighbor. Rather than taking the photos, she goes ahead and displays the photos to a public book. Ms. Cluster's neighbor had supporting evidence of the photographs that were taken because they had been revealed in the book ‘My Neighbor' as a judge the claims of the neighbor are clear because she had supporting evident. Again, Ms. Cluster did not explain why she had to take those photographs and display them. She did not have a supportive argument as to why she took the pictures therefore she was liable to the accusations (McKinney, W, 1996). Although the technology is advanced, and there are wrist watch cameras, as a journalist it is unethical to take photographs that are not necessary. The case with Ms. Cluster she misused her power as a reporter whereby they are entitled to pictures which are relevant. By taking her neighbor picture and also their pet, it was not acceptable because this was not related to the public. If anything is to be displayed to the public, according to the law, one must have consent and permission. Ms. Cluster did not bother to get permission from her neighbor but take the authority to take the photographs (McKinney, W, 1996). According to the neighborhood rules and law, it is prohibited to interfere with one's neighbor activities. This is a violation of their private rights. No one should come in and interfere with the neighbor life especially in those apartments where people are many. Ms. Cluster went ahead and interfered with her neighbor's life and revealed some of her private life which she did not think it was wrong. This brings problem and issues between the neighbors. They will start quarrying and argument and blaming each other. Therefore, it is advisable that people should live their lives especially those living in apartments. In this case, this was the beginning of problems and issues between Ms. Cluster and her neighbor and that's why she accuses her. As a judge, the journalist owed apologies to her neighbor for interfering with her life as a friend (Edward Thompson, 1985). Based on this case, as a judge my ruling would be based on the two complainants. First, the journalist claims were not supportive as to why she took the private photographs from her neighbor without the consent. Although she claims that she had not shown any of her intimate moment, it was not enough to let her go. She had to face penalties on the allegations against her. She is supposed to pay fines for interfering with her neighbor's life, taking her photographs, using the wristwatch on the job. Although there is room for her to defend herself from the allegations. On the side of her neighbor who have sued Ms. Cluster for invading her private life and taking the photograph. This shows Ms. Cluster had violated her individual right and disrespectful to her. The neighbor had a genuine claim because she had evident in the photographs exhibited in Ms. Clusters book ‘My Neighbor'. Her neighbor was bound to complain because she did not the intention Ms. Cluster had when taking pictures. Also, she had fear because she did not know how many times her neighbor have interfered with her life without her consent. My ruling is based on each complaint claim and the evidence each person has. Therefore, each one of them should get fair ruling and reasonable fines according to the claims against them (Edward Thompson, 1985).

REFERENCES

1. Edward Thompson. (1985). Contracts: Reprinted from ruling case law, VOL6 for law school purposes only. Northport.
2. McKinney, W. (1996). Ruling case law. Northport: Edward Thompson.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Judge

...Read the passage carefully and then answer the questions that follow it. Human passions have mysterious ways, in children as well as grown-ups. Those affected by them can’t explain them, and those who haven’t known them have no understanding of them at all. Some people risk their lives to conquer a mountain peak. No-one, not even they themselves, can really explain why. Others ruin themselves to win the heart of a certain person who wants nothing to do with them. Still others are destroyed by their devotion to the pleasures of the table. Some are so bent on winning a game of chance that they lose everything they own, and some sacrifice everything for a dream that can never come true. Some think their only hope of happiness lies in being somewhere else, and so they spend their whole lives travelling from place to place. And some find no rest until they have become powerful. In short, there are as many different passions as there are people. Bastian Balthazar Bux’s passion was books. If you have never spent whole afternoons with burning ears and rumpled hair, forgetting the world around you over a book, forgetting cold and hunger - If you have never read secretly under the bedclothes with a torch, because your father or mother or some other well-meaning person has switched off the lamp on the plausible ground that it was time to sleep because you had to get up so early - If you have never wept tears because a wonderful story has come to an end and you......

Words: 379 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Judge

...played a part in the cessation of the plaintiff? There are several inquiries that must be responded before a ruling can be made in this case. Did the company have the right to terminate Elaine without providing an explanation of the reasons that took the owner to make a decision to rescind her services? Are there satisfactory suggestions to a violation of the business ethics as an employer or discrimination against Elaine? Was the employment contract a valid contract or was it merely a paper on the table. (Henry p. 204) Elaine has needs to become a person who will need to look for the proofs to prove that the termination of her services was unlawful. Elaine estates that was terminated in a wrong way just because she thinks her she is being part of sex discrimination. The plaintiff arguments: Elaine arguments that the job offer provided grounds for career opportunities at the company in question and stated that her annual salary would be $30,000. Although the employer is an “at will” employer, it is not required to have employment contracts, the job offer letter substantiates a contract once it was accepted. Elaine argues that she has been discriminated against because Jerry hired a man named Kramer, who had less job experience and education than Elaine, for the position. She is the victim of wrongful termination by her former employer, and because of this she should be reinstated to her former position within the company. While the defendant in this case is an......

Words: 424 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Be the Judge

...an “at will employer”. The opportunity promised by her employer was given to another worker named Kramer who had less experience and a lower level of education than Elaine. The lawsuit is based upon wrongful termination and she looks to get her job back. The legal issues in this case involve the promise of job opportunities. With the company being an “at will” employer does that relieve them of offering an explanation as to their reasons for firing Elaine? Did the employer violate any ethics or discrimination laws in terminating her position? Is there sufficient evidence on behalf of the plaintiff that can prove such violations took place? Elaine and her attorney will focus on a statutory exception or a contract exception. Elaine received an offer letter promising great career opportunities which included an annual salary of $30,000. Elaine’s attorney may use this to argue that long-term employment was implied and that she was fired without just cause. Discrimination could be a part of Elaine’s case in that someone else; a man with less experience and education was given the position that she had been promised. She was fired without being given any reason for doing so, which also gives this argument credibility. Elaine’s case has merit and but requires the burden of proof to each element of her complaint. The exceptions that could be used in her case against Jerry other than sexual discrimination, are the Tort Exceptions, Implied-In-Fact Contracts, Statutory Exceptions, and......

Words: 1442 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Judge

...Tan Nguyen Judge People Based on Their Appearance Since the time we were children, we were told not to "judge a book by its cover." However, there are some instances where this is not only helpful, but necessary. For example, if I see someone who is a bad student, I can make the decision to avoid that person and not to make friend. Thus, judging people based on appearance is a very useful skill that can aid me through the rest of my long life. There are a lot of ways to judge people, one of them is food and how that person eats the food. As a beginner, I think a restaurant is a great place to start because I can also judge people by what they are eating and how they eat. For example, last weekend I went to Cheesecake Factory with my friends in Oakridge Mall. I saw a couple, and the man were eating steak, and the woman were eating a vegetarian dish. I think that man may has or will has problem with his health, beause meat eaters always have blood problem and intestinal diseases, obesity. The man maybe often impulsive. In life, he tasted much experience failure as well as success. The woman needs to be careful when choosing him to be her your colleagues or husband because they rarely remain calm and always reacted with criticism or blame. But the woman is different, she were eatting with her mouth shut, and she didn’t make any sound while she was chewing. The personality of this very carefully and always be cautious in all matters. She might has worked well with all the......

Words: 685 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Eval and Judge

...There are several different methods that we evaluate and judge other people. Fist we have to get an impression of someone before we begin to evaluate or judge them. There are several different characteristics we notice right away when we first meet someone, such as how well they are dressed and how well they take care of themselves as far as grooming. We put each of these characteristics into a schema. A schema is a set of expectations about something that is based on past experiences and is assumed to correct about everything in that category (Maisto & Morris, 2010). If this person’s appearance is unkempt, then we will assume that they are someone who just does not care about their appearance, but something else may be causing this person to become a slob that we are unaware of. There is a self-fulfilling prophecy that is the process by which we expect something from someone, such as expecting them to be friendly, and we act as if they are friendly. This person will then show us friendly traits (Maisto & Morris, 2010). Stereotyping is another way that we evaluate people. Stereotypes are a set of characteristics that are believed to be shared by all members of a specific social category. People who believe that those who live out in the country are stupid, inbred and all farmers; this is a form of stereotyping (Maisto & Morris, 2010). With these different ways we evaluating and judging people, we expect different things from everyone. If we saw someone who kept their......

Words: 467 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

You Be Judge

...You Be The Judge 11.1, page 288 In a boundary dispute over the location of an underground spring, plaintiff calls a dowser to testify that he dowsed plaintiff's land and estimates a spring flowing approximately 500 feet beneath the surface. 1. Does this testimony constitute scientific knowledge? No, dowsing is not recognizes to be effective in the scientific community. 2. Should it be admitted under the Frye test? No, this would not be admitted under the Frye test because it has not gained general acceptance in the particular field in which it belongs. 3. Should it be admitted under the Daubert test? No, the judge to allow admittance the court requires the expert to tie there assessment to known scientific conclusions. Explain your reasoning. Dowsing is not recognized in the scientific community, it was the ancient art of finding things, there is no scientific evidence to prove that dowsing is effective. For it to be admitted under Frye it must be sufficiently established and have gained general acceptance under the scientific community. Under the Daubert Standard even though the dowser might have specialized knowledge in dowsing it can not be admitted because it does not contain facts or data that have been proven and accepted in the scientific field. The testimony must be based on reliable principle and methods. It is the role of the trial judge to ensure relevance and reliable scientific evidence to allow the testimony to be admissible. The testimony of the Dowser...

Words: 296 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

You Are the Judge

...and skills were thoroughly assessed. Chunk had not committed a felony, which was why the company deemed it reasonable to hire him despite Chunk having lost his previous job due to outbursts of rage. The defendant can also argue that there was no proof that it was Chunk who started the fight. It could just as easily have been that Chunk attacked Wilbur on the grounds of self-defense. Upon viewing both sides of the case I would award the lawsuit to the plaintiff Wilbur. He sued the company on the grounds of taking responsibility for its employee’s actions. The company clearly compromised the safety of its costumers by hiring Chunk despite being aware of his past work history. In addition, the company was negligent in that they let Chunk continue to work despite having a row with a client merely a week before the incident. If I am the judge, the plaintiff Wilbur would win. Because of the above reasons, defense is lack of evidence and plaintiff’s evidence is more effective. The company should have been more responsible and offered Chunk sabbatical until he resolved his anger issues when the first incident was reported. The counseling company knows Chunk’s bad actions will make others in danger, but it still hires Chunk. In addition, the counseling company has a specific policy against violence. Employees should abide by this policy. If the employee violate this policy, he should be counseled first. If he still does that, he should be fired because he ignores the......

Words: 817 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Judges

...Judges Our system of government is a system that relies on balance in order to prevent a concentration of power and is arguably the most powerful. With its ability to declare both executive and legislative actions unconstitutionally, the judicial branch has a lot of space in determining the final say on whether or not our country can or cannot do a particular thing. This power requires that the judicial branch has effective judges in order to work properly.  All judges carry an enormous amount of responsibility. In criminal trials, they are responsible for making sure that the lawyers follow all of the rules of evidence, and ensure that defendants get every right that is afforded to them. They make sure that everything is fair and that the jury is given adequate information in order to decide the guilt or innocence of a party. In civil trials, the judges must decide hard cases by interpreting precedent and decide which policy would be best where the law is not exactly clear on a subject. Judges are responsible for many tasks within the courtroom. The most important responsibility of a judge is to take the oath of office and to uphold that oath. They must swear that they will do their best to ensure that all official duties within their capacity are successfully executed. Judges are somewhat like referees during trials as well as sentencing agents during criminal cases. Judges are......

Words: 812 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Judges

...branch have effective judges for everything to work properly.   Judges have immense responsibility. In criminal trials, they are responsible for making sure that the lawyers follow all of the rules of evidence, and insuring that defendants get every right afforded to them. They make sure that everything is fair, and that the jury is given adequate information to decide the factual guilt or innocence of a party. In civil trials, judges must decide hard cases. In other words, where the law is not exactly clear on a subject, and a novel case comes up, they have the responsibility of interpreting precedent and deciding, in some cases, what the best policy to adopt is. Judges are "bound" by precedent. In every case, the judge must write down his decision, explaining why he decided the way he did, and that decision is published in what are called reporters. These decisions become law. Then, when a similar case comes up, the judge must know the law that has been decided in previous cases, and must evaluate his or her case in light of those previous decisions. This is what is called "precedent." An effective judge will be guided by precedent. They will interpret those cases decided before the one at hand, and will decide what those precedents dictate. In cases where precedent does not dictate a ruling, an effective judge will look at what will result from different rulings, and pick the best possible policy. Conversely ineffective judges will ignore......

Words: 797 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Is Second-Hand Being a Danger to the Child in Question; and the Fact That the Judge Has Ordered the Mother to Stop Smoking Around Her Child.

...particular case presented, Case 4 the parties “involved are a Superior Court judge, a father, his 5-year-old son, and the mother of the child.” (Ruggiero 171) The moral issue is second-hand being a danger to the child in question; and the fact that the judge has ordered the mother to stop smoking around her child. People know the dangers of second-hand smoke and how harmful it can be your child’s health, or anyone’s health for that matter. When “the judge ordered the woman to stop smoking around her child, his judgement corresponds with the natural value that we have a moral obligation to care for ourselves and others. Also, we are prohibited from acting in ways that could harm innocent persons.” (Burnor 182) Based on the judge’s decision, “negative rights,” he made a claim against the mother that she should not be smoking around her child.” (Burnor 196) So he is deterring the child from second-hand smoke and making sure he is protected. Now the mother must practice “positive rights” (Burnor 195) to ensure that she does what is morally right to make sure the health and well-being of he son are of utmost importance. Also, the father can be more at ease knowing his son is free from second-hand smoke. Because of the judgement against the woman, she can accuse the judge and possibly her child’s father of violating her “human rights.” (Burnor 196) She may claim that she’s being discriminated against for being a smoker, which just may not the case here. Just because she was......

Words: 349 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Judge Interveiw

...Today I will interview a judge on his role in major criminal cases from his role beginning with first contact dealing with a plea bargain. The reason I choose to focus on that of plea bargains is because based on the videos I viewed this is the first initial contact the defendant has with the judge and most of the most memorable parts of many criminal court cases. Q: Good afternoon, one thing that stands out to me is why do we have so many plea bargains with in this country? A: Good question, for one our constitution states that everyone should offered that of a speedy trial. With that plea bargains can be looked at as such. Also if we were to send every case in front of jury many cases would never be heard and or pushed so far back that defendants will not receive the proper attention and or defense based on that fact if they had a public defender or private attorney. Q: when it comes to a plea bargain what is role? A: As a judge we oversee and supervise to make sure boundaries are set and it falls it the expectations of the community we are servicing. Also with this with have the right to accept or deny any plea bargain that is brought to us. But once a plea is made either guilty or no contest, it is our responsibility to make sure that the defendant is this decision on his own free will and in sole right mind. Once approved it will no longer go to trial. Q: When entering a plea hearing how much do you really know about case before it is presented to you and......

Words: 882 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Judge Danforth

...Seth Hendrix Mrs. Cunningham English 3 15 March 2016 Danforth Judge Danforth was a politician that believed in honor and recognition; he closely followed the rules of which he set in stone, and is a perfect archetype of the puritan society. As the governor of Massachusetts during the Salem witch trials, Judge Danforth was called, along with Judge Hawthorne, to deal justice and deal with the situation. Throughout the play he is made out to be incredibly precise and scrupulous with everything he does. Due to a perhaps pompous position of power, his attitude and demeanor come across as very stubborn. Nearing the end of the play, his mindset that any wrongdoing is punishable becomes applicable to him, and he is unwilling to consider the possibility he might have made a grave mistake. Almost ironically however, the real-life Thomas Danforth is much the opposite. Arthur Miller wrote The Crucible to criticize the McCarthy hearings and the hysteria surrounding them and he used the Salem witch trails to do so; as he saw many parallels between the two. To do this, Miller portrays Thomas Danforth, who, in real life, did not even sit on the Court of Oyer and Terminer,(Linder 1) (A group dedicated to the prosecution to those accused witches) is a bitter, scrupulous, controlling old man set on keeping order, or, what he believes to be order. The McCarthy hearings were quite harsh and Miller needed a reciprocated leadership shown in the Crucible. (Lorcher 1) To do this, Miller bent......

Words: 596 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Letter to the Judge

...Dear Judge Heartling, I am writing this letter on behalf of Jacob Coldon. I request and plead for leniency in his sentencing. I have known Jacob since he was 5 years old. During that time, I have always known Jacob to be a kind, giving and loving person. Jacob has always tried to do the right thing. How he ever got into this situation is so baffling to me, as this is not the young man I have known just about all of my life. Jacob is a defensive end on the football team and enjoys playing. He hopes to play football professionally one day, but unfortunately charges being brought up against him will put a halt on that. This is a terrible crime that has been committed and no one is trying to minimize the wrongdoing or hurt that Jacob has caused the victim, her family, and his own family and friends. This is the first crime Jacob has committed, and requiring him to register as a sex offender will destroy him and whatever future he has as a professional athlete. Jacob is only 17 years old and didn’t realize the seriousness of the crime. So please find it in your heart and take into consideration Jacobs age and the future he has ahead of him. You don't know me and you don't owe anything to me or Mr. Coldon. Yet, I am asking you to be as lenient as possible in delivering your sentence. May you find mercy in your heart. Thank you, Jennifer Rhoades...

Words: 257 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Brian Judge

...Brian Judge ENG 1111: College Writing 3/23/2010 Museum Visit 1. No, I have been to the museum once before 2. The entrance to the museum is very historical because the outside structure is similar to a palace where kings and queens lived. In order to get in the museum, you have to stand in line and when you get to the front desk, you have to either pay or show an ID if you are a college students. While in line, you can view the televisions above the front desk, which give ticket prices and such. After that, you walk to where security checks your ticket and then lets you in. If you have a bag, they will give you a ticket of some sort for you to come back and get it. The security there is very strict about the policies of the museum such as no touching whatsoever. 3. Two of the areas that I visited in the museum were the Secrets of Tomb 10A: Egypt 2000 B.C. and the exhibit of Albrecht Dürer who was known as aVirtuoso Printmaker. 4. The Egyptian exhibit had a dark setting to it with its historical accuracy. Being in the Egyptian exhibit was extremely exciting for me because since I am a fan of ancient Egypt, I was able to view several fragments, sculptures and tombs that once existed during that time period. Being in Albrecht’s room of prints was different because I hadn’t heard of him when it comes to art, so I was able to have a fresh start. I learned that he was the pivotal figure of Late Gothic and High Renaissance German art. 5. One......

Words: 674 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Impeachment of a Judge

...IMPEACHMENT OF A JUDGE PROCEDURE OF IMPEACHMENT: Impeachment is a formal process in which an official is accused of unlawful activity, the outcome of which, depending on the country, may include the removal of that official from office as well as other punishment. A member of the higher judiciary, which means the Judges and Chief Justices of the Supreme Court of India and the state High Courts, can be removed from service only through the process of impeachment under Article 124 (4) of the Constitution on grounds of proven misbehaviour or incapacity. In India, there is no other process by which a Judge can be removed from office before his term comes to an end. However, the process is very cumbersome. Impeachment of judges can only be done on grounds of 'proven misbehavior' and 'incapacity'. if a judge of SC is to be impeached, recommendation must be made by the chief justice of India to the President. if it is accepted then a proposal for impeachment must be introduced by atleast 100 MPs in Lok sabha or 50 MPs in Rajya sabha. the concerned judge is to be given a copy of the proposal before the discussion takes place in the Parliament. the motion should be passed by a majority of two-thirds of the members present and voting ,seperately in each house. if the motion is passed...

Words: 843 - Pages: 4