Premium Essay

Asch and Social Influence

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By aidanbrame01
Words 576
Pages 3
The experiment is related closely to the Stanford Prison and Milgram Experiments, in that it tries to show how perfectly normal human beings can be pressured into unusual behavior by authority figures, or by the consensus of opinion around them.

For the experiment, eight subjects were seated around a table, with the seating plan carefully constructed to prevent any suspicion.

Only one participant was actually a genuine subject for the experiment, the rest being confederates, carefully tutored to give certain pre-selected responses. Careful experimental construction placed a varying amount of peer pressure on the individual test subject.

Asch Experiment - Figure 1The experiment was simple in its construction; each participant, in turn, was asked to answer a series of questions, such as which line was longest or which matched the reference line. (Fig 1)

The participants gave a variety of answers, at first correct, to avoid arousing suspicion in the subject, but then with some incorrect responses added.

This would allow Asch to determine how the answers of the subject would change with the added influence of peer pressure.

The Asch Experiment results were interesting and showed that peer pressure could have a measurable influence on the answers given.

The control group, those not exposed to peer pressure where everybody gave correct answers, threw up only one incorrect response out of 35; this could probably be explained by experimental error.

The results for the other groups were interesting; when surrounded by people giving an incorrect answer, over one third of the subjects also voiced an incorrect opinion.

At least 75% of the subjects gave the wrong answer to at least one question, although experimental error may have had some influence on this figure. There was no doubt, however, that peer pressure can cause conformity.

It was debated…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Social Influences Paper

...psychology perspective. It will describe at least two examples of how human behavior changes based on social situations. The two behaviors that this paper will examine are teenagers who drink in a crowd of their peers but don't drink when they are alone and taking part in bullying in a group but not alone. In both of these scenarios the individual who participates in the behaviors to fit in are “changing their attitudes or behavior to accommodate the standards of peers or group by a process called conformity (Kowalski & Westen, 2005).” The paper will also discuss precursors and consequences of both of these behaviors. Next, the paper will analyze and identify any associated phenomenon like social facilitation, social loafing , or groupthink. Last, there will be some discussion from the NIMH on whether or not these behaviors necessitate intervention. Social Influences Paper Introduction “Sociologist and philosophers have recognized that people behave different in crowds than they do as individuals and that a crowd is more than the mere sum of its parts (Kowalski & Westen, 2005).” Human behavior changes based on the social situations they encounter. This paper will examine basic concepts of human interaction from a psychology perspective. It will describe at least two examples of how human behavior changes based on social situations. In analyzing these two perspectives there will be given a description of the specific......

Words: 1389 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Social Influence

...Social influence occurs when one's emotions, opinions, or behaviors are affected by others.[1] Social influence takes many forms and can be seen in conformity, socialization, peer pressure, obedience, leadership, persuasion, sales, and marketing. In 1958, Harvard psychologist, Herbert Kelman identified three broad varieties of social influence.[2] 1. Compliance is when people appear to agree with others, but actually keep their dissenting opinions private. 2. Identification is when people are influenced by someone who is liked and respected, such as a famous celebrity. 3. Internalization is when people accept a belief or behavior and agree both publicly and privately. Morton Deutsch and Harold Gerard described two psychological needs that lead humans to conform to the expectations of others. These include our need to be right (informational social influence), and our need to be liked (normative social influence).[3] Informational influence (or social proof) is an influence to accept information from another as evidence about reality. Informational influence comes into play when people are uncertain, either because stimuli are intrinsically ambiguous or because there is social disagreement. Normative influence is an influence to conform to the positive expectations of others. In terms of Kelman's typology, normative influence leads to public compliance, whereas informational influence leads to private acceptance. [edit] Types Social Influence is a broad......

Words: 4418 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Social Influences on Behaviour

...Abstract Extreme cases of social roles or influences usually need treatment. Such as in the case of social influences and altruism were in the extremes it is necessary to correct behaviors that occur. However, choice is the clear decision maker in determining actions, whether good or bad, correct or incorrect, education needs to be available for people to make the right decision. Social Influences on Behavior Paper By examining the basic concepts and of human interaction in social situations and the way behavior changes by examining altruism and social influence we can get a better understanding of these concepts through a psychological perspective. What happens in these situations and if the effects of the situations require treatment or if the behaviors require correcting. Altruism is “behaving in a way that helps another person with no apparent gain, or with potential cost, to oneself.” (Kowalski, R., & Westen, D., 2009) There are several theories within altruism, there is ethical hedonism, “…asserts that all behavior, no matter how apparently altruistic, is and should be designed to increase one’s own pleasure or reduce one’s own pain.” (Kowalski, R., & Westen, D., 2009) This theory offers that giving money, food, etc. is only done by an individual to compensate for their own sorrow and making themselves feel better. Another theory is reciprocal altruism, “…natural selection favors animals that behave altruistically if the likely benefit to each individual......

Words: 1020 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Social Influence

...Social Influence * Kelman’s varieties * Conformity * Persuasion * Effects on children * Examples of social influence * Social influence in relation to woman and men * Social influence in relation to sports Social influence is best described as when one’s behaviors or views towards something are changed by another person, group or other form of communication such as through TV or reading. Stanly Milgram conducted experiments in which people were required to give electric shocks to people if they gave the wrong answer to a series of questions. Participants continued to give electric shocks for bad answers even when the answerer was near death as long as an authority figure was present. Of course, no real electric shocks were given, and those supposedly receiving the electric shocks were actors. This was social influence that persuaded the people to continue giving shocks and I will give more examples of such experiments and studies. Children are influenced more and more by society these days. During soccer, young children roll around on the ground as if they have been shot by a sniper rifle to influence the referee to show a red card. If they do not act this way they will be taken off the field so they are influenced to do the wrong thing. Women are constantly influenced by society to have better shoes to fit in to society, or to have a new dress for each party they attend. This is peer pressure from magazines with such people as Kim......

Words: 306 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Social Influence

...The first product that is advertised in the media that I am going to discuss is children’s diapers. There are many brands out there, such as Huggies, Pampers and Luvs, and they are all targeted to the same audience. The audience that is being targeted is mothers and mothers to-be. They advertisers know that their audience is primarily women. The diaper commercials are aired during specific times, during specific television shows and even on specific networks. I have found that TLC airs diaper commercials, constantly, during television shows like “A Baby Story”, “I Didn’t Know I Was Pregnant” and “A Conception Story”. Airing these specific diaper commercials during these times is a very smart tactic. Social cognitive theory is used often during advertising, specifically commercial advertisements. Commercials are carefully targeted toward specific demographic groups. Each part of the commercial, from the actors and actresses that are hired to the background music, is chosen to help that specific person that is watching the commercial, identify with the product that is being advertised. You will notice that the timing of a diaper commercial will be different from the timing of a children’s toy commercial. There are different commercials shown during Saturday morning cartoons then there are during the evening news. When it comes to advertising diapers in magazines, you will only find a diaper advertisement in magazines such as Parent Magazine, Mom Magazine and Motherhood Magazine...

Words: 541 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Social Influences

...Social Influences We as people are the most complex living creatures on the planet. We require more needs than any other species out there. Of course, the most basic physical needs are number one: air, water, food, sleep, and reproduction. Second, we as humans need protection and safety from harms way. And the third basic human need according to Maslow is social needs. Our sense of identity comes from the way we perceive and interact with other people. Having social relationships is vital to the basic character of a person. Some sociologists would say that having other human relationships is so important to us, that communication is the primary goal of existence. Social influences make up who we are as people and carry with a person throughout their entire life. Social influences on us carry into our day to day lives and the relationships we have created. Society’s views on relationships have changed drastically over the years, some for the better, and others for the worse. Much of the social influences we have to deal with in our lives today relate to society’s views on love, and acceptance of sex out of wedlock. Our relationships are also molded around our careers, and society’s views about what is acceptable for a relationship and a career to succeed. American society has created and established many gender roles for our relationships and family’s, especially when it pertains to careers and money in a relationship. Although, these gender roles have been evolving......

Words: 1999 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Social Influences on Behavior

...Social Influences on Behavior 1 Social Influence on Behavior Frances Sequoyah PSY/300 February 10, 2014 Trisha Ferre Social Influences on Behavior 2 Abstract From the moment humans are born, they are social beings because without another person feeding, giving them personal care and love, no human infant would survive. Even after humans become adults and are able to take care of themselves, they still need or choose to interact with other individuals since the majority of humans need companionship of some type. Whether it is interacting with people who are friends or someone they choose as a companion. The only people who prefer not to associate with others are the ones with anti-social disorders or other mental illnesses. The following article will examine the fundamental concept of human interactions from the perspective of social psychology. This includes examples how human behavior changes when subjected to different social situations and what specific behaviors were shown and the context in which they occurred. The examples used will provide analyses of possible precursors and the consequences of different behaviors and will identify phenomenon associated with the selected behavioral examples such as social facilitation and social loafing. Social Influences on Behavior ...

Words: 1228 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Social Influences

...Social Influence Conformity 3 types of conformity - Kelman Compliance – privately disagreeing, but publicly going along with the group behaviour or attitudes. Identification – a temporary change in beliefs and behaviour while you remain a member of the group. Includes private and public change of belief. Internalisation – a permanent change in beliefs and behaviour. Conformity is more likely in ambiguous situations (where there is no obvious answer) Implicit norm – normal patterns of behaviour generally understood by all egg personal space, lining up for food/ toilets. Explicit norms – normal patterns of behaviour that are enforced by written guidelines or signs etc some become law. (No smoking signs, speed signs) Sherif – auto kenetic light effect 2 reasons why we conform. Duel Process model both process at the same time Asch 1951 Conformity in an unambiguous situation. Ao1 Describe Asch’s aims, findings, conclusions Ao2/3 Evaluate Asch’s experiment. Consider strengths/limitations of using a lab experiment. Consider S/L of Asch’s research in terms of culture, time-historical consider ethical issues. Aims To investigate if people gave in to conformity even when the answer is obvious, which is called unambiguous. To investigate normative social influence. Findings His findings showed that 32% of critical trials where a participant confirmed. 75% of the participants......

Words: 297 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Social Influences on Behavior

...Social Influences on Behavior Behaviorism explores the ways that are observable behavior can be learned and shaped in the environment (McAdams, D. P., 2006). “Social influence, refers to the influence of the presence of other people on thought, feeling, and behavior” (Kowalski & Westen, 2011). The effects of social influence from environments can have both positive and negative consequences. Each individual approaches situations with their own set of personal characteristics (McAdams, D. P., 2006); however different aspects of influence determine how an individual may modify their behaviors to react in a given situation. Let us explore two examples of socially influenced behaviors to understand the affects they may have on an individual. The blind obedience to authority study conducted by Stanley Milgram is an example of how social influence can actually change the way an individual will behave regardless of personal belief in the presence of an authority figure in a hierarchical situation (Kowalski & Westen, 2011). The Milgram experiment measured obedience to an authority figure through electric shocks, which are given by study participants to another person upon directives given from whom the participants thought of as an authority figure. Milgram’s study showed how far people would go to obey orders from an authority figure. Obedience is the act of carrying out commands in compliance to authority (Kowalski & Westen, 2011).......

Words: 1116 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Social Influence

...Normative social influence This type of social influence is associated most commonly with compliance (going along with the majority even if you don’t accept their beliefs because you want to be accepted). Normative social influence is when a majority are able to control other groups by exerting pressure on them to conform. Because the majority normally have the greatest power they can do this very easily. For example, the majority could make the minority feel uncomfortable about disagreeing, as we see in Asch’s study. Or the majority could even force them too with fear and power, as the Nazis did to so many Germans; they used scaremongering to enforce conformity. This is type of conformity is driven by the basic need to feel accepted and to have companionship with other people, the majority. Informational Social Influence This is where someone conforms to a view because they believe it to be correct. This is associated with Internalisation (conforming because you have accepted a group’s views and they now fit with your own beliefs). This type of conformity can occur with majority or minority influence, but it is most likely to happen when: * The right course of action is clear, there isn’t one obvious right answer * The situation is a crisis, you need to make a fast decision (both of these are evident when following a crowd who claim to be fleeing from a disaster, for example) * We believe the others to be experts; if we think the people we are conforming to......

Words: 401 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Social Influences

...Chapter 3 Influences in the Business Environment Personal use only Businesses operate in a dynamic, often turbulent, environment. The business environment refers to anything that affects the operation of a business. Farmers have understood the impact of the environment for centuries. The farmer has no control over aspects of the environment The business such as drought. However, the farmer can prepare for possible adversity in the environment and environment refers to quickly adapt to those changes. Effective managers are constantly monitoring the business environment to pick up any change that may impact on their business. If they pick up a change quickly and respond before their competitors, it may lead to a significant advantage to their business. This is what happened when Woolworths’ managers picked up the trend to the healthy life style before the managers of Coles. The Woolworths’ managers immediately responded by developing a focus on fresh produce, delicatessens, bakeries and dairy. Customers responded by leaving Coles and shopping at Woolworths. Now that Wesfarmers Limited has purchased Coles its managers are quickly implementing strategies to regain their competitive advantage. anything that affects the operation of the business 55 HomeThink Draw the Woolworths’ logo. What does it represent? Is it effective? 3.1 External influences The external influences from the business environment are those outside the control of a business’s managers.......

Words: 6294 - Pages: 26

Free Essay

Asch & Moscovici Contributed a Lot to Develop Their Theories on Social Influence. Describe Both Processes & Explain Their Differences

...theories on social influence. Two in particular are Asch and Moscovici. These talked about the majority influence and the minority influence. Solomon Asch conducted an experiment in 1951 to investigate the extent to which social pressure from a majority group could affect a person to conform. He showed the participants 3 lines and asked them which line had the same length as the one he had presented. Only one of the participants weren't collaborating with the researcher whilst the others had to say a wrong answer. Even though it was obvious which lines were the same, after hearing the collaborators say their wrong answers, the participants found themselves in a conflict whether they should give the same answer as the others even if it was wrong or say the right one. 75% of the participants gave into the group pressure at least once whilst 37% conformed on all trials. He found out that apparently people conform for two main reasons, because they want to fit in with the group (normative influence) and because they believe the group is better informed than they are (informational influence). Asch had assumed that the participants would be able to say the truth. However, about 70% of the participants went against the majority at least in one of the trials. They also had a strong conflict because they wanted to be like the rest of the group. Most gave both wrong and right answers to avoid being ridiculed but at the same time show perceptual accuracy. Minority influence......

Words: 490 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Social Influence

...What I understand about social influence is that present of other people can strongly influence individual behavior in attitudes, beliefs decisions and actions. This influence can be seen in our conformity, compliance, and group behavior. According to Solomon Asch and others that under certain conditions people will conform to a group's judgment even when it is clearly incorrect. In Milgrams' famous experiments, people who were torn between obeying an experimenter and responding to another's please usually choose to obey orders, even though obedience appeared to involve harming another person. This classic experiments demonstrate the potency of social forces, and they highlight the fact that we conform either to gain social approval by adhering to social norms or because we depend on the information that others provide. Social relations can be understand as how can we related to one another. We will ponder the bad and the good: from prejudice, aggression, and conflict to attraction, altruism, and peacemaking. Prejudice is a mixture of beliefs (often stereotypes), emotions, and predispositions to action. Research reveals how our ways of processing information for example, by overestimating similarities when we categorize people or by noticing and remembering vivid cases work to create stereotypes. The good of social relations propose that our social behaviors even our helpful acts maximize our benefits, which may include our own good feelings and minimize our costs....

Words: 288 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Social Influence

...Social Influence: Key Terminology Agentic state a state of feeling controlled by an authority figure, and therefore lacking a sense of personal responsibility. Authoritarian personality identified by Adorno et al. as someone who is more likely to be obedient. These people tend to hold rigid beliefs, and to be hostile towards other groups and submissive to authority. Autokinetic effect - a visual illusion where a small spot of light in a darkened room appears to be moving when in fact it is stationary. Autonomous state - being aware of the consequences of our actions and therefore taking voluntary control of our behaviour. Buffers - aspects of situations that protect people from having to confront the results of their actions. Collectivistic cultures - cultures (such as many in the Far East) in which the emphasis is on group solidarity and interdependence. Commitment - an individual's involvement in, and motivation for, a given viewpoint. Compliance - conforming to the majority view in order to be liked, or to avoid ridicule or social exclusion. Compliance occurs more readily with public behaviour than private behaviour, and is based on power. Conformity - changes in behaviour and/or attitudes occurring in response Consistency - the extent to which the same opinions are expressed by all minority group members (interindividual consistency) and over time (intra-individual consistency). Conversion - the influence of the minority on the majority. This is likely to......

Words: 1031 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Social Influences

...Social Influences on Behavior PSY/300 - Psychology June 20, 2011 Pamela Parks Social Influences on Behavior Social influences change ones’ behavior as soon as we become cognoscente of the facts that if we behave a certain way or speak well enough, we are more likely to receive the kind of attention we want. The same is true for the opposite. If we behave incorrectly or are not well spoken, we receive negative attention or demeaning attention. We care about what people think of us and our behavior changes depending on who we are with and the kind of impression we want to give. For example, I behave differently when I am with colleagues then I do when I am with friends or family. I also change my behavior accordingly if I am with colleagues who happen to also be friends. I know that I must still be professional and maintain a level of decorum that suits them and I do not allow myself to waiver from that for fear of losing that professional level of respect that I have earned. I think that one of the most obvious social influences on behavior comes in to play in a group setting which can be attributed to social loafing. Take for example our learning teams. They are created to allow for a flow of more creative thinking. More input and opinions create a better paper or at least that is what I think it is about. What happens however in some cases can be quite different. Let’s look at my learning team for this class. Although not the norm for a learning team, the......

Words: 775 - Pages: 4