Free Essay

Alternative Schools Are a Better Choice for Students

In: English and Literature

Submitted By Boo101971
Words 913
Pages 4
Alternative Schools are a Better Choice for Students
Christy Price
AIU Online

Alternative Schools are a Better Choice for Students What are alternative schools? Alternative schools according to the World Book Encyclopedia (2003) are, “… any public or private school that differs from traditional schools in curriculum, purpose, or teaching methods.” The definition comes from the 1960’s when free schools were created and contained smaller groups of students and teachers. During this time the general consensus was, kids would learn at their own pace and teachers were not meant to be viewed as authority figures but should be mentors to the students under their care. In comparison to public schools, which were seen as oppressive, free schools were a suitable alternative for many students (Miller 2002) For some students alternative high schools are the better choice for their education.
Students who attend alternative schools do not lack the ability to learn they just have different learning needs than other students. According to the Waterville Alternative School (2003), located in Waterville Maine, public schools are created on a “one size fits all” basis. That is, there is one set curriculum, schedule, and teaching style. Each student is expected to learn at the same pace; however, this is not the reality. Thus, alternative schools have been created as a way to meet each student’s individual needs.
Alternative schools are appealing to some students for a number of reasons. The enrollment is smaller in comparison to regular public schools. According to Cynthia Franklin (1992), most alternative schools do not exceed 200 students. Smaller class sizes allow for a more supportive environment for the student. Teachers are able to give more one on one attention to their students and even the principals can get involved with the students and the learning process.
With the individualized attention from teachers, students feel that the teachers are interested in what happens with their education and this leads to higher achievement rates (Thompson 2001). A large number of students, who attend alternative schools, are those who are labeled, “at risk.” There are a number of factors that give students this label. According to Chris Thompson (2001), these factors include, but are not limited to, “… class, race, gender, special needs, pregnancy, abusive home situations, relationship problems, drug abuse, alienation, boredom…” These factors, along with others, can lead to poor behavior and performance in school or even worse drop out altogether. For these students an alternative school provides a more suitable learning environment.
Another way alternative schools are better for some students is the individualized curriculum that is offered. Teachers understand the students have certain learning needs, thus they are presented with a curriculum that is “self-paced and mastery-based” (Franklin 1992). Students are able to work at their own pace and learning style, which results in higher rates of completion and accuracy. In traditional public schools students either understand the material progress forward or they have trouble with the material and fall behind.
The decision making process is also different in alternative schools. Students are allowed to have a say in the learning process and in traditional public schools teachers and administrators make those decisions for the students and students are not given a choice in what happens.
According to a study discussed by Edward Saunders (2002), Students at Walnut Creek Alternative high school were interviewed to find out if they believed in the characteristics of the alternative school and one hundred students were given two surveys.
The first survey dealt with past experiences in public school settings and topics for concern was the students overall school experience and their perceptions of teachers and administrators. One student stated that “I felt as if the teachers didn’t know me; I was just a number not a human being” (Saunders 2002). The second survey dealt with their current experiences at the Walnut Creek alternative high school and results showed student’s responses in regards to the alternative school were quite positive. Students described the teachers as “Good…they try to help me every way they can” (Saunders 2002). It was also noted that administrators treated students more fairly. The statistics from the two surveys show that the alternative school clearly ranked highest in both topic areas, only three percent of the students rated overall experience in public schools as excellent, in contrast to the seventy-nine percent of students who rated overall experience in alternative schools as excellent.
In conclusion the educational system’s “one size fits all” method of teaching is an issue that needs to be addressed. All students cannot be expected to learn at the same pace or in the same way, thus alternative schools are better for some students. H.G. Wells once stated that, “Our challenge is not to educate the children we used to have or want to have, but to educate the children who come to the schoolhouse door.”

References
Miller, R. (2002). Free schools, free people: education and democracy after the 1960’s. Albany:SUNY Press.

Waterville Public Schools, (2003). Statement of purpose. Retrieved June 26, 2013 from the World Wide Web: http://wshs.wtvl.k12.me.us/~alted/statement.html

Thompson, C. (2001). The most beneficial features of alternative schools, according to alternative school students. Retrieved June 26, 2013 from the World Wide Web: www.maapmn.org/research/ct_researchpaper.PDF

Saunders, J., & Saunders, E., (2001). Alternative school students’ perceptions of past (traditional) and current (alternative) school environments. High School Journal 85 (2), 12-23. Retrieved June 26, 2013…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Does School Uniforms Make Schools Better?

...Does School Uniforms Make School Better? Do school uniforms really make schools better? I say NO! Only because I, myself, went to a school that had to wear uniforms. While there are advantages of school uniforms, there are also some disadvantages. Depending on the requirements, school uniforms can be expensive to buy for parents. There are also arguments that wearing uniforms hides the child’s personality and therefore they cannot express themselves in their own way. The staff thinks it would be best for their students to wear uniforms and that the schools would be better disciplined but, what they failed to realize is that it was the uniforms getting us into trouble. Students would get sent out of class multiple times for dress code violations, then sent to ISS, then a campus level hearing for a possible referral to a district level hearing and then eventually your sent to alternative, because you didn’t have your shirt tucked in, or your pants were rolled up, but you know maybe all that happened because your mom bought your school clothes over the summer and you just so happen to GROW. Your shirt was un-tucked because it was to short and your pants were rolled up because you didn’t want to have high waters. According the article titled Advantages of School Uniforms on the-ibenefits.com website, “Many times, kids are ridiculed because of the clothes they wear, and it seems that no matter how hard parents try, kids know who is poor in the school. One of the advantages of......

Words: 458 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

School Choice: Public vs. Private

...School Choice: Private vs. Public Schools School choice is a hot topic concerning education, especially when it comes to public vs. private schools. How parents choose to educate their children is highly debated, though there are several advantages and disadvantages of the two. Therefore it is very important that both options be explored and the choice must be based on what is right for each particular child. Topics to research include tuition fees, admission protocol, academic curriculum, test scores, and teacher qualifications. Let’s take a look at several factors that may direct your decision in the right path. Fortunately, enrolling a child into a public school does not include tuition fees. Public schools are funded through federal, state and local taxes. When employed residents of a city pay taxes, they are providing the expenses needed to fund children’s education and costs of public schools in their community. Leaving the only sensible option, to take advantage of the money already invested into the school system through taxes and make use of it towards your child’s education. Though this is not the case with private schools, parents are responsible for public school tax, along with additional tuition fees charged for enrollment by their independent school of choice. Private schools do not receive tax revenues, but instead are funded through tuition, fundraising, donations and private grants. According to the National Association of Independent Schools (NAIS),...

Words: 1334 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Better Education with School Uniform

...Better Education with School Uniforms The use of uniforms in public schools is an interesting and controversial topic. It is believed that uniforms help decrease violence, maintain discipline in the schools, and enhance the student’s performance. I had the opportunity to talk with several teachers and hear their different points of view regarding the use of school uniforms; I also asked some parents for their point of view. The majority of parents and teachers agree that uniforms would greatly contribute to the solution. Ana Linder, a teacher at the alternative school, “Skill Center” in Norfolk, has more than twenty students in her class. These students have all been expelled from their regular schools for discipline problems, including violence. One reason for the violence is clothing. Ana told me about one student who had been expelled from school because he had pushed another student down a flight of stairs to take a jacket that a student was wearing. Another student stole an expensive pair of tennis shoes because he had been joked about the cheep ones he was wearing and his mother, being a single parent, could not afford the expensive ones. Kids today are very fashion conscious and if they can’t afford the latest trends they try to get them by any means possible. Since fashion is so important to students, with the price tag being the major issue, the use of uniforms would eliminate peer pressure to conform thus eliminating the need for violence to obtain these expensive......

Words: 583 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Costing Alternative Choices Summary

...Costing Alternative Choices Summary When making a decision between one course of action or the other, it is beneficial to determine which will option will either minimize costs or maximize gains. In the business world, managers make these decisions based on evaluating the effect of the differential costs – the difference between the two options. From data generated from a firm’s cost-accounting system, managers can apply the rules of cost behavior to determine which cost factors are relevant to taking the best course of action. In one case, the difference between costs might be evaluated. In another case, both costs and revenues may be evaluated. The cost-volume-profit model is useful in providing a foundation from which a decision can be made. It helps to map the break-even point by showing the intersection of the slope of the total revenue with that of total costs. It also shows where production levels lead to profits or losses. The total cost-volume is a function of fixed costs, variable costs and semivariable costs. In general, the cost-volume behavior of each is fairly consistent in that variable costs tend to be directly related to volume, fixed costs remain constant regardless of volume and semivariable costs have both fixed and variable components. While the cost behavior models are fairly accurate, managers must be careful not to ignore several key considerations and ask themselves: • Are the volume considerations within the relevant range of the......

Words: 437 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Which Is the Better School?

...D, chapman 11/6/2013 Dr. Godwin Lit. Review Which is the better school? Every high school athlete dream is to go to college and become some superstar later on in life. But some of the hardest choices come during your senior year in high school. The most anticipating question: What college will you be attending seems to come up every single day. But do you really know how hard, and what the process of picking a school out is? Most people choose their school based on race and who attended the school before them. As an athlete, seems like everyone is breathing down your neck your senior year asking about what school will you be attending. But most of those people don’t know the time and work put into choosing a school. You also have your parents giving you their input on what they think is best for you. But what people don’t understand is that the choice is ours and you have all these factors to weigh. Yes, most parents want their children to follow their footsteps and attend the school that they attended, but is that a really good choice? Also, race plays a big factor in choosing the school. No it’s not a segregation type thing but more of whether to attend a Historically Black College or a Predominantly White Institutions. When looking at recruiting other factors play in such as; if I get hurt will my education still get paid for? Or will I be just slapped on the wrist because I am a thlete and won’t gt my proper education....

Words: 267 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

A Better Choice

...A Better Choice s ETH/316 Wednesday 13,2013 “Each year, more than 208 million pregnancies occur worldwide; 185 million occur in the developing world alone. Worldwide, almost two in five women who become pregnant have either an abortion or an unplanned birth. About 6.7 million pregnancies occur in the United States each year. Nearly two-thirds of all pregnancies result in live births and about one-fifth in abortion; the remainder end in miscarriage. Nearly half of all U.S. pregnancies are unintended (49%); about 43% of these end in abortion” (Gutmacher Institution, 2013). A Better Choice helps women in the Wichita, KS area who are faced with unintended pregnancies that need help or guidance with the pregnancy. Founded in 1993, A Better Choice is a Catholic crisis pregnancy resource center, serving women of all ages and socio-economic levels who are struggling with the fear and uncertainty of an unplanned pregnancy. A Better Choice offers counseling and support that is compassionate, non-judgmental, and based on the teachings of the Catholic Church. Whether a woman has many issues to work through or needs a kind ear and encouraging word, A Better Choice is dedicated to serving the mother, her baby and family with Christ-like dignity and respect. (A Better Choice, 2013) A Better Choice makes and made a choice to be around because of the need of women. They see the struggle women have as far as not being financially, emotionally or physically ready to raise a baby. Some...

Words: 424 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Student Choices

...the blog anuragsingh.name (2010), this blog conclude the four lessons in business from Trader Joe’s which are do less do good, keep it simple, customer is king kong and old is still good. This blog is agree that Trader Joe’s so unique and can be applied to all business across the board. Trader Joe’s embraces the age old philosophy of simplicity which other great companies follow by same principle are Apple and Basecamp. The magic is that Trader Joe’s focuses on quality rather than quantity. By carrying fewer item, Trader Joe’s tries to make sure that each of the product they do carry on their shelves is a quality product and meets up to it’s standards. Also by having fewer items it’s able to negotiate better prices from the suppliers and thus passes it on to the customer. More choices is not always necessary a good thing. It confuses the customer and adds an extra layer of complexity to the operation. Focusing only a few things but doing them really well is one of the keys to success. According to the blog, Trader Joe’s is a very simple store in terms of furnishings & interiors. There are no flashing neon lights but simple back boards with stuff written on them. This does two things, first keeps the operations cost down which can be passed onto the customer & second helps people connect to the store. According to Forbes, written by Glenn Llopis (2012), Trader’s Joe’s is a perfect example of how to gain a competitive advantage in a crowded space by embracing the immigrant......

Words: 1718 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Chapter - 01 Limits, Alternatives, and Choices

...Chapter - 01 Limits, Alternatives, and Choices: Chapter 1: #11, 12 Question 11 Explain how (if at all) each of the following events affects the location of a country’s production possibilities curve: a. The quality of education increases – Production possibilities will increase b. The number of unemployed workers increases – Production possibilities will decrease c. A new technique improves the efficiency of extracting copper from ore – Production possibilities will increase d. A devastating earthquake destroys numerous production facilities – Production possibilities will decrease Question 12 Suppose that, on the basis of a nation’s production possibilities curve, an economy must sacrifice 10,000 pizzas domestically to get the 1 additional industrial robot it desires but that it can get the robot from another country in exchange for 9000 pizzas. Relate this information to the following statement: “Through international specialization and trade, a nation can reduce its opportunity cost of obtaining goods and thus ‘move outside its production possibilities curve.’” Production possibilities curves dictate that individual nations are limited to output combinations that fall within the parameters of its possibilities curve. Specialization in an area has the same effect as higher education or technological advance, it increases outputs and there is economic growth. The international country specializes in a certain process and uses domestic resources to produce the......

Words: 500 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Motivating High School Students

...involvement along with utilizing modern technology and cyberschooling will help motivate high school students to successfully graduate with their peers with a sense of accomplishment and pride. Though we cannot force students to want to learn and graduate we can implement new teaching techniques and technology that interests them which in turn will motivate them to want to learn. Motivating a student can be a challenge for teachers as well as parents therefore teachers and parents both need to create a positive environment providing a feeling of support and expectations. Studies show that many students do poorly because they do not completely understand what is expected of them. “Students who are uncertain about what to do will seldom perform well” (VirtualSalt). Teachers should spend more time explaining the subject, why the topic is important, interesting and worthwhile so that their own enthusiasm will be transmitted to the students and will therefore motivate them. It is also harder to motivate older students than it is to motivate younger ones. “The irony is that high school teachers particularly, and parents of high school kids, need to be more skilled at motivating” (USATODAY). Teachers can take free courses, whether through a traditional school setting or through an on-line setting, on ideas for motivating students as well as doing basic internet research. An example of teacher motivation that I......

Words: 1925 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Better Teachers, Better Schools

...Better Teachers, Better Schools Imagine this. You are a high school student in class, listening to the teacher discuss the area of a triangle in your geometry course. You cannot help but look around and see, like you, no one else wants to be there. You realize that the teacher has no real connection with students and truly does not know how to communicate the subject material. You cannot help but wonder, why are they teaching? Shouldn’t someone that more qualified to teach be in their place? From kindergarten to high school, choosing qualified teachers has been a daunting task. Schools nationwide choose teachers based on their experience in teaching and an interview process that they are required to complete. Although this seems like a sufficient way to choose great teachers, it is not enough. Too many people are becoming teachers when they clearly do not have the proper skills to lead a group of students. Just because a person has a high IQ, had a good GPA, has previous experience in the education field, or has en education major, does it mean that they have what it takes to be a teacher. A teacher needs to have good interactions with students, be an authoritative figure, be able to teach material, and much more. Just conducting an interview and a resume will not reveal if a candidate has these qualifications. This is why the hiring process for teachers should be much stricter, including an exam and a mock classroom evaluation, in addition to what is already in place....

Words: 2108 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Home-Schooling; a Public School Alternative?

...Home-schooling; a Public School Alternative? Monique Mapp In 2011, based on statistics from the National Household Education Surveys, an estimated 1.77 million students were home-schooled in the United States. This constituted a 0.5 percent increase from the surveys done in 2007. The reason for this upsurge is simple; home-schooling is a viable alternative to public education. The home-educated are reaching and surpassing standards set by public schools. Home-schooling is as effective as public-school in meeting a student’s academic, social, and physical needs, providing quality education in a focused and engaging environment. In 2011-2012, the U.S. Department of Education released statistics revealing that 74 percent of parents who choose to educate their children at home, did so because of a dissatisfaction with the academic instruction of other schools. Opposition declares that home-schooled children do not perform as well academically than their public-school counterparts. The fact is, however, the home-educated meet and exceed academic expectations when compared to their public-schooled peers. Both GPA and graduation rate is slightly elevated above that of public-school students. The average GPA of a home-schooled student is 3.41 compared to the 3.12 GPA of their public-schooled counterparts. Public-school students also graduated at a lower rate (58.6%) than home-schoolers (66.7%). Overall, home-schoolers are more academically prepared......

Words: 1220 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

School or Work Choice

...Often when you speak to older adults they will tell you the school days were the best days of your life, this is not because the school days were the best of their lives, simply that they were conditioned into believing this. No adult can honestly believe that the best days of their lives were when they were treated with little or no respect, or when they were beaten with a slipper for speaking out of turn. If they truly believed that school days were so good then why did most of them leave school at 16? Fortunately today teachers don't beat us with old slippers of canes but does that really make school a better environment for the student? Well the most you could say is that it's an improvement. The fact is that the school environment is an unhealthy one; everyday you're faced with the same old routine, and even worse the same people. During your younger teenage years in the lower part of the school we are all faced with a huge task, not learning about algebra or Shakespeare, but the ultimately more important lesson of learning who we are, and who we want to be. So during these turbulent years we are not placed in a constructive, and helpful environment, we are forced into a volatile environment where the minority are bullied and the majority are too afraid to be different, we are surrounded by social stereotypes, greebos, skaters, townies goths, etc. The only way to truly be an individual is to shun other people's opinions of......

Words: 785 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Becoming a Better Student

...Becoming a better a student Becoming empowered nurse with the necessary skills has always been my desire. I received my Associate Degree in Nursing, and my long term career goal is to continue on with the necessary steps to receive my Bachelor of Science in Nursing. The best way to achieve that goal is to become a better student. To become a better student, I must reach goals of practicing good time management, reduce stress, improve my writing skills, critical thinking and study skills. Once I have achieved these goals, I will be able to achieve the ultimate goal and to receive my degree of Bachelors of Science in Nursing. Time management and stress reduction “Demands for balancing classroom assignments, clinical practice, and personal life can be overwhelming for nursing students” (Pagana, 1994). I’m a working mother of four and things can get very hectic sometimes, leaving me feeling overwhelmed and stressed. So to get started I must learn how to manage my time and reduce my stress. The thing to know is that time management and stress management can go hand in hand. Time management and organization are essential tools to help with stress management. To get time management under control, the essential element is to plan. I will create daily, weekly and monthly check-off lists and start the night before reviewing what needs to be done on the next day. Making sure to take note of the tasks that need my immediate attention. “Checking off progress provides......

Words: 827 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Some People Think That Students in Single-Sex Schools Perform Better Academically. Others, However, Believe That Mixed Schools Provide Children with Better Social Skills for Adult Life.

...1 Some people think that students in single-sex schools perform better academically. Others, however, believe that mixed schools provide children with better social skills for adult life. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion. 2 Some employers believe that job applicants’ social skills are more important than their academic qualifications. Do you agree or disagree with this opinion? 3 Some people think that the government should make university education free for all students, regardless of their financial situation. To what extent do you agree or disagree? 4 When students study a foreign language, they should also study the culture and lifestyles of the people who speak the language. Do you agree or disagree? 5 Schools should only offer subjects that are beneficial to students’ future career success. Other subjects, such as music and sports, are not important. To what extent do you agree or disagree? 6 Today, more and more parents depend on their children’s grandparents for childcare. Do you think this is a positive or negative trend? 7 In many countries, average life expectancy has been increasing. What problems will this cause for individuals and for society as a whole? Suggest some solutions. 8 Some people believe that video games are harmless fun. Others, however, think that video games have a negative effect on their players. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion. 9 Some people think that advertising aimed at children should be banned....

Words: 594 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Career Choice Factors of High School Students

...Career Choice Factors 1 CAREER CHOICE FACTORS OF HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS By Michael Borchert A Research Paper Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Master of Science Degree With a Major in Career and Technical Education Approved: 2 Semester Credits ____________________________________________________ Investigation Advisor The Graduate College University of Wisconsin-Stout December, 2002 Career Choice Factors 2 The Graduate School University of Wisconsin-Stout Menomonie, WI 54751 Abstract Borchert Michael T. (Writer) (Last Name) (First) (Initial) Career Choice Factors (Title) Vocational Education Dr. Michael Galloy December/2002 82 (Graduate Major) (Research Advisor) (Month/Year) (No. of Pages) American Psychological Association (APA) (Name of Style Manual Used in this Study) Many factors affect career choices of high school students. Identifying these factors would give parents, educators, and industry an idea as to where students place most of their trust in the career selection process. It would also allow students to examine processes they use for career selection. The literature review has provided recommended models in career choices. The review of the literature showed that three areas of a studentfs life affect the career choices they make: environment, opportunity, and personality. All three played varying roles in career outcomes. This study attempted to identify to what extent these factors played a role in career......

Words: 20763 - Pages: 84